T

The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to what has been an important and constructive debate. In particular, I thank the committee and the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for ensuring that the serious issue of responsibility for waste remains firmly before this House. Let me say at the outset that the Government very much share the concerns that underpin the Bill. Waste crime causes serious environmental, social and economic harm. It damages our countryside and communities. It undermines legitimate businesses and leaves landowners and the public sector facing the consequences and, too often, substantial clean-up costs. On clean-up costs, the noble Lord, Lord Redesdale, mentioned the landfill tax. As he said, the tax has played an important role in moving waste away from landfill, but we also recognise that criminals exploit the system. Defra is currently working with the Environment Agency, HMRC and, ultimately, the Treasury on how the regime can better support our action against waste crime. We have heard today many examples of the appalling environmental damage and cost to communities at sites such as Hoads Wood and Kidlington. The noble Lord, Lord Krebs, asked about pollution into the River Cherwell. I can confirm and clarify that the ongoing monitoring of the river has demonstrated that the Kidlington waste site has not polluted the river. We need to take action, and the Government have committed to clearing up a small number of these particularly harmful sites, but, again, businesses must take appropriate responsibility for the waste they produce and exercise proper care when deciding how that waste is managed. I do not believe that those objectives are in dispute. There were a number of questions about the environment. The noble Baroness, Lady Miller, asked about forever chemicals and the report. Obviously, PFAS are widespread in the environment and it is an issue we need to tackle very seriously. However, the Environment Agency report published on 12 November, which I assume is the report she was referring to, found that levels of two key forever chemicals fell by 30% and 29% respectively between 2016 and 2025. That is good news, but there is clearly more to do. We need to consider whether those responsible for waste should be accountable. We as a Government believe that they should. The question is then whether the provisions in this Bill provide an effective and proportionate means of achieving that objective. The Government are also already taking significant action against waste crime. The noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, talked about the review of the waste crime strategy. The Government’s view is that waste crime’s prevalence and causes are well understood, as we have heard during the debate. The Government brought in the action plan from March; we have a 10-point plan with the Environment Agency and a further package of measures was announced in August. The noble Baroness also mentioned the important link between AMR and the circular economy. I absolutely agree that we should ultimately reduce the amount of waste that needs treatment. We are committed to transitioning to a circular economy so that the materials that we have previously thrown away can be reused. That is again something that the Government are keen to move forward on. We have committed an additional £45 million for the Environment Agency to spend on enforcement over the next three financial years. While that investment will help ensure that those responsible are held to account, prevention is also critical. The noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, talked about tyres, our duty of care and how we export our waste. That is an incredibly important point. The Government are reforming the carriers, brokers and dealers regime to strengthen controls over who can operate in the waste sector. I know that the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, welcomed this step, as did others. Introducing digital waste tracking to improve the quality and availability of information will also help us to understand better the issues that the noble Baroness, Lady Boycott, is talking about. The idea is that, together, those reforms will strengthen accountability right across the waste chain and help us to intervene earlier where we can see that there is criminal, bad or poor behaviour and activity. Defra is also working closely with the Environment Agency to explore how the wider regulatory and enforcement framework can be strengthened. That includes examining the effectiveness of the existing waste duty of care and measures that could address the weaknesses in the present system. I hope that helps to reassure the noble Baroness. We have looked carefully at this Private Member’s Bill. We are very sympathetic to its objectives, but our reservations are to do with the approach. First, the Bill would establish an additional statutory regime alongside the existing waste duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. Before creating new statutory duties, we need to fully understand how they would interact with the obligations already placed on those who produce and handle waste. We do not want to inadvertently create overlapping requirements, uncertainty about which duties apply or duplication that would add complexity without delivering corresponding benefits. We believe that further work is necessary to establish how the proposed obligations would complement rather than duplicate or conflict with the existing regime. The noble Lord, Lord Bourne, and my noble friend Lord Grantchester talked about businesses and the impact on them. We need to consider carefully which businesses should be captured. The Bill applies its principal requirements to large companies but does not define those companies. Instead, the conditions would be set subsequently through regulations. We think that there is an important policy question here. Company size may not necessarily be the best proxy for waste risk. The environmental risks associated with a business can depend upon the type and volume of waste it produces, the nature of its activities, and the structure of the supply chain through which that waste travels. There is a further practical difficulty if the regime were to apply to companies individually because, based on the definition of a “large company” in the Companies Act 2006, only a small proportion of companies would fall into that category. Equally importantly, because