Hansard·Westminster Hall·Vol. 793

Community Hospitals and Step-down Care

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

37 contributions12 members

Contributions

  1. David Chadwick (Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    I beg to move, That this House has considered community hospitals and step-down care. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I have secured this debate to raise the alarm about community hospitals across Powys and across Wales, which are in grave danger. Community hospitals are a legacy left to us by previous generations. They are a reminder of how communities once came together to solve their own problems and of what concentrated local power can achieve, yet their fates are now being decided by Welsh health boards, while the Minister for Health and Care in Wales does nothing. The plans to take services away from community hospitals across Wales have been inching forward for the past few years, first under the Welsh Labour Government and now under Plaid Cymru. I raised these concerns at Prime Minister’s questions with the former Prime Minister, who is no longer in this place. He told me that he would write to me, but he never did. Community hospitals are a vital part of the NHS, especially in rural areas.

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Brian Mathew (Melksham and Devizes) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    Does my hon. Friend agree that many community hospitals, including Melksham community hospital in my constituency, are significantly under-utilised? That historic hospital should be a beacon of community healthcare. If the Government are serious about shifting care away from acute hospitals, such community sites must receive investment to bring the space back into use to support clinical services, including step-down care and treatment of minor injuries.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Karl Turner (in the Chair)Labour

    Order. May I ask Members to make short interventions, not speeches?

    View contribution permalink →

  4. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    I thank my hon. Friend for that contribution. The statistics in my constituency and across Powys are certainly different. The average utilisation rate of beds in community hospitals across Powys is 91%, which shows that these community hospitals are already full—the services are already being fully used. We have an ageing population. One of the oldest council wards in Wales is next to Llandrindod community hospital, which is why these services are so desperately needed.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Liz Saville Roberts (Dwyfor Meirionnydd) (PC)Plaid Cymru

    On the point about the ageing population and Powys being an attractive area for people to retire to, does the hon. Member agree that the Barnett formula does not recognise need specifically on those issues for Wales?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    The right hon. Lady knows full well that I fully agree that the Barnett formula does not serve Wales as well as it should, and that we are disadvantaged in that sense. Community hospitals care for people who need nursing overnight or a few more days of support before they can go home safely.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party

    I thank the hon. Gentleman for securing this debate. He is right to underline the fact that the population is ageing and the proportion of those of pensionable age has continued to grow, particularly in rural areas. The Department of Health in Northern Ireland has recognised the need for change and has published a neighbourhood model of health and wellbeing. If we recognise the problems in Northern Ireland, Wales, Scotland and England, is it not time that all four nations got together to share their ideas and a way forward?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    What really matters in Wales is that the potential cut to community hospital services will have a knock-on impact in other areas of the Union, most obviously England. Lots of people from Powys rely on hospitals in Herefordshire and Shropshire because we do not have a general hospital of our own. Many people who rely on their community hospital do not stay overnight; they go there for blood tests, X-rays or to use the attached minor injuries unit. The ability to access those services in the community is a lifeline for many, particularly those who need regular blood tests and rely on an infrequent bus or a lift from a neighbour to get to the nearest general hospital, which for many people in Powys is in Herefordshire or Shropshire. The removal of these services on the Welsh side of the border will lead to greater demand on the English side.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Alex Easton (North Down) (Ind)Independent

    My community hospital in Bangor has been stripped of its minor injuries unit and GP ward. Does the hon. Member agree that community hospitals across the UK deserve more investment? We could make better use of NHS resources while enabling people to receive care closer to home.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    Quite. I have two boys aged four and two, and we have frequently had to go to minor injury units because of what small children tend to do. Residents across my constituency are concerned that if the local unit closes, the next time they have to take their child to a minor injuries unit it might be a 30-mile drive away instead of just around the corner. Community hospitals provide another service that we have not mentioned so far: in-patient mental health care. When it is provided locally, close to family and with a team to support someone after discharge, that is obviously better for mental health. They can also provide palliative and end-of-life care when symptoms are difficult to manage at home. For families spending those last days together, having a bed nearby means that they can visit their loved ones every day. Local beds are especially important for my constituents, because we do not have a general hospital in Powys. People in Powys who rely on a general hospital will have to leave their own neighbourhood and either cross the border into England or go down to Swansea for an operation. They come back to community hospitals to recover. In its own evaluation of local step-down and rehabilitation units, the health board heard that most families had less far to travel to visit, and that patients valued the support they received from physiotherapists. Yet, under Powys teaching health board’s “Better Together” proposals, the number of physical health in-patient beds could be cut from 148—with a utilisation rate of 91% on average—to just 60. Both options would remove those beds from Ystradgynlais, Welshpool, Llanidloes, Machynlleth and Bronllys. Under the 60-bed option, Llandrindod Wells would lose its beds too. In Knighton, the mothballed beds would remain closed. The proposals would also concentrate mental health care on only one site in Bronllys, which is by far the worst for public transport options, and would shut two minor injuries units in the county and remove X-ray services from several sites. Since the plans were announced, more than 10,000 people have signed my petition opposing the cuts. Every GP practice in Powys has signed a letter to the health board, raising their concerns about the cuts. Doctors have said to me privately that their biggest concern is the impact on palliative care and what it would mean for local residents in the last days of their life. Thousands of people have attended the public meetings that we have organised across the constituency. In Ystradgynlais, so many people came that they spilled out into the street and stood outside to listen, because we could not accommodate everybody inside. They pointed out some ludicrous stats that had been put forward in the pre-consultations, including the claim that they could get from Ystradgynlais to Brecon in 29 minutes, which is impossible. Local doctors, nurses and residents all oppose these plans. In the past fortnight, I have spoken at rallies at Llandrindod Wells and Ystradgynlais. On Saturday, hundreds of people gathered once more outside Ystradgynlais community hospital, while hundreds poured into the streets of Welshpool for a hospital bed push through the town centre organised by Richard Church, Carol Robinson and Glyn Preston. People across Powys are desperate not to lose these services. Welsh Liberal Democrat campaigners have raised similar concerns elsewhere in Wales. Maesteg community hospital was built in 1914 to care for injured servicemen. Miners from the Llynfi valley—

