Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for the outstanding work that she has done in this area. The noble Baroness put her name to the cross-party amendment to restrict social media access for under-16s. She most effectively made the case for it and continues rightly to press for safer platform design. Millions of parents around the country will be thanking her, the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and my noble friends Lady Barran and Lord Nash for their supreme efforts in getting this done.
His Majesty’s loyal Opposition are of course concerned by the harm that children face online, which is why in 2023 we introduced the Online Safety Act. Protecting children was a key aim within that Act, but it is clear that technology is moving at a blistering pace and we must always look to do more to keep children safe. We need a restriction of social media for those under 16. The medical evidence is clear, public opinion is clear and your Lordships’ House was crystal clear, but the key question remains: why is this taking so long? Will the Minister help us understand why his Government are not acting at pace on a critical issue to remove the need for legal remedies, given that prevention is better than cure?
Logically, if a child spends less time online, it follows that they are less likely to encounter harm. Is it not important that the Government, alongside the implementation of the social media ban for under-16s, continue to listen to irrefutable evidence from experts around the world and encourage children to use phones and tablets less and reduce their online presence?
This is relevant at both home and school. The noble Baroness, Lady Berger, recounted some horrific examples. We are now learning that school laptops are being used to expose children to online harms. A schoolboy used a messaging app that he could access on his school laptop to have conversations about guns and school shootings, and the school was forced to contact Prevent. There have been instances of attempted grooming via school-issued laptops. It is clear that such devices continue to have the potential to be gateways to dangerous content. It is important to clarify that technology can be a force for good—that is not in doubt—but the question remains: at what point should this technology be unleashed in the classroom with limited surveillance? What measures will the Government put in place to counter those clear and present dangers?
When we ask children to read and understand a factual text, there is a good reason to keep printed textbooks in the classroom. The research finds a small but consistent advantage for paper over tablets, so it is not always the case that technology is better.
I will continue with the theme that prevention is better than cure, which the Online Safety Minister, Ian Murray, referenced in the other place this month. Health professionals around the world are urging the removal of screens from early years education, keeping them to a minimum in primary schools and setting two-hour daily limits in secondary schools. This is not about banning screens altogether, but, given the access to harmful content and the health risks that devices pose, it seems clear that they should no longer be the default.
I end with a request to the noble Lord, Lord Hanson. We might not have even been having this debate if successive Governments had had the foresight to see what the dangers of devices to children might be—but that is hindsight, and it would have been extremely difficult to predict.
We now have an opportunity to at least perhaps reduce the harm that children can face online by strongly supporting the new guidance issued on 10 November by Lucy Powell, which points to lockable pouches, handing phones in at the start of the day, secure storage or not allowing them on site. In Cheshire and the Thames Valley, two police and crime commissioners have taken money recovered from crime and put it to work in schools, helping keep pupils’ phones out of reach during the school day. Will the Minister please ask his department to look at how this was done and, with the department’s support, consider a national rollout? If children’s time on devices is limited, surely their exposure to online harm and criminality can only be reduced.