Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]
Friday, 20 November 2026
Contributions
Second Reading
Moved by
Baroness Sheehan
That the Bill be now read a second time.
Baroness Sheehan (LD)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who are speaking in today’s debate. Their voices matter to the communities and individuals harmed by the actions of unscrupulous criminals, and to the many organisations that have written to noble Lords in support of the Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill. I do not have time to name every organisation, but they include Wildlife and Countryside Link—the largest environment and wildlife coalition in England, with a collective membership of 8 million people—as well as the National Farmers’ Union, the Countryside Alliance and Peers for the Planet. I am grateful for their support. It would be remiss of me not to thank the Environmental Services Association, the trade association for the regulated waste sector, for its advice and guidance in helping to ensure that the measures in the Bill are workable from an industry perspective. I thank it for its comprehensive and highly useful briefings; they have been invaluable. I also acknowledge the work that the Minister has undertaken to give this important issue the attention it deserves. I very much hope that she will recognise the merit of the two simple measures contained in the Bill. The measures are designed to help prevent the mass illegal movement of waste, to spare communities the environmental blight and misery that follows, and to bring an end to the injustice of requiring innocent landowners, including charities, farmers and private individuals, to bear the cost of clearing up illegally dumped waste. These costs can run into tens of thousands of pounds, and sometimes millions. In some cases, the full force of the law is brought to bear on the very people who are the victims of this crime. The purpose of the Bill is to strengthen responsibility at the point at which waste enters the supply chain. It seeks to turn off the tap at source, and does so by requiring a named director to take responsibility for a company’s waste from the point at which it is produced until its final destination. In short, it places responsibility firmly in the boardroom. Furthermore, where it is subsequently established that waste produced or handled by a company has been unlawfully managed, and that the company has failed to exercise due diligence, that company will be responsible for the cost of clearing up and remediating the illegally managed waste. That is fairness. These measures are straightforward, practical to implement and should not impose substantial costs on businesses or on government. Producer responsibility already exists; the Bill seeks to make it meaningful and enforceable. The Bill builds on, rather than replaces, the existing duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. It raises standards of governance, contractor assurance and board-level accountability for supply-chain oversight. It will close the loopholes that allow waste in bulk to leak into the hands of criminals, both at source and throughout its journey, and ensure that waste is responsibly managed across the supply chain. This Bill is necessary because the failure of our enforcement agencies to tackle waste crime is self-evident. I am sure that noble Lords have been unable to escape the media coverage of the many occasions on which the Environment Agency has failed to prevent tens of thousands of tonnes of putrid, often toxic, waste from blighting communities, polluting our land, water and air, and costing the taxpayer billions of pounds. The consequences extend beyond clean-up costs. They include landfill tax revenue, lost income for the legitimate waste management sector and a serious undermining of recycling efforts and the Government’s ambitions for a circular economy. I have seen for myself the devastation caused at the ancient woodland SSSI site at Hoads Wood in Kent, where taxpayers faced a bill of £15 million to clear 30,000 tonnes of waste. I have seen the site at Kidlington in Oxfordshire, where clearance is estimated to cost £7 million for 25,000 tonnes of waste. Worst of all, because it was located within metres of homes and a primary school, I saw the waste dumped at Bolton House Road in Bickershaw, Wigan. That site was infested with rats, flies and maggots. It was the cause of two fires in the summer of 2025, which forced the school to close because of the noxious fumes. The last of those sites is, of course, in the Prime Minister’s own constituency. I welcome his intervention on behalf of his constituents, which has finally secured the site’s clearance. I hope that he will also recognise the merits of this Bill in preventing such toxicity from entering the public domain elsewhere in the country. Those three sites have now been cleared or are in the process of being cleared, and others have been earmarked for clearance, but many remain without any clear plan of action. These include the sites at Camborne, Northwich, Over Farm in Gloucestershire, the Isle of Sheppey and Raspberry Hill Park Farm, among many, many others. The scale of the problem is stark. The Environment Agency’s own figures from its National Waste Crime Survey 2025 estimate that 38 million tonnes of waste are illegally managed in England each year. We are dealing with serious organised criminal networks operating on an industrial scale, with sophisticated logistics and management structures. More than a decade ago, Sir James Bevan, then chief executive of the Environment Agency, described waste crime as “the new narcotics”. Waste crime is a gateway to other serious organised crime, including money laundering, modern-day slavery and gun-running. It is frequently characterised by violence and intimidation. Indeed, so serious were the concerns that some witnesses to the Environment and Climate Change Committee’s inquiry into waste crime chose to remain anonymous. The old adage “Where there’s muck, there’s brass” might more accurately be revised today to “Where there’s muck, there’s gold”. Waste crime is attractive to criminals because the profits are eye-watering, while the chances of detection remain low. Your Lordships’ Environment and Climate Change Committee was shocked to learn during its inquiry into waste crime that, even when criminals are caught, fines can amount to only a few hundred pounds. Set against a potential payload of £2,500 per truckload, and with around 30 trucks a day arriving at Hoads Wood at the height of the activity, it is difficult to describe such penalties as a deterrent. The reality is that much of this industrial-scale illegal activity is facilitated by waste-handling sites permitted by the Environment Agency. I give one example of how this occurs at the waste-processing stage. Transfer stations and materials recovery facilities—MRFs—operating unlawfully, albeit with permits from the Environment Agency, can shred or blend mixed waste to obscure its origin. The waste is compacted and bulked up for loading on to large vehicles capable of carrying 25 tonnes; it can then be diverted to illegal dumping sites or exported. It is clear that much of the waste dumped at Hoads Wood, Bickershaw and Kidlington had passed through a transfer station, and I am confident that the same is true of the majority of the 117 high-priority illegal waste sites now acknowledged by the Environment Agency. Another form of large-scale illegal activity is the misdescription of waste and the exemptions regime in waste management, which is then disposed of unlawfully. There are many loopholes. It is clear that the resources available to criminal gangs far outstrip those of enforcement bodies. Enforcement agencies are unable to grip the problem because the opportunities are easy, the profits are enormous and the penalties are paltry. The most effective intervention must therefore be to prevent criminals gaining access to the waste in the first place. The Government’s 10-point action plan is welcome, even if some of its measures are, in my view, somewhat performative. In particular, I welcome the long-awaited reforms relating to carriers, brokers and dealers, as well as the implementation of the first phase of the digital waste-tracking system. These measures will be necessary to enforce the measures in this Bill. Waste crime is estimated to cost the UK economy around £2 billion every year, according to the Environmental Services Association. The Environment Agency has failed to get to grips with this problem, and my Bill is simple in its effect. Naming a director responsible for a company’s waste journey from the point of production to its final destination creates a clear focal point for producer responsibility. Where it is proven that waste produced or handled by an organisation lacks a satisfactory audit trail, that operator should be responsible for the cost of clearing up the illegally managed waste. I end on this note. In the committee’s public oral evidence session just last week, Philip Duffy, chief executive of the Environment Agency, said: “I mentioned anti-corruption. We have a real problem with who is signing off these contracts, either in local government or in the supply chain. Are we confident that we have enough controls to drive out corrupt practices from those areas? Transparency in that area is really important”. That is what my Bill will provide: transparency. The supporters of the Bill are at one with the ESA and the Environment Agency, apparently. I hope the Government will join us, or, as the Minister is aware, the battle to rid our country of the scourge that is waste crime will continue apace.