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    It behoves me to point out the obvious, which is that these are all matters to be answered by a Health Minister in Wales, and that the Health Minister here cannot answer them. I also need to point out that an extra £500 million was allocated to health in Wales in yesterday’s Welsh budget. It includes a national clinical plan in the spring and a community shift of expenditure directed to health boards of 0.5% of their budgets towards community services.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    The right hon. Lady is quite right to point out that healthcare is devolved to Wales, so these are predominantly Welsh issues, but everybody in this place should be concerned about the state of devolution. One of the big challenges in Wales is that we have a Welsh Health Minister—part of a new Government who have inherited a legislative framework from the previous Government—who is saying that he has no powers to do anything. That is not what devolution should look like, and it will drive people across Wales mad if it continues. We have a Welsh Health Minister who says he has no power to do anything about the health boards that are reportedly under his control. That is not a style of devolution that will keep people happy.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Liz Saville RobertsPlaid Cymru

    I understand that the Health Minister for Wales has written to the hon. Gentleman to explain the legislative framework as it stands. That includes the legislation on nursing staff levels, on which I think we agree, which was introduced by a predecessor of the hon. Gentleman’s as Liberal leader in Wales and which is affecting recruiting across rural areas.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Karl Turner (in the Chair)Labour

    Order. I remind Members that interventions must be short. They are not speeches.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    Staffing levels are obviously of critical importance, and that is one of the issues that confuses people. Powys teaching health board says that it needs to make these changes so it can hold on to the staff it has, but the staff I have spoken to are fed up. Who would put forward for a nursing job that they think might disappear in the next few months? That is having a damaging impact on morale across Powys and across Wales. Nurses have a choice of where to work, and my great fear is that this will drive our good, well-trained, professional nurses out of Wales. In the Llynfi valley, the community hospital is under threat and people are wondering where their loved ones will end up; Dean Ronan is leading the campaign to keep it open. In north Wales, Betsi Cadwaladr same-day urgent primary care at Ysbyty Alltwen in Tremadog, Ysbyty Gwynedd in Bangor and Ysbyty Penrhos Stanley in Holyhead are all under threat of closure. In Swansea, 30 step-down beds have been moved out of Gorseinon hospital to Singleton, further reducing capacity and pushing more people into Morriston hospital or general hospitals further afield. Sam Bennett has been expressing his concerns about the situation there. I think we all agree that over the past 40 years too many community and cottage hospitals have been closed, including in Builth Wells. Earlier this month, England’s chief medical officer, Professor Sir Chris Whitty, published his annual report on health in rural areas and small towns. It identified community hospitals as an important way to provide care in areas where larger hospitals are hard to reach. It also sets out why rural health services have to be planned around long distances, limited public transport and the available workforce. Those are precisely the conditions that people have to deal with in Powys. Taking beds and services further away runs against what the evidence tells us about access to rural healthcare. With that in mind, is it any wonder that A&E departments are backed up? Take away a minor injuries unit, and some of the people who would have used it will turn up at an A&E in a general hospital further away. Take away step-down beds, and patients who could have moved to a community ward may have to stay in an acute bed. That will further clog up our hospitals across Wales and England and will add to ambulance delays. Some health boards are using the promise of more care at home to justify removing beds, without explaining how they will deliver that care at the scale they are counting on. In Powys, the board says that it wants to expand care at home, district nursing and rehabilitation, but has not said how many staff it will need to do so; where it will recruit them from, particularly when it is struggling to fill its current vacancies; how many visits those staff will be able to deliver across a county the size of Powys; how much extra work will fall to the council; or who will have to pay for it. There is also the practical question of delivering frequent care across rural Powys. Several visits a day can mean several long journeys a day. A care worker covering scattered villages can spend a substantial part of a shift on the road, and that extra time and fuel has to be paid for. When several patients need frequent nursing and therapy, a local ward allows staff to provide that care in one place. That can be a better use of limited staff and budgets, and it gives patients more time with the people helping them to recover. I want more people to be able to recover at home, but even if the board delivers everything it proposes, patients will still need community hospital beds. People in Powys want answers. Where will their parents and loved ones recover after an operation? Where will they go for an X-ray after a fall? If someone they love needs end-of-life care, will they be close enough to visit every day? They deserve answers while there is still time to change the plans, yet the Welsh Health Minister keeps pointing back at the health board. The Welsh Government hold the purse strings and have a responsibility for the choices that the health board is being asked to make. The chairs of health boards in Wales are responsible for setting the strategic direction of health boards and are directly accountable to the Welsh Health Minister. The buck passing needs to stop. People in Powys deserve to hear directly from their Health Minister about what care they can expect and how it will be paid for. I want to know, here today, whether this Minister agrees with Sir Chris Whitty about the value of community hospitals. Do this Government want to see them stay open across the United Kingdom? Are they concerned about the impact of what is happening in Powys? Is the Minister concerned about the cross-border impact that it will have? I thank the thousands of residents across Powys who have spoken up and have stood in the cold and rain to show their concerns. The Welsh Health Minister should listen to them and think again before beds and crucial services are lost.