Rural Connectivity
Wednesday, 18 November 2026
Contributions
Karl Turner (in the Chair)Labour
I will call Henry Tufnell to move the motion; I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other Members that they may make a speech only with prior permission from the Member in charge of the debate and from the Minister. As I understand it, only one other Member has that consent. As is the convention for 30-minute debates, there will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up. I remind Members that interventions must be short.
Henry Tufnell (Mid and South Pembrokeshire) (Lab)Labour
I beg to move, That this House has considered telecommunications connectivity in rural areas. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Turner. Reliable broadband and mobile signal are not luxuries; they are essential for work, education, public services and everyday life. Yet in many rural communities, such as those in my constituency, such connectivity is still lacking. Analysis of Ofcom data reveals that mine ranks 444th out of 650 constituencies in the UK for mobile service quality. Just 1% of premises in my constituency have high-quality 5G stand-alone signal, compared with 86% nationally. Those numbers are staggering and the consequences of such poor connectivity are felt every day by my constituents.
Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party
Poor connectivity is not only a problem in the hon. Gentleman’s constituency—it is the same in mine. However, we are fortunate to have a company called Fibrus, which does tremendous work across Northern Ireland. Does he agree that the Government must back proven providers such as Fibrus with sustained and targeted funding, and thereby address the very issues to which he is referring?
Henry TufnellLabour
I agree that the Government must do more; I will come on to that point later in my speech. I thank the hon. Gentleman for his intervention. Tenby is one of Pembrokeshire’s largest towns and is a world-renowned tourist destination, yet it continues to suffer from persistent mobile notspots, particularly during the busy spring and summer months. Visitors struggle to use parking apps, businesses lose sales when card payment systems fail and residents are unable to access essential online services. I will say that today we have had positive news: O2 has announced that there will be eight outdoor small cells in place before the busy summer season next year, which will be some small consolation to the 5,000 people who live in Tenby and to the 70,000 people who regularly visit it. As I say, that is positive news—perhaps it reflects the timing of this Westminster Hall debate. Essential services are also impacted by poor connectivity. Community nurses can struggle to make calls while carrying out visits, transport apps become unusable, schools face barriers in accessing online learning resources and businesses are unable to take full advantage of digital opportunities. Across the county, poor broadband and mobile coverage are limiting economic growth and preventing people from taking up jobs that depend on reliable remote working. I have spent many months pressing mobile operators, infrastructure providers, the local authority and Ministers for action.
Rachel Gilmour (Tiverton and Minehead) (LD)Liberal Democrat
In my constituency, St George’s church in Dunster could host a mast without harming the historical fabric of the building, providing coverage for around 1,000 residents and visitors. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that often the real obstacle in rural areas is not the availability of signal, but securing the commitment of mobile network operators in those areas?
Henry TufnellLabour
I agree with the hon. Member that the pace of progress is too often far too slow. I recognise the issues that she has raised regarding her own constituency; I have made repeated representations to VodafoneThree about the severity of the problem in Tenby in particular, and there is a planned upgrade to a key mast that serves the town, but it will not be completed until 2028. For residents and businesspeople who continue to struggle with inadequate coverage every day, that is simply not good enough.
Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)Liberal Democrat
The hon. Member is setting out challenges in his constituency that are replicated in mine. Does he agree that it is outrageous that rural connectivity in France and Spain is better than the connectivity here in central London?
Henry TufnellLabour
The hon. Member is right. We too often face that rural premium, where rural areas get left behind and forgotten about while those upgrades happen in urban areas. That is not acceptable for her constituents or mine. I look forward to the publication later this year of the Government’s mobile market review, which will assess whether the current market structure is delivering the investment needed to improve mobile connectivity. For communities such as mine in Pembrokeshire, where coverage remains among the worst in the country, the test of that review must be whether it leads to faster investment, better coverage and an end to rural areas being left behind.
Perran Moon (Camborne and Redruth) (Ind)Independent
In Cornwall, we are 638th out of 650 constituencies for mobile coverage. On average nationally, 38% of premises choose between all four networks for a high-quality 5G non-stand-alone signal. In Camborne, Redruth and Hale that figure is zero. If consumers have nowhere to switch to, operators have next to no competitive impetus to improve quality. Does my right hon. Friend agree that one of the remedies for this absence of competition—and one way to incentivise proper investment in Cornwall—would be for Ofcom to make full spectrum licences conditional on robust performance standards?