Lord Grantchester (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to your Lordships’ Environment and Climate Change Committee for its inquiry on waste crime and to its chair, the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for sponsoring the Bill and introducing it to the House today. As Dr Anna Willetts of Gunnercooke legal practice, who wrote to us with her experience on waste crime, says in her submission: “It is this inquiry that has forced the Environment Agency and the Government to start taking waste crime seriously”. I congratulate them on this Bill, and I thank all those who have written in with their support. I declare my interest in having a dairy enterprise, as recorded in the register, with some experience of unwanted household waste dumped by the side of the road. Waste crime has proliferated in recent times. I am sure many of the speakers today will be aware of mass dumps in their vicinity, with Coal Pit Lane Farm near Middlewich in Cheshire being one such notorious site not far from me. The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, has outlined the scale of illegal waste dumping, which has proliferated due to the huge profits it generates for those avoiding the costs of responsible disposal, weak accountability imposed by the current law and low detection rates of those responsible. The inadequate penalties imposed are of little deterrence. To add insult to the present situation, it has been known for the property owner, as the direct victim, who has the responsibility to clear up the waste, to be prosecuted for “knowingly permitting” the deposit on their property. This has to stop. I am delighted to be here today to support the Bill. I am grateful to my noble friend the Minister, the Prime Minister and the Government, who have responded swiftly to introduce a 10-point plan and immediate improvements; for example, resourcing the Environment Agency more adequately after the austerity years of the Conservative Government. I appreciate the agency for its admissions of inadequacy and sudden increases in the placing of restriction orders on sites while inquiries are being followed up. Having said that, however, I have a few reservations about the effectiveness of the legislation being proposed. While it is excellent that companies are being made responsible rather than the landowner—be that the farmer or local authority, or land under a community asset—I note that in Clause 1(1) this applies only to large companies. This is defined under Clause 1(8) as being set in regulations. We do not have that detail today. Can the noble Baroness and my noble friend on the Front Bench responding for the Government say how they envisage this being defined? I contend that waste crime is not limited to being undertaken by large companies. All companies, and even private households where they commit such crimes, should be responsible and accountable. Mass sites build up from multiple small deposits. I ask the Minister to look carefully at the Bill to make the legislation effective at this first attempt, while necessarily making sure it is a proportionate measure that does not fall on the taxpayer or the innocent property owner. The Bill makes provision on the duties of large companies, liabilities, cost recovery and enforcement. However, it does not mention compensation to the landowner. Can the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, and the department consider this and come up with a fair proportion of costs, for example, to set a formula that would automatically be applied? This would thus absolve the landowner from further costs and proceedings to obtain any, as often the prosecuting counsel fails to include this in their proceedings. Finally, custodial sentences do not appear explicit under Clause 5. However, existing legislation allows for custodial sentences. Can the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, clarify the position? I would also like to consider how this Bill applies to water companies. However, I conclude that the Bill is an excellent start to tackling waste crime, and I hope further improvements come forward to ensure that, when it becomes law, it is effective in ending this crime.
Lord Sharpe of Epsom (Con)
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for introducing this debate on the Bill and the Bill itself. We are also grateful to the committee for its extensive work in diagnosing the scale of the problem, which is undeniably acute. Unfortunately, we have a problem with the proposed solution. There is no disagreement that tackling illegal waste disposal and fly-tipping is of the utmost importance, but we have concerns about the additional regulatory burdens that this Bill will impose on business. Businesses have endured more than two years of increasing costs and regulatory pressures under this Government. From the increase in employers’ national insurance contributions—the jobs tax—to the Employment Rights Act and the business rates regime, businesses have faced cost after cost. At a time when many are struggling to afford to recruit new employees, invest and expand, the last thing they need is yet another set of regulatory requirements. Clause 1 would require every qualifying large company to appoint a named director responsible for waste compliance, regardless of whether that business operates in the waste industry. While the Bill allows an existing director to assume that responsibility, it would nevertheless impose additional compliance, reporting and record-keeping obligations on businesses. Companies would also have to maintain records for at least six years and notify regulators of suspected waste-related criminal activity in their supply chains. These requirements would disproportionately burden the responsible businesses already doing the right thing, while doing little to tackle the rogue operators deliberately engaging in illegal waste disposal. It would impose further costs on legitimate businesses without addressing the underlying failures in enforcement. I declare my interests as a company director as set out in the register, but any individual accepting these responsibilities would have to be borderline insane. It is welcome that the Government finally recognised the need to reduce some of these burdens when, in January 2026, they abandoned their proposed audit reform and corporate governance Bill, acknowledging that further corporate governance measures would increase costs for businesses. They are therefore right to reject the recommendations of the Environment and Climate Change Committee. Conservatives set out in our 2026 “Alternative King’s Speech” and wider economic programme that we believe the Government should be reducing unnecessary regulation rather than continually adding to it. Our proposals include scrapping mandatory sustainability and climate-related ESG reporting requirements and removing diversity and inclusion reporting requirements for financial services businesses. The Government need to examine the cumulative burden of existing reporting and compliance requirements, and whether the time and resources currently devoted to unnecessary paperwork could be better directed towards productive investment, employment and ensuring that waste is disposed of responsibly. Businesses are already subject to a statutory waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. During the passage of the Crime and Policing Bill, the Conservatives successfully amended the legislation to give police officers explicit powers to seize vehicles used by fly-tippers. Despite being defeated in the House of Lords, the Government rejected that amendment in the other place, ultimately agreeing only to strengthen statutory guidance on the use of existing powers. Rather than imposing further regulatory burdens on responsible businesses, the Government should focus instead on ensuring that those committing waste offences face effective enforcement and punishment. The answer to fly-tipping cannot be simply to impose further regulatory costs on every large qualifying business in the country. If the Government are serious about encouraging growth, attracting private investment and making Britain a more competitive place to do business, they should be looking to reduce the cumulative burden of regulation, not add to it. For those reasons, I oppose the Bill.