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. Dr Roz Savage (South Cotswolds) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) for securing this important debate. Community hospitals are especially important in rural communities such as mine, where distances are greater, public transport is extremely limited and getting to hospital can depend on whether someone has a car or a friend or family member able to drive them. However, their value goes beyond convenience. Community hospitals provide a vital bridge between acute hospital care and returning home. For older people recovering from surgery, a stroke or serious illness, they can provide the rehabilitation and support those patients need in order to regain their independence. Across England, about 13,000 patients a day are medically ready to leave acute hospitals but are stuck there. Getting people into the right care is better for patients—better for their chances of recovery and for their morale—and better for their families, who are able to visit them. Vitally, that also frees up beds for those who really need them. I welcome the NHS ambition to provide more care at or close to home, but “care closer to home” must not become a euphemism for care without a bed. Some patients need the additional support that a community hospital provides. We could be still more ambitious in the way we use our community hospitals. They could become hubs for proactive healthcare, helping people to stay well, rather than simply treating them after they have become ill. That would save money as well as countless productive years. In east Surrey, for example, the Growing Health Together initiative brings GPs, community organisations and residents together to improve health outcomes through activities that tackle loneliness, encourage exercise and build community connections. What’s not to love about that? Community hospitals could be natural anchors for that kind of preventive and life-enhancing approach. That brings me to the issue of Cirencester hospital—a much-loved and cherished institution in my constituency. When its operating theatre was temporarily closed last year, local people were understandably concerned. I cannot tell you, Mr Turner, how many people have come up to me to tell me a personal family story about a fun night they spent in the minor injuries unit, or where they went to give birth. Working with Councillor Paul Hodgkinson, we organised a petition calling for services to be restored. In just a few days, we got more than 3,000 signatures. We delivered it to Downing Street in June 2026, but are still awaiting a response. I realise that a few other things were going on in Downing Street in June, but even so we would appreciate a response. I would be grateful if the Minister could help to secure one.

    View contribution permalink →

  17. The Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety (Dame Diana Johnson)Labour

    A response was sent in July 2026 from the ministerial correspondence and public enquiries unit at the Department of Health and Social Care. If the hon. Member has not got that letter, I have a copy here that I am happy to give her today.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Dr SavageLiberal Democrat

    I thank the Minister and am very grateful to hear that. I will co-ordinate with her afterwards to receive that copy. Since delivering the petition, I have met the ICB and been reassured that the future of Cirencester hospital is absolutely safe as part of the ICB’s ongoing re-engineering and rearrangement of facilities across Gloucestershire. That could have been better communicated to residents, which would have saved an awful lot of misunderstanding and unnecessary apprehension, but I am somewhat reassured that the future of the hospital is safe. I welcome the NHS’s commitment to Cirencester hospital’s long-term future and recognise that services need to evolve in response to the changing needs of our country, but those decisions must reflect local needs. There is substantial planned housing growth—many thousands of new homes—in the villages around Cirencester over the next few years, which needs to be factored into the capacity of local health services. Local people must have a genuine say in shaping the hospital’s future: it is not just that the one-way communication needs to be improved; there needs to be two-way communication and genuine consultation. I ask the Minister to ensure that healthcare planning reflects the needs of our growing rural communities, like those in South Cotswolds, and that community hospitals are seen not simply as facilities to be preserved, but as opportunities to develop. We should make the fullest possible use of these valuable local assets, which provide care close to home and help people to stay healthy in the first place. That is the future I would like to see for Cirencester hospital.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. Monica Harding (Esher and Walton) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing a debate on this important topic. My hon. Friends have spoken powerfully about rural provision and community hospitals, but I want to speak for a suburban constituency. The problem my hon. Friends describe—people stuck in acute beds with nowhere safe to go—is also serious in Surrey. I want to talk particularly about Molesey community hospital in my constituency, which serves people across my constituency and beyond, providing rehabilitation beds, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, community nursing, out-patient clinics and end-of-life care. Its aim is to help patients return to living independently or with care or other support. In short, it is exactly the kind of care closer to home that the Government say they want more of. It is also a place that my constituents care about deeply. However, the building has been neglected for more than 30 years. An estate left to age does not save money; it costs more to maintain every year, and it makes modern equipment and new ways of working harder to bring in. Without investment, the care inside will eventually fall short, however dedicated the staff are. The pressure on step-down care in my area is severe. My constituency sits within the Surrey and Sussex ICB, which NHS England’s discharge-ready date figures in September put joint last out of all 36 ICBs in England on discharge delays. Across England, the average patient leaves hospital just under a day after they are ready to go; in Surrey and Sussex, it is 1.6 days. For 85% of patients, discharge happens on the same day they are ready; the problem is those who face delays, often because they are waiting for further care to be available, including in community hospitals like Molesey and in the care system. For patients who are delayed at all, the average wait in Surrey and Sussex is more than 11 days, compared to under seven nationally. In September, 345 people in Surrey and Sussex waited three weeks or more after they were ready to leave. That is 2.4% of all discharges, well over double the national rate. In a single month, the ICB lost 23,695 bed days due to delayed discharge. That is the equivalent of nearly 790 hospital beds occupied every day of September by people who no longer needed to be there.

