Contribution
My Lords, it is my pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, who has laid out the arguments against the need for this Bill very clearly. I thank those who have briefed us, including the Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists, BPAS and the Library. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for his extensive explanation; I am afraid that he has not convinced me, but that may not surprise him.
I will focus on data. Regulations issued under the Abortion Act require specifically that a woman’s name and date of birth, or a personal identifier, be submitted on every abortion provided—not just on complications, as the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, implied earlier—to the Chief Medical Officer via the abortion notification system. It is important to note that NHS numbers are not required. That is important partly because, as has been outlined, some of the data on complications is collected before the patient is discharged from the clinic. That data, as we know, is managed by the Department of Health and Social Care. The second set of data, on hospital episode statistics, details activity that happens afterwards. The noble Lord referred to a woman at home having complications and ending up in A&E—that is a reassuring aspect of the data, because it does end up in the system; it may not be linked to the first dataset, but there is a reason for that.
The noble Lord cited some statistics. He said that 18 per 1,000 was a very high percentage of complications; in fact, that is 1.8%. It is very similar to the US figures for abortions up to 24 weeks: complications account for 2.1%, with major complications accounting for only 0.3%. The results for complications are much lower than could be implied by hearing about the data cited by the noble Lord. Our concerns remain that there is a narrative about significant levels of complications, when in fact that is not the case. I hope the noble Lord will accept that it is reassuring that our data matches that of America.
As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, said, the 10-year plan will produce a single patient record, but we need to remember why abortion and sexual health data is kept separate from other data: to protect women, especially those experiencing domestic abuse or honour-based abuse, and those under 16. A further reason for not linking abortion and hospital data is that, unfortunately, some people are behaving very badly inside the system at the moment. The Independent said two days ago:
“NHS hospital and ambulance trusts in England have recorded over 3,000 cases of staff improperly accessing patient information in recent years”.
The data comes amid increasingly high numbers of high-profile privacy breaches by health service workers, including, as we know, dozens who have viewed the medical records of victims after the attacks of Southport and Nottingham. Whether data is viewed for ghoulish gratification or even for campaigning reasons, all patients must be protected.
Last year, I spoke about some of the behaviour of authorities in the US that have banned abortions completely. Police in one area were demanding that foetal remains, after an early miscarriage, always be taken to hospital for investigation. This was overreach by the relevant authorities and has now been stopped, but that overreach continues in different areas in different ways.
One complication of pregnancy that in the UK would always end in an abortion is ectopic pregnancy. The NHS website says:
“Unfortunately, it’s not possible to save the pregnancy. It usually has to be removed using medicine or an operation”.
Why do I raise this issue? ProPublica, a newsroom organisation that investigates abuses of power, has just published a detailed report into the doubling of maternal deaths as a result of ectopic pregnancies since the 18 states banned abortion completely, specifically excluding the removal of an ectopic pregnancy. One appalled doctor said:
“A death related to ectopic pregnancy should really be a never event”.
Worse than that, anti-abortion activists and organisations are now posting online that a foetus can survive an ectopic pregnancy and that doctors who carry out the operation to remove the fallopian tube and the embryo to save the life of both mother and baby should not do so. Why do I raise this? The noble Lord’s Bill appears to be trying to make women who have abortions trackable. We have perfectly good systems in place to prevent this. Frankly, the UK is good at collecting data on complications. That should be enough.