Hansard·Lords Chamber·Vol. 861

Online Harm: Legal Remedies

Thursday, 19 November 2026

14 contributions7 members

Contributions

  1. Question for Short Debate

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Baroness Berger

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to ensure that families and guardians can access timely legal remedies where children face imminent harm online.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Baroness Berger (Lab)

    My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords taking part this afternoon. I want to begin with a scene that will play out in homes across this country tonight. It is 11 pm. A mother notices the light still on under her 14 year-old’s door. On his phone she finds a stranger threatening to send intimate images of her son to everyone he knows unless he pays up within the hour. She finds a feed telling her daughter how to hide her self-harm, or a chatbot that has spent weeks telling her child it is the only one who truly understands him or her. The mum does what she has been told to do. She reports it to the company on whose platform the harm presented. Back comes an automated response: “No violation found.” What does she do next? This is the question at the heart of this debate. Today, the honest answer is “very little”. She is far from alone. A survey by Internet Matters of 3,000 children and parents found that 71% of children had experienced harm online, yet only around a third reported it. Of those who did, more than one in four heard nothing back at all. Some 82% of parents backed an independent route to complain. Parents are asking for somewhere to turn. Ellen Roome knows that silence better than anyone. In April 2022, her son, Jools Sweeney, died at the age of 14. She wanted to understand what he had seen and done online before his death. The platforms would not help, so she became a campaigner. She gathered 126,000 signatures and brought her campaign to this Parliament. Jools’ law now means that a child’s data is preserved within five days of their death. In July, the High Court ordered a fresh inquest, more than four years on, after evidence Ellen herself uncovered. She is one of five British parents who have had to seek accountability in the courts of another country. Only last week, new duties came into force requiring platforms to explain how bereaved parents can request information about their child. I pay tribute to Ellen and every bereaved parent who has made that happen. I ask noble Lords to notice what these hard-won reforms have in common. Every one of them has begun after a child has died. As Ellen says, data preservation is the first step; access and accountability must follow. My Question today is about what comes before: the hours when a child is in danger and a family is trying to stop the worst. Let me be specific about what imminent harm looks like. I share this story with permission. Murray Dowey was 16 and lived in Dunblane. One evening in December 2023, he was contacted on Instagram by someone posing as a girl his own age. He was tricked into sharing an image and then blackmailed. His mother says he had been talking about going to the football the next day. He took his own life within hours. That is the speed of sextortion: from first message to crisis in a single evening. His parents are now suing Meta in Delaware, because there was nowhere here for them to go. Then there is content that pushes children towards self-harm and suicide. Bereaved families spent months urging action against a pro-suicide forum linked to deaths here in the UK. In July, Ofcom concluded that the forum’s decision to block UK users was the fullest extent of what could be achieved under the Act, and yet young people in the UK were still accessing it. It took a fresh outcry from those families to push it further. If the regulator believes it has reached the limit of its powers, what chance does a terrified parent have? There is a new frontier that we should be very concerned about. As the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, reminded your Lordships’ House earlier this year, where a child is groomed or threatened by a chatbot, the police will not act, “because there is no human perpetrator ”.—[ Official Report , 28/4/26; col. 1075.] Where threats or self-harm fall below the criminal threshold, Ofcom has no role at all. Let us be clear about what a parent or carer can do today. There is no individual right of action. The police will not act until a crime has been committed. Ofcom does not resolve individual complaints. The super-complaints regime cannot be used by individuals or about individual pieces of content. Only Ofcom can apply to a court to restrict a service. When harm is imminent, all a family can do is ask the platform, and hope. Even organised families are turned away. Bereaved Families for Online Safety speaks for 28 parents. At an Ofcom lived-experience meeting, they were told their concerns would need to be raised through a charity or another organisation. If 28 bereaved parents acting together cannot find the door, what realistic hope does a single mother have at 11 pm? A regime that takes children’s safety seriously needs three things. The first is injunctive relief: a fast, court-backed route to require a platform to act when a child faces imminent danger. We know that harm online moves in minutes. Our current remedies move in months, if they move at all. The second is formal standing for parents, guardians and the organisations that act for them, so that families can speak for their own children rather than waiting for others to act. Rather than platforms simply responding with an automated “No violation found”, there should be urgent safeguarding reviews conducted by humans when parents report serious harm involving children. The third is individual redress: an independent body for the family whose complaint