Hansard·Westminster Hall·Vol. 793

Water Companies: Planning Applications

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

37 contributions14 members

Contributions

  1. Jess Brown-Fuller (Chichester) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    I beg to move, That this House has considered the impact of water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mrs Barker. I thank hon. Members—they are mainly hon. Friends—for attending this important debate. My constituency of Chichester is home to some of England’s rarest and most precious chalk streams, such as the Lavant and the Ems. Chichester harbour is a national landscape and a site of special scientific interest, as well as the largest recreational harbour in the whole of Europe. My constituency is also on a low-lying coastal plain, and it is on the frontline of climate change. Significant swathes of it are prone to flooding, which has increased in recent years. Water matters to my constituents, whether that is because of the coastal erosion and flood risk faced by those along the coast or because of an appreciation of the biodiversity and unique environments created by our rivers and harbour. So when storm overflows across the constituency discharge raw sewage into those environments, which happens for hundreds if not thousands of hours a year, my inbox is filled by concerned residents saying, “Can’t we stop this happening? Why are they allowed to get away with this? Surely this should be illegal?” I am not shy when it comes to criticising Southern Water’s failure to adequately invest in water infrastructure as a result of decades of inaction and a prioritisation of shareholders over the natural environment. However, it is absolutely baffling that waste water treatment capacity is not a material consideration for new build developments, because water companies are not statutory consultees on planning applications.

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Sarah Green (Chesham and Amersham) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    Like me, my hon. Friend will have many constituents who are concerned about new developments coming onstream in places where sewerage capacity is already a worry. Does she agree that it is utterly senseless that the one organisation that knows whether the network has capacity—the water company—is not required to comment and cannot refuse access to the network once a development is approved?

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Jess Brown-FullerLiberal Democrat

    My hon. Friend is absolutely right. Water companies cannot refuse because they are bound by a statutory duty to connect as part of the Water Industry Act 1991.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party

    I commend the hon. Lady for raising these matters. Over the last two years and beyond, the Liberal Democrat party has been very much to the fore in highlighting these issues, and it deserves credit for doing that. In Northern Ireland, the water companies are statutory consultees, and if there is not capacity in the waste water system for a new development, that development does not go ahead. Does the hon. Lady want to see that kind of legislation here?

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Jess Brown-FullerLiberal Democrat

    I always appreciate the hon. Gentleman bringing a Northern Ireland perspective to these debates. I chatted to him before the debate, and it was interesting to hear him explain that Northern Ireland Water is always consulted on planning applications, and that if it does not have capacity, that can be taken into account. The Chichester and Arun districts, which my constituency sits in, have been set huge house building targets by this Government. Chichester district saw a 59% increase on the previous target, from more than 700 homes a year to more than 1,200 a year. Arun district’s target is even higher, with 1,400 homes expected to be delivered per annum. It is neither unreasonable nor outlandish for existing residents of those communities to expect that, when those new houses are built, they come with the necessary infrastructure to manage the additional pressures. We have numerous waste water treatment facilities in Chichester, and I have visited most of them, including ones that are operating at the limits of their licence. That is before the system becomes overwhelmed, at which point they enter “storm mode”, which permits them to release untreated water into the environment. Constraints at some of these sites—such as not owning land around them on to which they could expand—mean that upgrades to increase capacity are complicated and lengthy. I would like to provide an example of where that has happened in my constituency in recent months. The Highgrove development is 300 homes in the village of Bosham, and increases the size of Bosham by 27%. When the site was originally proposed, a group of concerned residents pointed out that the waste water treatment site would struggle to accommodate the additional sewage. On that occasion, the Planning Inspectorate added a planning condition that capacity was to be dealt with at the waste water facility before any of the houses could be occupied. The houses started to be built, but capacity upgrades were not forthcoming. The residents sounded the alarm, but the build progressed. Surprise, surprise, earlier this year the first tranche of houses was built and advertised, but no magic capacity had been created at the waste water treatment works. The developers then applied for a variation in the planning conditions to allow the waste water to be tankered off site as an interim measure, so that the houses might be occupied. To be honest, I do not remember the image of sewage tankers lined up along the road of the new estate in the glossy brochures provided to prospective buyers. To get round the planning condition, the developers’ solution is now to introduce a holding tank on site. It is estimated that that will hold three days’ worth of sewage, before the sewage is then released to the waste water treatment works when capacity is available. One assumes that that capacity would become available in the middle of the night, if at all, because capacity may never magically appear, especially in periods of heavy rainfall. In 2023, Bosham waste water treatment works discharged into Chichester harbour—an SSSI and national landscape—for 1,762 hours. That is 73 days that discharge went straight into our natural environment. Who knows what happens to the held sewage at Highgrove at points of high rainfall, when capacity does not exist? Well, I know what will happen: they will have to release it to the waste water treatment works, and it will end up in our precious environment. We had similar challenges at the Clappers Lane development in Earnley. Yet again, the issues of water capacity were not addressed before developers started advertising their new properties to prospective buyers.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Adrian Ramsay (Waveney Valley) (Green)Green Party

    I thank the hon. Lady for bringing this important debate to the House. I have an example from the market town of Harleston in my constituency that reinforces the point she makes. The Greater Norwich local plan identifies that existing sewerage constraints and the need for additional water supply are critical factors in the planned housing growth of 700 homes, which is a lot in a market town of 2,500 households. The local plan explicitly requires infrastructure capacity to be addressed to the satisfaction of Anglian Water. Does that not show that water companies must be statutory consultees so that that requirement is established before a development is given permission?

