Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]
Friday, 20 November 2026
Contributions
Second Reading
Moved by
Lord Moylan
That the Bill be now read a second time.
Lord Moylan (Con)
My Lords, I introduced an identically worded Bill in the previous Session and when it was debated at Second Reading, almost exactly two years ago in December 2024, there was pushback from certain noble Lords who accused me of being in the hands of dark American money. I hope we will hear no more along these lines today. It is untrue as well as insulting, and it trivialises an important topic. This Bill is not about altering in any way access to abortion. It is about the welfare of women, who are entitled to accurate information about the risks and procedure involved. I hope noble Lords who speak against the principle of the Bill will have good arguments as to why women and clinicians should not have accurate information. Nor is it my purpose to claim that abortion is unsafe; I am quite happy to agree that abortion is generally a safe procedure for women. Rather, the question this Bill raises is how safe it is. To know that, we need statistics that reflect real experience. The starting-point is that the Abortion Act 1967 requires each termination to be reported to the Chief Medical Officer and specifies the information that has to be provided. The information must include any complications arising from the procedure. This is known as the abortion notification system. The great majority of abortions, 80%, are provided by independent clinics, such as the charities BPAS—the British Pregnancy Advisory Service—and Marie Stopes, though there are other, smaller providers as well. The abortion notification system covers these independent providers and the 20% of terminations carried out in an NHS setting. The form they return is known in DHSC jargon as an HSA4 but, as I say, its contents are set out in a section of the Abortion Act. Completing and returning it is a statutory obligation for each termination. I have no reason to think that providers are not completing and returning the forms. I am sure they are complying with the statutory requirements put in place by Parliament in 1967, but that is where the weakness in statistics arises. In 1967, all abortions would have involved a surgical procedure and very likely an overnight stay, whether in an independent clinic or an NHS hospital. Complications would have become apparent quickly and so could have been included in the HSA4 form. The position today is very different. A surgical abortion is nowadays a rarity. Currently, about 85% of abortions are medically induced—that is, by taking a sequence of pills. As recently as 2012, only 48% of abortions were medically induced, but, by 2023 it was 85%. These terminations frequently take place at home, and indeed since the Covid pandemic it is possible for a woman to obtain the medication from an abortion provider without an initial in-person interview or examination. This shows that the abortion landscape is shifting very rapidly and clinicians need to have available the most robust data about complications, as indeed women do, for the purpose of informed consent. What does this changing pattern of provision mean for our understanding of statistics? If a complication is to arise from an abortion, it is likely that it will do so quickly. Haemorrhage, sepsis and the like are soon apparent, but a woman who has undergone a medical abortion at home is not, by definition, in a clinic or medical setting. What is she to do? The overwhelming likelihood is that she will report to A&E. The complication in that case will not be communicated to the abortion provider and will not therefore be reported on the HSA4 form. It will, however, be recorded in hospital statistics. I add at this point that there is no legal obligation on the Department of Health and Social Care to publish the statistics on abortion that it collects through the abortion notification system. It has, however, published them unfailingly until two years ago. When we debated my Bill in the last Session, in December 2024, we were making use of the 2023 abortion statistics. Noble Lords will be disturbed to learn that they are, even today, the most recently published statistics. Something seems to have gone grievously wrong at the DHSC, and no explanation has been provided. I hope that, today, the Minister can tell your Lordships why exactly the statistics have not been published in the last two years. What has gone wrong? I understand that, in the course of next month, it is likely that the 2024 statistics will be published, and the Minister will be able to say whether that understanding is correct. However, we are still way behind. When are the 2025 statistics expected? What has gone wrong and why are the figures not being made available? To some extent, that is a side issue to my main argument. Returning to that, do the official abortion statistics properly capture the true rate of complications? To know that, we do need to proceed on the basis of conjecture. If one wants to know the rate of complications arising from abortions, one needs to look, fairly obviously, not merely at forms returned by abortion providers but at what is going on in hospitals. Fortunately, we know about this. The Office for Health Improvement and Disparities, which is a branch of the NHS, turned its hand to the task of interrogating hospital data, and in November 2023 produced its report. The task was more challenging than one might have thought. There were, of course, many of the usual statistical conundra: what to count, what not to count, and whether definitions in different datasets were the same and so forth. In fact, almost the first half of its report is a careful and thorough essay on the methodology it used. It focused entirely on incidents arising in a hospital setting, using hospital episode statistics, and, importantly, separated out incomplete abortions that were not accompanied by a further complication—that is an important point I will come back to. It broke the complication rate down by age, showing, as is generally accepted, that it is somewhat higher for older women, and by type—for example, between haemorrhage, which is the most common complication, sepsis, cervical tear and so forth. Its headline finding, so to speak, was that the complication rate was between 3.5 and 4.4 per 1,000 in the period 2017 to 2021, which was the period it looked at, depending on the year. This compares with data published by the DHSC up to 2023 based on the abortion notification system alone, which shows a complication rate of about 1.2 to 1.4 per thousand in recent years. I understand this is statistically significant. However, the complication rate established by the OHID rose significantly, to about 17, 18 or 19 per thousand, if incomplete abortions without further complications were included. It is unfortunate, therefore, that it appears that there are no plans for the OHID to continue to collect the valuable data contained in its report. My Bill would place an obligation on the Government to do so. Clause 1 requires the Secretary of State to publish an annual report on complications, states that the purpose is “to inform policy and safe practice”, requires the inclusion of data from both the ANS and the hospital episode statistics, specifies that the report must cover the same areas of information as the 2023 report, gives the Secretary of State power to add further information he or she sees fit to include and states that the first report must appear within a year. Clause 2 covers territorial scope and commencement. In effect, the Bill applies to England. There is no other clause. It is important to note that the Bill mandates the collection of both ANS and HES data. Those who worry—especially professional statisticians—that there would be a rupture in the long-established ANS statistical sequence need have no concern. The ANS figures would still be collected, as required by law, before being aggregated with separately sourced HES data. There are real stories at the bottom of this. This morning, I received an email from a paediatrician practising in the Midlands. I do not feel I can name the person without their permission, but they said, “It is perfectly possible within current practice and guidance for a woman to be prescribed and take abortion medication remotely when she is more than 12 weeks pregnant, but only to realise this once the abortion has taken place. In this circumstance, it is entirely possible, and indeed has happened, that the woman delivers a baby who is of viable gestation and may be born with signs of life”—this would be at home—“and then subsequently dies. I am aware from my current practice and through liaising with peer networks that cases such as this have occurred. However, there is no formal reporting mechanism that exists to capture and monitor the frequency with which this is occurring”. Women have a right to know these things, and that email demonstrates that their clinicians want to know as well. We need better statistics. I will deal with some other possible objections. First, I refer to the comment from BPAS, quoted in the Library brief, that the Bill “exceptionalises” abortion. This is not so. What exceptionalises abortion is the original Abortion Act, with its unusual statutory requirement for mandatory reporting. BPAS is entitled to lobby for legislation to remove that exceptional requirement, but that is not this Bill, which simply accepts the legal status quo on this point. BPAS’s other comments seem to me to be very weak. The key point is that even it agrees that “further work needs to be done on collection and analysis of large datasets relating to women’s reproductive health”. The fact is that nobody, not even the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, defends the existing ANS statistical sets as giving a realistic picture. It also claims that there are better ways of dealing with the problem than this Bill. That may be true, but it does not suggest any. I have one further objection and then I shall sit down. It may be said that an Act of Parliament is a bit of a sledgehammer to crack this particular nut. I certainly see the force of that—it is true. But it is a Private Members’ Bill, intended to some extent to provoke debate. Indeed, if the Minister in responding were to give a firm undertaking to do what the Bill requires without the bother of statutory obligation, I would be perfectly content with that. I beg to move.