Karl Turner (in the Chair)Labour
Order. I asked Members for short interventions.
Henry TufnellLabour
I thank my hon. Friend for promoting me—I am not a right hon. Member—but I agree that we are too often in the situation of comparing how bad our constituencies are, and that we need organisations such as Ofcom to really grasp the nettle to make sure that this is not a race to the bottom in that sense. On that point, I urge the Minister to make sure that communities such as ours in Cornwall and west Wales are placed at the forefront of the Government’s efforts to improve telecommunications connectivity. The stakes are only becoming higher. From next year, the UK’s landline network will be switched from analogue copper lines to digital services that rely on broadband.
Chris Kane (Stirling and Strathallan) (Lab)Labour
I have recently been surveying villages across my constituency about this issue, and I was struck by what I heard from one constituent, Margaret. She informed me that she was unable to use her mobile emergency care button due to poor signal. Does my hon. Friend agree that the elderly are put at real risk by failings in this area?
Henry TufnellLabour
I agree. The actions taken will leave vulnerable constituents at greater risk, and leave rural areas with poor rural connectivity particularly exposed. During Storm Darragh, which affected my constituency in 2024, some homes in Pembrokeshire were left without power for nearly a week, yet the recommended minimum battery back-up for digital landline services is just one hour.
Mr Alistair Carmichael (Orkney and Shetland) (LD)Liberal Democrat
We were given categoric assurance that there would be back-up power sources at the mobile phone masts when those copper landlines were withdrawn. That has manifestly not happened. Does the hon. Member agree that it is for the regulator to ensure that its promises are kept?
Henry TufnellLabour
The right hon. Member’s point is well made. Prolonged outages leave both his constituents and mine completely cut off and unable to contact family members or emergency services—something that is particularly important when we are dealing with severe weather events. That lack of connectivity is compounded by digital exclusion. More than a quarter of my constituents are aged 65 or older and nearly half are over the age of 50. AbilityNet is a fantastic organisation offering free advice and support for older people and those living with disability to help them access and use technology. As more and more of our essential services move online, such organisations are crucial to ensuring that no one is left behind.
Lee Pitcher (Doncaster East and the Isle of Axholme) (Lab)Labour
I have a disabled constituent who lives in a rural community and has been trying to connect to the Openreach network for months. They had brain surgery, and they asked Openreach not to come during that time—yet they still do not have connectivity. Does my hon. Friend agree that we need to ensure that, when people are in such situations, providers support them to get set up?
Henry TufnellLabour
I completely agree with my hon. Friend; he makes a really important point, and I am sorry to hear about the situation facing his constituent. AbilityNet has funding from BT, but unfortunately that is due to end next summer, which means that constituents such as my hon. Friend’s and mine will face the huge issue of digital exclusion—and all at the same time as BT stands to make up to £2 billion in windfall profits from selling off the old copper cabling.
Dave Robertson (Lichfield) (Lab)Labour
My hon. Friend is making a great speech about the importance of connectivity to rural areas like the ones in our constituencies. Does he share my concern about the number of landowners who are issuing notices to quit and having masts removed from their land? The Government need to take that seriously and protect what we have, while also rolling out more.
Henry TufnellLabour
I thank my hon. Friend for making that point. The Government need to use every avenue they can to boost connectivity, and working with farmers and landowners is essential to make that happen. May I conclude by asking the Minister what steps his Department is taking to ensure that this money is being reinvested in supporting constituencies like mine, so that no rural community is left behind?