to a platform has failed, so that parents can challenge those decisions, wherever possible, before it is too late. Underpinning all three, platforms should prioritise complaints involving children and publish standardised data on response times and outcomes. We know that what goes unmeasured cannot be held to account. That brings me to an ombudsman, which many people before me in this place have argued for—for years—as did the Joint Committee on the Draft Online Safety Bill, in its unanimous report in December 2021. The Government’s reservation has been that individual complaints are complex and time-sensitive. I would gently say that this is precisely the case for a specialist body. The Financial Ombudsman Service has had statutory powers since 2001 and its decisions bind firms. In June, this Government confirmed that they will strengthen the Energy Ombudsman so that it can compel suppliers to pay compensation. If a customer in dispute over a gas bill deserves redress with teeth, a family whose child is in danger and facing harm deserves no less. In Australia, the eSafety Commissioner can order the removal of seriously harmful content targeting a child within 24 hours, and an ombudsman would help to do just that. Yet the Ofcom report on user redress, which could open the door to the establishment of an ombudsman, has been pushed back from 2028 to 2029. That is three more years of families asking the platforms, and hoping. I ask my noble friend the Minister four questions. First, if a parent today finds that their child is in imminent danger online, to whom should they turn and what can that person do? Secondly, will the Government ensure that the statutory review of the Online Safety Act expressly considers injunctive relief, formal standing for families and individual redress? Thirdly, will they bring forward the work considering the creation of an ombudsman, rather than waiting until 2029? Fourthly, will they require platforms to publish how quickly they act on reports of harm involving children? I want us to stop any more children and young people dying from what happens online.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Baroness Kidron (CB)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for her advocacy and powerful words. Nearly six years ago, I brought together a group of bereaved families who would later become the Bereaved Families for Online Safety. One evening, during the passage of the Online Safety Bill, following a meeting with the then Secretary of State, we went to a nearby restaurant, as many of the parents were meeting for the first time. I was gutted when I looked around the table and realised I was the only one present who had not lost a child. It was, as one parent put it, a club that no one wants to be a member of. What those families had in common was not simply that they had lost a child; each of them had tried to raise the alarm. Between them, they had gone to tech companies, the police, the regulator and their children’s schools while their children were still alive. It was only after their children had died that they came to me. Time and again, in matters of online safety, those who identify the harm and know what needs to be done cannot get those with the power to act to do so. It happened with Judy and Andy Thomas, who came to me after their daughter Frankie took her own life following exposure to suicide content on a school tablet. Their attempts to speak to someone at Instagram were repeatedly met with an automated message offering a memorial page, and they could not get a meeting with an Education Minister. I got Instagram to talk to them, and we saw a revolving door of Ministers, but the DfE is only now consulting to create filtering and monitoring standards, eight years after Frankie’s death. It happened, as we have heard, with Ellen Roome, who called for coroner data preservation notices to be made automatic. This House successfully secured preservation powers two years earlier, but they were not being used. Recently, she told me that coroners are still not using the provisions as intended, a fact underlined by a call I had yesterday with a newly bereaved parent. It happened to academics, who discovered that sexual predators were using Google Maps reviews of orphanages and children’s homes to identify and traffic children, but could not get the practice stopped. Incandescent with rage, I raised that issue directly with senior Google executives, and earlier this year they disabled those reviews worldwide. It is happening now with AI chatbots. Earlier this year, I spoke to a parent whose son was being groomed by a chatbot, yet when she reported it to the police, they said they could not act without a human predator. When I phoned Ofcom, I got a letter back the following week that said, “We are not empowered to adjudicate on individual consumer concerns”. I have told Ofcom’s leadership that its response was wholly inadequate in purely human terms, but it is right in the letter of the law: they are not empowered to help individuals. It should not be the unofficial work of an independent Peer to help parents in crisis; it should be a function of the state. While I do my best, help should come from someone who has appropriate legal standing and the resources to act on their behalf, not someone who can only cajole, threaten and plead. Those bereaved parents raised the alarm while there was still time to act, but they found that no one heeded their call. The same is true for teachers, health professionals and even children themselves. This is an emergency. As the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, eloquently set out, parents must have access to a legal remedy, not only after the event but in time to prevent it. At the time of the Online Safety Bill, I advocated for an e-safety commissioner, and this year, during the passage of the Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Bill and the Crime and Policing Bill, I tabled amendments that would have brought forward injunctive relief and a private right of action. The Minister will recall that he responded to one of those amendments by saying that “the intention is understandable, but the amendment raises key practical and legal concerns ”.