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Jess Brown-FullerLiberal Democrat

    The hon. Gentleman takes me on nicely to my next point, which is about local plans. In response to the debate, I imagine that the Minister will say it is best practice to consult water companies when setting local plans, and he is right. Local plans inform water companies’ long-term infrastructure investment decisions, but developments can and do come forward outside of those plans or earlier than anticipated.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Tom Gordon (Harrogate and Knaresborough) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    My hon. Friend might be surprised to hear that we have ended up in an awful situation across North Yorkshire, where we have seen the quadrupling of housing targets at the same time as the Conservative-run council has failed to put in place a local plan, which has exacerbated that problem. Thousands of houses are going through the planning system, with Yorkshire Water objecting on development grounds that there might be pollution and flood and public health risks. Does my hon. Friend agree that that is a damning indictment of Conservative-run North Yorkshire council and the Labour Government?

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Jess Brown-FullerLiberal Democrat

    My hon. Friend is right to highlight that areas with no local plan are at risk of speculative development. Between 2011 and 2025, 80% of the homes built in my constituency were speculative development on windfall sites. That is in part down to the failure of the Conservative-run district council to put a local plan in place. Developers also love a square, flat field because it is much easier to develop than many of the sites identified in local plans. Under the Liberal Democrats, Chichester district council now has a robust local plan, and work is beginning on the next one. However, for areas such as Pagham and Bersted, which sit in the Arun district council area, all development is speculative. The top-down house building target means that they cannot demonstrate a five-year housing land supply without consenting to development on greenfield land and flood plains. Giving water companies an earlier and more meaningful voice in planning decisions, especially for major developments relying on infrastructure already nearing capacity, would help to identify potential challenges before they arise. That is not an extraordinary request. I am simply asking for better alignment between planning decisions and funded infrastructure investment, because that would better protect our precious natural environment and existing customers. I put the following questions to the Minister. Should the Planning Inspectorate take waste water capacity into account on speculative developments, knowing that no assessment exists because the site was not identified in the local plan? Does the Minister recognise that the Government’s ambition to build 1.5 million homes will be severely hampered if there is nowhere to treat all the additional sewage caused by those extra homes, or is he comfortable with that ending up in key environmental areas such as Chichester harbour? Do the Government have any plans to implement schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010 to mandate sustainable urban drainage on new development, so that less rainwater ends up in the sewer system? Will the Minister’s default yes position on development around train stations and transport hubs take water infrastructure into account at all? Finally, considering that water and waste water infrastructure can take years to assess, design, fund and develop, but housing developments can be delivered far more quickly, will he look again at making water companies statutory consultees on planning applications, so that they can have a seat at the table when it matters most—when the decisions are being made?

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Chris Murray (Edinburgh East and Musselburgh) (Lab)Labour

    It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate on water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications. We are approaching Christmas, and I am going to be something of a ghost of Christmas yet to come. I am from Scotland, where water companies are statutory consultees on planning applications, and I am afraid to say that that has not worked in Scotland. Our water is still full of sewage, despite Scottish Water being a publicly owned water company. There is a much more important argument to be made, which I think the Government are making, about involving developers at the plan-making stage. Edinburgh has seen 10% population growth over the past 10 years. My constituency includes part of East Lothian, which has seen 16% population growth, and we are right beside Mid Lothian, which has seen 20% population growth over the past 10 years. We have found that incorporating water companies as statutory consultees has been a paper exercise that has not led to enforcement, has not held the water company—a publicly owned water company—accountable and has led to what our constituents do not want to see: sewage washing up on the shore. Water policy in England has been beset by the mistakes of the Conservatives for the past 14 years. My argument to my friends in England is that they should make different mistakes from those of the SNP and learn from what has happened to us. This measure is not a panacea and it has not worked. Evidence of that came just yesterday, when Portobello beach in my constituency was rated poor by the Scottish water regulator. Fisherrow Sands, in Musselburgh, has been poor for three years running. Those are Scotland’s most visited beaches, on the shores of our nation’s capital, yet they are awash with wet wipes and sewage. The situation is actually worse than I thought. Today, I met the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, the water regulator. Representatives told me that they monitor water only when they do not expect to find sewage. If they expect sewage, because it has been raining heavily, they do not even monitor. There were 109 days of unreported sewage spills in Scotland. Inexplicably, the agency sometimes tries to blame the spills on seagulls, but having personally picked up hundreds of wet wipes and sanitary products—which seagulls do not use—on those beaches, I can tell hon. Members that they are due to poor water regulation. This has been going on for years and, dismayingly, nothing has been done about it. Even more shockingly, despite my constituents having to deal with human sewage on the beach, the bosses of Scottish Water collected more than £250,000 in bonuses last year. In England, the Government are stepping in to cap the bonuses of water companies, but when I wrote to the First Minister of Scotland about this, he refused to intervene. That is why I have set up a petition to deal with it.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Jess Brown-FullerLiberal Democrat

    I really appreciate the hon. Gentleman’s passion about fixing this. I just want to highlight that I do not believe that making water companies statutory consultees on planning applications will fix the entire system; there are a lot more things that we need to do for the entire water industry. I would also caution him that despite the Labour Government’s move to ban bonuses for water company execs, water companies are already finding workarounds; they are increasing their standard salaries rather than having those bonuses. Water companies are quite clever when it comes to getting around the measures introduced to hold them to account.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Chris MurrayLabour

