Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, who, as many of the other speakers have, outlined many of the difficulties that parents and guardians face in trying to get quick remedies when their children face problems. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for securing this important short debate and for her moving opening speech. It feels as though legislation and policing are always catching up with the latest innovations that put our children in harm’s way online, with parents and guardians really struggling to get the response that they need swiftly.
All speakers raised the use of smartphones by children and young people and the difficulties that parents face when making complaints. From these Lib Dem Benches, I reaffirm that tech companies have for far too long treated them as data to be mined and not as children and young people requiring protection, from both unintended consequence and, more worryingly, deliberate attempts by bad actors to cause them harm online. Earlier this week, Oregon sued OpenAI for $2 billion because it believed that ChatGPT put kids in harm’s way.
Tech companies have continued to let harmful content roam free, including the perpetuation of negative body image and amplification of extreme and violent content. Their algorithms continue to be addictive to adults as well as children. But for children who are constantly doomscrolling, academic studies show that when schools insist on a no-phones policy, their academic work improves. On Tuesday, the Guardian reported a US study that showed a modest but consistent academic gain in results in those schools. I hope that UK parents will find that encouraging for our impending ban for under-16s.
I will highlight another damage to children: those who are abused to make clips to put online. I thank the Internet Watch Foundation, the first-ever such organisation, founded in September 1996—30 years ago—by Cambridge entrepreneur Peter Dawe, who even then, way ahead of others, was concerned about the damage that the internet could do. I knew Peter back in the 1990s and I visited the IWF a couple of times. That organisation, and especially its extraordinary staff, have led the world in how to tackle and bring down sites hosting images of child sexual abuse. The work is hard: watching obscene rape and children being encouraged to self-harm or commit suicide—this is being inflicted on other children every day—and getting sites pulled down, as well as reporting cases to the police, wherever they are being made or circulated globally.
As we know, because of tech and AI advances, today’s internet is even harder to police. That is why, from our Benches, we continue to have concerns about Ofcom’s ability to enforce the regimes it oversees through the Online Safety Act and the Broadcasting Code, which must give us cause for concern and explains why parents are finding things hard. Will the Government take these concerns seriously and assess options to increase Ofcom’s effectiveness? This includes splitting Ofcom into two regulators: one regulating online and broadcast content, the other regulating the communications infrastructure. It is clear that when platforms facilitate the creation or circulation of illegal material, Ofcom must use all its power to stop that material spreading and immediately issue a business disruption order to shut down the platform.
Under the Online Safety Act, Ofcom has the power to impose financial penalties of up to £18 million or 10% of global turnover. However, although Ofcom publishes press releases announcing headline fines against non-compliant platforms, it does not publish the data showing how many of these fines are actually collected. I ask the Government to require Ofcom to publish this data to assess the effectiveness of its enforcement powers. If it is good, that should help to give parents confidence.
From these Benches, we are concerned that Ofcom’s latest report shows that during the first nine months of the Online Safety Act there has been no significant change in the frequency or severity of harmful content encountered by children. This is a sobering reality that my colleagues in both Houses have warned about, which is why we called for a parliamentary review of the Act within the first six months of its implementation.
Will the Government also urgently consider implementing film-style age ratings on harmful social media platforms to protect children online? Liberal Democrats have also been calling for the creation of a new online crime agency to effectively tackle illegal content and activity online. The National Crime Agency is already overloaded. I hope that the Government will look at this urgently.
I commend the Government for the steps that they have recently taken, including the fact sheet for parents: New Rules to Protect Children Online. However, I note that paragraph 2 states:
“High-risk features including livestreaming and strangers being able to contact children will also be restricted for under 16s on other online services like gaming. This will be backed up by stronger requirements for age checks on platforms”.
Can the Minister confirm that social media giants cannot harvest children’s data to feed them addictive, algorithmically generated content that can drive inappropriate adults towards children, as outlined earlier by the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron? I ask simply because this issue is not mentioned clearly in the fact sheet.
Research by the Digital Futures for Children centre shows that Meta, Google, TikTok and Snapchat have cut the rollout of new online safety protections by nearly 40% over the last two years, with default protections declining by 59% and a greater reliance on opt-in tools that shift responsibility on to users and parents. That is why the umbrella group of charities and NGOs, including the NSPCC, the Online Safety Network and Plan International, have repeatedly raised the important point that the threats to children online cannot be left to parents and unenforceable guidance.
Platforms seem to respond only to the most serious actions—in the case of Oregon, suing them; in the case of the EU and many states in the EU, creating clear, front-line legislation that will protect children from these severe online harms. When will this Government follow? Above all, without the appropriate safeguards in place at a governmental level, tech companies will continue with slow and feeble responses.