Lord Krebs (CB)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, on introducing this highly topical and important Bill, and I thank her for her excellent chairmanship of the Environment and Climate Change Committee, of which I have the privilege of being a member. I also thank the noble Earl, Lord Russell, who first encouraged the committee to inquire into waste crime. Without his initial impetus, we might not have uncovered the issues that we have already heard about, which are so damaging to many communities and our environment. Our inquiry showed that waste crime is low-risk, high-reward and an excellent career choice for the aspiring young criminal. It is often run by international organised crime gangs, and, as the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, said, it is linked to other types of crime, such as people smuggling, drugs and money laundering. Of course, waste crime is not cost-free: the costs are borne by taxpayers, landowners, local authorities and farmers. It blights the lives of people living nearby and damages the environment. As the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, said, we all have our own favourite waste site near where we live. I live in Oxford and mine happens to be in Kidlington. As we have already heard, the Kidlington site contained 21,000 tonnes of illegal waste and is costing £7 million to clean up. Does the Minister have any information about the question of pollution into the nearby River Cherwell from the Kidlington waste dump? We have already heard from the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, about Philip Duffy, the chief executive of the Environment Agency, who gave evidence last week to the Environment and Climate Change Committee. I thought his comments were a succinct and cogent summary of why the Bill is needed. He welcomed the additional resources and effort being put into tackling waste crime in the field, as well as the 10-point plan. However, he said that this is tackling the symptoms rather than the cause; it is an end-of-pipe solution. Tackling the end of the pipeline by prosecuting those caught dumping illegal waste will never be effective enough because the courts are too slow, the chances of being caught are too low, and, if you are caught, the fines are too low. He might also have added that the people caught are generally the small fry. Mr Big is quite possibly living in the Cayman Islands or a Mediterranean villa—think “McMafia”. Philip Duffy went on to say that we need to go further upstream and tackle the problem at source. This is precisely what the Bill aims to do. It places responsibility on the producer of waste to ensure that it is disposed of legally. We heard from the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe of Epsom, that this will impose an unnecessary burden on many businesses, but, as the Environmental Services Association says, any business that is already behaving legally and is compliant will not feel extra costs; the impact of regulation will be felt by those who are irresponsible. We will also no doubt hear the question of whether the Bill is necessary, because there is an existing duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. But the fact that waste crime is such a big problem perhaps suggests that this duty of care is not enough. The Bill will strengthen the regulatory controls by having a named director, improved governance, clearer audit trails and financial liability. Finally, I will mention the fact that Ministers are obliged by the Environment Act 2021 to have due regard to the five environmental principles in any area of legislation. At least three of the principles are embedded in this Bill. The “polluter pays” principle, the “rectification at source” principle of addressing damage where it originates rather than downstream, and the “prevention” principle of stopping harm proactively before it occurs. Therefore, I urge the Government to show their commitment to these principles by accepting the Bill. It will be popular with communities, it will be popular with farmers—we are told by the NFU that 29% have experienced illegal waste dumping and 12% have been threatened—and it will be popular with the environmental movement. So what is not to like? I very much hope that the Minister will tell us that the Government accept the Bill.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Lord, Lord Krebs. He mentioned the Environment Act and the “polluter pays” principle within it. I have to express some surprise at the speech from the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, given that he was a Minister in the Governments that brought in, and said they were signed up to, the “polluter pays” principle. I commend the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, on bringing this forward—we have already heard much praise, but I will add to it anyway—and introducing it so clearly. Given that this is Second Reading, I thought it would be useful to give a little bit of context. The UK this year had its lowest ever score in Transparency International’s influential annual Corruption Perceptions Index. It said that corruption risks “becoming embedded as the ‘new normal’” in the UK. We can come up with a list of scandals, and everyone can choose their own: Mandelson, Covid procurement or the issue of waste that we are discussing today, which is certainly rising up the public agenda. We need to take this on. This Bill, in addressing one specific issue, starts to take on corruption, which we need to acknowledge is a problem. A report just out from researchers at the University of Surrey on behalf of the International Society of Economic Criminology sets out that 16% of UK adults have been asked for a bribe in the last 12 months and 11% have been asked to help move money that could have been linked to money laundering. Of those, 9% consented to the bribe and 7% consented to money muling—acts such as facilitating money laundering. We need to think about this across our society, and this Bill is tackling a particular and pressing issue that is impacting on people’s lives and the environment. I want to start at the other end, and I hope that we will hear something from the Minister on this. England generated nearly 180 million tonnes of total waste in 2024. We have to get that waste stream down, and this Bill has to be put in that context. With household waste in particular, giant multinational companies are, for their own convenience and profit, producing a huge amount of waste that then becomes a problem for society. I remind the Minister that many people have commented on the excellence of the inquiry into waste crime. It called for a “root and branch review” of the Government’s waste crime strategy, but the Government dismissed that. We should put on the record—we have already heard it several times, but it needs to be said and resaid—that that is extremely disappointing. I do not think anyone can honestly claim that we do not have a problem, because we clearly do have a problem with waste crime. I will use the rest of my time, given the timing of this debate, to say—noble Lords may not be aware of this—that this is World Antimicrobial Resistance Awareness Week. When we think about waste—take Kidlington as an example—we think about it as producing pollution through chemicals and plastics, but it is also the most amazing soup that is ideal for the generation of antimicrobial resistance. When we think about household waste, we should remember that exposure to toxins actually generates antimicrobial resistance. Pharmaceuticals, including antibiotics and antifungal drugs, should not be in the household waste stream but inevitably are. We must think about the conditions in that terrible toxic soup. Finally, I must mention in this context, as it relates to AMR and to the broader issue of waste crime, the factory farming of animals. In 2024, the Bureau of Investigative Journalism produced a report which found that more than 3,000 incidents of waste crime related to the factory farming of animals.
Baroness Grender (LD)
My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend Lady Sheehan on this Bill. I share the comments of other noble Lords about her excellent chairing of your Lordships’ Environment and Climate Change Committee, as well as its excellent investigation and report and subsequent Bill. Let me start with Hoads Wood, in Kent, which I know has already been referenced. It is a beautiful, ancient woodland, and a site of special scientific interest. Around 30,000 tonnes of waste were dumped there, piled up to 15 feet high. Clearing it took 2,500 lorry loads and cost the taxpayer some £15 million, and the job was finished only last month. It is not alone: there are around 700 known illegal waste sites in England, including so-called super sites, with one in Cheshire holding 280,000 tonnes of waste. This is not fly-tipping as most people picture it; it is serious, organised crime. My noble friend’s committee heard that gangs involved in drugs, firearms, money laundering and modern slavery are well established in this sector, and it found criminality to be “endemic”. Waste crime costs our economy well over £1 billion pounds a year, and only around a quarter of it is even reported. Think about who we send to confront it. Too often, it is a young planning or enforcement officer from the local council, or a junior Environment Agency official, knocking on the gate of a site run by a highly dangerous organised crime gang. This is not a fair fight, and it is not a safe one. That is why the Bill is trying to stop the waste reaching those criminals in the first place. Who pays? Too often, it is the farmer who wakes up to a field full of someone else’s rubbish. That farmer pays to clear it and then pays landfill tax on top of that—a double penalty for the victim. Other times, it is the council tax payer. The one party who almost never pays is the business that produced the waste in the first place. That is the gap the Bill attempts to close. Under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990, the duty of care is built around single transactions. A large company can hand its waste to the cheapest contractor going, asking no questions and shrugging when it turns up in a wood or a farmer’s barn. Its responsibility ends as it waves the lorry away. Even the chief executive of the Environment Agency has told this House that responsibility cannot simply end when the waste is collected. My noble friend has set out what the Bill does far better than I could. I simply say that a named director, proper records, and paying to clean up when you have failed in your duty of care is the “polluter pays” principle made real. It moves responsibility upstream into the boardroom, where it belongs. Some will worry about the burden on business. As we have heard, the Bill builds on the existing code of practice. Companies with proper environmental management already do most of this. Liability arises only when a company has failed in its duty of care, so a firm that did its checks properly has nothing to fear. The Delegated Powers Committee found nothing in the Bill to draw to the attention of this House. The ones who should worry are the criminal operators undercutting honest waste firms. That is why the Environmental Services Association backs this Bill, alongside the Countryside Alliance and the National Rural Crime Network. It is not often that the waste industry and the Countryside Alliance stand side by side. When they do, this House should listen. I welcome the Government’s waste crime action plan. As far back as 2018, the then Conservative Government were warned and urged to act. Their response was deemed to be piecemeal and failed to respond to the severity of the issue. This Bill, most importantly, supplies what we see as a missing piece: the producer, right at the start. I hope the Government will engage constructively with my noble friend. Those who create the waste should be responsible for where it ends up. It is a simple principle, and the Bill puts it into law. These Benches strongly support it.