Baroness Thornton (Lab)
My Lords, I first thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for the clear explanation of his Bill. Of course, it is not the first time we have heard the noble Lord’s exposition, and he has undertaken it with great detail and great research, even if I disagree with him from time to time. I do not disagree with the noble Lord in the comment he made about the change that there has been in the availability of abortion, particularly with the at-home pill and tele-abortion, and all to the better for women and their health. I thank the Library, BPAS and others for their briefing on the Bill. The noble Lord will not be surprised that I remain unconvinced by his speech—now as then—and of either the desirability or the necessity of this Private Member’s Bill. I agree with BPAS and feel quite strongly that it is not desirable, in principle, because the creation of a law to require the reporting of complications in this way exceptionalises abortion and fails to treat it like other forms of healthcare, where reporting on NHS statistics is there. There is a danger of stigmatising both clinicians and women. I have to say that despite what the noble Lord has said, my suspicion is that this might be part of the motivation for those who are supporting the Bill. My noble friend the Minister said in December 2024, when the House last considered the Bill, that it is “a very safe procedure in which major complications are rare at all gestations”. My noble friend went on to say: “The aims of the Bill can be achieved through existing routes … and further legislation is unnecessary”. Specifically addressing the issue of producing an annual report on complications, my noble friend said of the 2023 publication that the Labour Government had “no plans to issue a similar” annual “publication ”.—[ Official Report , 13/12/24; col. 1992.] So, the noble Lord knows that the Minister told us two years ago that our Government were not going to do that. I know my Government are very keen on accurate data and data collection driving policy. We are committed to the single patient record, for example, which itself presents sexual health issues, such as confidentiality for women, which we will be discussing during the passage of the Health Bill, currently before your Lordships’ House. But as my noble friend said in 2024: “We are not complacent; we are always seeking to improve ”.—[ Official Report , 13/12/24; col. 1993.] So I am confident that the Minister will report the situation as it is today. At the moment, it would be very difficult, if not impossible, to collect the statistics as outlined by the noble Lord. Everyone agrees with the noble Lord, including me, that further work is needed on collection and analysis of datasets; of course it is. But it would surely be better—and this is about the exceptionalism of this Private Member’s Bill—for it to be dealt with through the NHS 10-year plan and designed in a way that preserves the confidentiality and proper analysis of the relevant data. Regulations produced from the Abortion Act 1967 included complications as one of the earliest ways of collecting national data to improve patient care, because that is the point of collecting data. But the health service as a whole has moved on since the 1960s. Today, the recording, analysis and reporting of data is the norm, and this legislation is not necessary to achieve that.
Baroness Brinton (LD)
My Lords, it is my pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, who has laid out the arguments against the need for this Bill very clearly. I thank those who have briefed us, including the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, BPAS and the Library. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for his extensive explanation; I am afraid that he has not convinced me, but that may not surprise him. I will focus on data. Regulations issued under the Abortion Act require specifically that a woman’s name and date of birth, or a personal identifier, be submitted on every abortion provided—not just on complications, as the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, implied earlier—to the Chief Medical Officer via the abortion notification system. It is important to note that NHS numbers are not required. That is important partly because, as has been outlined, some of the data on complications is collected before the patient is discharged from the clinic. That data, as we know, is managed by the Department of Health and Social Care. The second set of data, on hospital episode statistics, details activity that happens afterwards. The noble Lord referred to a woman at home having complications and ending up in A&E—that is a reassuring aspect of the data, because it does end up in the system; it may not be linked to the first dataset, but there is a reason for that. The noble Lord cited some statistics. He said that 18 per 1,000 was a very high percentage of complications; in fact, that is 1.8%. It is very similar to the US figures for abortions up to 24 weeks: complications account for 2.1%, with major complications accounting for only 0.3%. The results for complications are much lower than could be implied by hearing about the data cited by the noble Lord. Our concerns remain that there is a narrative about significant levels of complications, when in fact that is not the case. I hope the noble Lord will accept that it is reassuring that our data matches that of America. As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, said, the 10-year plan will produce a single patient record, but we need to remember why abortion and sexual health data is kept separate from other data: to protect women, especially those experiencing domestic abuse or honour-based abuse, and those under 16. A further reason for not linking abortion and hospital data is that, unfortunately, some people are behaving very badly inside the system at the moment. The Independent said two days ago: “NHS hospital and ambulance trusts in England have recorded over 3,000 cases of staff improperly accessing patient information in recent years”. The data comes amid increasingly high numbers of high-profile privacy breaches by health service workers, including, as we know, dozens who have viewed the medical records of victims after the attacks of Southport and Nottingham. Whether data is viewed for ghoulish gratification or even for campaigning reasons, all patients must be protected. Last year, I spoke about some of the behaviour of authorities in the US that have banned abortions completely. Police in one area were demanding that foetal remains, after an early miscarriage, always be taken to hospital for investigation. This was overreach by the relevant authorities and has now been stopped, but that overreach continues in different areas in different ways. One complication of pregnancy that in the UK would always end in an abortion is ectopic pregnancy. The NHS website says: “Unfortunately, it’s not possible to save the pregnancy. It usually has to be removed using medicine or an operation”. Why do I raise this issue? ProPublica, a newsroom organisation that investigates abuses of power, has just published a detailed report into the doubling of maternal deaths as a result of ectopic pregnancies since the 18 states banned abortion completely, specifically excluding the removal of an ectopic pregnancy. One appalled doctor said: “A death related to ectopic pregnancy should really be a never event”. Worse than that, anti-abortion activists and organisations are now posting online that a foetus can survive an ectopic pregnancy and that doctors who carry out the operation to remove the fallopian tube and the embryo to save the life of both mother and baby should not do so. Why do I raise this? The noble Lord’s Bill appears to be trying to make women who have abortions trackable. We have perfectly good systems in place to prevent this. Frankly, the UK is good at collecting data on complications. That should be enough.
