B

Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to the inquiry by the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for highlighting such critical issues. I will confine my remarks to fly-tipping. It is a societal problem. It is anti-social, environmentally challenging, criminal and, at the end of the day, costly to all of us, as insurance premiums rise and we have to pay for them. I want to share the experience of Alex Sell, a farmer near Basildon, opposite the A13 and near the M25. In August of this year, he noticed that the padlock on his farm gate had changed. When he walked into his crop of maize, which by this time was six to seven feet tall, he realised that middle-screener fines had been dumped in the middle of the field. Ironically, the waste—wood, stone, plastic and metal—appeared to come from recycling centres. In all, 2,000 tonnes had been dumped. Mr Sell had few options: take it to landfill himself or pay to have it taken. It was taken to landfill, at a cost of £350,000. He lost this year’s crop, worth about £6,000, and, since he was unable to plant his winter barley, he lost his rotation and it will take two to three years for the fields to recover. Mr Sell was insured. Up till now his insurance has cost him £3,000 a month, but, after such a big claim, he does not know what it will be in future. Not surprisingly, Mr Sell was upset, but he was even more upset when he was pushed from pillar to post by the police and the Environment Agency. The police said it was a civil crime because it happened on private land and their responsibility stopped at the padlock. The Environment Agency said it was nothing to do with them but was a matter for the police. While this was happening to Mr Sell, another 2,000 tonnes was dumped among six neighbouring farms along the road. This was mostly domestic waste, often by people turned away from the local authority dump. I could cite many examples of fly-tipping and the harm and costs that it imposes on individual farmers, but Mr Sell’s experience demonstrates the issues faced throughout the United Kingdom on an almost daily basis. There is much to be commended in the noble Baroness’s proposals. I agree that large companies should appoint a named director who is responsible for compliance with the waste statutory duty of care. I heard the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, and I am sure that a lot of company directors will think it is insane, but if they were responsible in the first place then we would not have to impose this regulation. Companies should be liable for the costs of clean-up and clearance if their waste is mismanaged, and the Environment Agency needs to raise its game. In March this year, the Government published a waste climate action plan with a range of proposals designed to tackle the problem. It will be a cause for celebration if that works. Today, I ask my noble friend the Minister this: if it does not work, will the Government urgently revisit the legislation?

More from Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.