    The hon. Lady is quite right; we need to pursue water companies when they try to find workarounds. But I would still much rather have a Government willing to try than an SNP Government who do not even lift a finger. I understand that the hon. Lady is not arguing that this is a panacea solution, but the experience from the Edinburgh and East Lothian area, which is in a housing crisis, is that adding water companies to the planning system has just delayed the planning and lengthened the time it takes to get houses built, and has not had an impact on sewage. What does make a difference is monitoring—we have 100% monitoring in England but only 30% monitoring in Scotland—and investment in infrastructure. I am desperate for a Government to step up and grip the sewage crisis in Scotland. I am just jealous of my friends in England and Wales for having Governments willing to do that.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship this afternoon, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this debate. She has focused her remarks mostly on waste water companies; my remarks do apply to sewerage, but the main issue for Mid Sussex, as I think the Minister is already aware, is with freshwater companies, specifically South East Water. Water companies should be statutory consultees on planning applications, and the fact that they are not is having severe impacts on my constituents. At its heart, this debate is about whether we are giving sufficient weight to the availability of water infrastructure before deciding where, and how many, homes should be built. I believe that the current arrangements fall short of what is needed. Mid Sussex has seen substantial development over recent years. Our communities have accommodated new housing and made a significant contribution towards meeting the country’s housing needs, but there is a growing disconnect between the pace of development and the ability of essential services to keep up. Nowhere is that more apparent than with water. Pressure on water resources in Mid Sussex is exceptionally high; restrictions on water use have become an increasingly familiar experience. Drought conditions have placed further pressure on an already stretched system, while the possibility of much more severe restrictions has become a very real concern. The difficulties are not confined to the availability of water itself; the infrastructure responsible for delivering that water to people’s homes is also proving increasingly unreliable. In October, a major burst water main disrupted supplies to approximately 5,000 properties across Hurstpierpoint, Burgess Hill and Hassocks. More than 1,000 properties remained without water into the following day. Residents were forced to seek alternative supplies, while businesses and other local services faced considerable disruption. Sadly, that was not a one-off event. Communities in Haywards Heath, Cuckfield, Staplefield and Albourne—in fact, pretty much every community in Mid Sussex—have all experienced interruptions to their water supply this year alone. Alongside that, there are mounting concerns about the capacity of the sewerage network. A burst main south of Burgess Hill was spotted by a resident; it had been leaking raw sewage into a woodland for days. It took weeks to fix and involved the waste being tankered and then pumped into a different part of the network. Against that backdrop, we must consider the role of water companies in the planning process. At present, water companies do not have the same statutory consultee status on planning applications as a number of other infrastructure and public bodies, yet local planning authorities are expected to make complex judgments about whether proposed developments are sustainable. Not only is there clear evidence that that is leading to problems, as I have set out, but it is entirely illogical. How can we properly assess whether a development is suitable if we do not ensure that the body responsible for providing one of its key inputs can confirm it has the ability to do so? Statutory consultee status would address that problem. It would give water companies a defined responsibility to highlight shortages in supply, identify limitations in sewerage capacity and explain what improvements would be necessary to support successful development. I appreciate that this change would not resolve every difficulty facing the water industry, and I am not suggesting that water companies should be handed the power to block developments simply because they have concerns, but their technical knowledge and evidence must be properly incorporated into planning decisions. A formal consultation process would make it much harder for fundamental infrastructure constraints to be overlooked. That is particularly important in Mid Sussex, where the emerging local plan proposes provision for more than 24,000 homes. That is a considerable increase in the demands being placed on our communities. Before further development is approved, there must be a genuine understanding of how the additional demand will be met without compromising the supply available to existing households and businesses. Quite simply, we cannot keep approving developments on the assumption that infrastructure will somehow materialise afterwards. The Government are rightly focused on increasing the supply of housing, but the success of that ambition cannot be measured simply by the number of houses built. The houses have to be liveable. A home must have a dependable water supply and it must be connected to a sewerage system with sufficient capacity. The people who move in must be able to rely on the essential services that make somewhere a viable place to live. Therefore, I ask the Minister to consider how statutory consultee status could be introduced, with clear expectations around response times, meaningful technical assessments and transparency about the infrastructure investment required. We need a planning system that anticipates problems rather than one that waits for them to materialise. In Mid Sussex, we have already experienced what happens when population growth, inadequate infrastructure and pressure on water resources collide. We can and should build more homes, but we must do so responsibly. To do that, water companies have to be statutory consultees. I hope the Government recognise that that is not an unnecessary additional hurdle for development; it is a vital change that needs to be made if we are to have sustainable and functioning communities for a growing population.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Charlie Maynard (Witney) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairship, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this important debate. The question we are debating sits at the intersection between two of the biggest challenges facing my Witney constituency: planning and pollution. We see a huge number of illegal sewage spills. Windrush Against Sewage Pollution’s analysis of Thames Water’s illegal discharges between 2021 and 2025 found 1,231 were within Witney, making it the single worst impacted constituency in the country by quite some margin. Of those discharges, 271 alone came from Faringdon sewage treatment works and another 249 came from Appleton. Under the national planning policy framework, we are required by the Government to build 18,000 new homes in West Oxfordshire and 14,000 in Vale of White Horse. We absolutely should not have to take on that scale of development without the infrastructure in place to support it, whether that is transport, sewerage or any other infrastructure required. The capacity in our water and sewerage systems must be considered in full, otherwise we risk increasing sewage discharges into our local waterways and doing more damage. Let us take, for example, the recent application to build 200 new homes on Shrivenham’s community golf course in my constituency, while the nearby Shrivenham sewage treatment works persistently dumps raw sewage into the Tuckmill brook. One incident last year continued non-stop for more than 1,000 hours, or 41 days straight. No asset management period 8 scheme—the current cycle for water companies from 2025 to 2030—has been announced to upgrade that works, and given Thames Water’s poor financial status, it is hard to envision that it will fast-track any work to that sewage treatment works whatever its contractual obligations state. That goes on and on across my constituency. We therefore have a sewage works that is already failing on a large scale with no realistic prospect of improvement; a proposal for another 200 homes, which will increase the pressure on its capacity; and no solution proposed. That is one of countless examples of where we desperately need planning processes to take full account of the water and sewerage system capacity. Councils have some tools available to them. Since November 2022, West Oxfordshire district council, of which I was formerly a member, has attached Grampian conditions to new developments that prohibit homes from being occupied until water and sewerage infrastructure is operational; I believe that we were one of the first planning authorities to introduce such conditions. The council’s new draft local plan will go further, requiring any development that increases waste water discharges to have the infrastructure that is needed to manage such discharges without harming our rivers and ecosystems already in place. Crucially, the new plan commits the council to impose Grampian-style conditions wherever there is evidence of insufficient water supply or foul water capacity, so that infrastructure is delivered in step with new homes. [ Interruption. ] Would the Minister like to intervene? No. Okay. Grampian conditions are only as strong as the information behind them, however, and in my experience Thames Water has a track record of failing to provide information to the council. In addition, Grampian conditions offer no protection where developments rely on private package treatment plants, such as the one that has just been approved in Brize Norton, because those plants are not monitored inside the national system. Councils do what they can but they depend on water companies to be honest about capacity, and there are further problems about where the sludge goes and the obligations around the sludge produced by private package treatment plants. Crucially, however, we not only need a statutory duty for water companies to be consulted but—as per an amendment that my hon. Friend the Member for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron) tabled during the passage of the Water (Special Measures) Act 2025—a statutory duty to compel them to give full and accurate information on that process, including an honest assessment of their ability to fulfil their duties, with appropriate penalties when that is found not to have been the case. My hon. Friend’s amendment was not accepted by the Government, but if they are serious about meeting their house building targets, they must also take seriously the need to ensure that there is a robust planning process that protects our rivers, lakes and seas from further pollution. I am eager to hear the Minister’s thoughts on those three things: first, Grampian conditions; secondly, private package treatment plants; and, thirdly, compelling water companies to provide full and accurate information. There are three more things that I would also like to hear the Minister’s thoughts on. First, I am concerned about the WINEP—water industry national environment programme—plans, which were published in 2022. They move from calculating the population in an area and the output of a sewage treatment works to a tiered system, which gives an incentive to water companies to pollute up to the level of the next tier. That seems to be a really bad incentive, so I am interested to hear the Minister’s thoughts on it. Secondly, flow meters are installed everywhere apart from on sewage outlets. Why are the Government so resistant to putting flow meters on sewage outlets? If we had flow meters on sewage outlets, we would have a much more accurate set of data. Thirdly and finally, we would not be talking about sewage if we were not also talking about special administration. I ask the Minister to please work with his colleagues to put Thames Water into special administration.