Baroness MacLeod of Camusdarach (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to the inquiry by the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for highlighting such critical issues. I will confine my remarks to fly-tipping. It is a societal problem. It is anti-social, environmentally challenging, criminal and, at the end of the day, costly to all of us, as insurance premiums rise and we have to pay for them. I want to share the experience of Alex Sell, a farmer near Basildon, opposite the A13 and near the M25. In August of this year, he noticed that the padlock on his farm gate had changed. When he walked into his crop of maize, which by this time was six to seven feet tall, he realised that middle-screener fines had been dumped in the middle of the field. Ironically, the waste—wood, stone, plastic and metal—appeared to come from recycling centres. In all, 2,000 tonnes had been dumped. Mr Sell had few options: take it to landfill himself or pay to have it taken. It was taken to landfill, at a cost of £350,000. He lost this year’s crop, worth about £6,000, and, since he was unable to plant his winter barley, he lost his rotation and it will take two to three years for the fields to recover. Mr Sell was insured. Up till now his insurance has cost him £3,000 a month, but, after such a big claim, he does not know what it will be in future. Not surprisingly, Mr Sell was upset, but he was even more upset when he was pushed from pillar to post by the police and the Environment Agency. The police said it was a civil crime because it happened on private land and their responsibility stopped at the padlock. The Environment Agency said it was nothing to do with them but was a matter for the police. While this was happening to Mr Sell, another 2,000 tonnes was dumped among six neighbouring farms along the road. This was mostly domestic waste, often by people turned away from the local authority dump. I could cite many examples of fly-tipping and the harm and costs that it imposes on individual farmers, but Mr Sell’s experience demonstrates the issues faced throughout the United Kingdom on an almost daily basis. There is much to be commended in the noble Baroness’s proposals. I agree that large companies should appoint a named director who is responsible for compliance with the waste statutory duty of care. I heard the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, and I am sure that a lot of company directors will think it is insane, but if they were responsible in the first place then we would not have to impose this regulation. Companies should be liable for the costs of clean-up and clearance if their waste is mismanaged, and the Environment Agency needs to raise its game. In March this year, the Government published a waste climate action plan with a range of proposals designed to tackle the problem. It will be a cause for celebration if that works. Today, I ask my noble friend the Minister this: if it does not work, will the Government urgently revisit the legislation?
Baroness Miller of Chilthorne Domer (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lady Sheehan for her persistence in dealing with this issue, not only by chairing her committee but by bringing this Bill forward as the next step. Noble Lords have talked about fly-tipping and waste piles that look and smell bad, and the work of the committee really has awakened public consciousness to that. However, today I will talk about the waste that you do not see and rarely smell but which is poisoning our soils and rivers: the industrial waste that is channelled through the sewerage system and transferred for treatment, which clearly falls within the remit of the Bill. It is important that companies have a duty of care so that we do not end up seeing persistent chemicals going into the environment. Then there is the industrial trade effluent that is discharged straight into the sewer—yes, with consents, but given the investigation by River Action UK, the Guardian and WATERSHED Investigations that found there were 26,000 consents allowing 608 billion litres of commercial and industrial wastewater in the year they were looking at to enter sewage treatment works, can we really be sure that that duty of care is being exercised? Farmers should be able to confidently spread sewage sludge on their land as fertiliser, but now, given the toxic cocktail of chemicals that the sludge may contain, they cannot be at all confident. They should be worried about poisoning their land, and many of them are. Of course you can test the sludge before it is spread on land, but that is no substitute for controlling what enters the sewer in the first place. This whole regime started as a revenue stream for water companies, which now get some £340 million a year from industrial waste entering the sewerage system. If it contains forever chemicals, the idea that the waste is being got rid of is entirely wrong; it is simply being spread on land and entering rivers. I am very concerned about the effect of the chemicals and microplastics entering the food chain through crops growing on the soils that have had the chemicals on them or animals eating grass grown on those soils. Furthermore, this waste stream is entering our rivers, being absorbed into the silt and being washed out to sea, and it becomes part of the food chain through fishes. I congratulate the Government on the steps they have taken to address the source of persistent organic pollutants with the regulations debated this week. It is a good move to end the threat of POPs, but it is quite a long-term solution. We also need to address the short and medium term, which my noble friend’s Bill would do, by making companies pay more attention to what they are putting into the sewerage system. Finally, the water industry’s chemicals investigation is in its fourth phase, which began in April 2025. How is that going? Have the Government had an interim report about the chemicals they found? The Environment Agency recognises all this and is proposing a move to an environmental permitting framework, but will that be in the Water Bill? I say to the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, that the Conservative proposals I have heard to scrap the Environment Agency are dangerous and irresponsible. I accept that the Environment Agency is not perfect, but less regulation and monitoring is a terrible idea that really threatens public health.
Lord Bourne of Aberystwyth (Con)
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, who made some very telling points. I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, on introducing the Bill and on her distinguished chairmanship of the Environment and Climate Change Committee. The background to the Bill is the large-scale fly-tipping that we have seen throughout our country: the A34 in Kidlington was mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, who lives near it, and there is Grays in Essex, Middlewich in Cheshire and Bickershaw in the Prime Minister’s own Makerfield constituency. It is against that background that the Bill is being introduced. We have an increasing problem of illegal dumping. There is low risk of apprehension and massive returns for the criminals. The whole area needs more resourcing. I have to question whether the Environment Agency is the right body to take on organised crime in the way that we need to happen. We need more prosecutions and convictions. We probably need the power to confiscate the assets of criminals in this area. Significantly, we need a civil statutory remedy, and this legislation would provide that. Although organised criminal gangs are dumping on an industrial scale, they do not produce the waste. Businesses and companies are enabling the commission of these offences. In my view, this neat piece of legislation is designed to tackle that, and it is desirable for that reason. It would apply just to large companies—I will come on to the matter of definition in a minute—and to a named director who will be responsible for compliance. I have been a director too—I still am one. There are many obligations on directors, but these are appropriate duties for them, and the legislation can be confined to those companies that are producing waste; we can do that in the definition of the companies it applies to. This proposed legislation has, of course, been welcomed by many bodies and organisations, including the Countryside Alliance and the National Rural Crime Network. Significantly, the legitimate waste sector welcomes it. The legislation is fair to people who are obeying the law. It is fair to the Exchequer, as it will ease pressure on public authorities, which have to clear up highways and public land where we have this scourge. It is fair to the farming community and others, who have the monstrous clear-up costs that we have been hearing about; the noble Baroness, Lady MacLeod, referred to the costs of compliance on the farming community, which is just not fair to them. The legislation would help ease pressure on public health from dumped waste, which is a considerable issue, and pressures that contributes to fire hazards, which is a continuing and increasing problem in our country. I have some drafting concerns. I share the concern expressed by the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, about the definition of a large company. We need some clarity on that issue, and I am not entirely happy that it is left to the Secretary of State to define it. I suggest that some obligation around accounting, where it is dependent on turnover, the number of employees and the balance sheet—the assets held—might help provide a definition rather than, say, every public company, which would be far too wide. I would be interested in seeing that developed as the legislation goes forward. The legislation would also be important in changing behaviour. Although it is in a sense reactive in dealing with the problem that exists, it would lead in the long term to prevention, because it would send out a very strong message if it is properly applied and we can see prosecutions come forward. We are just not getting that at the moment, and that is a serious problem. I will be interested in hearing what the Minister has to say about the Government’s approach on this and whether they have any thoughts about the companies it should apply to and the companies that should be exempted. It should be possible to identify the companies that are enabling this—indeed, the Government are probably well aware of them. By defining it around them, we should be able to get the people we need to get to. With that, I give strong support to this proposed legislation.
