Hansard·Westminster Hall·Vol. 793

Brighton Main Line: Croydon Area Remodelling Scheme

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

15 contributions7 members

Contributions

  1. Clive Efford (in the Chair)Labour

    I will call Peter Lamb to move the motion; I will then call the Minister to respond. I remind other Members that they may make a speech only with prior permission from the Member in charge of the debate and from the Minister. As is the convention for 30-minute debates, there will not be an opportunity for the Member in charge to wind up.

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Peter Lamb (Crawley) (Lab)Labour

    I beg to move, That this House has considered Government support for the Croydon Area Remodelling Scheme on the Brighton Main Line. It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. The Brighton main line has been a significant area of focus of mine for about a decade. I am grateful for the support offered by my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East (Natasha Irons)—in whose patch the remodelling works are supposed to take place—during the two and a half years for which we have been in this place together. The Brighton main line is one of the most significant stretches of rail in the entire country. Roughly a fifth of all journeys in the UK take place along the line each day, and it acts as, essentially, the only direct rail link running the whole way through the north and south of London. The line plays a vital role for the many commuter towns along the route, enabling people to get to work each day. It provides the main public transport connectivity for two of the UK’s major airports, and without it much of the south would lack any direct rail connection with the city, and vice versa. Unfortunately, the very success of the line puts its future at risk. Despite covid and the shift to greater home working, the use of capacity on the line during peak hours has now reached pre-pandemic levels. In a little over three years’ time, the line will run out of capacity completely. People will be simply unable to get on trains. This will have an enormous impact on the economy of the sub-region, which is one of the strongest in the country, and on the quality of life of all those who rely on the line as a means of transportation. This issue has not crept up on us; I and others have been raising it for roughly a decade. We have known for years that capacity on the line was running out. Although longer trains with additional carriages and a few other minor improvements can buy us some time, the only way to resolve the capacity issue is for large-scale remodelling works to be undertaken to resolve the current pinch point at East Croydon. Despite initial setbacks, we successfully secured, through the work of the Brighton Mainline Alliance, a commitment from the Department for Transport to undertake the improvements, and the land assembly and planning works began. Yet it was not to last and, alongside High Speed 2, the works became another victim of the Sunak Government’s railway cuts—a fact many of us remained unaware of for a very long time. That decision was enormously short-sighted. The works may need to take place in London, but the scheme benefits services that run from Brighton all the way to Cambridge, Bedford and Peterborough, with connecting services covering much of the south-east and east of England. The project is about the full length of the Greater Thameslink growth corridor and the economic risk to the United Kingdom. The Government have announced, with great fanfare, the expansion of Gatwick and Luton airports, the securing of Universal Studios UK, and the construction of new towns such as Tempsford, all of which fall within the Greater Thameslink growth corridor, and all of which depend on an increase in rail capacity along the Brighton main line.

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Jim Shannon (Strangford) (DUP)Democratic Unionist Party

    I am here to support the hon. Gentleman; I always try to be helpful in my interventions. In Northern Ireland, we really needed the major development of Grand Central station, because the capacity need was at an all-time high, just as in the situation to which the hon. Gentleman refers. Does he agree that, while recognising the need for essential upgrades, we must consider carefully ways to keep disruption on railways to an absolute minimum, to reduce the impact on passengers? The hon. Gentleman talks about the way forward; I think the impact on passengers will be great.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Peter LambLabour

    I agree with the hon. Gentleman. In fact, the later we leave it, the more challenging it becomes, because we have less capacity and ability to put in place measures to limit the impact. We already experience that on a regular basis. At one point, I was due to meet representatives of the Department of Transport to discuss the rail link, and I arrived late because I was stuck outside East Croydon station. That happens to me regularly, as I commute to Parliament daily—I often find myself spending a fair amount of time on one side of East Croydon station or the other. We should do the maximum amount to minimise disruption. The line is crucial, and not just for people from the UK; it serves two international airports, so it is many people’s first experience of the UK. Significant delegations of investors looking to invest in the UK have been held on the line for prolonged periods, and have subsequently decided not to invest in the United Kingdom because of that experience.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Alison Bennett (Mid Sussex) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    The hon. Gentleman is making important points about a line that affects my constituency. Last month, 45% of trains from Haywards Heath ran late, and that is costing our economy money. When people need to make connections at, say Clapham Junction, they get delayed. Does the hon. Gentleman agree that time is money for those running businesses, and that the delays to improving East Croydon are unacceptable?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Peter LambLabour

