David Chadwick

David Chadwick

Liberal Democrat — Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

Community Hospitals and Step-down Care

Contribution

Staffing levels are obviously of critical importance, and that is one of the issues that confuses people. Powys teaching health board says that it needs to make these changes so it can hold on to the staff it has, but the staff I have spoken to are fed up. Who would put forward for a nursing job that they think might disappear in the next few months? That is having a damaging impact on morale across Powys and across Wales. Nurses have a choice of where to work, and my great fear is that this will drive our good, well-trained, professional nurses out of Wales. In the Llynfi valley, the community hospital is under threat and people are wondering where their loved ones will end up; Dean Ronan is leading the campaign to keep it open. In north Wales, Betsi Cadwaladr same-day urgent primary care at Ysbyty Alltwen in Tremadog, Ysbyty Gwynedd in Bangor and Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley in Holyhead are all under threat of closure. In Swansea, 30 step-down beds have been moved out of Gorseinon hospital to Singleton, further reducing capacity and pushing more people into Morriston hospital or general hospitals further afield. Sam Bennett has been expressing his concerns about the situation there. I think we all agree that over the past 40 years too many community and cottage hospitals have been closed, including in Builth Wells. Earlier this month, England’s chief medical officer, Professor Sir Chris Whitty, published his annual report on health in rural areas and small towns. It identified community hospitals as an important way to provide care in areas where larger hospitals are hard to reach. It also sets out why rural health services have to be planned around long distances, limited public transport and the available workforce. Those are precisely the conditions that people have to deal with in Powys. Taking beds and services further away runs against what the evidence tells us about access to rural healthcare. With that in mind, is it any wonder that A&E departments are backed up? Take away a minor injuries unit, and some of the people who would have used it will turn up at an A&E in a general hospital further away. Take away step-down beds, and patients who could have moved to a community ward may have to stay in an acute bed. That will further clog up our hospitals across Wales and England and will add to ambulance delays. Some health boards are using the promise of more care at home to justify removing beds, without explaining how they will deliver that care at the scale they are counting on. In Powys, the board says that it wants to expand care at home, district nursing and rehabilitation, but has not said how many staff it will need to do so; where it will recruit them from, particularly when it is struggling to fill its current vacancies; how many visits those staff will be able to deliver across a county the size of Powys; how much extra work will fall to the council; or who will have to pay for it. There is also the practical question of delivering frequent care across rural Powys. Several visits a day can mean several long journeys a day. A care worker covering scattered villages can spend a substantial part of a shift on the road, and that extra time and fuel has to be paid for. When several patients need frequent nursing and therapy, a local ward allows staff to provide that care in one place. That can be a better use of limited staff and budgets, and it gives patients more time with the people helping them to recover. I want more people to be able to recover at home, but even if the board delivers everything it proposes, patients will still need community hospital beds. People in Powys want answers. Where will their parents and loved ones recover after an operation? Where will they go for an X-ray after a fall? If someone they love needs end-of-life care, will they be close enough to visit every day? They deserve answers while there is still time to change the plans, yet the Welsh Health Minister keeps pointing back at the health board. The Welsh Government hold the purse strings and have a responsibility for the choices that the health board is being asked to make. The chairs of health boards in Wales are responsible for setting the strategic direction of health boards and are directly accountable to the Welsh Health Minister. The buck passing needs to stop. People in Powys deserve to hear directly from their Health Minister about what care they can expect and how it will be paid for. I want to know, here today, whether this Minister agrees with Sir Chris Whitty about the value of community hospitals. Do this Government want to see them stay open across the United Kingdom? Are they concerned about the impact of what is happening in Powys? Is the Minister concerned about the cross-border impact that it will have? I thank the thousands of residents across Powys who have spoken up and have stood in the cold and rain to show their concerns. The Welsh Health Minister should listen to them and think again before beds and crucial services are lost.

More from David Chadwick

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For David Chadwick's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the David Chadwick report card.