L

Lord Harper (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 18 November 2026

Debate

Railways Bill

Contribution

My Lords, I will speak to a number of these amendments. I have three tabled in my name, but I will start by referring to the lead amendment, Amendment 24 from my noble friend Lord Moylan. They are of course connected. For most people who work in the private sector, to suggest that a company have a pay and productivity policy, in which what you pay people bears some relation to the level of productivity in the business, would strike them as fairly unexceptional and quite reasonable. If businesses that operate in competitive marketplaces do not behave like that, they do not exist for very long. Trade unions that operate in businesses that work in competitive marketplaces absolutely understand that. In my experience, they behave accordingly and often have very constructive relationships with the management of the businesses they operate in, because they understand the fundamental truth that, if the business is not profitable, there are no secure, well-paid jobs for their members. You tend therefore to have a much more constructive relationship. In my experience, it is in the public sector, where there is always the taxpayer to bail out unproductive working practices, that you get some of the most unhelpful relationships, because unions know that they can use political power to try to extract more cash rather than delivering productivity. My noble friend Lord Moylan talked about what this Government did at the beginning of their time in office, which demonstrates why his amendment is well targeted. One of the consequences of the then Transport Secretary handing out no-strings-attached money to train drivers was that the existing negotiations under way between the RMT and the train operating companies —which were constructive and going well, and intended to reach a win-win deal through which we would deliver productivity improvements, which would help fund pay rises for all of the staff working in train operating companies, from the lowest paid to the highest paid, in a sustainable way that was fair to both farepayers and the taxpayer—were blown up. The RMT said, not unreasonably, “If you are going to hand out a load of free money to train drivers without asking for anything in return, it is not unreasonable that you do the same for our members”. That is what happened. Pay rises were given out to all the workers in the rail sector and there was nothing gained in return. Going back to the previous group, this is at a time when the taxpayer is having to put multibillion pounds-worth of subsidy into keeping those passenger services operating. My noble friend’s Amendment 24 is very reasonable. It seems to me extraordinary that the Government would not want to have that in place for their own negotiating arm. The three amendments in my name are all connected. The first flows from what the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, noted about minimum service levels. He referred to what happened in France. The amendment does not say that unions cannot take industrial action, but it recognises that many people depend on railways for their own economic freedom—to get to work or hospital, or to do important things—and that the freight sector has to keep products we all use flowing and many essential services working. It says that, if you are going to go on strike, you have to make sure that there is at least a minimum level of service to keep those essential things operating. I accept it is not a straightforward thing to deliver. We had a go at delivering it and it is complicated. It never had to be tested, but the legislation is complicated. The amendment is well intended, and I am interested to hear why the Minister does not think it is necessary. Amendment 50 is on industrial action ballots relating to passenger railway services. It does not try to do anything more widely, but would address the changes made in the Employment Rights Act, which got rid of the requirements whereby at least 50% of those entitled to vote had to participate in ballots and at least 40% of those entitled to vote had to vote in favour of industrial action. Those were swept away. We are not proposing in this amendment to change that more widely but, for the reasons I set out about its essential nature for many people and services in the country, it should certainly be re-established for the rail industry. Finally, my Amendment 51 is partly about today but also partly about the future. It connects back to the conversation we had on Amendment 24. GBR has been taking back into public ownership franchises as those contracts expire. They are separate companies owned by GBR. When we debated this in Committee, the Minister made it clear that the Government have no plans at the moment to consolidate any of those operating companies into a single entity or fewer entities. This amendment does two things. It says that unions cannot argue that people working for those different companies are actually all working for the same employer, even though they are all owned by GBR. That would stop there being a national rail strike. As soon as you can have a national rail strike, you significantly strengthen the bargaining power of unions, which means they will be in a much stronger position to extract money without any strings attached from Ministers and the taxpayer. That would be unhelpful. Finally, can the Minister confirm what will happen in the future? It is certainly the case that the rail unions want the companies all to be part of one entity once they are owned by GBR. They want one set of terms and conditions and one entity. It is my understanding that, without making any changes, at that point it would be possible for the trade unions to have a national rail strike. Is the Minister comfortable with that, or can the Government see that that is not a helpful place to be and it would be much better from their point of view if they had better bargaining power on behalf of the taxpayer? That is the reason I tabled my amendments.

More from Lord Harper (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.