Torcuil Crichton (Na h-Eileanan an Iar) (Lab)Labour
It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mr Turner. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire (Henry Tufnell) for securing this important debate, and I thank him and the Minister for allowing me to be part of the discussion. Resilience is the definition of island living, but in Na h-Eileanan an Iar recently we have encountered major problems with connectivity thanks to the move from copper line to digital. It means that when the power goes out, as it did in Harris recently, so do the telephone lines, the mobile phones and the internet connection. The digital back-up provided to vulnerable customers—a hybrid battery pack—simply is not adequate. Provision is patchy, to say the least, understanding of the system is limited and in any case a four-hour or one-hour battery pack is no good in a 48-hour storm, particularly when the mobile phone mast has no battery or diesel back-up either. To find answers to this connectivity problem, along with Donald MacKinnon, the MSP for Na h-Eileanan an Iar, and the South Harris community council, I convened a resilience meeting last Friday—irony of ironies, it was the day of the Microsoft outage, but the telephone companies and digital service providers were none the less able to attend. It was very useful and a good template for community resilience. Solutions are being found. The community is rising to the challenge, dusting off old preparedness documents and finding first responders who will go out when the digital signal goes down. It is a work in progress. It requires commitment from communities, but it also requires commitment and obligations from the telecoms providers. Under the Civil Contingencies Act 2004, telecoms providers are category 2 responders. They are required by the Government and Ofcom, as the right hon. Member for Orkney and Shetland (Mr Carmichael) pointed out, to ensure network security, maintain uninterrupted access to 999 emergency services and provide emergency power back-ups to vulnerable users. There are two things the Minister could commit to today. One is to ensure proper enforcement of those requirements, so that mobile masts have generator or battery back-up themselves and the battery pack that goes to consumers is not simply a box in a black plastic wrapper that is left unopened in a vulnerable consumer’s house. Phone companies should be obliged to give one-to-one instructions and reassurance, to ensure that vulnerable customers—who often rely on an emergency care button, as my hon. Friend the Member for Stirling and Strathallan (Chris Kane) pointed out—know how to operate those battery packs. Secondly, and most importantly, it is vital that phone companies and mobile phone mast providers are forced to come to the table and to be part of the response in an emergency or an outage. I would like to see the Civil Contingencies Act changed so that phone companies become category 1 responders and are required to attend local and national resilience meetings and be embedded in civil contingency responses. That way, the mobile phone mast companies will be there with everyone else in the room ahead of the storm, maybe in the same Land Rover as the power companies going out and fixing the masts after the storm, to ensure that our rural and island communities stay connected in the worst that the weather can throw at us, because, as everyone knows, the weather we have now is the best weather we are going to see in our lifetime.
The Minister for Creative Industries, Media and Online Safety (Ian Murray)Labour
It is great to have you in the Chair for this debate, Mr Turner. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire (Henry Tufnell) on securing it: the tenacity with which he has continued to push the issue in his constituency has been of great benefit to every rural constituency across the country. I hope that the news from Virgin Media O2 that broke just as we walked into this Chamber, about what is happening in Tenby, is a direct result of this debate being on the agenda, and that the company has moved quickly because of it. Hopefully, those 10 mobile sites will help the 5,000 people in Tenby, as well as all the visitors who go there. My hon. Friend is right to say that access to high-quality, reliable and secure digital connectivity is not a luxury, but part of the internal fabric of everything that we do. It is as important as energy and water, as interventions from hon. Members representing constituencies across the country have shown. It is how people stay in touch, how businesses grow and how the opportunities of the modern economy spread to every part of the country. If an area does not have connectivity as good as we would expect anywhere in the country, it could be hampered in economic growth. The Prime Minister has challenged us all to deliver good growth in every postcode. For that, we need good connectivity in every postcode, because it underpins what we need to do on our economy. The impact on communities of poor mobile connectivity, which my hon. Friend laid out, should not be underestimated. For most of us, staying connected to modern life starts with the phone in our pocket—although the phone signal in my flat in central Edinburgh is dreadful, so maybe my hon. Friend the Member for Edinburgh South West (Dr Arthur) needs to stop campaigning against phone masts. What matters to people is whether they can make calls for work, use data reliably, access services, stay connected to others and have that security blanket that we have heard about in relation to the emergency services and the emergency call buttons that elderly people use. I understand that my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire has experienced very poor coverage in his constituency, but there is positive work going on. Perhaps I could share some of it with him, because it is recent and is not yet reflected in the Ofcom coverage statistics, which are about six or seven months behind. BT has eight mast upgrades planned in his constituency, two of which will be completed this year and the remaining six next year. I do not know whether he was aware of that. We have already spoken about what Virgin Media O2 is doing in Tenby centre. He was right to say that only 1% of his constituency has stand-alone 5G, but the figures from Vodafone tell us that 50% should now have it through the Vodafone network, and Vodafone plans to take that to over 90% within the next 18 months. It would be interesting to get feedback from my hon. Friend on that after this debate. We fully understand that the experience on the ground does not necessarily reflect the figures that Ofcom uses and that there is a lag in those figures, but it seems to me that there is significant progress, and that is down to the tenacity of my hon. Friend.