    Absolutely. One reason for the introduction of the Gatwick Express service was to provide reliable connectivity between the city and the airport, and it is often used by business passengers. The reductions in the efficiency of that service over time have diminished an awful lot of that impact. The reality is that businesspeople who have a lot of work to be transacting find themselves increasingly unable to use the line efficiently at all. It is not simply a case of delays; the level of congestion makes it hard for anyone to use their time on the train usefully. They cannot sit down and deal with emails; they are absolutely packed in like cattle at peak hours. There is no way of moving, so the journey is entirely dead time for that person and their business. The cost attached of the improvements is significant—I do not doubt that—but the current estimate is a one-off cost in the realm of £2.9 billion. Gatwick’s expansion alone is set to increase the gross value added to the UK economy by £2 billion per annum. That is just one of the projects that is relying on the works taking place. I fully support the Government’s ambition to deliver growth in every postcode, which is likely to involve investing in regions that have not seen investment for quite some time. As I have said since long before I got into my current role, the economic regeneration of the north of England is essential for London and the south-east, where we have to deal with the constant issue of younger working-age people moving to the south because it is the only place where there is sufficient employment. That has created an utterly unsustainably high pressure on housing and infrastructure. Money can help to deal with some of the pressures, but the reality is that problems such as the water capacity in the south cannot easily be resolved. We physically cannot deal with the population size in the south of England. It is to the benefit of everyone currently living in the area to enable people to succeed and prosper in other parts of the United Kingdom. The problem is that that will not happen if we kill the goose that lays the golden eggs. London and the south-east are the only regions that are net contributors to the UK. They fund the rest of the UK, and if we fail to deliver the infrastructure that makes it possible for those areas to continue to function and to grow, every part of the country will suffer. It is worth noting that even without enabling the projects that I have already mentioned, the Croydon scheme is one of the few major projects that will ultimately pay for itself. The Brighton main line is the only line in the Greater Thameslink railway network—which I believe is the largest network in the country—that makes a profit. It subsidises all other routes and, unusually, the problem is not attracting people to go by rail; it is too many people travelling by rail. We therefore have guaranteed additional ticket sales when the extra capacity is introduced, and sales will only grow over time. Combined with the development work around East Croydon station that the works will enable, this will cover the scheme’s costs several times over. The works are essential for the quality of life of my local residents and all those who live along the lines that cover much of the south of England.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Jess Brown-Fuller (Chichester) (LD)Liberal Democrat

    The hon. Gentleman talks about the impact on the entirety of the south-east. It is difficult for me to explain to my constituents in Chichester that their trains are often delayed because of an issue in Croydon, but that is the reality of the situation. The bottleneck causes a ripple effect of delays down the entirety of the line, and the hon. Gentleman is right to point out the economic damage caused. Does he agree that if the Government invest in the Croydon area remodelling scheme, they will unlock untold economic benefits for the south-east, so that it can continue to be a net contributor?

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Peter LambLabour

    I absolutely agree. As a member of West Sussex county council I regularly utilised the line between Three Bridges and Chichester, and I often found myself late to meetings because of exactly that congestion. We are talking about an enormous area where this is one of the most significant pieces of infrastructure. The sheer scale of the economic and population impact, without reasonable alternatives in the area, needs to be taken into account in prioritising investment in this scheme compared with other investments. The works would deliver huge economic growth opportunities for the UK and, in the process, deliver new revenue for the Treasury and unlock the prized projects that the Government have secured or announced. Ultimately, the works would pay for themselves. In reality, given the capacity constraints along the Greater Thameslink growth corridor, we only have three years left before we hit a crisis, but it is a problem that I know we can solve. We know very well the solution—it has been scoped already—but the clock is ticking. I offer my thanks to the Minister for being here, and to all those who have attended to participate in this important debate.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Natasha Irons (Croydon East) (Lab)Labour

