L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I strongly support everything my noble friend Lord Moylan said, so I will not repeat it. I remind the Minister that, in the last spending review, the Department for Transport and the Treasury agreed that the DfT would significantly reduce the level of subsidy from the taxpayer to run rail operations. I am somewhat sceptical about how realistic that agreement was, because I have not seen any evidence yet that the Government have a plan for driving up revenue sufficiently to close the gap between revenue and costs in order to bring that subsidy down. My noble friend Lord Moylan is absolutely correct that the subsidy has to be covered by the department’s spending. That has to be secured in a spending review. We all know, from reading about all the pressures on the Government’s departmental expenditure at the moment, that at the next spending review the Department for Transport will struggle to sustain its existing level of funding, let alone get any more. It is absolutely in the interests of the rail system as a whole, GBR and the department to have a very good plan for reducing the subsidy required; otherwise, the Treasury simply will not agree the level of subsidy and the department will be forced to make decisions that are not sensible to reduce cost, and these will have an impact on the service that is delivered. My noble friend is right: if you are going to reduce the subsidy to the minimum level, the way you do that is not to cut costs and reduce services but to innovate and drive up the number of customers using the railway —passengers, freight customers and open access operators —and drive up the revenues and reduce the net cost to the taxpayer. If you do that, you will have a railway that is sustainable over the long term and that will deliver not just for the taxpayer but for the fare payer and the passenger at large. My noble friend’s amendments are very well intentioned; they flow with the agreement that the DfT made with the Treasury at the previous spending review, and I am pretty sure that they are in line with where the Department for Transport will end up negotiating with the Treasury at the next spending review, if everything we read about the pressures on public finances is true. I hope that, if the Minister cannot accept my noble friend’s amendments, he can at least accept that they have the right spirit and tell us what the department is going to do to make sure it can drive down the net cost of running the railway to the taxpayer.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.