—[ Official Report , 18/3/26; col. 935.] However, he did not set out what those concerns were, nor have the Government answered the desperate need of those caught in a trap of unresponsive companies and nowhere to go. Australia has an e-safety commissioner, the US has a private right of action, Ireland has both, and Canada is introducing both as we speak. I find it hard to believe that what they can do the UK cannot. In her opening speech, the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, called for companies to publish information about their response to reports of harms to children. In supporting that call, I wish to tell the House a short story. Some years ago, I was asked by activist shareholders to present a motion at Meta’s annual shareholder meeting. The motion was that Meta publish the harms to children in its annual report—not do anything about them but simply publish the harms. Unexpectedly, the motion won the support of a little over 51% of independent shareholder votes, and, for a very short time—a matter of minutes—we were jubilant. However, Mark Zuckerberg’s preferential voting rights mean that he has control of over 60% of the votes, meaning that the wishes of other shareholders can be overridden. Moments later, the vote was washed away. At the time, Meta was in contact with approximately 3.2 billion people across the globe. One man had the ability to determine the rules of engagement for a vast proportion of the world’s population. It is against that concentration of power that we are expecting individual parents to protect their children. An e-safety commissioner would be a permanent presence and a key advocate for citizens at all times. They could keep the regulator on their toes, see early signs of emerging harms, and combine front-line experience with briefing Ministers and officials. They would be a visible figure who is neither reshuffled nor replaced, and whose job is not to juggle the economic interests of the state with the safety and privacy of citizens. That evening, when I had pizza with the bereaved families, they told the Secretary of State that they had sought help while their children were still alive. All these years later, a parent in the same circumstances still has nowhere to turn. This is not a series of tragedies; it is, and has been for many years, a failure of successive Governments, including the present one, to curb the excesses of a sector that has shown cynical disregard for the safety of children. I doubt that the Minister will announce a major policy initiative in response to a QSD, though I hope he will commit to taking the substance of the debate to the Secretary of State. However, in the absence of such an announcement, I challenge the Minister to tell the House what his Government are going to do today, right now, for parents who need somewhere to turn before their child is murdered, groomed, perpetrates an act of violence or commits suicide as a result of online activities. What advice would his Government have us give to the next parent whose child is in imminent danger when they call?

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Lord Stevenson of Balmacara (Lab)

    My Lords, I congratulate my noble friend on securing this debate and her speech, which was excellent, as indeed was the one we have just heard. Taken together, they make the case almost irresistibly for action to be taken this day, and moving forward, in ways that are surely the right things for this Government to take on. We know, as brought out from the figures in the Library report, that the internet has become central to most children’s lives. Some 88% of children aged three to seven, and almost 99% of all children aged eight to 17, go online. This includes playing online games, listening to music and using social media. While children’s engagement with the technologies is central to their social lives, the evidence suggests that they are being exposed to a wide range of harms, including cyber bullying, online sexual harms, sexual exploitation and online radicalisation. The results are completely awful and unacceptable for a society such as ours. The question of how users should be able to complain about online services was debated at length by the Joint Committee on the Online Safety Bill. The unanimous decision, as we have heard, was that there was need for an ombudsman to help individuals, and in particular, children, with complaints and obtaining redress. However, when the Bill reached us from the other place, the wording was far from satisfactory, as it simply asserted that parents and children must be provided with, “clear and accessible ways to report problems online to the service provider”. During Committee and Report stages in the Lords, we put considerable pressure on the Government to strengthen this approach and pushed strongly for an ombudsman service or similar. As we have heard, the Government resisted this approach. There is a case for the argument they were running, although to leave us with nothing was not the right result. In the event, during Report we struck a deal—or thought we had— with the then Government, so that in addition to ensuring that there would be strongly enforceable legal duties placed on Part 3 services to offer accessible, transparent and easy to use complaints procedures, and to provide for appropriate action to be taken in response to complaints, the Act’s provisions in this area would be the subject of a report to be published by Ofcom within two years of commencement, which, by my reckoning must be