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Mr Gregory Campbell (East Londonderry) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party

    Does the hon. Lady agree that the Government not doing what she advocates actually costs us money? We need to support community hospitals as patients are moved into greater care in the community.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. Monica HardingLiberal Democrat

    I agree 100%. It costs more money in the long run, and there is also the human cost. Elderly patients can lose mobility in the time they are in hospital, which makes the problem worse, and they end up in hospital for the longer term. To compound the problem of delays in NHS services, those who need acute hospital beds cannot get them, because patients cannot be discharged. Even where performance is better, there is no room for complacency. Kingston and Richmond NHS foundation trust runs Kingston hospital, which many of my constituents use. It discharged 88% of patients with no delay in September, which is better than the national average and a credit to the management and staff there. However, even there, 787 bed days were lost in a single month. Our NHS—I know the Minister is aware of this—is fighting with one arm tied behind its back because we cannot sort out step-down care and adult social care. The Government’s own 10-year health plan talks about getting the most out of the existing NHS estate and bringing care closer to where people live. Molesey is that estate, and Molesey is that care. Letting it decline will be at odds with the Government’s own strategy. There is one more striking point. The data on the number of patients discharged into individual community hospitals is not published in a disaggregated format. How can we hold the Government to account and scrutinise NHS performance if the full data is not shared as a matter of course? We Liberal Democrats have called for thousands of extra step-down and social care packages every week, including in community hospitals, and for a national care agency to end the postcode lottery in care. We want to fix social care and invest in community hospitals, and then free up hospitals, including A&Es and acute care, to do their work, rather than covering for failures in the broader system. I ask the Minister several questions. First, will she look at the discharge-ready date figures in my ICB in Surrey and Sussex and push for improvement? Secondly, will she assure my constituents that Molesey’s essential services will be protected and the estate bettered, and agree that more step-down capacity there could cut discharge delays? Thirdly, what specific support will be given to Surrey and Sussex ICB this winter to improve its performance and cut discharge delays? Princess Alice hospice in Esher announced this week that it will have to make cuts to its services—both in-patient beds and home visits—because of a funding shortfall of £3.5 million. It receives just 20% of its funding from the Government. The rest comes through selling woolly jumpers, essentially, and from donations on the high street, which is not only unsustainable, but wrong. Those cuts and the Princess Alice hospice’s inability to expand its provision put more stress on A&E. I wrote to the Minister about that this week. Will she agree to look into an urgent solution for the Princess Alice hospice, alongside a more long-term sustainable solution for hospice care? As winter approaches, the urgency increases. The people of Molesey and my constituency of Esher and Walton, and the hundreds of people waiting on wards across Surrey and Sussex today, deserve nothing less than step-down care at capacity when it is needed.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Helen Maguire (Epsom and Ewell) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) for securing this important and timely debate on community hospitals and step-down care. Community hospitals are small local hospitals or units providing a range of clinical services to their local population. They have been part of our healthcare system for over 150 years, and there are over 500 operating throughout the UK. They originally developed out of cottage hospitals and sit on a strong tradition of localised care that their communities have known and benefited from for generations. Those cottage hospitals were simply converted cottages with spaces for beds and operations. They were established to prevent patients having to take long journeys to the general hospitals in towns and cities, and to provide local doctor surgeons with a clean space to work. Community hospitals have since developed into hubs of services meeting a range of needs, and they vary considerably as they have adapted to the needs of their local populations. Services may include community beds, clinics, minor injury services, diagnostic facilities, day care, mental health services and maternity care. That strong local tradition remains within community hospitals today, and they continue to be closely connected to their local area. They are therefore perfectly placed to understand local needs and act as an anchor in supporting prevention and the management of long-term conditions. They play an important role in reducing the pressure on larger acute hospitals by supporting early discharge and step-down care, freeing up beds, and reducing A&E demands. By reimagining what we can do with community hospitals, based around the needs of an ageing population and rising complexity, we can make a significant difference to patients. When thousands of people a day are stuck in hospitals, unable to go home because the care they need is not available, it makes no sense to close down community hospitals. Under our A&E plan, the Liberal Democrats would invest in thousands of extra step-down and social care packages every week, including in community hospitals. Community hospitals are particularly important in rural areas, where access to acute hospitals is often limited, as we have heard today. Rural populations frequently face great barriers to access, high delivery costs and persistent workforce shortages. In 2021, the chief medical officer’s annual report on health in coastal communities provided official recognition that rural places are not homogenous. Those living furthest from healthcare services