Sir Ashley Fox

Sir Ashley Fox

Conservative — Bridgwater

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

UK-EU Relations

Contribution

I represented the south-west of England and Gibraltar in the European Parliament for 10 years, and I have seen my fair share of rules and regulations written in Brussels and imposed on the United Kingdom. While we were members of the EU, we did at least have a say in how those were drafted, even if, rather too often, we ended up with compromises that we would not have chosen for ourselves. What the Government are now proposing in relation to food standards is worse than what we had during our membership of the EU, because we shall be a rule-taker, with no ability to amend the rules. I want Britain to have the closest possible trading relationship with the European Union, consistent with the result of the referendum. That means trading with the EU but not being subject to EU laws, paying into the EU budget or coming under the jurisdiction of the European Court of Justice, and that is precisely where the Prime Minister’s approach is going horribly wrong. A reduction in trade barriers is a good thing. We want our farmers and growers to sell their goods more easily on the European market, and we want to enjoy the good products that Europe has to offer us. That could be achieved by the UK and the EU recognising one another’s standards while remaining sovereign jurisdictions. Mutual recognition is a simple solution, yet regrettably something to which we know the EU would never agree. The EU has always demanded more. Its aim is that Britain accepts its regulatory framework and follows its laws, however unsuitable they may be. Its aim since 2016 has always been to drag us back within its regulatory orbit. This deal also means that, whenever there is a dispute about the contents of those laws, it is the European Court of Justice that will decide the outcome. The British people voted in 2016 to ensure that laws affecting this country would be made in this Parliament by representatives elected by the British people. They voted to restore accountability and democratic control, based in the UK. Subjecting ourselves once again to external laws and courts undermines that principle and moves us away from what was promised. The consequences are particularly concerning when it comes to the innovation and technology we have developed since leaving the EU. Britain is a world leader in gene-editing technology. Gene-edited crops can be made more resistant to disease, they require fewer pesticides, and they can withstand drought and changing climate conditions. They are a vital tool in helping farmers to produce more food while reducing costs and environmental pressures. This is exactly the kind of innovation Britain should champion. It is regrettable that the EU sees the hazard in everything. It always takes a more restrictive approach, focusing on potential hazard, rather than a more intelligent, risk-based approach to technological advance. If regulatory alignment means limiting our freedom to develop and deploy these technologies, we risk sacrificing one of the most significant opportunities created by Brexit. Labour Members should ask themselves: why would we voluntarily constrain our ability to innovate when the benefits to our farmers, consumers and food security could be so substantial? The Food and Drink Federation has said that some 400 regulations would need to be amended to facilitate an SPS agreement. These regulations will, of course, apply to the 92% of businesses that do not export to the EU in any event. CropLife UK says that any SPS deal would cost our farmers £800 million in the first year alone. The Government are happy for British businesses to foot the bill, while having no influence over how those rules are made. Of course, each time the UK joins a part of the single market, the EU will demand a payment from British taxpayers to pay for the privilege. Do we believe that laws affecting British farmers, businesses and consumers should be made here in Westminster or in Brussels? I believe that Britain can be a successful outward looking nation without surrendering control over its laws, its courts and its future.

More from Sir Ashley Fox

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Sir Ashley Fox's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Sir Ashley Fox report card.