about now. When he comes to respond to the debate, I would be grateful if my noble friend the Minister could confirm my understanding of the situation, which is as follows. First, Ofcom will shortly be undertaking a report about Part 3 services’ reporting and complaints procedures, assessing the measures in use by providers of Part 3 services to report content and make complaints. Secondly, I hope he will confirm that this Ofcom report will take into account users’ and others’ experiences of those procedures, including how easy they are to use and how clear they are for reporting content and making complaints, as we have heard evidence that they are not working. Thirdly, can my noble friend please confirm that, in this report, Ofcom has a duty to provide advice to the Secretary of State about whether she should use the powers provided in the Act now to make regulations imposing an alternative dispute resolution duty on category 1 services, and that Ofcom may make wider recommendations about how the complaints and user redress provisions can be strengthened, and how users’ experiences with regard to complaints can be improved more broadly? From the arguments already made today by earlier speakers, which are irresistible, I suggest the time has come to introduce the alternative dispute resolution scheme in this area, and to do it quickly. I look forward to hearing from my noble friend.

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Viscount Colville of Culross (CB)

    My Lords, I, too, am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, both for organising this short debate and for her powerful speech. This is a very important debate at a time when the Online Safety Act is being reevaluated. When the legislation was passing through this House, enormous efforts were made by noble Lords, some of whom are present in the Chamber now, to limit children’s exposure to harms. However, as technology moves on, and as gaps are appearing in the tech platforms’ ability to limit children’s exposure to harms, it is becoming clearer that a meaningful complaints mechanism needs to be incorporated into the Act. There needs to be a mandatory framework for users to be able to report complaints, a time limit for platforms to respond to the complaints and an appeals process for users who feel that their complaints have not been dealt with adequately. New research has highlighted the concern of children and their parents about their ability to report harms they encounter on platforms. The most common types of harm relate to contact with strangers, encountering hate and coming across hateful speech. Part of the problem is that 47% of the children who encountered online harm thought that the complaints procedure was unclear, while others said there were too many steps to creating a report. Certainly, a full complaint to Meta can take up to nine clicks, including selecting from 17 categories of illegal content. Meta has said that a simple complaint can be made in only three steps. Nevertheless, pressure should be brought on it and other platforms to ensure that a full and effective complaints procedure is available for all users of all ages. Besides the difficulty of reporting harms, many children say that they do not make reports because they do not know what happens after they report content or interference from other users. This reveals a lack of confidence that platforms will act on reports, and my noble friend Lady Kidron has given us a whole series of awful examples of complaints not being acted on. Users therefore feel that there is no point in following through with their complaint. The research has also shown that children and their parents would like an explanation from the platform about how it made the decision when it responded to the complaint. Obviously, parents play an important role in helping children with their complaints. However, many still want the process to be made easier, including being able to complain on the child’s behalf. As the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, just said, there is currently no mechanism for doing that. The Online Safety Act has a great lacuna in it, which other noble Lords have mentioned. Not only are users worried about reporting to the platforms but there needs to be an ultimate backstop for them to be able to complain directly to Ofcom or to an ombudsman if they feel they have had an unsatisfactory response to their complaint. Noble Lords have already brought attention to the Australian example of the eSafety Commissioner. In Australia, parents and guardians can take individual cases of serious cyber bullying to the eSafety Commissioner. If the material meets the legal threshold and is still online 48 hours after the report, the commissioner can issue a notice for the platform to remove the content. During the debate on the Online Safety Act in this House, noble Lords ensured that, in Section 160, there was a provision for Ofcom to assess how many platforms handle reports and other complaints about the harms users were exposed to online. Once it is commenced, Ofcom has up to two years to report, and the Secretary of State has three months to respond. However, Section 160 is still awaiting commencement. When do the Government plan to put this provision into effect, and when will the Minister respond on plans to set up an independent backstop to ensure that users who feel their complaints are not addressed can report their concerns? This debate is about complaints, but I will also raise a very worrying issue on the possibility of future harms. The Government are making huge progresses in amending the Online Safety Act to stop children being exposed to online harms, and their proposed social media ban could be very beneficial to so many families and children. However, its implementation must be carefully carried out to ensure that it does not create more harm to