Hilary Benn

Hilary Benn

Labour — Leeds South

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

UK-EU Relations

Contribution

It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Surrey Heath (Dr Pinkerton). This debate has been mainly in two parts. If I may use the phrase, there is a weary familiarity to the conversation taking place on the Conservative Benches about what Brexit meant. I have reflected on this matter over a long time, and the Conservatives remind me of diners who go into a restaurant and order a Brexit, having no idea what it will be. When the dish arrives, they say, “This isn’t what I ordered.” Why is that? Because there is a clear dissonance between the promises that were made and the reality. Their only way to deal with that is to say, “Waiter, waiter! This isn’t what I ordered.” That is what they do, rather than opening up to the fact that the promises that were made have not come to pass. Let me touch on Northern Ireland, which was mentioned earlier. The fact that Northern Ireland has the arrangements that it does was completely predictable, because we ended up with the United Kingdom, which was no longer in the European Union, having one set of rules; Ireland, which was still in the EU, and the rest of the EU having the European set of rules; and an open border between the two entities. Here is the question: how were we going to manage trade across an open border? It was plain-as-a-pikestaff obvious that the only way we could do that, given that the border was open, was by ensuring that goods arriving in Northern Ireland complied with the rules of the EU. Out of that came the Windsor framework. Once again, I pay tribute to the last Government for what they negotiated in the Windsor framework, which made things just about workable. About the only thing that all parties in Northern Ireland agreed on during my time as Secretary of State for Northern Ireland was their welcome for the SPS agreement, which my hon. Friend the Minister spoke about. That was precisely because it will make the movement of goods so much easier. The other debate that we have been having this afternoon is of a very different character, and it is about the way in which the world has changed in the last 10 years. I urge the House to lift up its eyes collectively and look around us at the world in which we live. The public’s view of Brexit has changed quite significantly, in so far as one can tell from the polling that has been done, because the public can see that it has been bad for our economy; the evidence of that is growing all the time. That is not very surprising. If you make trade with your biggest, nearest and most important trading partners more difficult, and make it involve more paperwork and more bureaucracy, do not be surprised if it damages your economy. However, it is also because other things have changed, and we are living in new circumstances. Who would have thought, decades after the fall of the Berlin wall, which was referenced, that Russia would invade Ukraine? Look at the threats we face, including people’s ability to turn up the temperature of freezers remotely and ruin all the food—something that no one appears able to prevent; other types of cyber-attack; the threat to communications; the vulnerability of our cables; hybrid conflict; and the fact that the United States of America, under the current President, has revelled in removing itself from international agreements, and has called into question the long-standing US commitment to the security of Europe. We have seen populism spreading, and I very much regret that the official Opposition in this House are now advocating for our leaving the European convention on human rights. Winston Churchill would not recognise the Conservative party of today, because he supported that, and it is very striking that the former Leader of the Opposition William Hague gave an interview in which he said, “I couldn’t be a candidate for the Conservatives at the next election, because I do not agree with leaving the European convention on human rights.” By the way, doing so would have serious implications for the Good Friday agreement. We see the climate continuing to change, and we talk a lot about migration. When it comes to our relations with the European Union, migration is clearly an issue. The great irony is that the last Government, having left the EU while arguing, “This is the way to take back control”, completely lost control of migration from the rest of the world, which they had control over from the very start. That had nothing to do with the European Union. We see populism spreading, and we have a world of economic powerhouses—China, the United States, Russia, and of course Europe. If anyone wants proof that our interests lie in a strong and close relationship with Europe, they should consider this question: when Russia invaded Ukraine, what happened in Europe? The countries of Europe rushed to meet—to ask, “What the hell are we going to do about this?”. It did not matter whether those countries were in the European Union or not, because the countries of Europe, including the United Kingdom, instinctively realised that this was a new threat, and that we would need to work together to deal with it. Co-operating with our neighbouring countries and like-minded countries is not a betrayal, and I could not agree more with what the Minister had to say about that.

More from Hilary Benn

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Hilary Benn's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Hilary Benn report card.