Baroness Freeman of Steventon (CB)
My Lords, until recently, I worked on producing decision aid information to help support patients to make medical decisions, which required researching and then presenting outcome statistics. This meant that I spent a lot of time trying to find data on side-effects and complications, as well as positive outcomes. My team spoke with probably 1,000 patients over several years to find out what they wanted to know and what outcomes were significant to them across many different conditions and procedures. Health data is perhaps surprisingly difficult to wrangle and interpret. Many of the commonest procedures, such as cataract removal and hip or knee replacements, are, like abortions, not usually done within the NHS. Yet, from the perspective of a researcher like me, the statistics on complications from abortion are of comparatively good quality. It is common to have to collate data from many different sources. I will give one example of finding statistics for other procedures. In England, around 60,000 people per year undergo a cholecystectomy—a treatment for gallstones. We found that the clinical trial data, Cochrane reviews and NICE guidance all failed to record that 10% of patients suffer new onset diarrhoea as a result of the surgery—the second biggest risk after ongoing pain. This had been studied and reported in separate literature, but not collated with the other side-effects. There are so many examples of complications data not being carefully collected and collated, yet, comparatively, a lot of care is taken over abortion outcome statistics. It could be improved, but so could all outcome statistics. Over the years of trying to produce information to help patients choose between different options, I have found that often other people want to use that information to persuade them. Even medical professionals can express concern about giving patients information. When asked to give a reason, they say things such as, “We don’t want to encourage women to have elective caesareans” or, “We don’t want to put people off having surgery”. It can be difficult for medical professionals, as well as many others, to accept that every individual has the right to make their own health choices within the law, even if they are choices that they disagree with. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, says that the report mandated by the Bill is needed for clinicians and patients to be able to give informed consent and make decisions based on the correct information. I would argue that the way to provide information for clinicians and patients is in the form of a decision aid or well-designed consent forms developed in close consultation with clinicians and patients, not a report to Parliament. Indeed, NICE has produced decision aids for medical versus surgical abortion for different gestation periods. These could be improved, but there is no need for any report to Parliament to do that. I note that, should the noble Lord instead want to persuade people, using complication statistics would be unlikely to achieve that aim. Having spoken with a lot of patients, I can say that the numbers are very rarely that important in their decision-making, especially not when the complication rates are as low as they are for abortion. Should the noble Lord wish to persuade policymakers to change the law on abortion, I point out how low these complication rates are compared with so many other common procedures. To give an example, the proportion of people who come out of cataract surgery with eyesight worse than before is around 20 out of 1,000. Around 50 out of 1,000 have a complication. For those having a hip replacement, it is quite similar: around 30 out of 1,000 come out of surgery with their hip worse as a result, and roughly 50 out of 1,000 have a complication. The rate of complications for abortion that we have heard of is less than three in 1,000—less than 20 in 1,000 even if you include the broadest categories of complications that the noble Lord mentioned. I do not think the statistics are any less certain for abortion than for cataracts or for hip and knee replacements. The statistics on abortion complications are not perfect, but they are better than many other medical statistics, and a report to Parliament will not improve them. Moreover, whichever way you look at them, they show relatively low rates of complications, and this information is already available to clinicians, patients and policymakers. Therefore, I oppose the Bill.
Baroness Sugg (Con)
My Lords, I fully recognise the importance of high-quality data and the need for healthcare services to learn from outcomes and continuously improve patient safety—and, of course, for women to have access to accurate information. Indeed, better data collection in women’s health is something I strongly support. I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Moylan for his introduction and explanation of the Bill. However, I remain unconvinced that the Bill is the right way to achieve those outcomes. As the House of Lords Library briefing notes, abortion complications are already recorded, abortion statistics are already published annually, and there is already a statutory framework requiring notification and reporting of relevant information. The question before us is not whether data should be collected but whether abortion alone should be singled out in primary legislation for a dedicated annual report. When we last debated the Bill in December 2024, the Minister argued that abortion is a safe procedure and no other area of healthcare has a legislative requirement of this kind for the publication of complication reports. As we have heard, the evidence before us continues to show that abortion is a very safe procedure and complications are rare, as set out in the briefing from the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. That briefing also warns that the Bill risks stigmatising both women accessing abortion care and the healthcare professionals who provide it. The college further argues that decisions around clinical practice and patient safety should be led by medical evidence and clinical expertise, rather than through primary legislation. Developments since our previous debate have strengthened rather than weakened the case against the Bill. The House of Lords Library briefing highlights that the Office for Statistics Regulation completed a compliance review of abortion statistics in April 2026 and concluded that the statistics continued to meet the standards required under the code of practice for statistics. The review found that the existing data source was suitable for producing the statistics, and the limitations of complications data were adequately explained. If the independent regulator responsible for assuring statistical quality has reviewed the system and confirmed that the statistics remain fit for purpose, it is difficult to see the case for legislating for a new reporting requirement before ongoing improvement work has been completed. I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, for sharing her experience on complications. There is also a practical problem. The Bill would require annual reporting that combines data sources that are not currently capable of providing the information in the format that the Bill demands. I would like to discuss this in the wider context of the Health Bill currently before Parliament, as other speakers have, and the Government’s plan for a single patient record. There remains genuine potential here to improve health data across the NHS, including women’s reproductive health data, but these reforms are still being developed and will be implemented over a number of years. As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, highlighted, stakeholders have rightly raised concerns that any future data-sharing arrangements must preserve confidentiality, particularly for women seeking sexual and reproductive health care. For many women, confidentiality is fundamental to their ability to access care safely, and that is particularly true of women experiencing domestic abuse, coercive control or honour-based abuse. I look forward to the debate on those amendments next week. While I fully agree that we should strive for improved data, a better route is through the broader reforms already under way. I would be grateful if the Minister, in her response, could outline what steps the Government are taking to improve the quality and interoperability of women’s health data, so that policymakers and clinicians can access the information they need. Good data matters, patient safety matters, and women’s health matters, but those objectives are best served through proportionate, evidence-based improvements across the healthcare system, not through primary legislation that singles out one lawful medical procedure. For those reasons, while I respect the intentions behind the Bill, I am not persuaded that it is necessary or that it would improve outcomes for women.