    View contribution permalink →

  15. Paula Barker (in the Chair)Labour

    Order. I remind Members to stick to the topic of the debate, which is planning.

    View contribution permalink →

  16. John Milne (Horsham) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller), who is also my constituency neighbour, on securing this debate. In my view, the role of water companies in the planning process is wholly unsatisfactory. In my constituency of Horsham, we have learned that the hard way. For four years, from 2021 onwards, construction in my constituency came to an almost complete halt because of water neutrality, an Environment Agency requirement that was introduced to protect an endangered water environment from over-abstraction. That requirement was introduced overnight and it disappeared overnight, but it left a trail of confusion in its wake. I thank the Minister for his personal involvement in helping us to get past that problem. Most damagingly of all, that has left us hugely behind on our house building target, even though it was legally impossible for us to do anything to meet it. As a result, we have been punished with numerous inappropriate permissions, most of all the 800 homes at Horsham Golf and Fitness village, which are not in the local plan. Of course, the water requirements and sewerage requirements for that development will now have to be worked out retrospectively; in the first instance, they were not even considered. Water and sewerage infrastructure is a complex issue, and I am not convinced that we have got to grips with it from a planning point of view. I support those who call for water companies to be made statutory consultees in planning applications. However, that change in itself would not go far enough, because—astonishingly—even if water companies were guaranteed a place at the table, their input would not necessarily have any weight in the planning process. They cannot refuse to support a specific application on the grounds of water supply or sewerage issues, even if they would like to. Indeed, judging from my conversations with Southern Water, it seems that it has never even occurred to the company to refuse an application. Under the Water Industry Act 1991, developers were given the right to have their houses or commercial buildings connected to the main supply, regardless of how practical that might be—the water companies literally cannot say no. Instead, they have to say what measures they will take to meet the extra demand in the future. In my constituency and in the wider area, including Chichester, that has led to— [Interruption.]

    View contribution permalink →

  17. Paula Barker (in the Chair)Labour

    Order.

    View contribution permalink →

  18. Sitting suspended for a Division in the House.

    View contribution permalink →

  19. On resuming—

    View contribution permalink →

  20. Paula Barker (in the Chair)Labour

    The debate may now continue until 5.45 pm.