in rural and coastal areas are most at risk of experiencing inequalities, particularly where there are poor and unaffordable transport connections. Since September 2024, the number of delayed patients in community trusts has been notably flat, holding consistently at about 2,150 to 2,300 with little to no variation. Yet we have seen an escalating process of service reductions at many of those hospitals. My hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe mentioned the devastating impact that cutting services in community hospitals across Wales will have, including for those in Powys, Gorseinon and Maesteg. Often the changes are introduced under a façade of trials, yet they almost always become permanent. We understand that pragmatic changes to services are sometime necessary as a result of shifting demand, but they are often done without proper consultation with or explanations for the affected communities. We wholeheartedly agree with the ambition to shift more care into the community—that is important—but reducing services in local community hospitals is at odds with that goal. In fact, the hubs have a vital role to play alongside neighbourhood health centres. It is in the name: community hospitals. I have seen the benefits of community hospitals at first hand. Leatherhead community hospital in my Epsom and Ewell constituency provides more than 33 specific consultation and out-patient services, including a stoma clinic, physiotherapy rehab, and speech and language therapy, for the diverse population that it serves. It is highly valued by the local community and shows the importance of maintaining strong accessibility, continuity of care and patient flows across community health infrastructure. Community hospitals are vital in the provision of those services and we must continue to support them. Whether it is GPs, pharmacies, ambulance services or social care, rural health services have too often been an afterthought, and the same is true for community hospitals. They attract less funding and attention compared with the larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and dilapidated estates. Community hospitals also play a vital role in facilitating step-down care. They support early discharge and step-down care for patients who are medically fit to leave acute hospitals but still need further support to gain independence prior to being fully discharged. Step-down care is vital because it bridges the gap between high-intensity hospital treatment and supporting people to return to living independently in their communities, which in itself prevents readmissions. Ineffective or missing step-down care is too frequent and the costs are too high. That results in delayed discharges, readmissions or improper placements, and it has major financial and human costs. When step-down care fails, patients experience significantly higher rates of emergency readmission. For already vulnerable groups, that is exacerbated. For example, homeless patients who are discharged without proper support face 2.5 times the rate of emergency readmission. At St Helier hospital, 13 out of 18 beds in the reablement unit had to close following the significant deterioration of the 90-year-old building. Structural cracks meant the building literally broke in two. Analysis of NHS England’s October 2024 data shows that the number of bed days lost to delayed discharge has an average monthly cost of about £210 million. Over a whole year, that adds up to a staggering £2 billion in costs to the NHS. NHS England cautions that that calculation is likely to be lower than the true cost, as it does not account for the wider costs associated with the inability to admit new patients. The Liberal Democrats represent those rural communities, and we know all too well the pressure that the system is under there and the important role that community hospitals play. That is why we have long called for a rescue plan for rural health services, in which rural community hospitals are an essential pillar. As part of that, alongside investment in community hospitals and step-down care, we have called for a strategic small surgeries fund to sustain services in rural and remote areas; and a strategy to close the gap in access to primary healthcare between urban and rural areas. We have also called for an emergency fund to reverse closures of community ambulance stations and cancel planned closures where needed, which would particularly benefit rural communities; an end, through a national care agency, to the postcode lottery of care provision, which disproportionately affects rural communities; and a national drive for rural community first responders to protect air ambulances, integrating them into the emergency care system and ensuring that they receive NHS funding in addition to charitable donations. In rural areas, it takes twice as long for people to reach their nearest GP by public transport as in urban areas, and around a third longer by driving, according to the Rural Services Network. Those findings were confirmed by Lord Darzi’s report on the NHS, which found that across much of rural England—including nearly the whole south-west, as well as much of the east of England—there are fewer than 46 dentists per 100,000 people. That is unacceptable, and we must change it. Access to vital community healthcare cannot be dictated by a postcode lottery. Community hospitals receive less funding and attention than larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and run-down estates. The bottom line is that community hospitals and step-down care are a service to us all. They bring multidisciplinary services closer to the community. They bridge the gap between hospitals and GPs. They relieve strain on hospital beds and A&E departments. They support faster discharge and rehabilitation, and help patients to regain that vital independence. They improve healthcare access for elderly and vulnerable patients by reducing the travel burden on patients and their families. I urge the Minister to reflect on all the calls from my colleagues and me during this important debate, because we must ensure that community hospitals and providers of step-down care receive the support they deserve.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Gregory Stafford (Farnham and Bordon) (Con)Conservative

