Free-to-air Television News
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Contributions
Motion made, and Question proposed, That this House do now adjourn. —(Gregor Poynton.)
Patrick Hurley (Southport) (Lab)Labour
I am grateful for the opportunity to raise an issue that underpins a huge amount of political discussion and discourse in Britain today: the regulation of free-to-air television news, the responsibilities of our television broadcasters, and the ability of the public to distinguish between journalism, political campaigning and outright conspiracy-theorising nonsense. I want to begin by making something absolutely clear. I believe passionately in a free press. I believe in robust journalism, in challenging interviews, in broadcasters holding politicians to account, and in people having access to a wide range of opinions. Indeed, in just the last couple of days I have given interviews and comment to a dozen or so outlets on a range of topics, and I have been challenged by all of them—so much the better for ensuring that contested and controversial issues find a reasonable and balanced way forward, underpinned by truth. I also believe that we have a responsibility to protect something that has served this country remarkably well for generations: the principle that television news—news underpinned by the spoken word and by visual images beamed into our homes—should be accurate, impartial and worthy of the public’s trust.
Ann Davies (Caerfyrddin) (PC)Plaid Cymru
Does the hon. Member agree that safeguarding our public service broadcasters is vital as we navigate our way through the changes facing the BBC? Welsh language news provision is prepared by the BBC for S4C. Does he agree that this provision should be ringfenced?
Patrick HurleyLabour
I am increasingly concerned about the way in which the BBC is managing the cuts, and I fully support what the hon. Lady has said.
Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party
I commend the hon. Gentleman for bringing forward this debate— I spoke to him beforehand. It is a really important issue, so I am grateful to him for letting me intervene. In Northern Ireland, trusted free-to-air news from BBC Northern Ireland and UTV is a vital lifeline for our rural and older communities, who rely on impartial, locally grounded journalism. Does he therefore agree that as viewing habits shift online, regulation must protect universal access to regional news, and guarantee that Northern Ireland’s distinct voice is never ever sidelined?
Patrick HurleyLabour
Regional news is of paramount importance, and we should do everything we can to protect it. There is a reason why Britain has historically treated newspapers and the print media and television news differently. Our newspapers have always been free to take political positions: The Guardian can support the Lib Dems; the Mirror can support Labour; The Telegraph can support Reform UK. Readers understand that. They know what they are buying. Television news, however, was developed under a different settlement. That settlement, to my mind, is informed by the principles of no less an authority on free speech than John Stuart Mill, one of the founding fathers of English liberty. He wrote persuasively on this topic, and with the House’s indulgence, I wish to quote some of his words. Mill wrote: “opinions lose their immunity, when the circumstances in which they are expressed are such as to constitute their expression a positive instigation to some mischievous act. An opinion that corn-dealers are starvers of the poor, or that private property is robbery, ought to be unmolested when simply circulated through the press, but may justly incur punishment when delivered orally to an excited mob assembled before the house of a corn-dealer,”. I heartily concur with Mill on that. In a modern-day context, it appears to me that the point at issue is whether television news, and by extension online provision of news in the same context, is more like the printed word or like something “delivered orally to an excited mob”. Is it more like being printed in a newspaper, or more like being spoken at a rally during the 19th century? Given the immediacy of the spoken word, and the passion aroused by visual imagery, I think that the question needs only to be put to be answered. It is obvious why television news is regulated to be impartial in a way that newspapers are not. Broadcasters were given access to a powerful medium, reaching directly into millions of homes on the understanding that news would be presented with due accuracy and due impartiality. That settlement has helped to ensure that British broadcasting has been respected around the world. However, in recent years something has changed. We are seeing the emergence of television channels increasingly resembling the hyperpartisan cable news networks of the United States—channels built around political identities, confrontation, dividing lines and manufactured controversy, where the lines between reporting the news in the interests of the public good and generating controversy in the interests of clicks and shares have been blurred. According to Ofcom, it helps to keep an eye on the TV, yet it appears that in the past decade Ofcom has taken its eye off the ball when it comes to broadcast standards and impartiality rules. Any organisation wishing to operate on television is subject to Ofcom regulation, which exists to protect the public from harm. Section 5 of the broadcasting code covers impartiality and accuracy, yet we are repeatedly seeing just criticism of Ofcom for not enforcing the provisions within the code. Take a comment from a news broadcaster this July in a discussion about the covid pandemic, who said: “There is no evidence that the vaccine saved a single person. There is no empirical evidence that it saved a single human being.” That strikes me as being as far from accurate, trustworthy or protecting the public from harm as possible. It is materially misleading. I think it is fair to say that these falsehoods are a harm to the public, yet insufficient action is being taken. Another example, from February, is about an interview with the US President that had been broadcast on a UK channel. This was criticism levelled at the time: “If there were ever a case that merited investigation for the broadcast of potentially misleading material and a failure to meet due impartiality requirements, this was it. This was a test case for how Ofcom regulates broadcasters on due impartiality. It has failed that test… It now appears that Ofcom has abandoned any pretence that meaningful regulation of broadcast content is still being maintained.” Those are not my words, but those of Ofcom’s own founding director of standards. It is a criticism so stinging that any regulator worth its salt would have woken up by now and realised it had been asleep on the job. Rule 5.3 of the broadcast code states: “No politician may be used as a newsreader, interviewer or reporter in any news programmes”, while rule 5.9 states that “presenters must not use the advantage of regular appearances to promote their views in a way that compromises the requirement for due impartiality.” Because I have not notified any other Member that I intend to refer to them, I shall not do so. However, I think that breaches of the code in this regard are both obvious and cause for concern.
