Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, who made some very telling points. I congratulate the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, on introducing the Bill and on her distinguished chairmanship of the Environment and Climate Change Committee.
The background to the Bill is the large-scale fly-tipping that we have seen throughout our country: the A34 in Kidlington was mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, who lives near it, and there is Grays in Essex, Middlewich in Cheshire and Bickershaw in the Prime Minister’s own Makerfield constituency. It is against that background that the Bill is being introduced.
We have an increasing problem of illegal dumping. There is low risk of apprehension and massive returns for the criminals. The whole area needs more resourcing. I have to question whether the Environment Agency is the right body to take on organised crime in the way that we need to happen. We need more prosecutions and convictions. We probably need the power to confiscate the assets of criminals in this area. Significantly, we need a civil statutory remedy, and this legislation would provide that.
Although organised criminal gangs are dumping on an industrial scale, they do not produce the waste. Businesses and companies are enabling the commission of these offences. In my view, this neat piece of legislation is designed to tackle that, and it is desirable for that reason. It would apply just to large companies—I will come on to the matter of definition in a minute—and to a named director who will be responsible for compliance. I have been a director too—I still am one. There are many obligations on directors, but these are appropriate duties for them, and the legislation can be confined to those companies that are producing waste; we can do that in the definition of the companies it applies to.
This proposed legislation has, of course, been welcomed by many bodies and organisations, including the Countryside Alliance and the National Rural Crime Network. Significantly, the legitimate waste sector welcomes it. The legislation is fair to people who are obeying the law. It is fair to the Exchequer, as it will ease pressure on public authorities, which have to clear up highways and public land where we have this scourge. It is fair to the farming community and others, who have the monstrous clear-up costs that we have been hearing about; the noble Baroness, Lady MacLeod, referred to the costs of compliance on the farming community, which is just not fair to them. The legislation would help ease pressure on public health from dumped waste, which is a considerable issue, and pressures that contributes to fire hazards, which is a continuing and increasing problem in our country.
I have some drafting concerns. I share the concern expressed by the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, about the definition of a large company. We need some clarity on that issue, and I am not entirely happy that it is left to the Secretary of State to define it. I suggest that some obligation around accounting, where it is dependent on turnover, the number of employees and the balance sheet—the assets held—might help provide a definition rather than, say, every public company, which would be far too wide. I would be interested in seeing that developed as the legislation goes forward.
The legislation would also be important in changing behaviour. Although it is in a sense reactive in dealing with the problem that exists, it would lead in the long term to prevention, because it would send out a very strong message if it is properly applied and we can see prosecutions come forward. We are just not getting that at the moment, and that is a serious problem. I will be interested in hearing what the Minister has to say about the Government’s approach on this and whether they have any thoughts about the companies it should apply to and the companies that should be exempted. It should be possible to identify the companies that are enabling this—indeed, the Government are probably well aware of them. By defining it around them, we should be able to get the people we need to get to. With that, I give strong support to this proposed legislation.