    View contribution permalink →

  21. John MilneLiberal Democrat

    Thank you, Mrs Barker. Before we were so rudely interrupted by the other Chamber, I was saying that water companies cannot refuse a planning permission and cannot say no. Instead, they have to explain how they are going to meet the extra demand. In my constituency, and indeed in the wider area, this has led to bizarre schemes, including a plan to ship water from Norway. In practice, it is very hard for anyone to object on capacity grounds alone. When we lay that alongside an overwhelming Government mission to build as many houses as possible in pursuit of a target—which is already unachievable—it is a recipe for disastrous decision making. I believe that the Government are content to let this absurd situation continue, because they are allergic to doing anything that might possibly stand in the way of any development anywhere. It is a strategy that delivers abundant permissions, but not actual houses that people can live in. That is a growing problem in water-stressed areas such as Horsham. We are at risk of accumulating zombie permissions for estates that cannot be built for decades to come, because local water companies will not be able to meet their over-optimistic supply targets. To conclude, it is time to give planning authorities the power to make meaningful decisions relating to water and sewerage. Statutory consultee status merely gives a water company a voice. Amending the Water Industry Act 1991 would give that voice force. I have invited the Minister to come to Horsham to explain to local people and help them to understand his overall housing strategy. That would be a message for Horsham people, but it could also serve the wider community. I hope that Minister will accept that invitation in the future.

    View contribution permalink →

  22. Calum Miller (Bicester and Woodstock) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to speak with you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for securing this important debate. I also thank my hon. Friends who have spoken already, particularly my hon. Friend the Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard)—noting that the sewage effluent that he referred to as such a plague on his constituency flows straight down and into mine. The relationship between planning and critical utilities is simply broken. In areas like my constituency, where there is substantial house building and employment growth, it is a huge issue. I want to take hon. Members back to September 2024, when we in Oxfordshire experienced one month’s rain in one day. In Bicester, Kidlington, Woodstock, Bucknell and Cassington, people were suffering incoming foul water that not only polluted but contaminated their homes, requiring them to move out for periods of upwards of six months and leaving them with a terrible legacy. I urge the Government to reconsider how to ensure that key infrastructure is built first before new developments open, because this is essential for existing residents and new homeowners. Other hon. Members have mentioned this, but let us look at how things work now. In my area, Thames Water will be consulted, but it is not a statutory consultee, so any objections or difficulties it raises do not stop the progress of developments. However, as other hon. Members have said, under the Water Industry Act 1991, Thames Water has a statutory obligation to connect both foul and potable water. What does that mean? It means that, as a standard condition, the developer must either create new capacity off site or improve or build new capacity on site through a dedicated private facility. That is a real issue in my area because sometimes that is simply not possible. For example, the Oxford sewage treatment works are at full capacity. That has the real possibility of delaying the connection of 4,400 homes that are currently being built near Kidlington, or, in the case of my residents in Woodstock, at the development at Bens Close. I want to take hon. Members back to almost exactly a year ago. I was shaking a bucket along with the firefighters of Woodstock and their supporter Claire, collecting for Children in Need, and the heavens opened. Claire was one of the residents who had seen her property flooded in September 2024, and she was traumatised, knowing that very heavy rainfall might flood her home again. She stayed and carried on collecting for Children in Need, and I discovered later that evening that her home had flooded yet again, along with her neighbours’, like Genevieve. This is an unsustainable and unacceptable situation because they suffer from the fact that their water connection, which Thames Water has installed, is not adequate to deal with both the surface and foul water drains, so every time it rains very heavily, they have water backing up into their homes as well as surface water flooding directly into their houses. Finally, where it is proposed by a developer to install a septic tank, as it is for my constituents in Enslow, all too often those septic tanks are poorly installed by developers in a rush; they service a community without adequate supply and through management company failings, residents in Enslow have been left with a noxious smell for a long period because of the poor maintenance of the septic tank. In all three of those examples, we have evidence that the failure to include the objections of the water companies at the time of development is creating real difficulties. I would like to address the comments made by the hon. Member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh (Chris Murray), whose area I know well—although I have not picked up sewage from the beach, I have certainly spent time there. He made a powerful case for the need to involve developers early, but the point I would like to make to the Minister is that we are in a broken cycle. When the water companies are not consulted automatically when they are obliged to connect, despite not having the ability to do so, and when, as with the forthcoming challenge in Kidlington, they are therefore unable to allow people to occupy the homes, then the local authority loses its five-year housing land supply and is obligated to allow more speculative development in areas that have no infrastructure whatsoever. Although the aspiration of involving developers early is good, it is not sufficient if the water companies are not involved early in the conversation. I want to close by making the point that it is not just water. I realise that water is the focus of this debate, but the same thing applies to electricity, as the Minister is well aware. Members will forgive me if this is something of a preoccupation, but the asylum centre proposed in my constituency has neither potable nor foul water nor electricity, and the fact that neither the water authority nor the electricity board was consulted means there will be a real challenge in connecting that facility. To conclude, I hope the Minister will be able to explain how the Government are seeking to ensure that we have an infrastructure-first approach so that residents like those in my constituency of Bicester and Woodstock can have greater confidence in the quality and sustainability of their homes in the future.