Lord Weir of Ballyholme (DUP)
My Lords, I support the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. Having heard the last few speakers, he may be glad that at least one person in the House supports his Bill. We know that the issue of abortion is highly controversial and particularly individual. I think everybody accepts that this is an incredibly sensitive topic. Given those sensitivities, it is right that we all take care over both language and tone in this debate, and I appreciate that all speakers so far have reflected this. It is also the case that there is a wide range of views on where abortion law should sit. Sometimes that is put into a very binary position of whether people are classified as being purely pro life or pro choice. However, it is more of a spectrum, because even those of us who are the most ardent pro-life supporters would certainly accept that there are a range of conditions and circumstances in which abortion is permitted and should be legally permitted. Similarly, I think the staunchest of pro-choice campaigners would accept that there should not simply be an unregulated system, and this should be about finding a legal balance between which circumstances are permissible and which are not. Some of us would take the view, particularly with recent changes, that the balance is not necessarily right, but the Bill does not change any of that. Similarly, that is the approach that we need to take in this country. We have always had this debate and, while it is a very passionate one, it has always been conducted in a civil and respectful manner. That contrasts with the position at times in the United States, where it has become a toxic issue that defines where politicians stand, sometimes even spilling over into those who would use violence to try to make their point. That is not a route that any of us want to go down. I always get slightly nervous when people start drawing comparisons and false analogies with any piece of legislation to suggest, however subtly, that this is some pathway down to where the United States is. We are a different people and a different country, and this is different legislation, and we need to bear that in mind. To that extent, therefore, we should be looking at where, within the context of this, we can find broad agreement. Surely all of us, irrespective of where we stand on the spectrum on abortion, believe it is right that women’s health and welfare should be put front and centre. At the heart of that is decision-making that is well informed. It is undoubtedly the case that events have changed rapidly over the last few years. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, mentioned the shift from 48% to 85%. Statistics show that medications at home have risen from, I think, 34% to 72%. So we are seeing a rapidly shifting situation, and it is undoubtedly the case that the annual ANS statistics do not in and of themselves seem to reflect an entirely accurate position. Even when you exclude the issue of incomplete abortions, the HES statistics that were produced in 2023 would suggest a rate of complication 2.6 times higher than the ANS statistics. We are not suggesting that ANS statistics should be abandoned—it is right that those are continued—but this is something in a parallel track. It is also the case that it has sometimes been used by Ministers, of whatever persuasion, to say, “Well, these statistics cannot be produced, they’re impossible to produce, they’re impractical to produce”, and so on, but we know that these statistics can be produced because that is what happened in 2023. So that gives us a potential way forward. Lastly, for any of us who have ever been in government, the accusation is often thrown about that you are deciding policy and producing legislation on the basis of your own views or a party-political position, not something that is evidence driven. That does not mean that you do not sometimes have contrasting evidence, or indeed that sometimes a Minister cannot say, “For the greater good of society, despite the evidence, we believe this is the best way forward for our society”, but to deny any attempt at making that evidence more accurate and to keep that from public discourse and debate is the wrong course of action. We should therefore be striving to improve that information base and that evidence. I take on board the point that has been mentioned, that the level of complications is statistically very low. That may therefore be a level of reassurance to individuals rather than a deterrent to a particular course of action. But let us at least give policymakers and individuals making those decisions the best possible opportunity to decide for themselves on the basis of the most accurate information possible.
Baroness Lawlor (Con)
My Lords, few can cavil with the aim of the Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan. Even fewer would disagree that, in general, up-to-date information should be available to patients in deciding treatment that is available under the NHS. People should know about the complications and side-effects, and the information and statistical data should be available. I disagree that this should be kept, as some noble Lords have suggested, within the medical profession or the patients. It is a question of the wider availability of data on the possible health outcomes of treatment, particularly in cases where it is being publicly funded. I am delighted about the progress on patient records, but it is important that we have accessible data such as exists for many treatments. Whether it is osteoarthritis, lupus or the medication available, we should know, whether we are a patient, a doctor or a member of the public who wants to get briefed on what is available. Just to go back to the Private Member’s Bill from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, he told us that a great deal of data exists at the moment, at least until 2023. We know about the HSA4 forms, which are compiled on the basis of ANS data, but those forms have their limitations; they have to be submitted within a fortnight and therefore they may not pick up treatments which have complications after a fortnight or which are reported elsewhere. Indeed, the DHSC itself has highlighted that these statistics should be treated with caution in view of some of the changes, including, of course, the change that medication can be taken entirely at home and therefore complications are likely to occur at home. The hospital episode statistics record data only for those admitted to hospitals and not those who are seen in A&E, ring 111 or may be in the out-patient department’s clinics. Therefore, the HES statistics are also limited. In fact, as with the ANS data, they do not record complications for which GPs are responsible, and neither does the 111 service. Clearly, however, both sets of data matter. We heard from the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that the 2023 one-off report was very useful in putting the data together, so we understood that different sorts of complications were recorded in different sorts of data. This matters if you are trying to get to the bottom of many statistics which are available today. To conclude, it has been objected that this measure would exceptionalise abortion. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, pointed out the requirements for reporting under the Act, and I add that abortion is an exceptional treatment. It has very different characteristics legally from other medical or quasi-medical procedures, and only the most hardened misanthrope could describe it as a treatment for illness, because it is not necessarily an illness for which one is being treated. One is being treated in line with a view or a choice which is made. I do not want to get into the abortion debate. However, it is important that women who opt for that treatment should have access to all the data, just as that is important for women who opt for any other treatment. In a proper parliamentary democracy, the report to Parliament is important. We should not restrict statistics and data on publicly funded activities provided on behalf of our Government. We should not have reports which are circulated privately to the profession of one group or another; they should be available to all in the interests of transparency and democracy.
Baroness Maclean of Redditch (Con)
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for introducing this important Bill to the House. He has made a compelling case to inform our discussion, and I am sure other noble Lords are grateful for that. First, I want to acknowledge that there are different views on this topic, as we have heard so far in the debate. We have heard a number of speakers raise points against the Bill and I will try to address some of those points in my remarks. However, I support the Bill, because the system designed to record complications from what is a major health event in a woman’s life no longer reflects the reality of women’s lives today. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, said, under the Abortion Regulations 1991, notification of an abortion via the statutory form requires medical practitioners to record complications occurring up until the time of discharge from the place of termination. However, we should be very clear that, in 1991, the vast majority of those terminations happened via surgical operations; figures indicate that these were 95% of the total at that time. Now the latest figures, from 2023, suggest that the situation has been almost entirely reversed; 87% of terminations are medical, which means after taking abortion pills, rather than by an operation. With operations, women remained under direct medical supervision until discharge, which allowed any immediate adverse effects to be observed, documented, reported and, crucially, treated in a timely manner. This is important because it calls into question the value of the forms—we have heard about the HSA4 form and the ANS—as they currently stand. The 2023 statistics showed that 72% of those terminations involved taking both medications at home following a remote consultation. That is a marked increase from previous years: it compares to 34.3% in 2020 and 51.9% in 2021. For an at-home medical abortion, there is no meaningful concept of clinical discharge. If a woman experiences adverse symptoms, such as severe haemorrhaging, retained pregnancy tissue or infection, she is likely not to return to an independent abortion provider but to present to her local NHS A&E or perhaps call 111. Any abortion-related complications would then be captured in hospital episode statistics. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, mentioned, the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities undertook a review which clearly showed that the hospital episode statistics identified an average complication rate 2.6 times higher than that derived from ANS data. In fact, when incomplete abortions are included—when the unpleasant-sounding products of conception remain—the complication rate is 11.9 times higher than was identified through the ANS data covering the same period. This is a significant disparity. That discrepancy has likely worsened, as the proportion of abortions that take place away from a clinical setting has increased since the publication of the data used by the OHID review. I was also concerned to read in that report that OHID found “no evidence” of abortion providers contacting the DHSC to ensure the data was updated when a woman had informed the abortion provider about a complication occurring after the form had been submitted. I want to be clear that personal views on the subject of abortion in general, whatever they are, have no bearing on this Bill. Quite simply, there is a gap in our understanding that needs to be plugged. Continuing to rely solely on the existing system leaves us with only a partial grip on the reality for women undergoing termination of pregnancy and the complications that they may experience. I note that the Minister indicated that there were possible concerns about technical difficulties when the Bill was in Committee. I accept that these are difficult systems to link up but, as the 2023 report shows, this is a surmountable problem. We should not accept that this is too difficult to do, as we are thinking about the safety of women. I am aware that work is being undertaken to digitise the process, so I look forward to hearing the Minister’s response. I hope the Government have reconsidered their position and will support the noble Lord’s quite modest proposal.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
My Lords, like many speakers today, this is my third time commenting on this Bill and my position has not changed.
