T

The Minister of State, Home Office (Lord Hanson of Flint) (Lab)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Online Harm: Legal Remedies

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lady Berger for securing this debate. A range of noble Lords who have considerable interest and expertise in these matters have spoken today, and I am grateful for the opportunity to address these issues. I should say to the House that I am a Home Office Minister, but I am addressing this debate on behalf of the Ministry of Justice and DCMS in particular. I will try to respond to all points and will certainly raise them with the relevant Secretaries of State. I want to cut straight to the vital point which my noble friend has quite rightly raised: what a parent can do and who they can turn to when their child is in immediate danger. As part of my response today, I will touch on specific legal remedies, but I also want to make it clear to my noble friend that, when that type of incident has occurred, families do not need to wait for initial proceedings through legal response before reporting concerns about a child’s immediate safety. The police and safeguarding agencies can and should take action swiftly where necessary. I have heard my noble friend raise some concerns around that issue, but it is important that we at least have that as the first port of call. A number of noble Lords and noble Baronesses raised important questions about redress and the transparency of how these systems operate. I will address those points first. I recognise the importance of ensuring that users have meaningful routes to redress. The Online Safety Act requires Ofcom to review the effectiveness of the reporting and complaints framework, and provides a power to introduce independent alternative dispute resolutions for category 1 services where necessary. My noble friend Lord Stevenson, the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham, raised the current timeline of Ofcom’s review, which will take place in 2029. The Government recognise the importance of effective routes for users to seek redress. The Online Safety Act gives the Secretary of State powers to require independent alternatives for dispute resolution for category 1 services. I say to all noble Lords who raised this that we do not rule out additional measures for user redress. Ofcom’s review of the existing reporting and complaints framework will be in 2029. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, raised this too. I want to ensure the House knows that we are considering how user redress can be strengthened further and have not ruled out additional measures. However, wider protections are available where a child faces imminent online harm. It is essential that families and guardians know the actions that they can take—which is the central point of my noble friend’s debate—where they can seek help and how they can access appropriate protection. The appropriate response where a child is at risk will depend on circumstances, but I will outline some of the criminal protections available for wider safeguarding arrangements and for action. My noble friend Lady Berger raised a number of potential legal remedies. She will know, but it is worth putting on record again, that the Family Law Act 1996 provides for orders that can prohibit a person contacting or going near someone with whom they are associated or a “relevant child”, within the meaning of the Act. These orders can address online behaviour where it constitutes molestation and prohibit a person contacting or communicating with a child. It is also important that we have the Family Justice Council, which has published best practice and guidance on a range of issues to support the safe, fair and consistent handling of applications. There are also a number of criminal law and protective measures. Noble Lords will know that if a parent or guardian is concerned that contact towards a child may constitute a criminal offence, they can report it to the police, and that where a child is in immediate danger they should contact the police urgently. The law does not differentiate between criminal offences committed on social media or elsewhere. Where something is illegal offline, it is illegal online and there is legislation that could apply. On bullying, for example, depending on the circumstances, the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 would operate. Certain offences will operate under the Public Order Act 1986. There are offences against communications that are grossly offensive or indecent under the Malicious Communications Act 1998 and the Communications Act 2003. The latter encompasses messages that are obscene or messaging. The Online Safety Act, referred to by a number of noble Lords, also introduces the offence of encouraging or assisting self-harm under Section 184. Similarly, regulations are in place in Northern Ireland. Those regulations ensure that the offence can capture conduct involving the intentional encouragement of serious self-harm. The threshold of “serious self-harm” includes encouraging or assisting harmful eating disorder behaviours when engaged in by a person suffering an eating disorder. Section 2 of the Suicide Act 1961 contains an offence of “encouraging or assisting” suicide. Section 15A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 contains an offence of sexual communication with a child. These offences all exist, and the Crown Prosecution Service has published guidance—although, I accept, in a slower time—to assist prosecutors in dealing with them. I come to a key area that was raised by the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, my noble friends Lord Stevenson and Lady Berger, the noble Baronesses, Lady Kidron and Lady Brinton, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham, which is online safety and platform protection. The protection of children from harm cannot and should not depend on families having to respond. I say that to the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, who mentioned compelling and harrowing stories in her contribution. The Online Safety Act places clear legal duties on regulated services to protect children from illegal harm and harmful content, and requires accessible routes for children, parents and others to report harmful content and raise complaints. Ofcom can and does take robust enforcement action where services fail to comply with their duties. For example—I hope this helps the House—Ofcom has taken down 100 sites that contain offensive or disturbing material and has issued fines to the value of £7 million to companies on enforcement action where services have failed to comply with their duties. These arrangements are no substitute for emergency safeguarding action, but they are key issues on which Ofcom can act. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, raised the question of fines, which I hope I have answered, and age verification. Ofcom already has the ability to regulate services through photo ID and data ID. I accept that we need to do more to protect children online. This goes to the heart of the issues raised by the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham. As part of the announcements made by Ofcom, we will put in place a social media ban with stronger protections for 16 and 17 year-olds. We have been asked when we are going to do this. I can say to the House that we intend to lay the first regulations before Parliament by the end of this year, with the restrictions expected to come into force in spring 2027. Under-16s will be banned from livestreaming, and unknown adults will be prevented from contacting children on a wide range of online services, including gaming services. I accept that chatbots are an important issue; that point was made very strongly by the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron. We had that debate when I dealt with them on other Bills, but I and the Government recognise that they are harmful. That is why we are going to bring currently unregulated AI services into the scope of the Online Safety Act’s illegal contact duties, and we are going to ensure that we include image-generating and coding bots. We are also trying to strengthen protection for children, specifically by preventing encounters for sexual conduct for zero to 18 year-olds. We are also looking at having mandatory brakes on the use of that material. If there is an immediate risk to a child’s life, the emergency services remain the first point of contact, but we will keep these matters under serious review. Alongside the legal remedies that I have outlined, a wider range of child safeguarding systems are in place. We have statutory guidance in the form of Working Together to Safeguard Children. There is clear guidance to practitioners to work with parents, carers and others to make a child’s environment safer. We are investing £2.4 billion in the families first partnership programme, which is helping to shift support away from crisis intervention and towards earlier help. It is important that, as noble Lords know, we have the multi-agency child protection teams that bring together social workers, the police, and health and education professionals to look at children’s online experience alongside what is happening in their homes, schools, peer groups or communities. I hope that the House will recognise that a range of measures are ongoing and that the Government keep these issues under review. Ultimately, there is a consensus in the House that children must be properly protected and the risk of harm must be regulated. Families and guardians must be able to access appropriate legal remedies without delay. I hope I have reassured the noble Baroness that those issues are taken seriously by the Government. I have had limited time to respond and I have gone over my 10 minutes. I will read the debate and ensure that all Members’ contributions are referred to the appropriate Secretaries of State. This will continue to be an ongoing discussion to which all Members will continue to contribute. Please rest assured that the Government are committed.

More from The Minister of State, Home Office (Lord Hanson of Flint) (Lab)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.