Contribution
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe (David Chadwick) for securing this important and timely debate on community hospitals and step-down care.
Community hospitals are small local hospitals or units providing a range of clinical services to their local population. They have been part of our healthcare system for over 150 years, and there are over 500 operating throughout the UK. They originally developed out of cottage hospitals and sit on a strong tradition of localised care that their communities have known and benefited from for generations. Those cottage hospitals were simply converted cottages with spaces for beds and operations. They were established to prevent patients having to take long journeys to the general hospitals in towns and cities, and to provide local doctor surgeons with a clean space to work.
Community hospitals have since developed into hubs of services meeting a range of needs, and they vary considerably as they have adapted to the needs of their local populations. Services may include community beds, clinics, minor injury services, diagnostic facilities, day care, mental health services and maternity care. That strong local tradition remains within community hospitals today, and they continue to be closely connected to their local area. They are therefore perfectly placed to understand local needs and act as an anchor in supporting prevention and the management of long-term conditions. They play an important role in reducing the pressure on larger acute hospitals by supporting early discharge and step-down care, freeing up beds, and reducing A&E demands. By reimagining what we can do with community hospitals, based around the needs of an ageing population and rising complexity, we can make a significant difference to patients.
When thousands of people a day are stuck in hospitals, unable to go home because the care they need is not available, it makes no sense to close down community hospitals. Under our A&E plan, the Liberal Democrats would invest in thousands of extra step-down and social care packages every week, including in community hospitals.
Community hospitals are particularly important in rural areas, where access to acute hospitals is often limited, as we have heard today. Rural populations frequently face great barriers to access, high delivery costs and persistent workforce shortages. In 2021, the chief medical officer’s annual report on health in coastal communities provided official recognition that rural places are not homogenous. Those living furthest from healthcare services in rural and coastal areas are most at risk of experiencing inequalities, particularly where there are poor and unaffordable transport connections.
Since September 2024, the number of delayed patients in community trusts has been notably flat, holding consistently at about 2,150 to 2,300 with little to no variation. Yet we have seen an escalating process of service reductions at many of those hospitals. My hon. Friend the Member for Brecon, Radnor and Cwm Tawe mentioned the devastating impact that cutting services in community hospitals across Wales will have, including for those in Powys, Gorseinon and Maesteg. Often the changes are introduced under a façade of trials, yet they almost always become permanent.
We understand that pragmatic changes to services are sometime necessary as a result of shifting demand, but they are often done without proper consultation with or explanations for the affected communities. We wholeheartedly agree with the ambition to shift more care into the community—that is important—but reducing services in local community hospitals is at odds with that goal. In fact, the hubs have a vital role to play alongside neighbourhood health centres. It is in the name: community hospitals.
I have seen the benefits of community hospitals at first hand. Leatherhead community hospital in my Epsom and Ewell constituency provides more than 33 specific consultation and out-patient services, including a stoma clinic, physiotherapy rehab, and speech and language therapy, for the diverse population that it serves. It is highly valued by the local community and shows the importance of maintaining strong accessibility, continuity of care and patient flows across community health infrastructure. Community hospitals are vital in the provision of those services and we must continue to support them.
Whether it is GPs, pharmacies, ambulance services or social care, rural health services have too often been an afterthought, and the same is true for community hospitals. They attract less funding and attention compared with the larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and dilapidated estates.
Community hospitals also play a vital role in facilitating step-down care. They support early discharge and step-down care for patients who are medically fit to leave acute hospitals but still need further support to gain independence prior to being fully discharged. Step-down care is vital because it bridges the gap between high-intensity hospital treatment and supporting people to return to living independently in their communities, which in itself prevents readmissions.
Ineffective or missing step-down care is too frequent and the costs are too high. That results in delayed discharges, readmissions or improper placements, and it has major financial and human costs. When step-down care fails, patients experience significantly higher rates of emergency readmission. For already vulnerable groups, that is exacerbated. For example, homeless patients who are discharged without proper support face 2.5 times the rate of emergency readmission. At St Helier hospital, 13 out of 18 beds in the reablement unit had to close following the significant deterioration of the 90-year-old building. Structural cracks meant the building literally broke in two.
Analysis of NHS England’s October 2024 data shows that the number of bed days lost to delayed discharge has an average monthly cost of about £210 million. Over a whole year, that adds up to a staggering £2 billion in costs to the NHS. NHS England cautions that that calculation is likely to be lower than the true cost, as it does not account for the wider costs associated with the inability to admit new patients.
The Liberal Democrats represent those rural communities, and we know all too well the pressure that the system is under there and the important role that community hospitals play. That is why we have long called for a rescue plan for rural health services, in which rural community hospitals are an essential pillar. As part of that, alongside investment in community hospitals and step-down care, we have called for a strategic small surgeries fund to sustain services in rural and remote areas; and a strategy to close the gap in access to primary healthcare between urban and rural areas.
We have also called for an emergency fund to reverse closures of community ambulance stations and cancel planned closures where needed, which would particularly benefit rural communities; an end, through a national care agency, to the postcode lottery of care provision, which disproportionately affects rural communities; and a national drive for rural community first responders to protect air ambulances, integrating them into the emergency care system and ensuring that they receive NHS funding in addition to charitable donations.
In rural areas, it takes twice as long for people to reach their nearest GP by public transport as in urban areas, and around a third longer by driving, according to the Rural Services Network. Those findings were confirmed by Lord Darzi’s report on the NHS, which found that across much of rural England—including nearly the whole south-west, as well as much of the east of England—there are fewer than 46 dentists per 100,000 people. That is unacceptable, and we must change it. Access to vital community healthcare cannot be dictated by a postcode lottery. Community hospitals receive less funding and attention than larger acute hospitals, resulting in workforce shortages and run-down estates.
The bottom line is that community hospitals and step-down care are a service to us all. They bring multidisciplinary services closer to the community. They bridge the gap between hospitals and GPs. They relieve strain on hospital beds and A&E departments. They support faster discharge and rehabilitation, and help patients to regain that vital independence. They improve healthcare access for elderly and vulnerable patients by reducing the travel burden on patients and their families. I urge the Minister to reflect on all the calls from my colleagues and me during this important debate, because we must ensure that community hospitals and providers of step-down care receive the support they deserve.