Baroness Boycott (CB)
My Lords, I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, very much for securing this debate and getting the Private Member’s Bill, and for all the fantastic work she has done on the Environment and Climate Change Committee. I will make just a few remarks about the waste that really goes out of sight because, in fact, it goes out of the country by lots of different means. I will try to keep my remarks as brief as possible. At the moment, we are exporting 675,000 tonnes of plastic. Around a fifth of that is going to non-OECD countries, with sharp rises in Indonesia and Malaysia. It is not just plastic; we are exporting scrap iron and steel, scrap paper and scrap refuse-derived fuel—1.5 million tonnes in 2025. UK law prohibits exporting hazardous waste and household waste to non-OECD countries, and almost all that kind of waste is sent abroad for “disposal”. However, exports are also illegal where the recovering countries ban the import. The few words I will say about tyres in a minute are very important, because they end up in India being burned, causing absolutely disastrous pollution consequences. How does this work? Any ban drawn at the OECD border can be very easily sidestepped. Waste is shipped legally to an OECD hub, such as the Netherlands or Turkey, and then it goes onwards to a non-OECD country, or banned household waste is at that point mislabelled as clean and not toxic. Between 2020 and 2021, UK waste exports to the Netherlands rose by over 60%, while Dutch plastic exports to Asia, Africa and Latin America more than doubled. It is terrible that our waste ends up polluting the lives of schoolchildren in India. I have to say just a few more words, about tyres. UK high street businesses charge us an actual recycling levy of £3 to £6 a tyre, which we pay. That allows brokers to get around the rules of disposal and send them to India—where they are supposedly recycled as tyres—which does not have such high safety records. For years, the Environment Agency said that its power stopped once waste left England and that it had no verifiable evidence of illegal pyrolysis. However, a man who lives in the West Country send me GPS satellite photographic evidence relating to his tyre company. He put GPS trackers in the tyres and watched their journey across the globe, finally seeing them go up on a pyre in the middle of India, creating disgusting black smoke. This is very bad. Around 80% of UK waste rubber is exported to India. Our checks began on 1 October 2025 and by 23 February this year, only 54 of 4,185 notified shipments—that is 1.3%—had returned completely geotagged proof of arrival and what happened at the point of disposal. By 3 August, full compliance had gone up to just 15%. That is something for the Minister to look at. As the Bill sets out, our duty of care should not stop at the border. I read last year about the origin of the entire recycling movement, which began in America in 1970 when people had read Silent Spring and were starting to get very worried about the environment. An advert went out on American television called “The Crying Indian”—anyone can find it if they type that in. It shows an Italian actor dressed up as an Indian, with a plait and in a coat, rowing down a river. He ends up on a highway where rubbish gets dropped and it splatters in front of him. He turns to the camera, and a tear rolls down his cheek; then a sign comes up saying, “Keep America Beautiful”. My research on this showed that the advert was paid for by Aramco, Coca-Cola, Pepsi-Cola, Marlboro Cigarettes and all the other big multinationals that knew they had to get ahead of what people were seeing about their practices. Ever since then, waste has been our responsibility—whether we are the farmer, or in considering the way we throw things away. All these years later, we are seeing this massive crime, which the Bill of the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, so brilliantly tries to correct, so I hope everyone in the House will support it.
Lord Redesdale (LD)
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for introducing this Bill, and for the work of her committee and their excellent report. I should also mention the campaigning and tenacity of my noble friend Lord Russell, who has made this issue his own personal crusade. While this Bill looks at ways of tackling waste crime, I believe there is a simple way to dramatically reduce both large-scale and small-scale waste crime with the stroke of a pen: by getting rid of the landfill tax. The economic case for waste crime is basically tax evasion, which has not really been mentioned, but the basis of landfill tax is that to get rid of a tonne of waste, you have to pay £130 in tax, whereas your gate fees are £34 to actually put the rubbish into the ground. In preparation for this debate, I was writing a business plan for a different business, but I thought I would replicate the headings of that plan and look at the economics of waste crime. I have to say, the profit margin of waste crime is really impressive—though, I hasten to add, I am not actually going to undertake any waste crime. The main business case is the tax evasion element. That tax affects the amount of waste crime taking place is made clear by the fact that the increase in the amount of waste crime is matched by a corresponding increase in the landfill tax. The landfill tax has now hit such a point that illegal dumping is extremely profitable not only as a large-scale waste crime but for small businesses undertaking such dumping. I have just had the bill for some work being done on my land, and the contractor has added £450 for waste disposal. I trust the builder implicitly, and most people will pay for the disposal of waste, but it is quite clear from the amount of waste that is made up of small building material, including kitchen cabinets, baths and the like, that a large element of small waste crime comes from this. I was on the Front Bench covering Defra during the genesis of the landfill tax back in 1996, a mere 30 years ago. I was an enthusiastic supporter of the landfill tax, which has been widely recognised as successful. There has been behaviour change—from almost 100% of waste going into landfill to about 90% being diverted at the moment. However, that has recently changed, because of some unintended consequences. The landfill tax is a very blunt tool. In 1996, the standard rate was £7 a tonne and the lower rate was £2 a tonne. At present, it is £130.75. I do not know why they are using pence, but it is £130.75 at the standard rate and £8.65 at the lower rate. That is a 1,700% increase in tax, which is eye-watering, and it is clear that the Treasury sees this as a way of making money. Indeed, the Treasury makes £623 million a year on landfill tax. However, the cost of waste crime is estimated at between £1 billion and £2 billion a year. These costs can be broken down considerably. The cost to EA was mentioned; £45 million is now going through the waste crime action plan and £15 million on clean-up costs. The cost to local authorities in clean-up costs alone last year was reckoned at £150 million, and local authorities are actually paying the tax. It is difficult to find a figure for it across the board, but they must be making up an element of the £623 million. So in reality, the landfill tax is being paid by council tax payers, whose bills are then increased to pay the clean-up costs. I know that asking the Minister to take on the Treasury would elicit at least a wry smile, but I ask her to talk to the Chancellor because, in the last Budget, he talked about “preventive departmental expenditure”. If Defra were prepared to do a cost-benefit analysis against the Red Book, the case for getting rid of the landfill tax would be very strong, and it would save the country and the environment a great deal.