    It is once again a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I congratulate the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing this debate, and I thank the hon. Members who have described the hospitals that their communities love, and their concerns about their future. There are about 500 community hospitals in the UK. For many patients, they are where recovery begins: somewhere to regain strength and independence after an acute ward, before going home. That is step-down care, and I pay tribute to the staff, the leagues of friends and the volunteers who sustain those hospitals, and to the Community Hospitals Association. The case is simple. A patient who is medically fit but still in an acute bed is in the wrong place. They are not getting the best care for their recovery, and they are taking a bed that someone else needs—perhaps someone in A&E or on a trolley in a corridor. In August, an average of 13,704 patients a day who were medically fit to leave were stuck in acute beds. Those are NHS England’s figures, analysed by the Nuffield Trust, which calls discharge delays: “One of the biggest challenges facing the NHS”. The King’s Fund puts last year’s cost at around £2.7 billion, up 7.5%, with almost one hospital bed in 10 taken by someone who does not need to be there. Behind each of those numbers is somebody’s mother, father, grandfather, grandmother or sibling, getting weaker by the day. The situation is getting worse. The Health Service Journal reported this week that the cost of delayed discharges is running above the Government’s projections, and that NHS England has told Ministers that it cannot afford the beds it needs this winter. What is the plan to get a grip on this, and where are the beds going to come from? At Health questions on 20 October, I put that question to the Minister for Secondary Care. I asked why delayed discharges are at an all-time high under this Government, and why the Government are failing so badly at getting people out of hospital and into care, either step-down or at home. The reply was the usual obfuscation and whataboutery. This Government have now been in office for over two years. The Minister did accept that patients being in the wrong place is “not good for their health or their outcomes” —[ Official Report , 20 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 951.] but she gave me no numbers, no date and no plan. She gave me the three shifts, which I welcome because I support care closer to home, but support for the destination is no substitute for a route, and every day without one means somebody lying in the wrong bed. Care cannot be moved into the community without the people to deliver it. In June, the Minister for Secondary Care said that the workforce plan would be published “imminently”. Funnily enough, it was not. Two weeks ago, the Secretary of State told me that it would be in the new year. Patients are waiting, and the Government are clearly not moving with enough alacrity to get this sorted. I see this in my constituency of Farnham and Bordon. When services at in-patient wards in Haslemere hospital were paused in 2025, patients who needed a community bed were offered places elsewhere in the Royal Surrey county hospital’s footprint, including at Milford hospital. I pay tribute to the staff who keep Haslemere going and to the League of Friends of the Haslemere and District Hospital. As other hon. Members have mentioned, access is needed as much as beds. For an older person, someone without a car or someone whose family live far away, getting to care is half the battle. In Farnham, I launched the Hoppa, an accessible door-to-door community transport service that takes residents to Frimley Park, GP surgeries and the Royal Surrey. The town council, the borough council, a local charitable trust and community groups made it happen. I have supported the same service in Haslemere, and I am working with the Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB to extend it across the Hampshire side of my constituency. The Government’s answer is neighbourhood health. They will deliver 250 neighbourhood health centres—the first 120 by 2030, apparently—with £426 million over four years for the primary care estate. As I have said, I have absolutely no quarrel with care closer to home, and I have asked the Health Secretary to make Haslemere, Farnham, and Whitehill and Bordon neighbourhood health centres. However, the Nuffield Trust has questioned whether the framework can be delivered alongside the biggest restructuring of the NHS in a decade. Indeed, GPs voted overwhelmingly against this year’s contract. In June, my hon. Friend the Member for Hinckley and Bosworth (Dr Evans) asked how community hospitals fit into this plan. He was told that they should be seen alongside neighbourhood teams, primary care and social care. That describes a system; it does not say where the beds are. The strategy has no funding line for the community hospitals doing this job today. Ministers say that these are decisions for ICBs, yet the Health Bill removes the duty on commissioners to notify the Secretary of State of a proposed reconfiguration while keeping the power to call them in. The Government cannot say that it is all local and then remove the notification that tells them what the local decisions are. In March, the Department said that it had been notified of just nine notable changes, one of them affecting a community hospital’s beds. How does the Department know what is actually happening to community bed capacity across England? The last Conservative Government expanded community diagnostic centres, with 170 now operating. We built 125 surgical hubs and grew urgent treatment centres and same-day emergency care, all to treat people nearer to home. We want to build on that with a proper intermediate tier that counts community hospitals as part of the answer. Denmark and Norway place intermediate care with a municipality, and Sweden uses small rural facilities for step-down. The money matters too. Every day of delay that is avoided saves about £345 per bed. Even a modest reduction would therefore be worth hundreds of millions of pounds a year to the Exchequer and could be reinvested in the services that we so badly need. On behalf of the Conservatives, I will outline our plans on that in greater detail soon. Today, I ask the Minister six things. First, when will the workforce plan be published? I have raised it on six separate occasions, with three different Health Secretaries, and I hope that the Minister can give me a more concrete answer today than the Secretary of State could two weeks ago. Secondly, what is the plan for step-down capacity this winter? Thirdly, will the Department publish national data on community hospital bed numbers and closures, and keep the duty to notify on reconfigurations in the Health Bill? Fourthly, what role will existing community hospitals play in the 250 neighbourhood health centres, and will any of the £426 million be used to support community hospitals specifically? Fifthly, when will the Government respond to the Carr-Hill review, and how will neighbourhood health reach rural communities? Finally, will the Government recognise community transport as part of the care pathway and package to support community hospitals? Community hospitals earn their place. With beds, staff and a way for people to reach them, they offer some of the best value in the NHS. I look forward to the Minister’s response to those questions and her support for our community hospitals.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. The Minister for Public Health and Patient Safety (Dame Diana Johnson)Labour