    View contribution permalink →

  23. Gideon Amos (Taunton and Wellington) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    It is a pleasure to serve with you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I pay credit to my hon. Friend the Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) for foregrounding such an important issue in development for communities across the country. She has been a formidable champion on this issue, including when we were debating the Planning and Infrastructure Bill and she tabled, along with me, an amendment to make water companies statutory consultees. It was voted on and was sadly defeated by Labour MPs on that occasion. My hon. Friend the Member for Westmorland and Lonsdale (Tim Farron) also proposed that idea in an amendment to the Water (Special Measures) Act. Again, that was defeated by the other parties. In July, the Government rejected the House of Lords Environment and Climate Change Committee’s recommendation that water companies should become statutory consultees. In doing so, they rejected the Cunliffe recommendations. A number of Members have made excellent points in this debate, and I congratulate them all. My hon. Friend the Member for Mid Sussex (Alison Bennett) highlighted the challenges of water management failures in her constituency. My hon. Friend the Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard) highlighted the use of Grampian conditions. I heard the Minister suggest from a sedentary position that the problem was solved because of the use of Grampian conditions; but if that is going to be relied on across the country, how can councils properly impose planning conditions or introduce the ideas well used in Witney if they do not have the information from the water companies, which have not been consulted, to tell them what kinds of condition should be imposed? My hon. Friend the Member for Horsham (John Milne) highlighted the fact that these issues are leading to calls to import water from Norway. Surely there cannot be a more compelling example of the problems we have with water and planning in the development system in this country. My hon. Friend the Member for Bicester and Woodstock (Calum Miller) highlighted the problem with the accountability of the water industry. The hon. Members for Strangford (Jim Shannon) and for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh (Chris Murray) pointed out that water companies are statutory consultees in both Northern Ireland and Scotland. The hon. Member for Edinburgh East and Musselburgh suggested that it had not made any difference, but I invite both hon. Members to consider how much worse it might be had there not been any consultation with water companies on development in those nations. The question for the Government and for the Minister is whether it is really better not to consult, and therefore to expose residents and stakeholders to the risks of water supply capacity issues, of sewerage and drainage issues and of homes flooding. Is it right that the Government should expose those groups to those risks? Why take those risks? Surely consulting water companies is the minimum we should do to manage and mitigate them. My hon. Friend the Member for Chichester explained that homes coming forward outside a local plan is now more or less the norm. With one stroke, the Government rendered most local plans out of date—I believe it is most, but I stand to be corrected. As of March, only 90 councils have up-to-date local plans, because once the Government imposed their new standard method they rendered huge numbers of local plans suddenly out of date. That means that development in all those areas will come forward outside the local plan process, with no strategic environmental assessment of the flooding impacts, water demands or sewerage implications. We are living in an unplanned planning system in most of England at the moment. Why take that risk? Why not consult water companies so that authorities have the information they need, given that these decisions are so much more important than they were before the standard method was brought in when local plans were in effect? In Taunton and Wellington, we find ourselves at the centre of a perfect storm of all three of the risks I mentioned: the risks of water running out, of homes flooding and of drains and sewerage systems failing. I had to rewrite my speech after a BBC report this morning explained that the French weir, which I campaigned to have designated back in 2023, now has the most sewage-filled bathing water in the whole country. What more graphic example can there be of the failure of water and sewage management and planning alongside development in this country? It is time for the water companies to step up and take action to invest in the sewage works in Bradford-on-Tone and across the system. Consultee status would highlight the stresses and the need for investment in sewerage and drainage infrastructure. With so many developments outside a local plan, it is vital that we get flood risk information from statutory consultees, in particular water companies, if they were made statutory consultees. Although the Environment Agency is responsible for flood management, water companies bear responsibility for drainage and therefore for reducing flood risk result. Driven by increasingly unpredictable rainfall and weather patterns, hundreds of thousands of homes are now unable to get insurance and therefore face difficulty in getting mortgages. [ Interruption. ] I infer from your coughing that time is short, Mrs Barker, so I will do my very best to make a short version of my speech, but the impacts of flooding in my constituency are significant. Consultee status would highlight the need to invest in drainage to reduce flood risk, in sewage measures and in measures to support water supply. My hon. Friend the Member for Chichester made an excellent case for doing so. I urge the Government to take on board her proposal.

    View contribution permalink →

  24. Paula Barker (in the Chair)Labour

    I call the Opposition spokesperson, who has five minutes.

