B

Baroness Thornton (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I first thank the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, for the clear explanation of his Bill. Of course, it is not the first time we have heard the noble Lord’s exposition, and he has undertaken it with great detail and great research, even if I disagree with him from time to time. I do not disagree with the noble Lord in the comment he made about the change that there has been in the availability of abortion, particularly with the at-home pill and tele-abortion, and all to the better for women and their health. I thank the Library, BPAS and others for their briefing on the Bill. The noble Lord will not be surprised that I remain unconvinced by his speech—now as then—and of either the desirability or the necessity of this Private Member’s Bill. I agree with BPAS and feel quite strongly that it is not desirable, in principle, because the creation of a law to require the reporting of complications in this way exceptionalises abortion and fails to treat it like other forms of healthcare, where reporting on NHS statistics is there. There is a danger of stigmatising both clinicians and women. I have to say that despite what the noble Lord has said, my suspicion is that this might be part of the motivation for those who are supporting the Bill. My noble friend the Minister said in December 2024, when the House last considered the Bill, that it is “a very safe procedure in which major complications are rare at all gestations”. My noble friend went on to say: “The aims of the Bill can be achieved through existing routes … and further legislation is unnecessary”. Specifically addressing the issue of producing an annual report on complications, my noble friend said of the 2023 publication that the Labour Government had “no plans to issue a similar” annual “publication”.—[Official Report, 13/12/24; col. 1992.] So, the noble Lord knows that the Minister told us two years ago that our Government were not going to do that. I know my Government are very keen on accurate data and data collection driving policy. We are committed to the single patient record, for example, which itself presents sexual health issues, such as confidentiality for women, which we will be discussing during the passage of the Health Bill, currently before your Lordships’ House. But as my noble friend said in 2024: “We are not complacent; we are always seeking to improve”.—[Official Report, 13/12/24; col. 1993.] So I am confident that the Minister will report the situation as it is today. At the moment, it would be very difficult, if not impossible, to collect the statistics as outlined by the noble Lord. Everyone agrees with the noble Lord, including me, that further work is needed on collection and analysis of datasets; of course it is. But it would surely be better—and this is about the exceptionalism of this Private Member’s Bill—for it to be dealt with through the NHS 10-year plan and designed in a way that preserves the confidentiality and proper analysis of the relevant data. Regulations produced from the Abortion Act 1967 included complications as one of the earliest ways of collecting national data to improve patient care, because that is the point of collecting data. But the health service as a whole has moved on since the 1960s. Today, the recording, analysis and reporting of data is the norm, and this legislation is not necessary to achieve that.

More from Baroness Thornton (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.