Earl Russell (LD)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken and congratulate my noble friend Lady Sheehan on a very well-drafted and important Private Member’s Bill. The Bill is clear and concise in its aims and is backed by industry and charities alike. It offers an ingenious and practical strategic reset of our waste regulations and, most importantly, puts in place a deterrent to bad behaviour. It is a serious and workable proposition, which I believe would strengthen and complement the actions the Government have taken already. This is not an either/or but a question of both. I also want to thank the Minister and departmental officials, particularly those on the front lines, because there has been an important cultural shift in this debate. As well as all the actions that have been mentioned, there is a growing culture of openness, which is fundamental to making further progress. However, there is no doubt much more to do. This feels like an important moment for reflection on our future direction. As all noble Lords have noted, for too long we have accepted broken systems that have given us nothing but broken results. A fear of finding out has predominated. The waste criminals have got away with it. Whether it is the 38 million tonnes of waste, enough to fill Wembley Stadium 35 times, the £2 billion cost or the fact that only a quarter of cases are reported, there have been continuous and persistent regulatory failures, and that has allowed the criminals to supersize their operations. As the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, put it, everybody has their favourite local large-scale waste site, whether it is Hoads Wood, Kidlington or Wigan. The current legal framework is, to my mind, a “good chaps” system of regulation when it comes to big businesses. That is outdated and is not working. It is the victims—the landowners—who feel the pain, have to carry the cost of clean-up and then have the landfill tax added on top. The Bill aims to address these root problems by turning off the waste tap and criminal supply lines, as the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, put it, and imposing the “polluter pays” principle. It establishes a direct legal line of sight between corporate boardrooms and the ultimate destination of the waste that they generate. Having a named director assumes due diligence and the need for annual compliance and adequate record retention—increasing that to six years—and inputs civil liabilities for failures to do that. There are counterarguments: this is a Private Member’s Bill that everybody has worked on to try to make it as effective as possible. The Government may argue that the incentives in place are adequate; I disagree. I think these complement them. Where you have digital waste tracking and these other measures, which are welcome, criminals are likely to still operate outside those legal frameworks. So, cutting off supply has real relevance and importance. Without board-level accountability, we will not be able to shut off this supply. Some, in particular the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, argue that this is unnecessary red tape; I disagree. Companies have responsibility for the waste that they generate. If they continue to be able to go to the lowest price, this problem will continue, and it is a burden on society. They already have ISO 14001 duties. They are already doing a lot of this stuff. We cannot continue to rely on post-incident to deal with these problems—that is just not working—so cutting off the supply is really important. I hope the Minister will give the proposals in the Bill serious consideration. It is about proper due diligence. There are some problems with the Bill. It is unclear how liability would operate when waste has been through several intermediaries. But audit trails, proper legal responsibility and auditing can solve that problem. The definition of “large companies” has been addressed. The noble Lord, Lord Bourne, put forward suggestions that are workable but need a bit of definition. There is also the issue of financial penalties only and where they sit with existing legal requirements, particularly in relation to imprisonment. But these are small things that can be clarified and sorted out. I hope the Government will continue to take further action on these important issues. I hope that they will be bringing forward further legislation on these issues. I hope that we can get better joined-up working between agencies so that we can fight these serious, organised criminals. I hope that we can move away from overregulation of the legitimate sector, get better training for our judiciary and more appropriate punishments. We also need reform of the landfill tax. I hope the Minister will look seriously at this Bill.
Lord Blencathra (Con)
My Lords, I begin by congratulating the noble Baroness on bringing forward the Bill. There is no disagreement across the House that fly-tipping, illegal dumping and the improper disposal of waste are serious problems. They blight communities, damage the environment and often leave taxpayers and landowners bearing the cost of cleaning up mess that they did not create, as we have heard all so clearly this morning. During the progress of the Crime and Policing Bill through your Lordships’ House, the Official Opposition raised this issue time and again. We welcome the fact that Ministers listened to noble Lords on these Benches and accepted an amendment to ensure that those who are convicted of fly-tipping can also be given three points on their driving licence. That is an important deterrent, and I should emphasise at this point that we firmly support tough measures to crack down on fly-tipping and a tough approach to offences that already exist. When we take a regulatory approach, often good actors in a sector face additional burdens and costs because of the conduct of bad actors. That is something we should always bear in mind before taking a further regulatory approach to problems. Sadly, not all our debates on fly-tipping during the progress of the Crime and Policing Bill were so constructive, and we had Divisions on making fly-tippers liable for clearing-up costs, as well as allowing the seizure of vehicles used in connection with fly-tipping. The Government initially resisted these proposals, but, thanks to the dedication of my noble friends on these Benches, I am pleased to say that the Government did strengthen the guidance on the power of local authorities to seize vehicles used in connection with fly-tipping. Ministers also reassured Parliament that local authorities already have the power to prosecute fly-tippers and that, on conviction, a cost order can be made by the court so that landowners’ costs can be recovered from the perpetrators. These points were made quite forcefully by my noble friend Lord Sharpe of Epsom. So can the Minister give the House an update on the impact of the anti-fly-tipping measures in the Crime and Policing Act 2026 so far? Is it the Government’s view that further steps are needed? Businesses and individuals who fly-tip should be held accountable. They should pay the full costs of clearing up fly-tipped waste and face the appropriate criminal sanctions. Only by being tough on selfish and irresponsible fly-tippers will we end this blight on our rural communities. Can the Minister say what steps the Government are taking to support farmers facing the stress and cost of dealing with massive illegal fly-tipping on their land, as we have heard so clearly today? There have been far too many stories of farmers waking up in the morning to find thousands of tonnes of waste dumped on their land, which costs them tens of thousands of pounds to clear up. I have a number of concerns and questions about this Bill’s necessity and practical effect. My first concern is about whether the Bill addresses a genuine gap in the law or merely a failure to enforce existing law. The Bill is built on the existing waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. If a company already has a legal duty to ensure that its waste is transferred and handled responsibly, and if regulators already possess the powers to investigate and enforce compliance, we need to understand precisely what deficiency in the current framework this Bill seeks to remedy. In short, is the problem inadequate legislation, as the promoter of the Bill suggests, or inadequate enforcement? If the existing law is sufficient but not being properly enforced, adding a further layer of regulation may make us feel virtuous without actually improving the environmental outcomes. My second concern is a regulatory one. The Bill would require every large company to appoint a named director responsible for waste compliance. At first sight, that seems entirely sensible, yet many large companies already have environmental compliance officers, sustainability directors, audit committees and extensive governance procedures. What evidence is there that environmental failures arise because no one at board level is responsible, rather than because existing responsibilities are not being enforced? Perhaps the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, could respond to that at the conclusion of this debate. The noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, made excellent points on the taxation cost. So much of the massive dumping we have seen has come about because it is cheaper to get criminal cowboys to dump your domestic waste and building rubble than to dump it legally at the enormous cost of the landfill tax. I would be grateful if the noble Baroness would comment on the excellent points that the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, made. The Bill introduces further notification requirements, record-keeping requirements and reporting obligations. Companies will inevitably need additional auditing systems, compliance procedures, legal advice and management oversight. Before imposing these obligations, Parliament should know the likely costs. Has any assessment been made of the regulatory burden that this Bill would impose? What estimate has been made of the cost to business, particularly businesses operating complex supply chains involving numerous waste contractors and subcontractors? My fourth concern relates to liability. The Bill is more carefully drafted than some may initially assume. It does not appear to impose absolute liability on a company merely because it once generated a particular item of waste. Liability arises when a company has failed to discharge its waste duty of care. However, that raises an important practical question: what actually constitutes sufficient due diligence? Suppose a company uses a licensed waste contractor, checks that the contractor is properly authorised, keeps all the required documentation and follows current guidance. If that contractor, or perhaps a