    It is a great pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I congratulate the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing this important debate, and I thank all Members who have contributed. As the hon. Gentleman knows, health is a devolved matter, and decisions on NHS Wales services, including in Powys, are for the Welsh Government and the relevant health board. I note that there was a rather lengthy exchange between the hon. Gentleman and the right hon. Member for Dwyfor Meirionnydd (Liz Saville Roberts), who leads Plaid Cymru in Westminster. I do not want to intrude too much on the private grief in that corner of the Chamber, but I would expect Members’ concerns about access to healthcare in their constituencies to be taken very seriously. As an English Health Minister, I will always meet Members to discuss their concerns. I recognise that communities along the border use services on both sides of it, and that obviously matters to the hon. Gentleman’s constituents. Arrangements are in place between England and Wales to ensure that patients who live near the border can access timely and appropriate care regardless of the administrative boundaries. Responsibility for that sits with the ICBs in England and with the local health boards in Wales. The UK Government continue to work closely with the Welsh Government on areas of shared interest, including improving health outcomes and addressing common challenges across our health systems. While recognising the cross-border connections, I will focus my remarks on healthcare provision in England, as Members would expect. The debate has been a really good opportunity to discuss how we can deliver more care closer to home, as we have set out in the 10-year health plan, and the important role that community hospitals can play in delivering that vision. As we have heard, community hospitals have a long and proud history. For more than 150 years they have provided local, accessible care that is adapted for the communities they serve. Hon. Members have spoken this morning about their local community hospitals in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, and I was pleased that we also heard reference to the chief medical officer’s excellent annual report, “Health in Rural Areas and Small Towns”, in which he specifically mentioned the important role of community hospitals in ensuring access to health services in rural areas and small towns. Community hospitals play a key role in delivering step-down and intermediate care, thereby ensuring that patients receive care in the right place for them. While this is hugely beneficial to patients, there are also benefits to the wider health and care system when community and intermediate care work as they should. If we can move patients safely out of an acute bed when they no longer need that level of care, that bed will be available for those who need it, thereby improving the flow in the hospital and relieving the pressures in emergency departments and ambulance handovers. I am happy to look into the concerns raised by the hon. Member for Esher and Walton (Monica Harding) about discharge delays and step-down care in her constituency.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    The health trusts on the English side of the border in Herefordshire and Shropshire have expressed their concern multiple times, including to the Welsh Affairs Committee, about the impact of decisions by the Powys teaching health board on them and their ability to provide services to patients. Will the Minister tell us in more concrete detail the plans to fix the problems with cross-border healthcare, including in respect of medical record sharing?

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Dame Diana JohnsonLabour

    Discussions are being held among the relevant authorities. I do not have a detailed read-out of the results of those discussions, but it is important that the Welsh Government, the ICBs and the UK Government have those conversations. Making sure that patients can access healthcare as close to home as possible should be at the heart of this. We would all want those discussions to focus on that. It is important to recognise what these hospitals mean to the communities they serve, which rely on them. It is right to recognise that they are staffed by dedicated nurses, therapists, doctors and care staff, supported in many cases by volunteers and local charities. Many have been woven into local life for generations, and I want to put on the record my thanks to everyone who works in or supports a community hospital.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. Monica HardingLiberal Democrat

    Will the Minister congratulate community groups such as the League of Friends of Molesey Hospital that keep those hospitals front and centre of the community and fight for them?

    View contribution permalink →

  28. Dame Diana JohnsonLabour

    I absolutely agree with the hon. Lady and pay tribute to those groups. As we are talking about the workforce, I want to respond to the shadow Minister, the hon. Member for Farnham and Bordon (Gregory Stafford), who raised the issue of the long-awaited workforce plan. We need to get the plan right, which is why it is taking some time, but I gently point out to him that in the 14 years his party was in power, it failed to ever produce a workforce plan for the NHS.

    View contribution permalink →

  29. Gregory StaffordConservative

    Will the Minister give way?

    View contribution permalink →

  30. Dame Diana JohnsonLabour

    I am very happy to give way, but I was in Parliament for those 14 years, so I know jolly well what happened.

    View contribution permalink →

  31. Gregory StaffordConservative

    The Minister may have missed this, but we did produce a workforce plan. The whole point of the new Government’s workforce plan is to update the Conservative one, so I think she needs to check the record.