the Bill does not define “company” it is not clear whether size would be assessed for each individual company or across a group as a whole. If it applied at company level, there is a risk that an individual subsidiary overseeing waste management activities could fall below the threshold and therefore avoid compliance with the requirements proposed in the Bill. These are not reasons to do nothing, but they demonstrate why the scope of a new statutory regime needs careful development before it is placed in legislation. I turn to the Bill’s proposal for a named director responsible for waste duty of care compliance. I absolutely agree that senior-level, clear accountability can be valuable, but legislation must also be precise about what that accountability means in practice. The Bill requires a named director to take “reasonable steps” but does not define with sufficient clarity what those steps entail or how the responsibility would interact with existing systems of corporate governance. The same need for precision arises in relation to the Bill’s notification and record-keeping requirements. The Bill requires companies to report any material breach of the waste duty of care and any reasonable suspicion of waste-related criminal activity within their supply chains. These concepts would need to be defined with clarity if businesses are to fully understand what the law requires of them and regulators are to enforce those requirements consistently. I turn to one of the most significant elements of the Bill: the liability for clean-up costs. Again, the Government absolutely agree with the principle behind this. There are few things more frustrating than seeing those affected by illegally managed waste bear substantial costs, with those responsible escaping the consequences. A number of noble Lords, including the noble Baroness, Lady Grender, the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, and my noble friend Lady MacLeod, talked about the implications for farm owners and landowners who are victims of, rather than contributors to, waste crime and fly-tipping. The Government’s policy remains that landowners are responsible for clearing waste on their land. However, we understand the impact that this can have on landowners, so we are exploring with the insurance industry whether barriers exist to a more accessible private insurance market that would allow farmers, businesses and landowners to be compensated against illegal waste dumping on their land. The Bill also enables a public authority, landowner or other person to recover costs associated with moving waste, securing a site, preventing further environmental harm and restoring affected land, water or other environmental assets. However, before introducing a regime such as that, we would need to establish fair and clear tests of causation, the necessary evidential requirements and how liability should be apportioned where waste is passed through several businesses or waste operators before it is ultimately mismanaged—that goes to the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Blencathra. We also need to understand fully how this new form of civil liability would interact with the environmental enforcement and remediation regimes that already exist. I stress that these are not objections to the principle that businesses should take responsibility for their waste; nor do they diminish the seriousness with which the Government view waste crime. Rather, they reflect our responsibility to ensure that when Parliament legislates, the resulting framework is clear, evidence-based, proportionate and capable of effective enforcement. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, asked about the impact of anti-fly-tipping measures in the Crime and Policing Act 2026. It is a bit too early for us to assess this, although I agree with the noble Lord that this marks an important step towards ensuring that individuals who fly-tip face the appropriate sanctions. On the noble Lord’s other question about recovery of costs from waste criminals, there are several powers that can be used to achieve this, but they depend on being able to identify the perpetrator and, in the case of recovery of proceeds from crime, will not necessarily match the costs pound for pound. The noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, has rightly brought attention to important questions about what happens to waste after it leaves a business, about responsibility through sometimes complicated waste chains and about who ultimately bears the consequences when that waste is illegally managed. These are questions that deserve serious consideration. My department is already taking action across many of the areas highlighted by the Bill and is actively exploring avenues for further reform. That work gives us the opportunity to look at the regulatory system as a whole, to work with the Environment Agency, other affected parties, businesses and other stakeholders, and to ensure that any future measures are properly targeted, proportionate and, importantly, enforceable. I hope I can reassure the noble Baroness and other noble Lords that the Government share the determination to tackle the harms that have prompted this Bill. We want businesses to fulfil their responsibilities. We want those who deliberately exploit weaknesses in the waste system to be held to account. We want a regulatory framework that enables our regulators to pursue waste crime effectively, but, for the reasons I have set out today, the Government are not persuaded that the Bill as currently drafted provides the right legislative framework for achieving those objectives. We therefore have reservations about the Bill, but we very much look forward to continuing to engage constructively with the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, and noble Lords across the House as we develop our wider work to tackle waste crime and strengthen responsibility for waste. I reassure my noble friend Lady MacLeod and the noble Earl, Lord Russell, that we are still working on improving our ability to tackle waste crime. I thank again the noble Baroness for bringing this important issue before the House. I thank all noble Lords who have contributed to today’s debate and look forward to more engagement with the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan.

More from The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Baroness Hayman of Ullock) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.