Lord Moylan (Con)
It is the second time.
Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)
There was a Committee stage as well. The Green Party and I oppose the Bill, and I make no apology for situating it in the undeniable context of the extremely well-funded campaign, originating chiefly in America but felt around the world, against women’s right to reproductive healthcare. This is driven by disturbing anti-female ideology. As I said at the last Second Reading, this is a long-running campaign. The success of that campaign in the US has had awful impacts on the health of American women, as the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, outlined. Predictably, those who are subject to economic and social disadvantage suffer the most. The wealthy will always find a way to access abortion and, most usually, a safe method of abortion. However, I want to be positive and note that this debate is happening in a context where we can celebrate real progress in the UK. Not only have we seen come into force a legal amendment that prevents women being criminalised for ending their own pregnancies, but it has also delivered pardons for about 150 women who were affected by that law. I note, however, that that law does not currently apply in Scotland. The Scottish Green Party is seeking to deliver in Scotland the same legal protection that women in England and Wales now have, as well as looking to a full decriminalisation of abortion so that it is treated like any other health procedure. It is worth looking at the history of this. We are celebrating the end of something, so let us go back to the start. I credit the Guardian with reporting this. What has happened over the centuries? In 1862, just after the law that was often used against women having abortions came in, Fanny Worboys, a widow, was injured in a back-street abortion and then sentenced to three months in prison as a result. I tell that story as a way of saying, “Never again”. We have to keep moving forward, not backward as this Bill would take us. Just in the past week or so, we have seen some positive news in Hungary of significant potential improvements put forward by the Government to improve women’s access to reproductive healthcare. This has been said before, but it always needs to be repeated: abortion is a very safe and effective procedure, and safer at all gestations than continuing a pregnancy to term. In one large-scale study in the US, the overall complication rate up to 24 weeks was 2.1% and major complications were at about 0.3%. This debate is also in the context of your Lordships’ House dealing with the Health Bill in some depth. I look forward to the comments of the noble Baroness, Lady Barker. She and I commented earlier this week about making sure that that Bill maintains and protects the crucial right to confidentiality and the long-standing right to anonymous sexual health treatment, including abortion. What this Bill asks for potentially threatens that. Sexual healthcare records should be accessible only with explicit opt-in consent on an episode-by-episode basis. As the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, said, this is particularly important as we are hearing quite regularly, I am afraid, reports of healthcare records being accessed in utterly inappropriate and very disturbing ways. Public confidence is absolutely crucial here: we want people to know that they have that right to privacy. I will finally comment on the single patient record and how it interacts with this, which a number of noble Lords referred to. I declare an interest in that the Taiwanese Government funded this; I went to Taiwan, where we focused on health with the APPG on Taiwan. They have a single patient record in Taiwan, and they have a great deal of confidence in it. They were a bit surprised that we were so surprised. The way it works is that, if a medical professional is going to access your records, they essentially have to insert three cards into a machine: one is your healthcare card, one is the individual practitioner’s card and one is the institution’s card. The record cannot be accessed without those three cards. That shows one way in which a society has solved this problem. We have to solve this problem, but we have to keep confidentiality.
Baroness Meyer (Con)
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Moylan for so clearly introducing this important Bill, which I support. It asks the Government only to publish an annual report giving an accurate picture of the complications of abortions. Building on the Government’s 2023 analysis, it would report complications by age, method, stage and type. This would help identify trends, assess risks and improve medical care. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, said at Second Reading, in many ways this debate is about statistics and statistical mythology. Whatever our views on abortion, women deserve reliable information and the same standards of transparency, accountability and patient safety that apply to other medical procedures. However, our reporting system gives us an incomplete picture. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, explained so clearly, the HSA4 forms will often only record complications before discharge, meaning that problems arising later may never appear. However, in an at-home abortion, discharge may happen after the pills are dispensed but before abortion has taken place. This matters because abortion practices have changed dramatically. Pill by post, which began as a temporary measure, became permanent in 2022, and, by 2023, nearly three-quarters of abortions—that is more than 200,000—were at home. Our reporting system must keep pace with that change. In November 2023, the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities compared abortion notifications with hospital records. The report found that between 2017 and 2021, complication numbers were over two and a half times higher in hospital data on the HES than in data collected via the HSA4 forms. Given that the number of abortions by pill by post has grown by nearly 40% since then, the difference may be much higher today. An incomplete abortion may require further medical treatment or, sometimes, another procedure. It can also lead to severe complications, such as sepsis. How can a woman give her informed consent if the information available does not adequately reflect complications arising after discharge? How can the Government assess safety without reliable evidence? Abortions involve both the mother’s health and well-being and the ending of an unborn human life. That makes it all the more important that we approach it with seriousness, compassion and the fullest possible medical evidence. The Crime and Policing Act 2026 removed the specified criminal liability from women acting in relation to their own pregnancy at any stage. That makes accurate reporting of complications, including later in pregnancy, all the more important. My noble friend Lady Stroud’s Amendment 425 sought to improve the safety of women by requiring a confidential appointment in person before abortion pills were supplied. It followed the freedom of information response suggesting that one in 17 women needed hospital treatment after an abortion at home. The amendment was not agreed, but how can the Government judge whether safeguards are working when the figures give us only part of the picture? This Bill would help Parliament scrutinise outcomes, help doctors improve care and help women make properly informed decisions. We cannot turn a blind eye just because the subject is sensitive. As the noble Lord, Lord Weir, observed, the mark of a tolerant and open society is its willingness to deal with inconvenient opinions. Surely the women who believe in “my body, my right” should also support their right to know the risks and complications of any procedures to their bodies? That is why I support this Bill.
Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)
My Lords, I support this Bill—not surprisingly, given that noble Lords will remember I moved Amendment 458 to the Crime and Policing Bill earlier this year, which had a similar goal. I find it disappointing that some noble Lords have accused my noble friend of bad faith in bringing forward this Bill. I would ask them to look at the details of what is a simple Bill: it merely seeks to bring greater clarity and transparency to the provision of abortion, something that we can all welcome. It also posits a fundamental question: why is this the only aspect of women’s health and well-being on which opponents are actively campaigning against the collection, collation, analysis and release of timely data? Who could possibly not support efforts to increase and improve clinical care and patient choice? Why are they afraid of the evidence? The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, is usually a stickler for evidence in support of the efficacy of a policy, yet many of her remarks had nothing whatever to do with my noble friend’s Bill. The noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, mentioned clinical procedures as though pills by post had never happened. There was a great deal of chutzpah in the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, lecturing some of us on propriety when she is a representative of an institutionally racist party. That is an issue of decency. To rehearse the baseless and pernicious trope that this is all about dark American money is beneath her. The abortion landscape has changed. Since 1967, the number of abortions has gone through the roof. Therefore, with pills by post having been made permanent in 2022, it is an exceptional issue. What has not changed in recent years is the fact that complications around abortion are still not being accurately reported. We say we trust women to make their own decisions about their reproductive health, but we are intentionally depriving them of information they need to inform that decision. Current ANS statistics include only complications known about at the time a woman is discharged. In the case of pills-by-post abortions, which today make up the majority, providers are unlikely to hear from the woman after they send her the pills. Complications will simply not be known about or recorded on the HSA4 form. So, a woman being rushed to hospital after taking abortion pills with something such as excessive bleeding or a retained placenta is not included in the Government’s complication figures. However, such hospital admissions resulting from abortion are recorded in the publicly available HES statistics. I will not test the patients of the House with statistics that others have cited, except to say that when the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities incorporated HES into its one-off report on abortion complications in 2023, the complication rate jumped from 1.1 per 1,000 abortions to 19.3 per 1,000 abortions—a very significant increase. The Minister has repeatedly told me in replies to Parliamentary Questions that this more accurate report, reflecting the HES figures, will not be repeated. I ask again, why not? Why is it that the real situation must be shrouded in secrecy? What are the Government afraid of? Why has it taken two years to publish the 2024 abortion statistics, which we hear will be published on 3 December? It would not be difficult for the Government to collect, collate and report these HES figures. It has been done before. Finally, the Bill would not just give women and doctors the best available information when they are making decisions about abortion; the annual publication of both ANS and HES data alongside each other would help us all more easily assess the long-term relationship between abortion and complication rates. For those reasons, I emphatically support this very important Bill.
Baroness Barker (LD)
My Lords, I imagine that, like me, many noble Lords went back went back to read our previous debate in Hansard . Had they done so, they would know right away that nobody accused the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, of taking money from anybody at all. He drew that misinterpretation from something we did say, which was that the reason we are back discussing this is that it is part of the tactics of the anti-abortion campaigns that take their lead from America and have been taking funding from America into this country to support their activities. The anti-abortion campaigners really want to get rid of telemedicine. They accuse providers of being shrouded in secrecy, and they exaggerate the data on complications so that, time and time again, we hear this drumbeat of a message that abortion is somehow dangerous for women and that women are being mistreated. On the contrary, I hope all noble Lords have read the excellent Library briefing prepared for this Bill, as it bears out exactly what the noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, told us in great detail. Providers do provide a great deal of information, as much as they possibly can, and the statistics authorities have said the statistics that are produced around abortion meet the compliance standards. I am afraid that the narrative that the noble Lords are building up is a false one. I particularly pick out the comments by the noble Baroness, Lady Maclean, when she drew attention to what is referred to as incomplete remains of abortions. I say to her that that actually does include miscarriages. We need to be extremely careful about the way in which people choose to present statistics. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, drew on one email from one practitioner to cast doubt on the profession. I do not buy that, I am afraid. I would prefer to listen to the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, which, when it was proposed that telemedicine be made permanent, relied on data from 50,000 abortions. The overwhelming proof is that the procedure is safe. It is not only safe; it is better for women, because they have their procedures early, and women from rural areas and disadvantaged areas are much more able to access the care that they need. In particular, women who are being coerced and controlled are the women who really need provision by telemedicine. Noble Lords should think very carefully about that before they set up a system whereby women who have abortions may be trackable, which I think the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, spotted. It is important, as we have already started to discuss in the Health Bill, that women who need these procedures should be able to do so anonymously and that their data should be kept in total confidentiality. Those of us who oppose the Bill are not opposed to better data. I will also say to the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that the DHSC has explained why the 2024 data has been delayed. It said that the “publication is delayed due to several operational issues. These include several technical challenges that have significantly reduced our ability to process paper HSA4 notifications … This coincided with an increase in the overall number of abortion notifications”. Together, those factors created a backlog, but the department said it is working to make sure it gets better and more timely data. Rather than denigrating the people who work in this field, we really ought to take pride in the fact that we produce some of the best statistics in the world on a very difficult subject. I hope that we will stand back from this debate and that we will, in the future, not have an annual debate designed solely to undermine abortion services in this country.
Lord Kamall (Con)
My Lords, before I start, I must ask myself why I volunteer to come in on Fridays. The last time I was in on a Friday, it was the assisted dying Bill, and now we have an abortion Bill. I should be more careful before volunteering to do Front-Bench duty. I thank my noble friend Lord Moylan for setting out the case for the Bill and all noble Lords, whatever their views, who spoke in this debate. As someone who studied engineering and maths and later worked with econometricians, noble Lords may realise that I am slightly geeky about the need for reliable data and statistics; in fact, the noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, has often pointed that out to me. Noble Lords will be aware that I often question the Minister on what data is collected in order to make better decisions and improve the standard of health and social care. The Bill itself calls for the publication of an annual report on complications from abortions. We have heard it said that, where possible, hospital episode statistics and abortion notification system complication rates should be collected, alongside those for incomplete abortions, in order to improve patient safety. As my noble friend Lord Moylan said, Parliament expressed its will that such data be reported confidentially and securely to the Chief Medical Officer, under Section 2 of the Abortion Act 1967, which gives effect to the Abortion Regulations 1991 that require doctors carrying out abortions to notify the relevant person of any complications that occurred during the course of an abortion. The law is therefore already clear that data relating to complications as a result of abortions should be collected and reported to the Minister for Health or the Chief Medical Officer. However, as many noble Lords have pointed out, since 1967, due to medical advances, the method of abortion has changed, with medical abortions typically using mifepristone or misoprostol accounting for 87% of abortions. In fact, 72% of all abortions now occur at home. The statistics have not necessarily kept up with these medical advances. That is a pity because, as in other parts of healthcare, it is important—I think all noble Lords agree—to collect accurate data to understand the reasons for complications from abortions in order to make them safer for women who have medical abortions. The safety rate may well be very high but, where there are complications, we should be trying to make those figures even higher. If some of the complications are, for example, due to medication being taken at the wrong time, we would hope that such data would put pressure on the big pharma companies that produce these pills to improve patient awareness in order to increase their safety. Where there are complications, we should not allow the big pharma companies to hide behind the larger debate on abortion. I have also heard concerns that this Bill would somehow exceptionalise abortion. I understand the concern, but patient safety should be our primary concern. In this House, we regularly debate particular problems that require attention, quite often on a Friday in relation to Private Members’ Bills. When we debate Private Members’ Bills, we are inevitably focused on narrow areas of policy, since we have only limited time to debate them. Let us take the Corporate Waste Responsibility Bill, which was debated earlier: it focused on fly-tipping, but I do not think anyone would criticise the noble Baroness, Lady Sheehan, for exceptionalising that issue. I really see the question as whether the Minister’s department collects and publishes information on which clinicians, patients and the public can properly rely. It would be a pity if data collection is characterised as exceptionalising abortion rather than seeking to improve patient safety. Having said all that, like other noble Lords, I have to ask whether primary legislation is the most appropriate means of achieving better statistics. Indeed, my noble friend Lord Moylan told your Lordships in 2024, and again today, that the Government could deliver improved reporting on this topic without legislation. Noble Lords have also referred to the fact that the DHSC has explained the reasons for the delay in the statistics. Can the Minister explain what practical steps the Government are taking to collect accurate data on complications from abortions, as my noble friend Lady Sugg asked, and whether that is through the proposed single patient record? It if is, how will that respect patient privacy and confidentiality? These are issues that I know we will discuss next week when debating the single patient record under the Health Bill. There is a concern within that Bill about the duty of confidentiality in new Section 250E(3), inserted by Clause 52, which in effect proposes the removal of the common-law duty of confidentiality. We will have to come back to this in the Health Bill debate. What conversations are the department having with big pharma companies producing medical abortion pills to improve patient safety overall, so that feedback gets back to them and they can understand where there are complications, however small they might be, so that we can get even higher safety statistics than we already have and many noble Lords are proud of? I look forward to the Minister’s response. I also hope that it is enough to persuade my noble friend Lord Moylan that perhaps the primary legislation is not needed and that the Government are working towards the goal that he seeks.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Department of Health and Social Care (Baroness Merron) (Lab)
My Lords, I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for his clear introduction of the points he seeks to pursue in this Bill. I am also grateful to noble Lords who have contributed to this debate, which follows on from one we had a few years ago, as noble Lords have referenced by way of Hansard . I will address the points that are for the Government. Parliament has determined the legal framework in respect of abortion, and the role of the Government is to ensure access to safe, legal abortion services within that framework. Of course, Parliament decides the circumstances in which abortion should be available. Any changes to the law—the noble Lord, Lord Weir of Ballyholme, spoke to this when he talked about debate and ranges of opinion—are rightly a matter for parliamentarians to decide. Abortion is an issue on which the Government adopt a neutral stance as a matter of conscience. The Government have expressed reservations about the Bill because, as the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, correctly predicted, as we agree with the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, and other noble Lords that legislation is not necessary to provide for the publication of an annual report. The aims of this Bill could be achieved through existing mechanisms, and there is no need for new legislation. Indeed, in 2023 the department published a report on abortion complications and retains the ability to publish further reports when appropriate. We do not currently plan to publish separate annual reports on abortion complications, as there is no operational requirement to do so. I am sure noble Lords will understand that all of us should avoid legislating where reasonable and effective alternative mechanisms are already available, as in this case. The department publishes annual abortion statistics in a report that includes complications by procedure and gestation, as routinely recorded by the abortion notification system. According to 2023 data, complications were reported in 1.1 per 1,000 abortions in 2023. Abortion notifications submitted to the Chief Medical Officer record known complications until the time—I want to emphasise this in view of the debate—of the patient’s discharge from the abortion service. It is recognised that complications can occur after discharge, so they may not always be recorded on these notifications. That reflects the reality of the situation, and no amount of demanding that it is otherwise will be able to address that. Complications are also recorded in other patient record systems, such as hospital episode statistics, which have been referred to today, where a woman has been admitted as an in-patient. My noble friend Lady Thornhill and the noble Baronesses, Lady Sugg, Lady Brinton and Lady Bennett, spoke to this point and rightly emphasised the need for confidentiality to protect the safety and well-being of women, as is the case in respect of sexual health services. As noble Lords know, I am extremely enthusiastic about the single patient record improving care for patients, and we will be debating that next week; I should remind noble Lords that abortion data will not be included in the single patient record. In 2023, the Government published a comparison between the abortion notification system and hospital episode statistics data on abortion complications in England from 2017 to 2021. On the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Maclean, about the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities, I believe she said that she had heard reports of OHID not contacting the department. It might be helpful if I clarify that the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities remains part of the department, and it was so during the 2023 report on complications that occur post-discharge. The HSA4 form, which I believe she suggested was not being updated if the complication was post-discharge, is not designed to capture information on complications occurring after discharge from the place of termination. That is simply not its role. Hospital episode statistics and the abortion notification system capture abortion complications differently. In response to the noble Baroness, Lady Lawlor, I would say that each source has different strengths and limitations. We should therefore be careful about making comparisons. Any interpretation should certainly be regarded with caution.
Lord Moylan (Con)
The Minister refers to the OHID report on collecting HES, which was published in 2023. Is she saying, in relation to her earlier remarks, that that report and the work that went into collecting the statistics either resulted in a breach of patient confidentiality or were thought during the course of that collection to be capable of resulting in such a breach, given that the work was based entirely on collecting hospital codes in relation to particular conditions and not personal data?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I was not making any reference to the points that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, has just raised. I was simply clarifying the situation because of the point made by the noble Baroness, Lady Maclean. The noble Baroness, Lady Meyer, talked about how we can judge whether safeguards are working in respect of data and suggested that data shows only part of the picture. I would not interpret it that way. My view, which we have heard from other noble Lords, is that if we were going to routinely link abortion data with wider health records, which we are not going to do, there is no doubt that safety, safeguarding and confidentiality considerations for women would be writ large. We cannot risk distressing women and putting their lives and well-being at risk, and I do not believe anybody in your Lordships’ House would wish to do so. It would also unintentionally disincentivise the most vulnerable women from accessing necessary services, including abortion services. I am sure none of us would wish to be responsible for that. The noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, brought her experience, which was much valued, to the whole area of complications across a range of medical procedures. I was glad that she referred to the decision aids that are issued by NICE, which I felt was helpful. To return to the data on the hospital episode statistics, it shows that in 2021 in England, complications, including those from incomplete abortions, occurred in 19 out of 1,000 abortions—just under 2%. I make that point because there has been debate about the level of complications in this area. This comparison publication is not part of the Government’s routine publications. To re-emphasise what I said the previous time we debated the Bill proposed by the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, the Government have no plans to issue a similar publication annually. The department continues to work with providers and commissioners to ensure that abortions are delivered safely, in accordance with the Abortion Act, and that complications are recorded accurately. It might be helpful if I made some reference to progress made since the last time we debated this issue. The noble Baroness, Lady Sugg, asked what health information is available. We have committed to publishing neighbourhood-level comparable data on service performance, access, outcomes and the experience of women, all through the renewed women’s health strategy, and that will be monitored through the women’s health data dashboard. I have already had it confirmed by other noble Lords that the report for 2023 on annual abortion statistics was published earlier this year, and the report for 2024 will be published on 3 December. The delay is not out of fear, I can say to the noble Lord, Lord Jackson, but for the reasons noble Lords have faithfully quoted me on in parliamentary Questions. I can assure all noble Lords, including the noble Baronesses, Lady Barker, Lady Freeman and Lady Sugg, who referenced this, that the Office for Statistics Regulation’s April 2026 compliance review concluded that abortion statistics for England and Wales continue to meet the code of practice for statistics and should retain their accredited official statistics status. In response to this compliance review, the department published a user engagement plan to ensure that statistics on abortion remain relevant, useful and accessible.
Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)
I accept the point that the Minister raised about being resistant to the idea of an annual report, but to improve data collection, where there is some consensus, does she not concede that OHID noted that there was “no evidence that abortion providers were contacting the DHSC to ensure that the data was updated when a woman informed the provider about a complication that occurred after the form had been sent. It is unlikely that women will typically inform abortion providers when complications emerge”. Is the Minister in a position to give the House an undertaking that the department will remind abortion providers of their obligations with respect to that cohort of women?
Baroness Merron (Lab)
I am not aware that there is a problem with abortion providers, such that we need to remind them.
Baroness Brinton (LD)
The issue is that if people who have gone home then go back and report things to the ANS but have been in A&E, it gets double-counted. That is why, once they have left the clinic, the data stops at that point and it becomes hospital data, if that is needed. Otherwise, it is not a complication that is serious enough, as I understand it.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
The noble Baroness is indeed correct. I am not sure what the noble Lord was reading from, but if he wishes me to take a look at it, of course I will do.
Lord Jackson of Peterborough (Con)
I made reference to the November 2023 report.
Baroness Merron (Lab)
Yes; my interpretation is clearly somewhat different from the noble Lord’s. I finish by saying that work is continuing to clear the backlog, which we know is the case, and to catch up on the publication of the annual abortion statistics reports. Dates for the publication of the 2025 and 2026 annual official abortion statistics will be announced in due course. On the point that the noble Lord, Lord Kamall, made about communication and contact with pharma companies, I would be pleased to write to him further on that.
Lord Moylan (Con)
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in the debate, the great majority of whom engaged to some extent with the Bill. I will go through a few comments that were made. The noble Baronesses, Lady Thornton and Lady Sugg, and others, raised the question of abortion being exceptionalised by the Bill. I refute that. It is the case that abortion is treated exceptionally because of the 1967 Act. I do not know what was in the minds of parliamentarians in 1967 when they put the requirement for mandatory reporting in a statute—something that exists, I agree, but does not exist for other medical procedures—but they did so, and I am simply taking that for granted. Nobody has suggested removing it. It is perfectly legitimate to suggest removing it, but you need a different Private Member’s Bill. It is not one that arises in relation to today. The noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, also said it was difficult to collect the statistics to which I am referring. It is more difficult to collect them than it might be if they were reported directly. The OHID had to go into hospitals to get the data, but data is already available, as the Minister said. It is recorded in hospital episode statistics by code—the NHS has a code for nearly every procedure it carries out. It would be less difficult to collect it if hospitals were simply required to report it on a routine basis. It would then be held centrally and could be gathered. It is not a difficult thing to do. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, misunderstood me in one respect. I said I thought that the HSA4 form is required for every termination, not only in the case of complications, so she is right about that. We are in strong agreement on the matter. As far as data is concerned, I did not say that 1.8%, or 2% if you prefer to round it up, was a high figure. I simply said that it is a great deal higher—about 10 times higher—than the figure routinely reported, with great complacency, by the department, which is extremely misleading. The Minister deflected the point about confidentiality. There is no suggestion that, in carrying out its work in 2023, the OHID either had access to individual personal records or that there was a risk of breach of confidentiality, or that one occurred. There are many interesting questions in the debates on the Health Bill concerning the single patient record that may well relate to confidentiality. None of them is relevant to what is being discussed here. Confidentiality is not an issue, and it is not at risk. The noble Baroness, Lady Freeman of Steventon, brought great expertise to this, but the conclusion of her argument arose in the assertion that “a lot of care is taken over abortion … statistics”. In my speech, I said that I am confident that abortion providers do return HSA4 forms and, except for the recent collapse and catastrophe over the last couple of years, statistics have until 2023 been published accurately. The fact is that they capture only about 1/10th of the incidents that they are meant to capture. It seems to me the noble Baroness brings a certain level of complacency to this. To say that they are being carefully collected when they are not even aimed at collecting incidents that take place outside the abortion notification system seems to me either complacent or misleading.
Baroness Freeman of Steventon (CB)
May I come back to the noble Lord?
Lord Moylan (Con)
I would like the noble Baroness to. Yes, please—I am hoping she will.
Baroness Freeman of Steventon (CB)
The fact that the other data is collected in hospital episode statistics shows that it is being collected. I think the noble Lord is concerned that they are not being reported together, in one year, in the way that they once were in the past, but it is not that we do not have that data. It is being carefully collected in hospital episode statistics, as he says, and coded correctly, as well as in the abortion clinic reports. My point was that this data is well collected and it is possible to collate it. These are not issues for a report to Parliament.
Lord Moylan (Con)
Of course, we are all agreed that it is collected. The point I am making, and the point of this whole Bill, is that it is not collated. It is not brought together. It is in hospital records that are never looked at by the department. I would hope that the noble Baroness, as someone interested in medical statistics, would be on my side about this. The data is there, and it is left there. If that is what she meant when she referred to careful collection, that might be strictly accurate, but if you never look at the data, the careful collection is of no relevance whatever. I will not dwell on very much of what the noble Baroness, Lady Barker, said, but she talked about telemedicine. I said nothing against telemedicine, as it happens, but I ask her to consider that the growth of telemedicine, which she welcomes, to the point where it constitutes 87% of terminations, means that the way in which we gather statistics might need to change to capture that development. Is she not open to agreeing that? No, she wants to carry on with a system that was designed in 1967—what changed in 1991 was that, in essence, a paper form was no longer required. It goes back to 1967 and was designed to suit the medical circumstances of 1967, which, as she says, no longer apply. I will give way.
Baroness Barker (LD)
I have not said that I believe that there should not be any change in the recording of statistics; I said that I do not agree with the noble Lord’s Bill. I think all of us who have witnessed and worked for the transformation in abortion services are absolutely open to there being changes in reporting, but they need to be appropriate and carefully worked out, not only with providers but with women who go through the process, to make sure that they are not collected in such a way that they achieve a different aim, which is to deter people from having the service in the first place.
Lord Moylan (Con)
That work has been done, sensitively and accurately, by the Office for Health Improvement and Disparities. Why should it not be available publicly going forward? Why is the noble Baroness so opposed to those figures being published when they are perfectly capable of being collected? Finally, I turn to the Minister, for whom I have the highest personal and professional regard. I thought she was slightly all over the place this time. She did not answer my questions about when we can expect the 2025 figures. We are two years late already. I believe she did not confirm that the 2024 figures were coming out in December, although I asked her to. Are they or not? When are we going to get the 2025 figures? They are behind as well. We look forward to reading the 2024 figures, if they are coming out. The crucial thing is that the Minister acknowledged, as the noble Baroness, Lady Freeman, has done, that the figures that we need, which are 20 times higher than the ones she publishes, are recorded. They are in the hospitals. She cannot and did not explain coherently why they should not be regularly published along with the other statistics which she intends, I assume, to continue publishing regularly. Finally, I come back to the question of whether legislation is necessary. Of course it is not necessary—I said in my speech that it is not necessary—but it is necessary as long as the Government fail to do what they ought to be doing, which is to publish the statistics that women and their clinicians want and need in order to make an informed choice.
Bill read a second time and committed to a Committee of the Whole House.
House adjourned at 2.50 pm.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441639.