Ben Lake (Ceredigion Preseli) (PC)Plaid Cymru
Much progress has also been made in my constituency. With that in mind, the Minister will be aware of concerns about the digital switchover of the old copper landlines. I appreciate that the January 2027 deadline is an industry one, but is there a way of extending it for mobile notspots so that the landline is decommissioned only when the mobile signal has arrived?
Ian MurrayLabour
I will come back to that point later, if I may, because a number of hon. Members have raised the switchover, particularly in relation to 2G connectivity, but the hon. Gentleman is right to raise it. We have big ambitions on connectivity and are having to work very closely with the industry to make sure that they are delivered. I think everyone in this debate, including the Government, is of the same view: we need to get this sorted, and as quickly as possible. By 2030, we want people across the UK to see tangible improvements in connectivity in their everyday life, and we want economic growth and opportunity to be more widely shared. As part of that, we have ambitions for high-quality stand-alone 5G connectivity everywhere by 2030—in villages and rural communities, as well as towns and cities—and that must be delivered commercially, without Government subsidy. All three mobile network operators have committed to significant investment plans that align with those ambitions. Hearing local constituents’ experiences through their representatives in this place is how we can determine whether it is being rolled out, and rolled out quickly enough. We fully share the ambitions to push on as quickly as possible and to see those deadlines not as a target but as the backstop, with everything done much more quickly. Although stand-alone 5G is already available outside 93% of premises across the UK, we understand that we need to go much further, particularly in constituencies such as Mid and South Pembrokeshire, and we continue to work with operators to support that.
Chris KaneLabour
In Cowie in my constituency, there is one street that does not get any signal, while the rest of the village does. When people get a taxi home, the taxi driver will not drop them off at their door, because they cannot get the mobile payment to operate. Delivery drivers also get lost. Even within villages, there can be single streets that do not get connectivity, so we need to look at this at a granular level as well.
Ian MurrayLabour
That is really important for the economy and businesses. It is not just about the streets in my hon. Friend’s constituency; if a cab parks in a car park and there is no connectivity, they cannot take payment, which is great for the passenger but not necessarily for the driver. That is why it is so important for the economy and for everything to be connected in a way that feeds into everything, from businesses and taxis to emergency responses.
Jim ShannonDemocratic Unionist Party
Should we not recognise broadband providers like those to whom I referred in my earlier intervention, who do good work and deliver on all the tasks that they are purposed with, compared with those who are perhaps not as assiduous or as careful when it comes to replying to complaints?
Ian MurrayLabour
I agree. We see this almost through a rural, topographical or digital inclusion lens, but it is everywhere in the country. Whether we are in central Stirling, in central Edinburgh, which I represent, or in rural Wales or Northern Ireland, there will be notspots, so we have to make sure that there is coverage everywhere. It is about quality coverage and about having resilience in that coverage. Despite all that, the Government acknowledge that there are still areas with no access to mobile connectivity at all. Technological developments such as direct-to-device satellite technology are a potential solution; some platforms already offer that. In fact, I saw an O2 advert on Channel 4 last night that was advertising its new contracts for direct-to-device satellite technology. Lessons have been learned from the delivery of the shared network programme, which is hugely successful and has demonstrated where there are better solutions that can be used, including in high deployment areas. Developments in the market are very positive, but I fully understand the pressure to make sure that we can get it done. I will touch on the PSTN switch-off and the issues raised by my hon. Friend the Member for Stirling and Strathallan (Chris Kane) and others. The digital switchover was a major undertaking that started almost a decade ago. It is already improving resilience and reliability. Over 96% of the original 35 million landlines have already been migrated from analogue to digital. In November 2024, the Government secured additional measures to protect customers. The safeguards include prioritising the identification of vulnerable multiple communication customers, free engineer visits and free battery back-up devices. In the event of a power outage, digital service providers of fibre are much more resilient than traditional copper landlines.
Alison BennettLiberal Democrat
About six months ago, I received a letter from Baroness Lloyd saying that the gigabit broadband project, which was providing a Government subsidy to get broadband connected to rural areas, was being re-scoped. Can the Minister provide an update on that?