Chris Kane (Stirling and Strathallan) (Lab)Labour
Does my hon. Friend agree with me that journalism itself is a profession that is grounded in all the things that we hold dear, such as impartiality and professionalism, and that the blurring of the lines between what is a professional journalist and what is an entertainer in the media industry at the moment is not helpful? Journalism and broadcast journalism are something to be cherished and protected. Does he agree that when Government are looking at this, they should make sure that the impartiality of journalism is protected and that we celebrate what journalists bring to our democracy?
Patrick HurleyLabour
I agree entirely, with the one caveat that some of these people are neither journalistic nor entertaining. Last month, in a hearing of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee, the chair of Ofcom, Sir Ian Cheshire, suggested that someone should “set up a left-wing version of GB News.” First, this appears to be an implicit admission that Ofcom has granted a licence to an explicitly right-wing channel, despite its multiple protestations to the contrary. Even more seriously, it also suggests that Sir Ian either does not understand or is ignorant of the law governing impartiality on Ofcom-licensed channels. That law is enshrined in the Communications Act 2003, which gives Ofcom a statutory duty to ensure that “news included in television and radio services is presented with due impartiality”. The Act spells out precisely what that statutory duty entails: impartiality requirements apply to all programmes dealing with “matters of political or industrial controversy”, and “matters relating to current public policy.” The discrepancy between Sir Ian’s comments to the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport Committee and the wording of the Act is obvious. I wish to finish by putting a few specific questions to the Minister. First, do the Government remain committed to the principle that free-to-air TV news should be subject to due accuracy and impartiality, regardless of the political perspective of the broadcaster’s owners? Secondly, what assessment has the Department made of Ofcom’s ability to address patterns of partiality across a broadcaster’s output, rather than considering individual programmes in isolation? Finally, will the Minister consider engaging with Ofcom about the wider implications of increasingly partisan television broadcasting, including whether further research into public expectations and trust is needed? I want to end where I began. My point is not about silencing voices with which we disagree. It is about ensuring the impartiality of news in a medium that is recognised as having the power of the spoken word and the power of the visual image. I do not want a Britain in which every political tribe has its own TV news channel, its own version of events, and pretends to its own set of facts. I want a country where people can disagree about politics while retaining some confidence in the information on which those disagreements are based. I think that is worth protecting. I hope the Minister will agree that the principles that have underpinned British broadcasting for generations remain just as important today as they have ever been.
The Minister for Creative Industries, Media and Online Safety (Ian Murray)Labour
I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Southport (Patrick Hurley) on securing this important debate. I would like to pay a special tribute to him for the work he has done in this area. We often use the tragic circumstances of the Southport attack as an example of where local media came to the fore. During that crisis, there was an amount of misinformation and disinformation circling. It gave us all hope that local people turned to local news outlets to make sure that they were reading the truth and what was accurate. I pay tribute to the Stand Up For Southport journalists, who recently received money from our local news fund, which forms part of our local news strategy, as well as to the Southport Visiter and BBC North West for the role they played for local people. I think that gives us hope that we do journalism, particularly local journalism, very well in this country. The UK has a long tradition of TV acting as a source of impartial and trustworthy news. In response to the question posed by my hon. Friend, I can confirm that the Government remain committed to ensuring that free-to-air TV news is duly accurate and impartial. Free-to-air TV news plays a vital role in supporting a healthy information environment, and we rely on our broadcasters to interrogate power, explain complex global events and help to build a shared understanding of the world, which then strengthens social cohesion and democratic participation. Now more than ever, the need for trusted news is essential to our democratic and cultural life. This includes our public service media providers, which remain among our most trusted news sources. Research shows that audiences who rely on public service news are more likely to correctly identify important factual information, to have higher levels of trust in institutions and to be less polarised. That is because the truth and facts matter. A key pillar of audience trust in TV news is its regulation by Ofcom. Under Ofcom’s broadcasting code, which my hon. Friend has mentioned, news on licensed TV services must be reported with due accuracy and presented with due impartiality. In undertaking this role, Ofcom carries out its duties independently of Government. However, that does not mean that the Government and this House should not scrutinise and take action through the democratic process where it believes that audiences and businesses should be better served. I understand that there are concerns about the effectiveness of Ofcom’s regulation of specific news broadcasters, and some have criticised Ofcom’s speed and willingness to act. On that point, my hon. Friend asked about Ofcom’s ability to assess patterns of potential partiality across a broadcaster’s output. I think it is important for me to be clear that