    View contribution permalink →

  25. Gareth Bacon (Orpington) (Con)Conservative

    Five minutes? Thank you very much, Mrs Barker; it is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship. I commend the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She made the case extremely well. Unfortunately, I will have to skip large chunks of my speech, because so much time has been taken. The argument that has been made has pros and cons. At a time when the country’s population is at record levels and demand for housing is surely at an all-time high, house building in this country is nowhere near the levels it needs to be at. An increasingly convoluted and time-consuming planning process, a multiplicity of increased taxes and regulations, inflation at higher than targeted levels, correspondingly high interest rates and the falling availability of construction workers have all combined to strangle housing development. Any change we make to the system must support sustainable and affordable house building, not make it less viable. I agree that it is vital for the planning system to lead to homes that have safe and reliable water supplies, firm foundations and decent insulation, and which are crafted with quality and care. But it is also critical that developers can afford to build the homes and sell them at affordable market prices. Unfortunately, we find all too often that neither is viable. At first glance, greater consultation may seem like a solution, but as the quality and quantity of homes continues to decline, can we justify adding more statutory consultees to an already fatigued system? At present, developers are saddled with excessive cost, times and procedural measures that result in lengthy reports, protracted surveys and drawn-out assessments. These consultations do not just carry financial costs; they also take up an inordinate amount of time. In many cases, they simply set out facts and analysis that we already know, arriving back at square one via a winding route through forests of assessment and oceans of consultation. That is not just unproductive but unviable, especially for small and medium-sized enterprises, of which there is an alarmingly shrinking number. The statistics prove this to be a stark and sobering reality. For example, according to Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government figures, in the first quarter of 2026, while 91% of applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period—or “an extended period”—closer examination reveals that just 19% of major planning applications were decided within the statutory 13-week period. A major contributing factor to those delays, of course, is extra complexity thrown in to the planning system. I will skip sections of my speech here, because of the time. Between 2022 and 2025, more than 300 planning applications were escalated to the Secretary of State because of disputes with consultees. While it is not solely to blame, it is clear that consultation fatigue is a core part of the wider problem: a planning process that is obese, fattened up by paperwork and bureaucracy that has reached an unmanageable stage. Last week, the Centre for Policy Studies noted: “No decision-maker, consultee or even committee can meaningfully read an application of the length the UK system turns out.” It found that in Germany, the planning process for a 14-unit development may run to just eight to 10 documents and sets of drawings totalling less than 50 pages. Recently in Walthamstow, an application ran to 1,250 pages, an increase in total pages of around 2,500%. Why is this a good thing? Importantly, with water companies as a commercial entity, there is a danger that giving them extended statutory consultee powers reverses the incentive to create a better water system. I say that for two reasons. First, a business that has the right to formally object to an application has less pressure to upgrade its service where refusing or delaying is easier than investing. Unlike any other previous statutory consultees, many of which often represent policy rather than business interests, a commercial company may adopt a gatekeeping role that ends up rewarding under-investment. That may be particularly true for companies with strained finances, which we know is the case for many water companies. Secondly, as commercial entities with investment constraints set through price reviews, the objections of water companies may better reflect their funding and capital limitations rather than physical planning constraints. Those are clear reasons not to list water companies as statutory consultees, but there is an important qualifier; there is another side to this that is equally important. As I mentioned, we have a duty to support homebuyers and to ensure that the homes they work so hard to afford provide access to the most basic of human rights: running water. Unlike other utilities, water is a regulated monopoly. A customer cannot switch water supplier, as they can with broadband, gas or electricity. Reliable and safe water supply is essential, and any company falling short of its statutory duty to provide a secure supply must be held to account. Plans are all very well, but it is delivery that matters. In 2026—nearly 2027 now—it is to the discredit of Governments past and present that homes both new and old are found without a clean, economical and sustainable water supply. It is an even greater shame that some homes are without a water supply at all. I have spent some time on the cons—some of the reasons not to include water companies as statutory consultees—but I can see the merits of this move as well. As the hon. Member for Chichester pointed out, at present a local planning authority can approve a site, only for the realisation to come much later that water capacity is completely lacking. A formal consultation could push these problems further up the chain and allow for more solutions and greater proactivity. That would allow for clarity in the system and would work to ground decisions in objective fact rather than in vague reasoning, as well as exposing the decision to scrutiny. Finally and most importantly, it could support public confidence. Such confidence has hardly been lower, but giving water companies a statutory duty to assess capacity could conceivably help to alleviate concerns. It could also support councils to answer concerns about sewage and water with credible, factual and full datasets, meaning informed answers to pressing questions. The potential solutions are numerous. We could, for example, see proper analysis of where, who and what needs our vital and diminishing water supplies—a system based on prioritisation rather than a postcode lottery. [ Interruption. ] I am just coming to my conclusion, Mrs Barker. We could build on this to modify the planning system. There are perhaps merits in bespoke assessments in areas where water scarcity is most problematic. Planning applications in such areas could trigger an automatic statutory requirement to consult water companies, so as to include them only where they are most needed and will add genuine value to an application. We could also decide that water companies should become statutory consultees in every case. The truth is that the answer is far less clear than the problem is apparent. I am, however, pleased to have been given the opportunity to raise these thoughts and ideas with the Minister, and to highlight the Opposition’s strong concerns about this pressing issue. I will be very interested to hear his thoughts.

    View contribution permalink →

  26. Paula Barker (in the Chair)Labour

    Before I call the Minister, it may be helpful for Members to know that in an hour-long debate, the Opposition spokespersons’ speeches should be five minutes, and the Minister’s should be 10 minutes.

    View contribution permalink →

  27. The Minister for Housing and Planning (Matthew Pennycook)Labour

    It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mrs Barker. I congratulate the hon. Member for Chichester (Jess Brown-Fuller) on securing this important debate. She is a doughty champion for her constituents, and her opening remarks were a powerful articulation of entirely legitimate concerns about the role of water companies in planning for new residential development. I also thank the other hon. Members who participated in the debate; I welcome the valuable insights that they shared from their constituencies. I want to make it clear at the outset that I note and appreciate fully the concerns that exist across the House in respect of the delivery of water supply, drainage and waste water infrastructure. I recognise how strongly hon. Members feel about this matter. Water scarcity is a genuine and growing constraint, and not for one second, in anything I say, am I conveying the Government’s view that the status quo is acceptable. There is a real problem here, and it is complex, but in the time available I want to detail the steps that the Government have already taken to address the issue and to reassure hon. Members, if I can, that we are acutely aware of the need to do more, and in particular to ensure—to address the point well made by the hon. Member for Bicester and Woodstock (Calum Miller)—much closer alignment between planning for development and planning for necessary water and waste water infrastructure. I want to touch briefly on the national planning policy framework, because it is very clear that sustainable development should be pursued, both through the preparation and implementation of local development plans and through the application of policies in the framework in decision making. In short, national policy is unambiguous that new housing must be accompanied by appropriate provision for water supply, drainage, waste water, water management and flood risk infrastructure. However, I must make it clear that the focus of planning policies and decisions should be whether proposed development is an acceptable use of land, rather than matters that are subject to control under other regulatory regimes. In short, planning decisions should assume that those regimes operate effectively. That reflects a well-established position in law: the courts have consistently held that it is not the role of the planning system to duplicate controls that are the statutory responsibility of other bodies, nor should decision makers substitute their own judgment on matters for which other regulators hold relevant expertise and responsibility.

