L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I have to say, speaking on behalf of the Conservative Benches, that our party does not approve of this Bill. We are the party of private enterprise and prosperity, and the competition that creates that prosperity. We are proud of what the privatised railways have achieved in fantastically increased numbers of passengers and wonderful new rolling stock, which the Treasury would never have paid for if the railways had not been taken out of that system and put into a privatised structure. None the less, we recognise the need for reform. Those who go back to my speech on the Bill two years ago, which began the process of terminating the TOCs franchises, will recall that I said then that the system that had been adopted had shown cracks, and that these were well exposed when we came to Covid. Reform is needed, and we set in hand the Williams review to point the way. It created the single controlling mind that the Government and the Minister wish to see brought into the railways, but it continued to involve the private sector in the running of passenger rail services. The problem the Government have made for themselves in deciding to be both the single controlling mind—effectively, the regulator of the system—and a provider of passenger rail services is that they have created a load of internal tensions, because they are in competition with other private parties. For example, they are in competition for access to the track and in relation to retail sales, and online retail sales in particular, where they are going to be both the competitor and the decision-maker. It could be said that there is an appeals system to the ORR, but that appeals system is extremely exiguous and rests only on judicial review grounds. The Government have created these problems for themselves, and they are going to arise again on Report. We should bear in mind that, after this Bill has been brought into effect and the system has been completed—which will take some years, I admit—only 75% of the movements on the rails will be GBR movements. The other 25% will be non-GBR movements, principally freight, existing open access services, the large number of services provided by mayors—in particular London Overground, London Underground, Merseyrail and so forth—and a certain amount of heritage rail traffic. These are now going to be in competition for access to the track, but their main competitor will be deciding who gets that access. To understand the mentality of those who are proposing this structure from the Government’s point of view, I quote from the consultation document, published last week, for the new licence that GBR will be given. In it, the Government say: “It is vital that GBR can operate with authority, independence, and clear strategic direction, without the day-to-day influence of government or disproportionate regulatory burden”. I can think of many private companies and businesses in this country that would like to be able to say that they operate without day-to-day government interference or a disproportionate regulatory burden. They do not get that pass, but GBR wants it. It is not keen to be accountable to Parliament; it wants that independence and does not want a strong regulatory system in control of it. That is dangerous and, as I said, something that various amendments continue to address. This amendment addresses a most egregious clause—Clause 1(3)—which states that, once GBR has been designated, a process that the Secretary of State is required to go through, “no Minister of the Crown, and no person who is a member of the body”— GBR— “may take any steps that will result in the body ceasing to be wholly owned by the Crown”. The Government will say that all this does is to require primary legislation for the privatisation of GBR in the future. I say that it goes way beyond that, as “any steps” would include an incoming Minister for a new Government instructing civil servants to prepare such legislation. The clause is drafted far too widely and it should go. I pulled it out as a small illustration of the—what shall I call it?—arrogance or hubris on the part of those who wish to see a railway system that is almost completely free of governmental control, parliamentary accountability and regulatory conformity. The clause ought to go and the Minister should be willing to say so. With that, I beg to move.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.