B

Baroness Sheehan (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who are speaking in today’s debate. Their voices matter to the communities and individuals harmed by the actions of unscrupulous criminals, and to the many organisations that have written to noble Lords in support of the Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill. I do not have time to name every organisation, but they include Wildlife and Countryside Link—the largest environment and wildlife coalition in England, with a collective membership of 8 million people—as well as the National Farmers’ Union, the Countryside Alliance and Peers for the Planet. I am grateful for their support. It would be remiss of me not to thank the Environmental Services Association, the trade association for the regulated waste sector, for its advice and guidance in helping to ensure that the measures in the Bill are workable from an industry perspective. I thank it for its comprehensive and highly useful briefings; they have been invaluable. I also acknowledge the work that the Minister has undertaken to give this important issue the attention it deserves. I very much hope that she will recognise the merit of the two simple measures contained in the Bill. The measures are designed to help prevent the mass illegal movement of waste, to spare communities the environmental blight and misery that follows, and to bring an end to the injustice of requiring innocent landowners, including charities, farmers and private individuals, to bear the cost of clearing up illegally dumped waste. These costs can run into tens of thousands of pounds, and sometimes millions. In some cases, the full force of the law is brought to bear on the very people who are the victims of this crime. The purpose of the Bill is to strengthen responsibility at the point at which waste enters the supply chain. It seeks to turn off the tap at source, and does so by requiring a named director to take responsibility for a company’s waste from the point at which it is produced until its final destination. In short, it places responsibility firmly in the boardroom. Furthermore, where it is subsequently established that waste produced or handled by a company has been unlawfully managed, and that the company has failed to exercise due diligence, that company will be responsible for the cost of clearing up and remediating the illegally managed waste. That is fairness. These measures are straightforward, practical to implement and should not impose substantial costs on businesses or on government. Producer responsibility already exists; the Bill seeks to make it meaningful and enforceable. The Bill builds on, rather than replaces, the existing duty of care under Section 34 of the Environmental Protection Act 1990. It raises standards of governance, contractor assurance and board-level accountability for supply-chain oversight. It will close the loopholes that allow waste in bulk to leak into the hands of criminals, both at source and throughout its journey, and ensure that waste is responsibly managed across the supply chain. This Bill is necessary because the failure of our enforcement agencies to tackle waste crime is self-evident. I am sure that noble Lords have been unable to escape the media coverage of the many occasions on which the Environment Agency has failed to prevent tens of thousands of tonnes of putrid, often toxic, waste from blighting communities, polluting our land, water and air, and costing the taxpayer billions of pounds. The consequences extend beyond clean-up costs. They include landfill tax revenue, lost income for the legitimate waste management sector and a serious undermining of recycling efforts and the Government’s ambitions for a circular economy. I have seen for myself the devastation caused at the ancient woodland SSSI site at Hoads Wood in Kent, where taxpayers faced a bill of £15 million to clear 30,000 tonnes of waste. I have seen the site at Kidlington in Oxfordshire, where clearance is estimated to cost £7 million for 25,000 tonnes of waste. Worst of all, because it was located within metres of homes and a primary school, I saw the waste dumped at Bolton House Road in Bickershaw, Wigan. That site was infested with rats, flies and maggots. It was the cause of two fires in the summer of 2025, which forced the school to close because of the noxious fumes. The last of those sites is, of course, in the Prime Minister’s own constituency. I welcome his intervention on behalf of his constituents, which has finally secured the site’s clearance. I hope that he will also recognise the merits of this Bill in preventing such toxicity from entering the public domain elsewhere in the country. Those three sites have now been cleared or are in the process of being cleared, and others have been earmarked for clearance, but many remain without any clear plan of action. These include the sites at Camborne, Northwich, Over Farm in Gloucestershire, the Isle of Sheppey and Raspberry Hill Park Farm, among many, many others. The scale of the problem is stark. The Environment Agency’s own figures from its National Waste Crime Survey 2025 estimate that 38 million tonnes of waste are illegally managed in England each year. We are dealing with serious organised criminal networks operating on an industrial scale, with sophisticated logistics and management structures. More than a decade ago, Sir James Bevan, then chief executive of the Environment Agency, described waste crime as “the new narcotics”. Waste crime is a gateway to other serious organised crime, including money laundering, modern-day slavery and gun-running. It is frequently characterised by violence and intimidation. Indeed, so serious were the concerns that some witnesses to the Environment and Climate Change Committee’s inquiry into waste crime chose to remain anonymous. The old adage “Where there’s muck, there’s brass” might more accurately be revised today to “Where there’s muck, there’s gold”. Waste crime is attractive to criminals because the profits are eye-watering, while the chances of detection remain low. Your Lordships’ Environment and Climate Change Committee was shocked to learn during its inquiry into waste crime that, even when criminals are caught, fines can amount to only a few hundred pounds. Set against a potential payload of £2,500 per truckload, and with around 30 trucks a day arriving at Hoads Wood at the height of the activity, it is difficult to describe such penalties as a deterrent. The reality is that much of this industrial-scale illegal activity is facilitated by waste-handling sites permitted by the Environment Agency. I give one example of how this occurs at the waste-processing stage. Transfer stations and materials recovery facilities—MRFs—operating unlawfully, albeit with permits from the Environment Agency, can shred or blend mixed waste to obscure its origin. The waste is compacted and bulked up for loading on to large vehicles capable of carrying 25 tonnes; it can then be diverted to illegal dumping sites or exported. It is clear that much of the waste dumped at Hoads Wood, Bickershaw and Kidlington had passed through a transfer station, and I am confident that the same is true of the majority of the 117 high-priority illegal waste sites now acknowledged by the Environment Agency. Another form of large-scale illegal activity is the misdescription of waste and the exemptions regime in waste management, which is then disposed of unlawfully. There are many loopholes. It is clear that the resources available to criminal gangs far outstrip those of enforcement bodies. Enforcement agencies are unable to grip the problem because the opportunities are easy, the profits are enormous and the penalties are paltry. The most effective intervention must therefore be to prevent criminals gaining access to the waste in the first place. The Government’s 10-point action plan is welcome, even if some of its measures are, in my view, somewhat performative. In particular, I welcome the long-awaited reforms relating to carriers, brokers and dealers, as well as the implementation of the first phase of the digital waste-tracking system. These measures will be necessary to enforce the measures in this Bill. Waste crime is estimated to cost the UK economy around £2 billion every year, according to the Environmental Services Association. The Environment Agency has failed to get to grips with this problem, and my Bill is simple in its effect. Naming a director responsible for a company’s waste journey from the point of production to its final destination creates a clear focal point for producer responsibility. Where it is proven that waste produced or handled by an organisation lacks a satisfactory audit trail, that operator should be responsible for the cost of clearing up the illegally managed waste. I end on this note. In the committee’s public oral evidence session just last week, Philip Duffy, chief executive of the Environment Agency, said: “I mentioned anti-corruption. We have a real problem with who is signing off these contracts, either in local government or in the supply chain. Are we confident that we have enough controls to drive out corrupt practices from those areas? Transparency in that area is really important”. That is what my Bill will provide: transparency. The supporters of the Bill are at one with the ESA and the Environment Agency, apparently. I hope the Government will join us, or, as the Minister is aware, the battle to rid our country of the scourge that is waste crime will continue apace.

More from Baroness Sheehan (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.