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Dame Diana JohnsonLabour

    I will go away and check that, but for many, many years the Labour Opposition were arguing that we needed a proper workforce plan. I will check whether one was produced, but it took many years of badgering the Conservative Government to take what most of us think is a sensible approach to workforce planning. On the shadow Minister’s point about the Carr-Hill formula review, work is ongoing to look at the best distribution of funding for GP practices. Let me turn to neighbourhood health, which has been talked about a lot. It is very clear that our ambition is to move out of hospitals and into local communities, and neighbourhood health is at the heart of that ambition. It is about bringing together teams from across the NHS, local government and the voluntary sector to improve the health and care of the people living in the area. We published the neighbourhood health framework in March this year to help local leaders to develop and scale neighbourhood health services. Through the medium-term planning framework, systems are required to set out how they will shift activity from hospital to community. That ambition is why we will deliver 250 neighbourhood health centres, with 120 of those opening by 2030. We want to make it easier for people to access care closer to where they live up and down the country. The centres will provide easier, more convenient access to a wide range of health and care services on people’s doorsteps, with a neighbourhood health centre in every community. Community hospitals play an important part in the wider community health service landscape. We know that we need strong community health services to support our ambitions for the NHS, which is why we have set clear guidance through the medium-term planning framework specifically on community health services. For the first time, we have set a target to reduce long waits for community health services. By 2028-29, at least 80% of community health service activity should take place within 18 weeks, bringing community health services in line with targets for elective care. To help to reduce variation and improve access to community health services, we have set out a clear expectation of the community health services that ICBs should be commissioning. “Standardising community health services”, published in 2025, with further details added in 2026, provides an overview of the community health services that ICBs should be commissioning. That is hugely important. We want to increase community health service capacity to meet growth in demand. Members have raised issues such as the development of housing estates and how important it is to have provision for the additional families who will reside there. We expect that the growth in demand will be around 3% nationally per year, and we need to address that. We are also taking action to reduce unwarranted variation, to cut waits and to improve access to high-quality community services, as the hon. Member for South Cotswolds (Dr Savage) asked the Government to do. On step-down and intermediate care, timely discharge into the right setting matters enormously for patients, and for the NHS to function properly and efficiently. I recognise that capacity is not evenly distributed across the country. Some areas have strong intermediate care offers and others have gaps. The pressure is felt most acutely in places where rural geography makes alternatives harder to arrange. We will address that by ensuring that intermediate care is planned properly at a local level, as part of the neighbourhood health plans, and by being clear that ICBs are accountable for commissioning to meet the needs of their populations. Decisions on how services are configured must be made locally, and they must be accompanied by appropriate engagement with patients, staff and local communities. We all know about the pressures on the NHS across much of the country, including an ageing population, the increasing prevalence of long-term conditions, growing demand for rehabilitation and recovery services and, in some areas, significant population growth driven by new housing development.

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Helen MaguireLiberal Democrat

    One of the paths that we have been developing is to ensure that there are sufficient GPs when houses are at the planning stage. Does the Minister agree that it is important that new housing developments of 1,000 homes or whatever are not proposed unless there are the GP services to support them?

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Dame Diana JohnsonLabour

    Recognising the needs of growing communities should be part of the planning that ICBs are involved in. I absolutely accept that that needs to be taken into account. The pressures on the NHS make local community-based services more important, not less. Meeting the challenges will require strong joined-up community services, including community nursing, therapies, rehabilitation, urgent community response, virtual wards, primary care and social care, all working together around the needs of patients. Ultimately, the future of community hospitals should not be considered in isolation; they form part of the broader community health infrastructure, which includes neighbourhood health teams, community providers, primary care, mental health services, social care and the voluntary sector. The question is not simply how many community hospitals we have, but how we use community assets and services to provide high-quality care closer to home. I am grateful to the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe for bringing this issue to the House. Community hospitals and step-down care matter to patients, families and the wider NHS system. They have an important role in the neighbourhood-based model we are building. As we continue our work to strengthen neighbourhood health services and shift care closer to home, the experiences and concerns raised by Members today will make an important contribution to the discussion. I again thank all Members who participated in the debate.

    View contribution permalink →

  35. David ChadwickLiberal Democrat

    This debate has been a timely and urgent opportunity to raise the frustrations and concerns of communities across Powys that fear for the future of their community hospitals, which were built by communities for communities, often before the NHS existed. People took the initiative to address their own concerns, and now groups such as the League of Friends of the Llandrindod Wells Hospital, the Knighton Hospital and Community League of Friends and groups for other community hospitals across Powys fear that the fundraising they have generated over the years and decades and poured into their local community hospitals might all have been for nothing if those services are taken away by Health Ministers or health boards that are further away. That is why we have to restore local transparency and accountability over healthcare services across the United Kingdom, and definitely in Wales. I thank the Minister for her remarks. I urge her to look at the cross-border impacts of the decision. If the Powys community hospitals disappear, the beds will end up on the English side of the border. There is a lot to be done to improve public transport options for people and to share medical records between England and Wales. If people are discharged from a hospital in Hereford to receive palliative care in Wales, they and their families desperately need their records to follow them. Question put and agreed to. Resolved, That this House has considered community hospitals and step-down care.

    View contribution permalink →

  36. Sitting suspended.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440363.