Contribution
My Lords, I begin by congratulating the noble Baroness on bringing forward the Bill. There is no disagreement across the House that fly-tipping, illegal dumping and the improper disposal of waste are serious problems. They blight communities, damage the environment and often leave taxpayers and landowners bearing the cost of cleaning up mess that they did not create, as we have heard all so clearly this morning.
During the progress of the Crime and Policing Bill through your Lordships’ House, the Official Opposition raised this issue time and again. We welcome the fact that Ministers listened to noble Lords on these Benches and accepted an amendment to ensure that those who are convicted of fly-tipping can also be given three points on their driving licence. That is an important deterrent, and I should emphasise at this point that we firmly support tough measures to crack down on fly-tipping and a tough approach to offences that already exist. When we take a regulatory approach, often good actors in a sector face additional burdens and costs because of the conduct of bad actors. That is something we should always bear in mind before taking a further regulatory approach to problems.
Sadly, not all our debates on fly-tipping during the progress of the Crime and Policing Bill were so constructive, and we had Divisions on making fly-tippers liable for clearing-up costs, as well as allowing the seizure of vehicles used in connection with fly-tipping. The Government initially resisted these proposals, but, thanks to the dedication of my noble friends on these Benches, I am pleased to say that the Government did strengthen the guidance on the power of local authorities to seize vehicles used in connection with fly-tipping.
Ministers also reassured Parliament that local authorities already have the power to prosecute fly-tippers and that, on conviction, a cost order can be made by the court so that landowners’ costs can be recovered from the perpetrators. These points were made quite forcefully by my noble friend Lord Sharpe of Epsom. So can the Minister give the House an update on the impact of the anti-fly-tipping measures in the Crime and Policing Act 2026 so far? Is it the Government’s view that further steps are needed? Businesses and individuals who fly-tip should be held accountable. They should pay the full costs of clearing up fly-tipped waste and face the appropriate criminal sanctions. Only by being tough on selfish and irresponsible fly-tippers will we end this blight on our rural communities.
Can the Minister say what steps the Government are taking to support farmers facing the stress and cost of dealing with massive illegal fly-tipping on their land, as we have heard so clearly today? There have been far too many stories of farmers waking up in the morning to find thousands of tonnes of waste dumped on their land, which costs them tens of thousands of pounds to clear up.
I have a number of concerns and questions about this Bill’s necessity and practical effect. My first concern is about whether the Bill addresses a genuine gap in the law or merely a failure to enforce existing law. The Bill is built on the existing waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. If a company already has a legal duty to ensure that its waste is transferred and handled responsibly, and if regulators already possess the powers to investigate and enforce compliance, we need to understand precisely what deficiency in the current framework this Bill seeks to remedy. In short, is the problem inadequate legislation, as the promoter of the Bill suggests, or inadequate enforcement? If the existing law is sufficient but not being properly enforced, adding a further layer of regulation may make us feel virtuous without actually improving the environmental outcomes.
My second concern is a regulatory one. The Bill would require every large company to appoint a named director responsible for waste compliance. At first sight, that seems entirely sensible, yet many large companies already have environmental compliance officers, sustainability directors, audit committees and extensive governance procedures. What evidence is there that environmental failures arise because no one at board level is responsible, rather than because existing responsibilities are not being enforced? Perhaps the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, could respond to that at the conclusion of this debate.
The noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, made excellent points on the taxation cost. So much of the massive dumping we have seen has come about because it is cheaper to get criminal cowboys to dump your domestic waste and building rubble than to dump it legally at the enormous cost of the landfill tax. I would be grateful if the noble Baroness would comment on the excellent points that the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, made.
The Bill introduces further notification requirements, record-keeping requirements and reporting obligations. Companies will inevitably need additional auditing systems, compliance procedures, legal advice and management oversight. Before imposing these obligations, Parliament should know the likely costs. Has any assessment been made of the regulatory burden that this Bill would impose? What estimate has been made of the cost to business, particularly businesses operating complex supply chains involving numerous waste contractors and subcontractors?
My fourth concern relates to liability. The Bill is more carefully drafted than some may initially assume. It does not appear to impose absolute liability on a company merely because it once generated a particular item of waste. Liability arises when a company has failed to discharge its waste duty of care. However, that raises an important practical question: what actually constitutes sufficient due diligence? Suppose a company uses a licensed waste contractor, checks that the contractor is properly authorised, keeps all the required documentation and follows current guidance. If that contractor, or perhaps a subcontractor further down the chain, subsequently disposes of the waste unlawfully, at what point can the company be said to have done enough?
I was fascinated by the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester. He made the very valid point that these massive, horrendous tips we see, such as in Kidlington, are not caused by one commercial company illegally dumping its waste; they are caused by thousands and thousands of little bits dumped by illegal criminal gangs, which add up to huge mountains. As he was speaking, something occurred to me. Suppose someone wants to remodel his Persimmon home. He wants to get rid of his John Lewis fridge, perhaps replace his Wren fitted kitchen, change his Persimmon porch and dump his old B&Q barbecue. He does not call on the legitimate companies to do it. He checks on the web and discovers someone who seems dirt cheap, or reasonably cheap, and calls in that contractor. Where does that contractor dump his stuff? He dumps it in places such as Kidlington and adds to the tens of thousands of tonnes of waste.
I cannot see in the Bill where the corporate waste responsibility will help places such as Kidlington. John Lewis is not responsible because its furniture was dumped there, nor is Wren Kitchens, Persimmon or B&Q. We must be careful not to imagine that this Bill can solve the problems of these horrendous dumps around the countryside, because there does not seem to be a direct responsibility on the corporation that initially built the fridge or the barbecue. I wonder whether we are mistakenly believing that the Bill is the solution to those huge, horrendous dumps we see in the country.
There is also the question of who may recover costs. The Bill permits recovery not only by public authorities and landowners but by “other persons” who have incurred relevant costs. That phrase appears rather broad. Are we creating a mechanism that could encourage extensive litigation against companies long after waste has left their control? If so, what safeguards are proposed against speculative or disproportionate claims?
More broadly, I would be interested to hear from the Minister what powers already exist under current legislation for recovering clean-up costs from those responsible for the mismanagement of waste. To what extent are those powers already capable of achieving the objectives of this Bill if they are used effectively? That question returns me to the central issue before us. If a company has failed in its duty of care, should it bear responsibility? Of course it should, and it should be made to pay. But if that principle is already reflected in existing law, we need to be convinced—and I am not fully convinced—that this Bill adds something genuinely useful, rather than simply duplicating current requirements. It does not seem to me to solve the problem of the Kidlingtons of this world.
The House should be particularly careful before creating new criminal offences, new reporting requirements and new liabilities for business, unless we are satisfied that existing powers have been shown to be inadequate. These points were made most strongly by my noble friend Lord Sharpe of Epsom. For those reasons, while I am content for the Bill to receive a Second Reading and for these issues to be examined in greater detail, including the questions raised by the noble Earl, Lord Russell, I hope that both the promoter and the Minister will address a simple but important question: what can this Bill achieve that existing legislation, if properly enforced, cannot?