children. An area of concern for so many campaigners and parents is ensuring that children are not exposed to unmediated livestreaming. Com groups—a collection of bad actors across the internet—move between platforms and continuously avoid detection through their rapid changes of platform. They have been responsible for the most horrific images and videos imaginable, livestreamed to an audience. This includes a sickening suicide, which was livestreamed to users across the world, and there are other instances of victims being encouraged to self-harm, watched by a live audience of all ages across the globe. Many people, both inside and outside Parliament, have campaigned to ensure that this hideous functionality is very heavily regulated and that friction is built into the system. These controls were not in the first children’s code issued by Ofcom in 2025. Campaigners subsequently called for the introduction of these measures to mitigate online harms to children. One proposal was that live streaming for children should require an adult moderator to be present to supervise any livestreaming event. This is an eminently sensible safeguard to keep our children safe. There was hope that the measures would be included in Ofcom’s additional safety measures online, which have been long awaited, but when they were published on Monday, any measures to mitigate live streaming had been dropped. The reasoning was that the planned ban on social media for under-16s would stop all livestreaming to children, so the functionality would not need to be controlled. That might be a sensible decision, as long as the ban on social media will affect 100% of under-16. However, that is not what happened in Australia. When the ban first came into effect, 60% of Australian children were getting around it. Now, the percentage of evaders has risen to 80%. We are told that this huge increase is because Australia does not have an effective age assurance system, so children can easily get around the ban by lying about their age to open an online account. We are told that, in the UK, much more impressive age verification technologies, which have been rolled out across the country, will stop children getting onto social media sites once the ban is introduced. However, it is self-evident that nobody wants to have something they value taken away from them, especially teenagers, for whom social media is the main form of information and social interaction. They will move heaven and earth to get an older friend, older siblings or parents to help them evade the ban. When that happens, they will be exposed to unregulated livestreaming. I call on the Minister not only to limit the harms children are exposed to; we owe it to a generation of young people to protect them as effectively as we can from the horrors of the internet.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Baroness Brinton (LD) [R]

    My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, who, as many of the other speakers have, outlined many of the difficulties that parents and guardians face in trying to get quick remedies when their children face problems. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for securing this important short debate and for her moving opening speech. It feels as though legislation and policing are always catching up with the latest innovations that put our children in harm’s way online, with parents and guardians really struggling to get the response that they need swiftly. All speakers raised the use of smartphones by children and young people and the difficulties that parents face when making complaints. From these Lib Dem Benches, I reaffirm that tech companies have for far too long treated them as data to be mined and not as children and young people requiring protection, from both unintended consequence and, more worryingly, deliberate attempts by bad actors to cause them harm online. Earlier this week, Oregon sued OpenAI for $2 billion because it believed that ChatGPT put kids in harm’s way. Tech companies have continued to let harmful content roam free, including the perpetuation of negative body image and amplification of extreme and violent content. Their algorithms continue to be addictive to adults as well as children. But for children who are constantly doomscrolling, academic studies show that when schools insist on a no-phones policy, their academic work improves. On Tuesday, the Guardian reported a US study that showed a modest but consistent academic gain in results in those schools. I hope that UK parents will find that encouraging for our impending ban for under-16s. I will highlight another damage to children: those who are abused to make clips to put online. I thank the Internet Watch Foundation, the first-ever such organisation, founded in September 1996—30 years ago—by Cambridge entrepreneur Peter Dawe, who even then, way ahead of others, was concerned about the damage that the internet could do. I knew Peter back in the 1990s and I visited the IWF a couple of times. That organisation, and especially its extraordinary staff, have led the world in how to tackle and bring down sites hosting images of child sexual abuse. The work is hard: watching obscene rape and children being encouraged to self-harm or commit suicide—this is being inflicted on other children every day—and getting sites pulled down, as well as reporting cases to the police, wherever they are being made or circulated globally. As we know, because of tech and AI advances, today’s internet is even harder to police. That is why, from our Benches, we continue to have concerns about Ofcom’s ability to enforce the regimes it oversees through the Online Safety Act and the Broadcasting Code, which must give us cause for concern and explains why parents are finding things hard. Will the Government take these concerns seriously and assess options to increase Ofcom’s effectiveness? This