Contribution
It is once again a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I congratulate the hon. Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) on securing this debate, and I thank the hon. Members who have described the hospitals that their communities love, and their concerns about their future.
There are about 500 community hospitals in the UK. For many patients, they are where recovery begins: somewhere to regain strength and independence after an acute ward, before going home. That is step-down care, and I pay tribute to the staff, the leagues of friends and the volunteers who sustain those hospitals, and to the Community Hospitals Association.
The case is simple. A patient who is medically fit but still in an acute bed is in the wrong place. They are not getting the best care for their recovery, and they are taking a bed that someone else needs—perhaps someone in A&E or on a trolley in a corridor. In August, an average of 13,704 patients a day who were medically fit to leave were stuck in acute beds. Those are NHS England’s figures, analysed by the Nuffield Trust, which calls discharge delays:
“One of the biggest challenges facing the NHS”.
The King’s Fund puts last year’s cost at around £2.7 billion, up 7.5%, with almost one hospital bed in 10 taken by someone who does not need to be there. Behind each of those numbers is somebody’s mother, father, grandfather, grandmother or sibling, getting weaker by the day.
The situation is getting worse. The Health Service Journal reported this week that the cost of delayed discharges is running above the Government’s projections, and that NHS England has told Ministers that it cannot afford the beds it needs this winter. What is the plan to get a grip on this, and where are the beds going to come from?
At Health questions on 20 October, I put that question to the Minister for Secondary Care. I asked why delayed discharges are at an all-time high under this Government, and why the Government are failing so badly at getting people out of hospital and into care, either step-down or at home. The reply was the usual obfuscation and whataboutery. This Government have now been in office for over two years. The Minister did accept that patients being in the wrong place is
“not good for their health or their outcomes”—[Official Report, 20 October 2026; Vol. 791, c. 951.]
but she gave me no numbers, no date and no plan. She gave me the three shifts, which I welcome because I support care closer to home, but support for the destination is no substitute for a route, and every day without one means somebody lying in the wrong bed.
Care cannot be moved into the community without the people to deliver it. In June, the Minister for Secondary Care said that the workforce plan would be published “imminently”. Funnily enough, it was not. Two weeks ago, the Secretary of State told me that it would be in the new year. Patients are waiting, and the Government are clearly not moving with enough alacrity to get this sorted.
I see this in my constituency of Farnham and Bordon. When services at in-patient wards in Haslemere hospital were paused in 2025, patients who needed a community bed were offered places elsewhere in the Royal Surrey county hospital’s footprint, including at Milford hospital. I pay tribute to the staff who keep Haslemere going and to the League of Friends of the Haslemere and District Hospital.
As other hon. Members have mentioned, access is needed as much as beds. For an older person, someone without a car or someone whose family live far away, getting to care is half the battle. In Farnham, I launched the Hoppa, an accessible door-to-door community transport service that takes residents to Frimley Park, GP surgeries and the Royal Surrey. The town council, the borough council, a local charitable trust and community groups made it happen. I have supported the same service in Haslemere, and I am working with the Hampshire and Isle of Wight ICB to extend it across the Hampshire side of my constituency.
The Government’s answer is neighbourhood health. They will deliver 250 neighbourhood health centres—the first 120 by 2030, apparently—with £426 million over four years for the primary care estate. As I have said, I have absolutely no quarrel with care closer to home, and I have asked the Health Secretary to make Haslemere, Farnham, and Whitehill and Bordon neighbourhood health centres. However, the Nuffield Trust has questioned whether the framework can be delivered alongside the biggest restructuring of the NHS in a decade.
Indeed, GPs voted overwhelmingly against this year’s contract. In June, my hon. Friend the Member for Hinckley and Bosworth (Dr Evans) asked how community hospitals fit into this plan. He was told that they should be seen alongside neighbourhood teams, primary care and social care. That describes a system; it does not say where the beds are. The strategy has no funding line for the community hospitals doing this job today.
Ministers say that these are decisions for ICBs, yet the Health Bill removes the duty on commissioners to notify the Secretary of State of a proposed reconfiguration while keeping the power to call them in. The Government cannot say that it is all local and then remove the notification that tells them what the local decisions are. In March, the Department said that it had been notified of just nine notable changes, one of them affecting a community hospital’s beds. How does the Department know what is actually happening to community bed capacity across England?
The last Conservative Government expanded community diagnostic centres, with 170 now operating. We built 125 surgical hubs and grew urgent treatment centres and same-day emergency care, all to treat people nearer to home. We want to build on that with a proper intermediate tier that counts community hospitals as part of the answer. Denmark and Norway place intermediate care with a municipality, and Sweden uses small rural facilities for step-down.
The money matters too. Every day of delay that is avoided saves about £345 per bed. Even a modest reduction would therefore be worth hundreds of millions of pounds a year to the Exchequer and could be reinvested in the services that we so badly need. On behalf of the Conservatives, I will outline our plans on that in greater detail soon.
Today, I ask the Minister six things. First, when will the workforce plan be published? I have raised it on six separate occasions, with three different Health Secretaries, and I hope that the Minister can give me a more concrete answer today than the Secretary of State could two weeks ago. Secondly, what is the plan for step-down capacity this winter? Thirdly, will the Department publish national data on community hospital bed numbers and closures, and keep the duty to notify on reconfigurations in the Health Bill? Fourthly, what role will existing community hospitals play in the 250 neighbourhood health centres, and will any of the £426 million be used to support community hospitals specifically? Fifthly, when will the Government respond to the Carr-Hill review, and how will neighbourhood health reach rural communities? Finally, will the Government recognise community transport as part of the care pathway and package to support community hospitals?
Community hospitals earn their place. With beds, staff and a way for people to reach them, they offer some of the best value in the NHS. I look forward to the Minister’s response to those questions and her support for our community hospitals.