Ian MurrayLabour
Although the Building Digital UK project should cover 99% of the country by 2032, that is still the ambition. We are now turning our attention to the last 1%. There are the same challenges with mobile connectivity. How do we get that last 1%? Are there technological solutions today? Will there be technological solutions by 2032 that allow us to close that gap? What do we need to do? These will be the very hardest geographical places to reach. As technology is moving all the time, there are ways in which we can resolve that last 1%, but the Government’s target is 99% coverage through Project Gigabit by 2032, and we are on track to deliver that. On emergency calling, it is essential that everyone, particularly those who are most vulnerable, can connect to the emergency services when they need to. There are protections in place to make sure that they can. Ofcom rules require communications providers to ensure customers can access emergency services in a power cut, as we have heard, including providing a solution such as battery back-up free of charge to customers who rely solely on a landline.
Torcuil CrichtonLabour
I thank the Minister for highlighting what I said earlier. The hard evidence from consumers in my constituency is that when the power is off the battery packs do not last long enough, and the battery packs are in the houses. The digital phone mast has no battery to keep it going. They are pointless. Ofgem has to regulate the phone companies and make sure there are digital back-ups.
Ian MurrayLabour
I am grateful for that example and for the other practical examples that we have heard from around the country. If my hon. Friend writes to me on that issue, we will take it away. I am also keen to look at the change from category 2 to category 1 for emergencies, because he is right that if the connectivity goes down, the phone companies should be part of that process, along with energy and other service responders. Of course, there is never any bad weather in his constituency, so he may not need to call upon them as much as others. Several hon. Members raised mobile site resilience. In June, Ofcom strengthened its guidance for mobile operators to protect against the risk of severe loss during power cuts. Although mobile phone networks are generally resilient, they can be disrupted by events such as severe weather—we have heard about that happening on a number of occasions—and the loss of power to mast sites, which my hon. Friend spoke about. Communications providers have a statutory obligation to ensure that their networks and services remain available. If that is not happening, I ask Members to please let me know as the Minister and to report that to the regulator. Communications providers are required to report significant incidents directly to Ofcom, which has the power to investigate, rectify and penalise communications providers for any infringement of their duties. Those practical examples are really useful for the regulator and the Government.
Mr CarmichaelLiberal Democrat
Island communities have a further level of resilience threat, as the cable to the island can break. When will we hear detail on what the Government will do to increase protection for undersea cables?
Ian MurrayLabour
Legislation on undersea cables is on its way, and it will be part of that process. We have announced that that will be coming forward relatively shortly, and I hope to engage with the right hon. Gentleman, who is from the furthest-away island community, to determine what that should look like. Let me answer some of the questions from my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire. He asked about money being reinvested from BT back into the network. In the telecoms access review, Ofcom asked BT to clearly identify the income associated with copper recovery in its accounting system. That will ensure that those profits are taken into account when the regulator sets the level of charge controls on certain wholesale products. However, the regulator and the Government do not directly intervene in the ways in which BT spends those profits, but at least there will be transparency about how it is done. Ofcom will take that into account when it looks at BT’s spending. BT and the two other big suppliers have massive investment plans and we need to ensure they are delivering them as quickly as possible. I do not know whether I have any other questions to answer. I want to take up the challenge from my hon. Friend about the completion date of 2028 for the new mast. Perhaps we can have a further discussion about that to see whether there is anything we can do to push for the infrastructure to be built more quickly.
Dave RobertsonLabour
I will be very brief. I am really concerned about notices to quit and access to those sites in the long term. Will the Minister look at whatever the evidence says needs to be looked at, including the electronic communications code, if that is where the data points?
Ian MurrayLabour
We are certainly examining that at the moment. The mobile market review is looking at all aspects of connectivity across the country. When we have these debates and issues are raised, we will take them back examine them very closely. I am grateful to my hon. Friend the Member for Mid and South Pembrokeshire for securing this debate. We will continue to debate these issues, because Members want to represent their constituents and inform the Government of where the notspots and resilience issues are. We will take those issues away because we want to resolve them. Connectivity is an issue for all of us. The Government’s ambition is clear: we want the whole country to be connected. The Prime Minister has told Ministers and the Government that he wants growth in every postcode, and that can be delivered only through connectivity in every postcode. That is the Government’s ambition. Question put and agreed to.
Sitting suspended.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440364.