the Government are committed to a free, independent and plural media. My hon. Friend mentioned that as well. I understand his concern, but Ofcom’s legislative duties do not require it to take a view of partiality across a broadcaster’s entire catalogue. It is important that broadcasters are free to determine their own editorial output. Nevertheless, they must still ensure that due impartiality is maintained. When considering these matters, Ofcom is able to assess a series of editorially linked programmes to see a wider picture. My hon. Friend asked whether Ofcom has the necessary powers and resources to act promptly and effectively, whether the Government will engage with Ofcom about the wider implications of increasingly partisan television broadcasting, and whether further research into public expectations and trust is needed. I recognise the importance of the regulator being equipped to act effectively in all the areas that it regulates—concerns have been raised on that point in the House in recent weeks—especially when we are in a fast-moving developing media environment. Through our media Green Paper, we are considering whether Ofcom has the right tools and powers around broadcasting regulation. We will set out our decisions in the new year. In addition, Ofcom has extensive information gathering powers and regularly carries out research on media consumption and audience attitudes. That includes looking at issues of trustworthiness, accuracy and impartiality, such as Ofcom’s recent “News Report 2026”, published on 15 September, which I am sure my hon. Friend is aware of. I want to cover the specific issue of politicians presenting programmes. As the Secretary of State has previously said, including from the Dispatch Box, navigating our media landscape has been complicated by a dangerous blurring of fact and polemic. That includes politicians presenting programmes that could reasonably be interpreted as news or indeed current affairs. Under sections 5.1 and 5.3 of Ofcom’s broadcasting code, “No politician may be used as a newsreader, interviewer or reporter in any news programmes unless, exceptionally, it is editorially justified.” But, outside of an election period, there are no restrictions on politicians presenting non-news programmes, including current affairs. The recent Demos report demonstrates that the issue of politician-presenters is not unique to the UK. The approaches taken vary across our European neighbours, but the UK does appear to be more of an outlier when it comes to allowing politicians to present current affairs programmes. Those findings support our view that there is a clear rationale to strengthen the rules here. We are considering options to tackle the problem. We are actively listening to the concerns raised by the House and by many Members of the House, including my hon. Friend, and will set out our decision as soon as we can. While we address those immediate regulatory challenges, we must also look to the horizon. The media sector is undergoing a profound structural transformation, with audience viewing habits and news sources rapidly shifting from traditional broadcast networks to the online ecosystem. Earlier this year, the Government published a media Green Paper entitled, “Watch this space”. Through that, we are considering options to make it easier for people to discover reliable and trusted news sources on social media. We want to ensure that, in line with an online world with near-infinite sources of information, high-quality, editorially judged news continues to reach audiences. At present, social media companies have disproportionate control over what content is made visible to audiences, including through their algorithms. We want to rebalance that to ensure that high-quality news is not crowded out. The policy aims to actively promote high-quality, trustworthy journalistic reporting and to ensure that everyone has access to news. There is no intention to restrict or censor content or to favour any particular viewpoint. Instead, the aim is to ensure that users can access accurate, trustworthy information from a broad range of news providers. As my hon. Friend says, we heavily regulate broadcast news, but it is a free-for-all online, rife with conspiracy theories and alternative truths. We must ensure that the public get the truth that they deserve. The Green Paper also proposes wider reforms that will help to protect the long-term future of the UK’s media ecosystem, as mentioned by the hon. Member for Caerfyrddin (Ann Davies), including public service media providers such as the BBC, STV, ITV, Channel 4, Channel 5 and S4C. Those providers could also be given new duties to tackle misinformation and disinformation, which is particularly important as figures show that more than half of adults in the UK now include social media as one of the ways in which they get their news and current affairs. Free-to-air television news is one of the country’s greatest civic assets. It informs our electorate, holds the powerful to account and provides a regulated space where audiences can be confident that they can access trusted, accurate and impartial news. To maintain that standard, we must ensure that our regulatory framework is fit for the digital age and robust enough to command the total confidence of the British public—and, of course, Members of the House. Through our media Green Paper, we are considering how to ensure that Ofcom continues to have the right powers to protect audiences and regulate TV services today and into the future. That includes considering the best way to support trustworthy news media in a rapidly changing landscape, including what action may be needed to support audience confidence in the accurate, impartial news they likely expect from TV. I very much look forward to working with my hon. Friend the Member for Southport to continue our work on these issues, because they are important not just for the House and all our constituents, but for democracy and for our country as a whole. Question put and agreed to.
House adjourned.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440357.