    View contribution permalink →

  28. Charlie MaynardLiberal Democrat

    Will the Minister give way?

    View contribution permalink →

  29. Matthew PennycookLabour

    If the hon. Member will allow me to make a linked point, he can then come back to me if he wants to. Infrastructure constraints can be a material consideration; I think the hon. Member for Chichester said that they could not be, but they can. Where there is clear evidence that a regulatory regime is not operating effectively in a particular area, decision makers may need to depart from the general assumption. However, such departures must be based on substantive evidence, not a precautionary approach. In other words, the planning system should not become a proxy regulator for the water industry. If the hon. Member for Witney (Charlie Maynard) still wants to intervene, I am happy to give way.

    View contribution permalink →

  30. Charlie MaynardLiberal Democrat

    I thank the Minister. Does he accept that up and down the country, developments are being approved and brought forward despite everybody knowing that no water treatment capacity will be built out and, in many cases, that the capacity is already failing? The carte blanche answer that the law will cover it is not working. We are in a completely failing predicament.

    View contribution permalink →

  31. Matthew PennycookLabour

    I will come on to some points of detail that I hope will address that. I will say that where appropriate, planning conditions and obligations can play a role. They were dismissed by hon. Members earlier, but they are legally enforceable, provided that the relevant legal and policy tests are satisfied. Let me make a few more points; the hon. Gentleman is more than welcome to intervene again, if there is time. The hon. Member for Chichester asked me about schedule 3 to the Flood and Water Management Act 2010, which provides a statutory framework for sustainable drainage systems. The Government’s position is that 16 years have passed since the introduction of the Act. We need to consider the most efficient and effective way of securing the objectives of part 3, and our considered view is that they are best achieved through national policy, which we have strengthened. The national planning policy framework now makes clear that for developments of all sizes, sustainable drainage techniques should be used where a development could have drainage impacts, and appropriate long-term management arrangements should be in place. The framework, as now constituted, will mean that sustainable drainage technologies are taken up far more widely in new development, but the Government will continue to monitor whether more needs to be done. On the central point of the debate, in August, in parallel to the publication of the new NPPF, the Government published our response to the consultation on reforms to the statutory consultee system. We were clear that the system is not operating effectively: we were told as much not only by housebuilders but by local planning authorities across the country. The Government response confirmed that we will maintain the moratorium on new statutory consultees in the planning application process, subject to periodic review. While the Government considered carefully the case for giving water companies statutory consultee status, we are clear that statutory consultations should be focused where a legal duty is necessary and adds value. In our view, creating blanket additional statutory requirements can introduce duplication, regulatory burden and delay, without necessarily ensuring that the underlying infrastructure is planned or delivered any earlier. Indeed, I would go further, as I did in a debate on 12 March 2025, when I touched on many of the same issues discussed today. I would argue that making water companies statutory consultees not only is not a panacea, as several hon. Members have accepted, but would risk allowing them to argue against the delivery of new homes rather than focus on their responsibility to ensure that the appropriate infrastructure is in place at the outset. Of course—this is important—water companies not having statutory consultee status does not prevent them from submitting their views on individual applications. There seemed to be some confusion from the Liberal Democrats that being a statutory consultee offers a veto over planning decisions—it does not. Statutory consultees are allowed to input material considerations, which water companies can already do on individual planning applications. Any interested party can make representations. Water companies can work proactively with councils to identify developments of interest, and where particular water issues arise, local planning authorities can consult them directly.

    View contribution permalink →

  32. Alison BennettLiberal Democrat

    Does the Minister accept that in the vast majority of cases, water companies do not participate in the planning process?

    View contribution permalink →

  33. Matthew PennycookLabour

    I do not accept that, and I will come on to make that point. Due partly to other hon. Members speaking for slightly longer than they should have, I have run out of time to respond to many of the points made. Let me make a central point: the Government’s view remains that strategic issues such as water capacity, drainage and waste water management are best dealt with at the strategic plan-making stage, when cumulative requirements can be identified across an area and infrastructure needs can be addressed early, rather than through individual planning applications. As was widely accepted in hon. Members’ contributions this afternoon, we want water companies to be engaged earlier and more strategically through the plan-making system. That is why although water companies are not statutory consultees on individual planning applications, statute requires that they are consulted in the preparation of local plans. Water companies are under a statutory duty to provide new water and sewerage connections, and must plan for future growth through their water resources and waste water management plans. The water resources planning guideline published by the Environment Agency and Ofwat sets out how those companies should forecast demand for water based on existing customers and planned levels of household and non-household growth. Given the time, Mrs Barker, I will have to finish there. Hon. Members have raised a number of wider points, and I would have loved to touch on local plans in more detail. I am afraid that the Liberal Democrat spokesperson, the hon. Member for Taunton and Wellington (Gideon Amos), is plain wrong to suggest that the changes to the national planning policy framework at a stroke rendered plans across the country out of date—that is simply wrong. If the hon. Gentleman is going to be a Front-Bench spokesperson on these issues, he really needs to do his research. We have strengthened the plan-making system, introducing new measures to subject water and sewage to “requirement to assist” regulations. I am more than happy to sit down with the Liberal Democrat Members present and other hon. Members to discuss the issue in more detail, and to write to hon. Members with more detailed responses on the many specific points that were raised. Question put and agreed to. Resolved, That this House has considered the impact of water companies not being statutory consultees on planning applications.

    View contribution permalink →

  34. Sitting adjourned.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440367.