Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for introducing this Bill, and for the work of her committee and their excellent report. I should also mention the campaigning and tenacity of my noble friend Lord Russell, who has made this issue his own personal crusade.
While this Bill looks at ways of tackling waste crime, I believe there is a simple way to dramatically reduce both large-scale and small-scale waste crime with the stroke of a pen: by getting rid of the landfill tax. The economic case for waste crime is basically tax evasion, which has not really been mentioned, but the basis of landfill tax is that to get rid of a tonne of waste, you have to pay £130 in tax, whereas your gate fees are £34 to actually put the rubbish into the ground.
In preparation for this debate, I was writing a business plan for a different business, but I thought I would replicate the headings of that plan and look at the economics of waste crime. I have to say, the profit margin of waste crime is really impressive—though, I hasten to add, I am not actually going to undertake any waste crime. The main business case is the tax evasion element. That tax affects the amount of waste crime taking place is made clear by the fact that the increase in the amount of waste crime is matched by a corresponding increase in the landfill tax.
The landfill tax has now hit such a point that illegal dumping is extremely profitable not only as a large-scale waste crime but for small businesses undertaking such dumping. I have just had the bill for some work being done on my land, and the contractor has added £450 for waste disposal. I trust the builder implicitly, and most people will pay for the disposal of waste, but it is quite clear from the amount of waste that is made up of small building material, including kitchen cabinets, baths and the like, that a large element of small waste crime comes from this.
I was on the Front Bench covering Defra during the genesis of the landfill tax back in 1996, a mere 30 years ago. I was an enthusiastic supporter of the landfill tax, which has been widely recognised as successful. There has been behaviour change—from almost 100% of waste going into landfill to about 90% being diverted at the moment. However, that has recently changed, because of some unintended consequences.
The landfill tax is a very blunt tool. In 1996, the standard rate was £7 a tonne and the lower rate was £2 a tonne. At present, it is £130.75. I do not know why they are using pence, but it is £130.75 at the standard rate and £8.65 at the lower rate. That is a 1,700% increase in tax, which is eye-watering, and it is clear that the Treasury sees this as a way of making money. Indeed, the Treasury makes £623 million a year on landfill tax. However, the cost of waste crime is estimated at between £1 billion and £2 billion a year.
These costs can be broken down considerably. The cost to EA was mentioned; £45 million is now going through the waste crime action plan and £15 million on clean-up costs. The cost to local authorities in clean-up costs alone last year was reckoned at £150 million, and local authorities are actually paying the tax. It is difficult to find a figure for it across the board, but they must be making up an element of the £623 million. So in reality, the landfill tax is being paid by council tax payers, whose bills are then increased to pay the clean-up costs.
I know that asking the Minister to take on the Treasury would elicit at least a wry smile, but I ask her to talk to the Chancellor because, in the last Budget, he talked about “preventive departmental expenditure”. If Defra were prepared to do a cost-benefit analysis against the Red Book, the case for getting rid of the landfill tax would be very strong, and it would save the country and the environment a great deal.