Gareth Bacon

Gareth Bacon

Conservative — Orpington

Speaking in the House of Commons on 18 November 2026

Debate

Water Companies: Planning Applications

Contribution

Five minutes? Thank you very much, Mrs Barker; it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I commend the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She made the case extremely well. Unfortunately, I will have to skip large chunks of my speech, because so much time has been taken. The argument that has been made has pros and cons. At a time when the country’s population is at record levels and demand for housing is surely at an all-time high, house building in this country is nowhere near the levels it needs to be at. An increasingly convoluted and time-consuming planning process, a multiplicity of increased taxes and regulations, inflation at higher than targeted levels, correspondingly high interest rates and the falling availability of construction workers have all combined to strangle housing development. Any change we make to the system must support sustainable and affordable house building, not make it less viable. I agree that it is vital for the planning system to lead to homes that have safe and reliable water supplies, firm foundations and decent insulation, and which are crafted with quality and care. But it is also critical that developers can afford to build the homes and sell them at affordable market prices. Unfortunately, we find all too often that neither is viable. At first glance, greater consultation may seem like a solution, but as the quality and quantity of homes continues to decline, can we justify adding more statutory consultees to an already fatigued system? At present, developers are saddled with excessive cost, times and procedural measures that result in lengthy reports, protracted surveys and drawn-out assessments. These consultations do not just carry financial costs; they also take up an inordinate amount of time. In many cases, they simply set out facts and analysis that we already know, arriving back at square one via a winding route through forests of assessment and oceans of consultation. That is not just unproductive but unviable, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises, of which there is an alarmingly shrinking number. The statistics prove this to be a stark and sobering reality. For example, according to Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government figures, in the first quarter of 2026, while 91% of applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period—or “an extended period”—closer examination reveals that just 19% of major planning applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period. A major contributing factor to those delays, of course, is extra complexity thrown in to the planning system. I will skip sections of my speech here, because of the time. Between 2022 and 2025, more than 300 planning applications were escalated to the Secretary of State because of disputes with consultees. While it is not solely to blame, it is clear that consultation fatigue is a core part of the wider problem: a planning process that is obese, fattened up by paperwork and bureaucracy that has reached an unmanageable stage. Last week, the Centre for Policy Studies noted: “No decision-maker, consultee or even committee can meaningfully read an application of the length the UK system turns out.” It found that in Germany, the planning process for a 14-unit development may run to just eight to 10 documents and sets of drawings totalling less than 50 pages. Recently in Walthamstow, an application ran to 1,250 pages, an increase in total pages of around 2,500%. Why is this a good thing? Importantly, with water companies as a commercial entity, there is a danger that giving them extended statutory consultee powers reverses the incentive to create a better water system. I say that for two reasons. First, a business that has the right to formally object to an application has less pressure to upgrade its service where refusing or delaying is easier than investing. Unlike any other previous statutory consultees, many of which often represent policy rather than business interests, a commercial company may adopt a gatekeeping role that ends up rewarding under-investment. That may be particularly true for companies with strained finances, which we know is the case for many water companies. Secondly, as commercial entities with investment constraints set through price reviews, the objections of water companies may better reflect their funding and capital limitations rather than physical planning constraints. Those are clear reasons not to list water companies as statutory consultees, but there is an important qualifier; there is another side to this that is equally important. As I mentioned, we have a duty to support homebuyers and to ensure that the homes they work so hard to afford provide access to the most basic of human rights: running water. Unlike other utilities, water is a regulated monopoly. A customer cannot switch water supplier, as they can with broadband, gas or electricity. Reliable and safe water supply is essential, and any company falling short of its statutory duty to provide a secure supply must be held to account. Plans are all very well, but it is delivery that matters. In 2026—nearly 2027 now—it is to the discredit of Governments past and present that homes both new and old are found without a clean, economical and sustainable water supply. It is an even greater shame that some homes are without a water supply at all. I have spent some time on the cons—some of the reasons not to include water companies as statutory consultees—but I can see the merits of this move as well. As the hon. Member for Chichester pointed out, at present a local planning authority can approve a site, only for the realisation to come much later that water capacity is completely lacking. A formal consultation could push these problems further up the chain and allow for more solutions and greater proactivity. That would allow for clarity in the system and would work to ground decisions in objective fact rather than in vague reasoning, as well as exposing the decision to scrutiny. Finally and most importantly, it could support public confidence. Such confidence has hardly been lower, but giving water companies a statutory duty to assess capacity could conceivably help to alleviate concerns. It could also support councils to answer concerns about sewage and water with credible, factual and full datasets, meaning informed answers to pressing questions. The potential solutions are numerous. We could, for example, see proper analysis of where, who and what needs our vital and diminishing water supplies—a system based on prioritisation rather than a postcode lottery. [Interruption.] I am just coming to my conclusion, Mrs Barker. We could build on this to modify the planning system. There are perhaps merits in bespoke assessments in areas where water scarcity is most problematic. Planning applications in such areas could trigger an automatic statutory requirement to consult water companies, so as to include them only where they are most needed and will add genuine value to an application. We could also decide that water companies should become statutory consultees in every case. The truth is that the answer is far less clear than the problem is apparent. I am, however, pleased to have been given the opportunity to raise these thoughts and ideas with the Minister, and to highlight the Opposition’s strong concerns about this pressing issue. I will be very interested to hear his thoughts.

More from Gareth Bacon

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.

For Gareth Bacon's full parliamentary record including voting history, expenses and all other contributions, see the Gareth Bacon report card.