includes splitting Ofcom into two regulators: one regulating online and broadcast content, the other regulating the communications infrastructure. It is clear that when platforms facilitate the creation or circulation of illegal material, Ofcom must use all its power to stop that material spreading and immediately issue a business disruption order to shut down the platform. Under the Online Safety Act, Ofcom has the power to impose financial penalties of up to £18 million or 10% of global turnover. However, although Ofcom publishes press releases announcing headline fines against non-compliant platforms, it does not publish the data showing how many of these fines are actually collected. I ask the Government to require Ofcom to publish this data to assess the effectiveness of its enforcement powers. If it is good, that should help to give parents confidence. From these Benches, we are concerned that Ofcom’s latest report shows that during the first nine months of the Online Safety Act there has been no significant change in the frequency or severity of harmful content encountered by children. This is a sobering reality that my colleagues in both Houses have warned about, which is why we called for a parliamentary review of the Act within the first six months of its implementation. Will the Government also urgently consider implementing film-style age ratings on harmful social media platforms to protect children online? Liberal Democrats have also been calling for the creation of a new online crime agency to effectively tackle illegal content and activity online. The National Crime Agency is already overloaded. I hope that the Government will look at this urgently. I commend the Government for the steps that they have recently taken, including the fact sheet for parents: New Rules to Protect Children Online . However, I note that paragraph 2 states: “High-risk features including livestreaming and strangers being able to contact children will also be restricted for under 16s on other online services like gaming. This will be backed up by stronger requirements for age checks on platforms”. Can the Minister confirm that social media giants cannot harvest children’s data to feed them addictive, algorithmically generated content that can drive inappropriate adults towards children, as outlined earlier by the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron? I ask simply because this issue is not mentioned clearly in the fact sheet. Research by the Digital Futures for Children centre shows that Meta, Google, TikTok and Snapchat have cut the rollout of new online safety protections by nearly 40% over the last two years, with default protections declining by 59% and a greater reliance on opt-in tools that shift responsibility on to users and parents. That is why the umbrella group of charities and NGOs, including the NSPCC, the Online Safety Network and Plan International, have repeatedly raised the important point that the threats to children online cannot be left to parents and unenforceable guidance. Platforms seem to respond only to the most serious actions—in the case of Oregon, suing them; in the case of the EU and many states in the EU, creating clear, front-line legislation that will protect children from these severe online harms. When will this Government follow? Above all, without the appropriate safeguards in place at a governmental level, tech companies will continue with slow and feeble responses.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. The Earl of Effingham (Con)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Berger, for the outstanding work that she has done in this area. The noble Baroness put her name to the cross-party amendment to restrict social media access for under-16s. She most effectively made the case for it and continues rightly to press for safer platform design. Millions of parents around the country will be thanking her, the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and my noble friends Lady Barran and Lord Nash for their supreme efforts in getting this done. His Majesty’s loyal Opposition are of course concerned by the harm that children face online, which is why in 2023 we introduced the Online Safety Act. Protecting children was a key aim within that Act, but it is clear that technology is moving at a blistering pace and we must always look to do more to keep children safe. We need a restriction of social media for those under 16. The medical evidence is clear, public opinion is clear and your Lordships’ House was crystal clear, but the key question remains: why is this taking so long? Will the Minister help us understand why his Government are not acting at pace on a critical issue to remove the need for legal remedies, given that prevention is better than cure? Logically, if a child spends less time online, it follows that they are less likely to encounter harm. Is it not important that the Government, alongside the implementation of the social media ban for under-16s, continue to listen to irrefutable evidence from experts around the world and encourage children to use phones and tablets less and reduce their online presence? This is relevant at both home and school. The noble Baroness, Lady Berger, recounted some horrific examples. We are now learning that school laptops are being used to expose children to online harms. A schoolboy used a messaging app that he could access on his school laptop to have conversations about guns and school shootings, and the school was forced to contact Prevent. There have been instances of attempted grooming via school-issued laptops. It is clear that such devices continue to have the potential to be gateways to dangerous content. It is important to clarify that technology can be a force for good—that is not in doubt—but the question remains: at what point should this technology be unleashed in the classroom with