    It is a pleasure to serve under your chairmanship, Mr Efford. I thank my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb) for securing the debate and for his continued support in the campaign to unblock the Croydon bottleneck. As the Minister knows, I have raised this issue repeatedly in the House. It has implications not just for my constituents but for passengers, businesses and communities right across London, the south-east and beyond. Last week, alongside the Good Growth Foundation, I launched a new report, “A Gateway to Gatwick and Beyond”, which sets out the enormous economic potential of the Croydon area remodelling scheme. The report found that in 2024, 67% of trains at East Croydon station were delayed or cancelled, and those delays were felt by passengers from Brighton to Bedford and everywhere in between. By addressing the Croydon bottleneck we could unlock more than £5 billion in economic benefits over the next 20 years—including more than 10,000 permanent jobs and over 14,000 new homes on brownfield land—and save commuters over 200,000 hours in commuting time. The Labour Government have rightly backed the expansion of Gatwick and Luton airports, and the development of the Universal Studios site in Bedford. Those major investments will drive economic growth and create jobs, but what connects two of our fastest-growing airports and some of our most significant new developments is a stretch of Victorian railway infrastructure that struggles to cope with the demands already placed on it. If we are serious about realising the full economic potential of those developments, we must also invest in the infrastructure that connects them. I appreciate the financial challenges that face the Government, so our report looks at how we could fund this vital scheme. We propose a mutual investment model to bring together central Government, local authorities and the private sector to share the cost of developing the improvements. The scheme would have a number of significant beneficiaries, from Gatwick airport to major landowners and developers in Croydon. If investment in our railway is to unlock billions of pounds in development and increase the value of commercial and residential land, there is a case for capturing some of that value to help to pay for the infrastructure that makes it possible. The full cost of the scheme need not fall at the feet of the Treasury, and I would welcome the Minister’s thoughts on how we might explore alternative funding models to get the scheme moving again. But, as I have previously stated, my main motivation for backing this billion-pound scheme that could unlock billions in economic growth and opportunity across the south-east is simply to get a lift at Norwood Junction station. Network Rail will not progress plans for a lift on the off-chance that any scheme may include remodelling options for the station, yet for now the Department of Transport says that the scheme remains cancelled. That leaves my constituents stuck in a frustrating cycle of lift limbo. For disabled passengers, elderly residents and parents with pushchairs, the lack of step-free access is not simply an inconvenience, but a barrier to using their local railway station.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Alison BennettLiberal Democrat

    The hon. Member makes an important point about the lack of step-free access at Norwood station. People wanting to travel from there to Wivelsfield station in my constituency would face the same problem, as it has step-free access on only one side. Step-free access was granted under Access for All and then found to be not funded. Does she agree that it is essential that everybody, regardless of their accessibility needs, can travel on our rail network?

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Natasha IronsLabour

    I completely agree. Step-free access is not just a nice-to-have; it is essential to ensure that we have an inclusive public transport system to which everyone has equal access. There is an opportunity for us to break the cycle. I recently met colleagues from Network Rail and GTR who are working closely with the Department for Transport on the case for the Thameslink growth corridor. I understand that Network Rail plans to undertake essential renewals in the Norwood area in the early 2030s, which presents a window of opportunity to deliver improvements, making better use of public money and minimising disruption to passengers. I would be grateful if the Minister considered what steps his Department could take to capitalise on that opportunity and, crucially, how we can ensure that step-free access at Norwood Junction station is finally secured. We have an opportunity to unblock billions of pounds in economic growth, build thousands of homes, create thousands of jobs and make a tangible difference to the lives of commuters using Norwood Junction station. The Labour Government are committed to breaking down barriers to opportunity. At Norwood Junction, that barrier is quite literally a flight of stairs. I hope the Minister will help us to finally get out of our lift limbo.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Transport (Justin Madders)Labour