subcontractor further down the chain, subsequently disposes of the waste unlawfully, at what point can the company be said to have done enough? I was fascinated by the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester. He made the very valid point that these massive, horrendous tips we see, such as in Kidlington, are not caused by one commercial company illegally dumping its waste; they are caused by thousands and thousands of little bits dumped by illegal criminal gangs, which add up to huge mountains. As he was speaking, something occurred to me. Suppose someone wants to remodel his Persimmon home. He wants to get rid of his John Lewis fridge, perhaps replace his Wren fitted kitchen, change his Persimmon porch and dump his old B&Q barbecue. He does not call on the legitimate companies to do it. He checks on the web and discovers someone who seems dirt cheap, or reasonably cheap, and calls in that contractor. Where does that contractor dump his stuff? He dumps it in places such as Kidlington and adds to the tens of thousands of tonnes of waste. I cannot see in the Bill where the corporate waste responsibility will help places such as Kidlington. John Lewis is not responsible because its furniture was dumped there, nor is Wren Kitchens, Persimmon or B&Q. We must be careful not to imagine that this Bill can solve the problems of these horrendous dumps around the countryside, because there does not seem to be a direct responsibility on the corporation that initially built the fridge or the barbecue. I wonder whether we are mistakenly believing that the Bill is the solution to those huge, horrendous dumps we see in the country. There is also the question of who may recover costs. The Bill permits recovery not only by public authorities and landowners but by “other persons” who have incurred relevant costs. That phrase appears rather broad. Are we creating a mechanism that could encourage extensive litigation against companies long after waste has left their control? If so, what safeguards are proposed against speculative or disproportionate claims? More broadly, I would be interested to hear from the Minister what powers already exist under current legislation for recovering clean-up costs from those responsible for the mismanagement of waste. To what extent are those powers already capable of achieving the objectives of this Bill if they are used effectively? That question returns me to the central issue before us. If a company has failed in its duty of care, should it bear responsibility? Of course it should, and it should be made to pay. But if that principle is already reflected in existing law, we need to be convinced—and I am not fully convinced—that this Bill adds something genuinely useful, rather than simply duplicating current requirements. It does not seem to me to solve the problem of the Kidlingtons of this world. The House should be particularly careful before creating new criminal offences, new reporting requirements and new liabilities for business, unless we are satisfied that existing powers have been shown to be inadequate. These points were made most strongly by my noble friend Lord Sharpe of Epsom. For those reasons, while I am content for the Bill to receive a Second Reading and for these issues to be examined in greater detail, including the questions raised by the noble Earl, Lord Russell, I hope that both the promoter and the Minister will address a simple but important question: what can this Bill achieve that existing legislation, if properly enforced, cannot?
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to what has been an important and constructive debate. In particular, I thank the committee and the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for ensuring that the serious issue of responsibility for waste remains firmly before this House. Let me say at the outset that the Government very much share the concerns that underpin the Bill. Waste crime causes serious environmental, social and economic harm. It damages our countryside and communities. It undermines legitimate businesses and leaves landowners and the public sector facing the consequences and, too often, substantial clean-up costs. On clean-up costs, the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, mentioned the landfill tax. As he said, the tax has played an important role in moving waste away from landfill, but we also recognise that criminals exploit the system. Defra is currently working with the Environment Agency, HMRC and, ultimately, the Treasury on how the regime can better support our action against waste crime. We have heard today many examples of the appalling environmental damage and cost to communities at sites such as Hoads Wood and Kidlington. The noble Lord, Lord Krebs, asked about pollution into the River Cherwell. I can confirm and clarify that the ongoing monitoring of the river has demonstrated that the Kidlington waste site has not polluted the river. We need to take action, and the Government have committed to clearing up a small number of these particularly harmful sites, but, again, businesses must take appropriate responsibility for the waste they produce and exercise proper care when deciding how that waste is managed. I do not believe that those objectives are in dispute. There were a number of questions about the environment. The noble Baroness, Lady Miller, asked about forever chemicals and the report. Obviously, PFAS are widespread in the environment and it is an issue we need to tackle very seriously. However, the Environment Agency report published on 12 November, which I assume is the report she was referring to, found that levels of two key forever chemicals fell by 30% and 29% respectively between 2016 and 2025. That is good news, but there is clearly more to do. We need to consider whether those responsible for waste should be accountable. We as a Government believe that they should. The question is then whether the provisions in this Bill provide an effective and proportionate means of achieving that objective. The Government are also already taking significant action against waste crime. The noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, talked about the review of the waste crime strategy. The Government’s view is that waste crime’s prevalence and causes are well understood, as we have heard during the debate. The Government brought in the action plan from March; we have a 10-point plan with the Environment Agency and a further package of measures was announced in August. The noble Baroness also mentioned the important link between AMR and the circular economy. I absolutely agree that we should ultimately reduce the amount of waste that needs treatment. We are committed to transitioning to a circular economy so that the materials that we have previously thrown away can be reused. That is again something that the Government are keen to move forward on. We have committed an additional £45 million for the Environment Agency to spend on enforcement over the next three financial years. While that investment will help ensure that those responsible are held to account, prevention is also critical. The noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, talked about tyres, our duty of care and how we export our waste. That is an incredibly important point. The Government are reforming the carriers, brokers and dealers regime to strengthen controls over who can operate in the waste sector. I know that the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, welcomed this step, as did others. Introducing digital waste tracking to improve the quality and availability of information will also help us to understand better the issues that the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, is talking about. The idea is that, together, those reforms will strengthen accountability right across the waste chain and help us to intervene earlier where we can see that there is criminal, bad or poor behaviour and activity. Defra is also working closely with the Environment Agency to explore how the wider regulatory and enforcement framework can be strengthened. That includes examining the effectiveness of the existing waste duty of care and measures that could address the weaknesses in the present system. I hope that helps to reassure the noble Baroness. We have looked carefully at this Private Member’s Bill. We are very sympathetic to its objectives, but our reservations are to do with the approach. First, the Bill would establish an additional statutory regime alongside the existing waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. Before creating new statutory duties, we need to fully understand how they would interact with the obligations already placed on those who produce and handle waste. We do not want to inadvertently create overlapping requirements, uncertainty about which duties apply or duplication that would add complexity without delivering corresponding benefits. We believe that further work is necessary to establish how the proposed obligations would complement rather than duplicate or conflict with the existing regime. The noble Lord, Lord Bourne, and my noble friend Lord Grantchester talked about businesses and the impact on them. We need to consider carefully which businesses should be captured. The Bill applies its principal requirements to large companies but does not define those companies. Instead, the conditions would be set subsequently through regulations. We think that there is an important policy question here. Company size may not necessarily be the best proxy for waste risk. The environmental risks associated with a business can depend upon the type and volume of waste it produces, the nature of its activities, and the structure of the supply chain through which that waste travels. There is a further practical difficulty if the regime were to apply to companies individually because, based on the definition of a “large company” in the Companies Act 2006, only a small proportion of companies would fall into that category. Equally importantly, because the Bill does not define “company” it is not clear whether size would be assessed for each individual company or across a group as a whole. If it applied at company level, there is a risk that an individual subsidiary overseeing waste management activities could fall below the threshold and therefore avoid compliance with the requirements proposed in the Bill. These are not reasons to do nothing, but they demonstrate why the scope of a new statutory regime needs careful development before it is placed in legislation. I turn to the Bill’s proposal for a named director responsible for waste duty of care compliance. I absolutely agree that senior-level, clear accountability can be valuable, but legislation must also be precise about what that accountability means in practice. The Bill requires a named director