Contribution
Regional news is of paramount importance, and we should do everything we can to protect it.
There is a reason why Britain has historically treated newspapers and the print media and television news differently. Our newspapers have always been free to take political positions: The Guardian can support the Lib Dems; the Mirror can support Labour; The Telegraph can support Reform UK. Readers understand that. They know what they are buying. Television news, however, was developed under a different settlement. That settlement, to my mind, is informed by the principles of no less an authority on free speech than John Stuart Mill, one of the founding fathers of English liberty. He wrote persuasively on this topic, and with the House’s indulgence, I wish to quote some of his words.
Mill wrote:
“opinions lose their immunity, when the circumstances in which they are expressed are such as to constitute their expression a positive instigation to some mischievous act. An opinion that corn-dealers are starvers of the poor, or that private property is robbery, ought to be unmolested when simply circulated through the press, but may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob assembled before the house of a corn-dealer,”.
I heartily concur with Mill on that. In a modern-day context, it appears to me that the point at issue is whether television news, and by extension online provision of news in the same context, is more like the printed word or like something “delivered orally to an excited mob”. Is it more like being printed in a newspaper, or more like being spoken at a rally during the 19th century? Given the immediacy of the spoken word, and the passion aroused by visual imagery, I think that the question needs only to be put to be answered.
It is obvious why television news is regulated to be impartial in a way that newspapers are not. Broadcasters were given access to a powerful medium, reaching directly into millions of homes on the understanding that news would be presented with due accuracy and due impartiality. That settlement has helped to ensure that British broadcasting has been respected around the world.
However, in recent years something has changed. We are seeing the emergence of television channels increasingly resembling the hyperpartisan cable news networks of the United States—channels built around political identities, confrontation, dividing lines and manufactured controversy, where the lines between reporting the news in the interests of the public good and generating controversy in the interests of clicks and shares have been blurred. According to Ofcom, it helps to keep an eye on the TV, yet it appears that in the past decade Ofcom has taken its eye off the ball when it comes to broadcast standards and impartiality rules.
Any organisation wishing to operate on television is subject to Ofcom regulation, which exists to protect the public from harm. Section 5 of the broadcasting code covers impartiality and accuracy, yet we are repeatedly seeing just criticism of Ofcom for not enforcing the provisions within the code.
Take a comment from a news broadcaster this July in a discussion about the covid pandemic, who said:
“There is no evidence that the vaccine saved a single person. There is no empirical evidence that it saved a single human being.”
That strikes me as being as far from accurate, trustworthy or protecting the public from harm as possible. It is materially misleading. I think it is fair to say that these falsehoods are a harm to the public, yet insufficient action is being taken.
Another example, from February, is about an interview with the US President that had been broadcast on a UK channel. This was criticism levelled at the time:
“If there were ever a case that merited investigation for the broadcast of potentially misleading material and a failure to meet due impartiality requirements, this was it. This was a test case for how Ofcom regulates broadcasters on due impartiality. It has failed that test… It now appears that Ofcom has abandoned any pretence that meaningful regulation of broadcast content is still being maintained.”
Those are not my words, but those of Ofcom’s own founding director of standards. It is a criticism so stinging that any regulator worth its salt would have woken up by now and realised it had been asleep on the job.
Rule 5.3 of the broadcast code states:
“No politician may be used as a newsreader, interviewer or reporter in any news programmes”,
while rule 5.9 states that
“presenters must not use the advantage of regular appearances to promote their views in a way that compromises the requirement for due impartiality.”
Because I have not notified any other Member that I intend to refer to them, I shall not do so. However, I think that breaches of the code in this regard are both obvious and cause for concern.