    It is a pleasure to see you in the Chair, Mr Efford. I congratulate my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley (Peter Lamb) on securing this important debate and on his continued advocacy for his constituents and the millions of other passengers using the Brighton main line every year. My hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East (Natasha Irons) is an equally passionate and persistent advocate for improvements on the rail system in her constituency and beyond. As we have heard, the Brighton main line is far more than a railway; it is an economic lifeline. It connects the south coast with London, opening up access to Gatwick airport and carrying millions of passengers to jobs, businesses and opportunities every year. A railway of this importance demands sustained investment. The Brighton main line underpins billions of pounds of economic activity, helps businesses to prosper, supports communities and connects people with opportunities across the south-east and beyond. Since it was completed in 2020, the £7 billion Thameslink programme has delivered a once in a generation transformation of north-south rail through London. New class 700 trains brought substantially greater capacity and customer experience to the Brighton main line, while modern technology has helped to deliver a more reliable and resilient railway for passengers. That transformation extended to many stations along the line. London Bridge and London Blackfriars were comprehensively redeveloped, while Farringdon has become a major strategic interchange that brings Thameslink and the Elizabeth line together. The result is a stronger, better-connected railway that continues to play a fundamental role in the economic success of London, the south-east and the communities it serves. Planning within the railway now increasingly recognises the importance of the Thameslink growth corridor as a whole, stretching from Brighton in the south all the way through to Cambridgeshire, Peterborough and Bedford. We heard reference to the international visitors to the country through Gatwick airport. Over £250 million was spent upgrading Gatwick Airport station, delivering a more accessible concourse, doubling the space for passengers and improving the reliability of trains calling at the station. For too many years, Gatwick station had impacted service across the Brighton main line due to the extended time that passengers needed to board and alight trains. Following platform widening and the creation of an entirely new passenger concourse, passengers can board more quickly. [Paula Barker in the Chair ] In addition, recent upgrades to the track and signalling infrastructure in the Gatwick area reduced delays and cut the journey time between Brighton and London by up to five minutes, while improving overall performance and reliability. The significant suite of works at Gatwick has also reduced knock-on delays further up and down the line. We have heard extensively in this debate about the importance of connectivity with other elements of the network. I hope that my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley has seen some improvements in the line, but he is right to look ahead. He knows that there are challenges that have not gone away—challenges that were identified a considerable time ago. Plans to bring Gatwick’s northern runway into routine use represents an exciting investment in Crawley and the wider south-east. We know that this has the potential to create more jobs, strengthen the local economy and support the airport’s long-term resilience, but we are clear that additional airport capacity must be matched by sustainable and reliable surface access. The Brighton main line, Gatwick Airport station and the wider Thameslink growth corridor will therefore have an important role in supporting air passenger growth. As we have heard, before the pandemic the Croydon area remodelling scheme—I will refer to it as CARS, which seems a little ironic, given that this is a rail debate—was developed as a way to address overcrowding, increase capacity and improve reliability on the Brighton main line. The complex junction at Selhurst, often referred to as the Croydon bottleneck, alongside the challenging operation of East Croydon and Norwood Junction stations, place significant constraint on the capacity and smooth operation of the network. CARS was developed to address those challenges by extensive remodelling of the tracks and rail junctions north of East Croydon station. The programme also included plans for the redevelopment of East Croydon and Norwood Junction stations. At the time, Network Rail estimated that the scheme would take more than 10 years to deliver, costing about £2.9 billion. Delivery would also require substantial disruption to passengers travelling along the Brighton main line. But as we know, the covid-19 pandemic changed travel patterns, created uncertainty about future demand and placed considerable pressure on public finances. As my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley mentioned, the previous Government took the decision to cancel the scheme at the 2021 spending review, although, as he noted, that was probably not communicated as swiftly as people would have wanted. Sadly, on 8 July last year the Secretary of State updated Parliament on rail infrastructure schemes progressing following the 2025 spending review, and as my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley is aware, CARS was not allocated any funding at that time. However, the Government are committed to delivering infrastructure that offers the greatest benefit to passengers and the wider economy as quickly as possible within a fully funded and deliverable programme. Given the limited funding available for rail enhancement projects and significant recent investment already made on the line, including for the Thameslink programme and the Gatwick area upgrades, the difficult decision was taken at the spending review 2025 not to prioritise the scheme for that particular period. That is not to say we will not look at it closely moving forward. I am very interested to read the Good Growth Foundation report that my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East mentioned. It will be an opportunity for the Department and probably the Treasury, given that there are interesting suggestions in there about funding options, but we will consider that in the round and whether there is anything on which we can move forward. I reassure Members that work is going on right now to find innovative and affordable measures that can improve services on such a crucial area of the network. That includes considering whether elements of CARS could be delivered in phases alongside planned upcoming renewals, as has been referred to. Of course, we acknowledge that this approach would not deliver immediately the full benefits of CARS, but it would still deliver key passenger-facing benefits, including improved reliability across the BML and wider Thameslink growth corridor, and also, hopefully, deliver step-free access at Norwood Junction station, which my hon. Friend the Member for Croydon East has been campaigning for so persistently. I should make it clear that if we can take those steps, that does not rule out delivery of the full CARS in future, but we are looking towards more pragmatically delivering passenger benefits in a staged way that is likely to be within the funding envelopes that will come in due course. As Members would expect, next year’s spending review will be an important opportunity to make the case for future investment. I look forward to working with my hon. Friend the Member for Crawley and all hon. Members, alongside the Rail Minister, to develop that case. I thank my hon. Friend for securing today’s debate and for the commitment that he continues to show in championing improvements for rail passengers. I understand the disappointment caused by the original decision in 2021 and the decision last year. Although we recognise that that has not led to us being able to tackle the immediate challenges and impacts of the Croydon bottleneck, we are committed to working constructively with partners in the coming months and years to find what we can do within the funding envelopes that might be available to us. I can assure hon. Members that the Rail Minister is more than happy to engage with them and all stakeholders to find any interim solutions that might be of assistance to passengers on that part of the network. Question put and agreed to.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Sitting suspended.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5440366.