E

Earl Russell (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken and congratulate my noble friend Lady Sheehan on a very well-drafted and important Private Member’s Bill. The Bill is clear and concise in its aims and is backed by industry and charities alike. It offers an ingenious and practical strategic reset of our waste regulations and, most importantly, puts in place a deterrent to bad behaviour. It is a serious and workable proposition, which I believe would strengthen and complement the actions the Government have taken already. This is not an either/or but a question of both. I also want to thank the Minister and departmental officials, particularly those on the front lines, because there has been an important cultural shift in this debate. As well as all the actions that have been mentioned, there is a growing culture of openness, which is fundamental to making further progress. However, there is no doubt much more to do. This feels like an important moment for reflection on our future direction. As all noble Lords have noted, for too long we have accepted broken systems that have given us nothing but broken results. A fear of finding out has predominated. The waste criminals have got away with it. Whether it is the 38 million tonnes of waste, enough to fill Wembley Stadium 35 times, the £2 billion cost or the fact that only a quarter of cases are reported, there have been continuous and persistent regulatory failures, and that has allowed the criminals to supersize their operations. As the noble Lord, Lord Krebs, put it, everybody has their favourite local large-scale waste site, whether it is Hoads Wood, Kidlington or Wigan. The current legal framework is, to my mind, a “good chaps” system of regulation when it comes to big businesses. That is outdated and is not working. It is the victims—the landowners—who feel the pain, have to carry the cost of clean-up and then have the landfill tax added on top. The Bill aims to address these root problems by turning off the waste tap and criminal supply lines, as the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, put it, and imposing the “polluter pays” principle. It establishes a direct legal line of sight between corporate boardrooms and the ultimate destination of the waste that they generate. Having a named director assumes due diligence and the need for annual compliance and adequate record retention—increasing that to six years—and inputs civil liabilities for failures to do that. There are counterarguments: this is a Private Member’s Bill that everybody has worked on to try to make it as effective as possible. The Government may argue that the incentives in place are adequate; I disagree. I think these complement them. Where you have digital waste tracking and these other measures, which are welcome, criminals are likely to still operate outside those legal frameworks. So, cutting off supply has real relevance and importance. Without board-level accountability, we will not be able to shut off this supply. Some, in particular the noble Lord, Lord Sharpe, argue that this is unnecessary red tape; I disagree. Companies have responsibility for the waste that they generate. If they continue to be able to go to the lowest price, this problem will continue, and it is a burden on society. They already have ISO 14001 duties. They are already doing a lot of this stuff. We cannot continue to rely on post-incident to deal with these problems—that is just not working—so cutting off the supply is really important. I hope the Minister will give the proposals in the Bill serious consideration. It is about proper due diligence. There are some problems with the Bill. It is unclear how liability would operate when waste has been through several intermediaries. But audit trails, proper legal responsibility and auditing can solve that problem. The definition of “large companies” has been addressed. The noble Lord, Lord Bourne, put forward suggestions that are workable but need a bit of definition. There is also the issue of financial penalties only and where they sit with existing legal requirements, particularly in relation to imprisonment. But these are small things that can be clarified and sorted out. I hope the Government will continue to take further action on these important issues. I hope that they will be bringing forward further legislation on these issues. I hope that we can get better joined-up working between agencies so that we can fight these serious, organised criminals. I hope that we can move away from overregulation of the legitimate sector, get better training for our judiciary and more appropriate punishments. We also need reform of the landfill tax. I hope the Minister will look seriously at this Bill.

More from Earl Russell (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.