to take “reasonable steps” but does not define with sufficient clarity what those steps entail or how the responsibility would interact with existing systems of corporate governance. The same need for precision arises in relation to the Bill’s notification and record-keeping requirements. The Bill requires companies to report any material breach of the waste duty of care and any reasonable suspicion of waste-related criminal activity within their supply chains. These concepts would need to be defined with clarity if businesses are to fully understand what the law requires of them and regulators are to enforce those requirements consistently. I turn to one of the most significant elements of the Bill: the liability for clean-up costs. Again, the Government absolutely agree with the principle behind this. There are few things more frustrating than seeing those affected by illegally managed waste bear substantial costs, with those responsible escaping the consequences. A number of noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, and my noble friend Lady MacLeod, talked about the implications for farm owners and landowners who are victims of, rather than contributors to, waste crime and fly-tipping. The Government’s policy remains that landowners are responsible for clearing waste on their land. However, we understand the impact that this can have on landowners, so we are exploring with the insurance industry whether barriers exist to a more accessible private insurance market that would allow farmers, businesses and landowners to be compensated against illegal waste dumping on their land. The Bill also enables a public authority, landowner or other person to recover costs associated with moving waste, securing a site, preventing further environmental harm and restoring affected land, water or other environmental assets. However, before introducing a regime such as that, we would need to establish fair and clear tests of causation, the necessary evidential requirements and how liability should be apportioned where waste is passed through several businesses or waste operators before it is ultimately mismanaged—that goes to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra. We also need to understand fully how this new form of civil liability would interact with the environmental enforcement and remediation regimes that already exist. I stress that these are not objections to the principle that businesses should take responsibility for their waste; nor do they diminish the seriousness with which the Government view waste crime. Rather, they reflect our responsibility to ensure that when Parliament legislates, the resulting framework is clear, evidence-based, proportionate and capable of effective enforcement. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, asked about the impact of anti-fly-tipping measures in the Crime and Policing Act 2026. It is a bit too early for us to assess this, although I agree with the noble Lord that this marks an important step towards ensuring that individuals who fly-tip face the appropriate sanctions. On the noble Lord’s other question about recovery of costs from waste criminals, there are several powers that can be used to achieve this, but they depend on being able to identify the perpetrator and, in the case of recovery of proceeds from crime, will not necessarily match the costs pound for pound. The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, has rightly brought attention to important questions about what happens to waste after it leaves a business, about responsibility through sometimes complicated waste chains and about who ultimately bears the consequences when that waste is illegally managed. These are questions that deserve serious consideration. My department is already taking action across many of the areas highlighted by the Bill and is actively exploring avenues for further reform. That work gives us the opportunity to look at the regulatory system as a whole, to work with the Environment Agency, other affected parties, businesses and other stakeholders, and to ensure that any future measures are properly targeted, proportionate and, importantly, enforceable. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness and other noble Lords that the Government share the determination to tackle the harms that have prompted this Bill. We want businesses to fulfil their responsibilities. We want those who deliberately exploit weaknesses in the waste system to be held to account. We want a regulatory framework that enables our regulators to pursue waste crime effectively, but, for the reasons I have set out today, the Government are not persuaded that the Bill as currently drafted provides the right legislative framework for achieving those objectives. We therefore have reservations about the Bill, but we very much look forward to continuing to engage constructively with the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, and noble Lords across the House as we develop our wider work to tackle waste crime and strengthen responsibility for waste. I reassure my noble friend Lady MacLeod and the noble Earl, Lord Russell, that we are still working on improving our ability to tackle waste crime. I thank again the noble Baroness for bringing this important issue before the House. I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to today’s debate and look forward to more engagement with the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan.
Baroness Sheehan (LD)
I thank the Minister for her response. I am very grateful that the Government are not going to reject the Bill outright. Having reservations means that dialogue will continue. I hope that we can find a way to bring forward some of the measures in the Bill. I want to use a little time to address some of the issues that have been raised, starting with the definition of a “large company”. I remind all noble Lords that producer responsibility for waste rests with each and every one of us. That is one of the distinctions that I wanted to make when we refer to large companies. Clause 1(8) states: “‘large company’ means a company that is subject to the waste duty of care and satisfies”, et cetera. I wanted to make sure that public bodies, such as local authorities and the NHS, are captured because that is where a large part of the problem falls. So, yes, “large company” is left open to be defined by the Government applying common-sense measures. That is all that term means. As the noble Lords, Lord Krebs and Lord Bourne, mentioned, there are ways of defining it that will make the provision workable. I thank them both for their articulate support for the Bill. I want to address the comments from the noble Baroness, Lady MacLeod. It was welcome to have those personal examples laid out before noble Lords. It is one of the major reasons why the unfairness of the current system is so bald and why we have to try to do something about it. To correct her slight misapprehension, it is waste crime on the larger scale. Two thousand tonnes is not fly-tipping. The definition of fly-tipping, where local authorities’ responsibility stops, is 20 tonnes, so 2,000 tonnes is a substantial amount. I am not surprised that it cost a huge amount. The Bill as drafted, in Clause 4(1), says that the costs suffered by individuals such as landowners and farmers who are innocent can be recovered. It says: “A relevant authority, landowner, or other person who has incurred recoverable costs … may recover those costs as a civil debt”. I hope that that answers the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, on the costs to landlords. On the landfill tax issue, when the committee first held its inquiry, we heard that one of the things that the Government were looking to reform was the landfill tax regime. They chose not to take those reforms forward. I am very pleased that they took forward the carrier, broker and dealer reforms and the digital waste-tracking reforms. This is something that I have never challenged, and I have not seen the Government’s workings on it. I am conscious, as my noble friend Lord Redesdale said, landfill tax has been very successful. I know that he went on to express reservations—but I want to be very careful, in reforming that tax, that we do not throw out the baby with the bathwater. It has delivered real success in reducing recycling rates. I happened to be a local councillor in Richmond upon Thames and a cabinet member responsible for energy and climate change, where we were trying to get our recycling rates down, and the landfill tax was invaluable in helping us to achieve that. I would not like to see that negated to a point where it was no longer effective, because waste is a valuable resource. Metals and plastics can be recycled and recovered, and paper and cardboard can be recycled, and so on. It generates income, in fact. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, made a number of points. The issue was the regulatory burden—and I think that the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, addressed those points quite nicely. I can forward on to the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, if he has not seen it, the comprehensive briefing from the Environmental Services Association, which tackles this very point. I shall send on the relevant parts of it. On page 4, under appendix, it says that businesses that already operate robust waste management systems, maintain effective records and undertake proportionate due diligence, should be well-placed to comply with the new requirements. There should not be very many other onerous costs to those businesses, if they are already complying. This is more about producing a level playing field for all businesses, to stop the huge amount of leakage of waste illegally into the waste supply chain system. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, mentioned a number of points, and I think that the Minister also wanted to know what is added to Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act. This is something that I grappled with quite a lot when I was thinking about bringing this Bill forward. I know that the current regime is not working; that regime, which incorporates Section 34, is unable to grip this problem. It is very clear to me that putting in place measures which would put some flesh on the bones of the way that the producer’s duty of care responsibility has to be delivered is very necessary. There are many examples in the ESA’s briefing that mention this, so I refer noble Lords to that. With that, again, I welcome the Minister’s comments. I am glad that the discussion is not closed and I commend this Bill to the House.
Bill read a second time and committed to a Committee of the Whole House.
← Previous
European Union (Withdrawal Arrangements) Bill [HL]
Next →
Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441638.