Matthew Patrick

Matthew Patrick

Labour — Wirral West

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

UK-EU Relations

Contribution

This debate is giving me déjà vu. The Tories have brushed off their Brexit playbook and are replaying their best hits, but sadly—I think sadly—they have a very limited number of new things to say. Let us be clear: Brexit has caused real damage to this country. It has hurt livelihoods. It has created a status quo that is not good enough and simply must change. I am grateful to the Prime Minister for opening up the debate on how it can change, but I believe that if we are to have a debate worthy of this topic, we need to show a bit of humility. We need to make some concessions, perhaps even change our minds, because few topics entrench views and divide our country into camps—leave and remain—quite like this one, and I think it is dangerous when an issue generates maximum emotion and minimum reflection. Cards on the table: I campaigned for remain in 2016, but my learning did not stop on 23 June. My instinct was that being in the EU was a good thing, but we would survive outside it. We are a strong country and I believed we could get by. For what it is worth, I still have faith in our country. I still think that we are a great country and that we can weather storms, but the question that debates like this bring me back to is this: do we not have higher ambition for ourselves than to be able to roll with the punches? Do we not see the problems facing our country, many of which are global in nature, as needing a joined-up response? They include climate change; conflicts that spark humanitarian crises and block trade, causing prices to skyrocket, economies to suffer, and the flow of irregular and illegal immigration; the race towards artificial intelligence and all that it brings; a culture change that is being ushered in by atomised and addictive algorithms; and the issues that flow from that culture change, such as a falling birth rate, buoyant populism, and dangerous levels of Islamist and extreme right-wing terrorism. The issues go on, and they run deep. I am left asking myself, why add to our problems by failing to address the wrongs before us? It is not just about trade, but about our power to confront the global problems threatening us. At the same time, let us not kid ourselves that a panacea awaits us at the end of a road marked “rejoin”. That binary thinking—that one side is good and virtuous and the other stupid and ruinous, which is an accusation thrown at one another by both camps—has stopped us listening to the reasonable dissenting voices of those who also want the best for our country. Some Brexit commentators have pointed out that the world has changed since 2016. Well, this is not a moment for those who campaigned for remain simply to say, “We were right all along; let’s repent, let’s rejoin and let the good times roll.” First, the public will have a thing or two to say about that, and secondly, I believe those commentators are right. In 2016 we argued about trade. Today our challenges are greater and the stakes higher. We have full-scale war in Europe, an increasingly brazen and hostile Kremlin, and an unpredictable America. Commentators are right to say that the world has changed and that it is a harsher place than it was 10 years ago, as the right hon. Member for Witham (Priti Patel) said, but they do not recognise that a harsher world ups the price of standing alone. The motion before us is no better, because it ignores the realities and leans back on arguments that serve the Tory party, rather than the country. We might ask, should we rejoin? For me, it is not that simple. I felt uneasy when those advocating for Brexit argued that the status quo was so bad that we should simply jump to something else. That argument ended with a debate about whether the status quo was good, not what change looked like. Those of us who saw then, and see now, the value of the European Union and our role within it would do well to remember that half-argument. In fact, we should ask ourselves, what does this club offer us and what does it want from us? Any decision about our membership of it should be made, clearly and ruthlessly, in our interest. I believe that if we can get to a reformed and strengthened Europe that is ready to partner with us, and that makes us stronger and better equipped to tackle the great challenges ahead, it is a decision worth taking and an argument worth having. I welcome what the Government are pushing forward—a deal that will cut the cost of a weekly shop—but the motion before us ignores all of this. For me, it shows how far the Tories have fallen. Absent new ideas for the future, they go back to an old foe and roll out their greatest hits. They are fooling no one. They know what damage their Brexit has done to this country, but they are just too afraid of Reform to say it.

More from Matthew Patrick

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Matthew Patrick's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Matthew Patrick report card.