B

Baroness Sheehan (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

I thank the Minister for her response. I am very grateful that the Government are not going to reject the Bill outright. Having reservations means that dialogue will continue. I hope that we can find a way to bring forward some of the measures in the Bill. I want to use a little time to address some of the issues that have been raised, starting with the definition of a “large company”. I remind all noble Lords that producer responsibility for waste rests with each and every one of us. That is one of the distinctions that I wanted to make when we refer to large companies. Clause 1(8) states: “‘large company’ means a company that is subject to the waste duty of care and satisfies”, et cetera. I wanted to make sure that public bodies, such as local authorities and the NHS, are captured because that is where a large part of the problem falls. So, yes, “large company” is left open to be defined by the Government applying common-sense measures. That is all that term means. As the noble Lords, Lord Krebs and Lord Bourne, mentioned, there are ways of defining it that will make the provision workable. I thank them both for their articulate support for the Bill. I want to address the comments from the noble Baroness, Lady MacLeod. It was welcome to have those personal examples laid out before noble Lords. It is one of the major reasons why the unfairness of the current system is so bald and why we have to try to do something about it. To correct her slight misapprehension, it is waste crime on the larger scale. Two thousand tonnes is not fly-tipping. The definition of fly-tipping, where local authorities’ responsibility stops, is 20 tonnes, so 2,000 tonnes is a substantial amount. I am not surprised that it cost a huge amount. The Bill as drafted, in Clause 4(1), says that the costs suffered by individuals such as landowners and farmers who are innocent can be recovered. It says: “A relevant authority, landowner, or other person who has incurred recoverable costs … may recover those costs as a civil debt”. I hope that that answers the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Grantchester, on the costs to landlords. On the landfill tax issue, when the committee first held its inquiry, we heard that one of the things that the Government were looking to reform was the landfill tax regime. They chose not to take those reforms forward. I am very pleased that they took forward the carrier, broker and dealer reforms and the digital waste-tracking reforms. This is something that I have never challenged, and I have not seen the Government’s workings on it. I am conscious, as my noble friend Lord Redesdale said, landfill tax has been very successful. I know that he went on to express reservations—but I want to be very careful, in reforming that tax, that we do not throw out the baby with the bathwater. It has delivered real success in reducing recycling rates. I happened to be a local councillor in Richmond upon Thames and a cabinet member responsible for energy and climate change, where we were trying to get our recycling rates down, and the landfill tax was invaluable in helping us to achieve that. I would not like to see that negated to a point where it was no longer effective, because waste is a valuable resource. Metals and plastics can be recycled and recovered, and paper and cardboard can be recycled, and so on. It generates income, in fact. The noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, made a number of points. The issue was the regulatory burden—and I think that the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, addressed those points quite nicely. I can forward on to the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, if he has not seen it, the comprehensive briefing from the Environmental Services Association, which tackles this very point. I shall send on the relevant parts of it. On page 4, under appendix, it says that businesses that already operate robust waste management systems, maintain effective records and undertake proportionate due diligence, should be well-placed to comply with the new requirements. There should not be very many other onerous costs to those businesses, if they are already complying. This is more about producing a level playing field for all businesses, to stop the huge amount of leakage of waste illegally into the waste supply chain system. The noble Lord, Lord Blencathra, mentioned a number of points, and I think that the Minister also wanted to know what is added to Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act. This is something that I grappled with quite a lot when I was thinking about bringing this Bill forward. I know that the current regime is not working; that regime, which incorporates Section 34, is unable to grip this problem. It is very clear to me that putting in place measures which would put some flesh on the bones of the way that the producer’s duty of care responsibility has to be delivered is very necessary. There are many examples in the ESA’s briefing that mention this, so I refer noble Lords to that. With that, again, I welcome the Minister’s comments. I am glad that the discussion is not closed and I commend this Bill to the House.

More from Baroness Sheehan (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.