limited surveillance? What measures will the Government put in place to counter those clear and present dangers? When we ask children to read and understand a factual text, there is a good reason to keep printed textbooks in the classroom. The research finds a small but consistent advantage for paper over tablets, so it is not always the case that technology is better. I will continue with the theme that prevention is better than cure, which the Online Safety Minister, Ian Murray, referenced in the other place this month. Health professionals around the world are urging the removal of screens from early years education, keeping them to a minimum in primary schools and setting two-hour daily limits in secondary schools. This is not about banning screens altogether, but, given the access to harmful content and the health risks that devices pose, it seems clear that they should no longer be the default. I end with a request to the noble Lord, Lord Hanson. We might not have even been having this debate if successive Governments had had the foresight to see what the dangers of devices to children might be—but that is hindsight, and it would have been extremely difficult to predict. We now have an opportunity to at least perhaps reduce the harm that children can face online by strongly supporting the new guidance issued on 10 November by Lucy Powell, which points to lockable pouches, handing phones in at the start of the day, secure storage or not allowing them on site. In Cheshire and the Thames Valley, two police and crime commissioners have taken money recovered from crime and put it to work in schools, helping keep pupils’ phones out of reach during the school day. Will the Minister please ask his department to look at how this was done and, with the department’s support, consider a national rollout? If children’s time on devices is limited, surely their exposure to online harm and criminality can only be reduced.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. The Minister of State, Home Office (Lord Hanson of Flint) (Lab)

    My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lady Berger for securing this debate. A range of noble Lords who have considerable interest and expertise in these matters have spoken today, and I am grateful for the opportunity to address these issues. I should say to the House that I am a Home Office Minister, but I am addressing this debate on behalf of the Ministry of Justice and DCMS in particular. I will try to respond to all points and will certainly raise them with the relevant Secretaries of State. I want to cut straight to the vital point which my noble friend has quite rightly raised: what a parent can do and who they can turn to when their child is in immediate danger. As part of my response today, I will touch on specific legal remedies, but I also want to make it clear to my noble friend that, when that type of incident has occurred, families do not need to wait for initial proceedings through legal response before reporting concerns about a child’s immediate safety. The police and safeguarding agencies can and should take action swiftly where necessary. I have heard my noble friend raise some concerns around that issue, but it is important that we at least have that as the first port of call. A number of noble Lords and noble Baronesses raised important questions about redress and the transparency of how these systems operate. I will address those points first. I recognise the importance of ensuring that users have meaningful routes to redress. The Online Safety Act requires Ofcom to review the effectiveness of the reporting and complaints framework, and provides a power to introduce independent alternative dispute resolutions for category 1 services where necessary. My noble friend Lord Stevenson, the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham, raised the current timeline of Ofcom’s review, which will take place in 2029. The Government recognise the importance of effective routes for users to seek redress. The Online Safety Act gives the Secretary of State powers to require independent alternatives for dispute resolution for category 1 services. I say to all noble Lords who raised this that we do not rule out additional measures for user redress. Ofcom’s review of the existing reporting and complaints framework will be in 2029. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, raised this too. I want to ensure the House knows that we are considering how user redress can be strengthened further and have not ruled out additional measures. However, wider protections are available where a child faces imminent online harm. It is essential that families and guardians know the actions that they can take—which is the central point of my noble friend’s debate—where they can seek help and how they can access appropriate protection. The appropriate response where a child is at risk will depend on circumstances, but I will outline some of the criminal protections available for wider safeguarding arrangements and for action. My noble friend Lady Berger raised a number of potential legal remedies. She will know, but it is worth putting on record again, that the Family Law Act 1996 provides for orders that can prohibit a person contacting or going near someone with whom they are associated or a “relevant child”, within the meaning of the Act. These orders can address online behaviour where it constitutes molestation and prohibit a person contacting or communicating with a child. It is also important that we have the Family Justice Council, which has published best practice and guidance on a range of issues to support the safe, fair and consistent handling of applications. There are also a number of criminal law and protective measures. Noble Lords will know that if a parent or guardian is concerned that contact towards a child may constitute a criminal offence, they