B

Baroness Freeman of Steventon (CB)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, until recently, I worked on producing decision aid information to help support patients to make medical decisions, which required researching and then presenting outcome statistics. This meant that I spent a lot of time trying to find data on side-effects and complications, as well as positive outcomes. My team spoke with probably 1,000 patients over several years to find out what they wanted to know and what outcomes were significant to them across many different conditions and procedures. Health data is perhaps surprisingly difficult to wrangle and interpret. Many of the commonest procedures, such as cataract removal and hip or knee replacements, are, like abortions, not usually done within the NHS. Yet, from the perspective of a researcher like me, the statistics on complications from abortion are of comparatively good quality. It is common to have to collate data from many different sources. I will give one example of finding statistics for other procedures. In England, around 60,000 people per year undergo a cholecystectomy—a treatment for gallstones. We found that the clinical trial data, Cochrane reviews and NICE guidance all failed to record that 10% of patients suffer new onset diarrhoea as a result of the surgery—the second biggest risk after ongoing pain. This had been studied and reported in separate literature, but not collated with the other side-effects. There are so many examples of complications data not being carefully collected and collated, yet, comparatively, a lot of care is taken over abortion outcome statistics. It could be improved, but so could all outcome statistics. Over the years of trying to produce information to help patients choose between different options, I have found that often other people want to use that information to persuade them. Even medical professionals can express concern about giving patients information. When asked to give a reason, they say things such as, “We don’t want to encourage women to have elective caesareans” or, “We don’t want to put people off having surgery”. It can be difficult for medical professionals, as well as many others, to accept that every individual has the right to make their own health choices within the law, even if they are choices that they disagree with. The noble Lord, Lord Moylan, says that the report mandated by the Bill is needed for clinicians and patients to be able to give informed consent and make decisions based on the correct information. I would argue that the way to provide information for clinicians and patients is in the form of a decision aid or well-designed consent forms developed in close consultation with clinicians and patients, not a report to Parliament. Indeed, NICE has produced decision aids for medical versus surgical abortion for different gestation periods. These could be improved, but there is no need for any report to Parliament to do that. I note that, should the noble Lord instead want to persuade people, using complication statistics would be unlikely to achieve that aim. Having spoken with a lot of patients, I can say that the numbers are very rarely that important in their decision-making, especially not when the complication rates are as low as they are for abortion. Should the noble Lord wish to persuade policymakers to change the law on abortion, I point out how low these complication rates are compared with so many other common procedures. To give an example, the proportion of people who come out of cataract surgery with eyesight worse than before is around 20 out of 1,000. Around 50 out of 1,000 have a complication. For those having a hip replacement, it is quite similar: around 30 out of 1,000 come out of surgery with their hip worse as a result, and roughly 50 out of 1,000 have a complication. The rate of complications for abortion that we have heard of is less than three in 1,000—less than 20 in 1,000 even if you include the broadest categories of complications that the noble Lord mentioned. I do not think the statistics are any less certain for abortion than for cataracts or for hip and knee replacements. The statistics on abortion complications are not perfect, but they are better than many other medical statistics, and a report to Parliament will not improve them. Moreover, whichever way you look at them, they show relatively low rates of complications, and this information is already available to clinicians, patients and policymakers. Therefore, I oppose the Bill.

More from Baroness Freeman of Steventon (CB)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.