L

Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I want to add a brief footnote to the excellent speech made by my noble friend Lady Harding. It is worth putting on the record what the Competition and Markets Authority has said on precisely this subject. It said: “In a more closely integrated model, additional safeguards are likely to be required in order to achieve the government’s aim to ensure the sector benefits from the effects of fair and open competition between GBR and TPRs”. The question is whether government Amendment 9 delivers that commitment. My view is that, without Amendment 16, Amendment 9 does not work, because the ORR simply will not have the information to decide whether there has been discrimination against independent retailers, so I agree with her every word. The only point I want to make is that there seems to be a parallel between GBR and BT, in that both are companies that own infrastructure but also retail. What happened in the case of BT was that Openreach, the infrastructure company owning the cabinets, telephone wires and broadband services, was separated from BT. The other part of BT is a retailer, and that retail part competed with TalkTalk and Virgin Media. Ofcom took an interest when exactly the sort of concerns expressed by my noble friend Lady Harding were expressed by the retailers competing with BT, which asserted that Openreach was giving them preferential terms. The conclusion that Ofcom came to was that, although BT Group could own both, they had to be separate companies. My noble friend’s amendment does not go as far as that. It would simply require the retailing operation to have separate cost and revenue accounts. This seems an entirely sensible way to avoid exactly the sorts of concerns expressed by retailers. If it does not go through, there will be less investment by them in innovation and developing new techniques. Again, it is worth putting on the record that the independent retailers have grown the market for ticketing by some £450 million. It is in the interest of GBR as a whole for the independent sector’s retailing to continue to innovate and grow the market. I hope, having listened to the debate, that the Minister will not oppose Amendment 16.

More from Lord Young of Cookham (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.