can report it to the police, and that where a child is in immediate danger they should contact the police urgently. The law does not differentiate between criminal offences committed on social media or elsewhere. Where something is illegal offline, it is illegal online and there is legislation that could apply. On bullying, for example, depending on the circumstances, the Protection from Harassment Act 1997 would operate. Certain offences will operate under the Public Order Act 1986. There are offences against communications that are grossly offensive or indecent under the Malicious Communications Act 1998 and the Communications Act 2003. The latter encompasses messages that are obscene or messaging. The Online Safety Act, referred to by a number of noble Lords, also introduces the offence of encouraging or assisting self-harm under Section 184. Similarly, regulations are in place in Northern Ireland. Those regulations ensure that the offence can capture conduct involving the intentional encouragement of serious self-harm. The threshold of “serious self-harm” includes encouraging or assisting harmful eating disorder behaviours when engaged in by a person suffering an eating disorder. Section 2 of the Suicide Act 1961 contains an offence of “encouraging or assisting” suicide. Section 15A of the Sexual Offences Act 2003 contains an offence of sexual communication with a child. These offences all exist, and the Crown Prosecution Service has published guidance—although, I accept, in a slower time—to assist prosecutors in dealing with them. I come to a key area that was raised by the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, my noble friends Lord Stevenson and Lady Berger, the noble Baronesses, Lady Kidron and Lady Brinton, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham, which is online safety and platform protection. The protection of children from harm cannot and should not depend on families having to respond. I say that to the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron, who mentioned compelling and harrowing stories in her contribution. The Online Safety Act places clear legal duties on regulated services to protect children from illegal harm and harmful content, and requires accessible routes for children, parents and others to report harmful content and raise complaints. Ofcom can and does take robust enforcement action where services fail to comply with their duties. For example—I hope this helps the House—Ofcom has taken down 100 sites that contain offensive or disturbing material and has issued fines to the value of £7 million to companies on enforcement action where services have failed to comply with their duties. These arrangements are no substitute for emergency safeguarding action, but they are key issues on which Ofcom can act. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, raised the question of fines, which I hope I have answered, and age verification. Ofcom already has the ability to regulate services through photo ID and data ID. I accept that we need to do more to protect children online. This goes to the heart of the issues raised by the noble Viscount, Lord Colville of Culross, and the noble Earl, Lord Effingham. As part of the announcements made by Ofcom, we will put in place a social media ban with stronger protections for 16 and 17 year-olds. We have been asked when we are going to do this. I can say to the House that we intend to lay the first regulations before Parliament by the end of this year, with the restrictions expected to come into force in spring 2027. Under-16s will be banned from livestreaming, and unknown adults will be prevented from contacting children on a wide range of online services, including gaming services. I accept that chatbots are an important issue; that point was made very strongly by the noble Baroness, Lady Kidron. We had that debate when I dealt with them on other Bills, but I and the Government recognise that they are harmful. That is why we are going to bring currently unregulated AI services into the scope of the Online Safety Act’s illegal contact duties, and we are going to ensure that we include image-generating and coding bots. We are also trying to strengthen protection for children, specifically by preventing encounters for sexual conduct for zero to 18 year-olds. We are also looking at having mandatory brakes on the use of that material. If there is an immediate risk to a child’s life, the emergency services remain the first point of contact, but we will keep these matters under serious review. Alongside the legal remedies that I have outlined, a wider range of child safeguarding systems are in place. We have statutory guidance in the form of Working Together to Safeguard Children . There is clear guidance to practitioners to work with parents, carers and others to make a child’s environment safer. We are investing £2.4 billion in the families first partnership programme, which is helping to shift support away from crisis intervention and towards earlier help. It is important that, as noble Lords know, we have the multi-agency child protection teams that bring together social workers, the police, and health and education professionals to look at children’s online experience alongside what is happening in their homes, schools, peer groups or communities. I hope that the House will recognise that a range of measures are ongoing and that the Government keep these issues under review. Ultimately, there is a consensus in the House that children must be properly protected and the risk of harm must be regulated. Families and guardians must be able to access appropriate legal remedies without delay. I hope I have reassured the noble Baroness that those issues are taken seriously by the Government. I have had limited time to respond and I have gone over my 10 minutes. I will read the debate and ensure that all Members’ contributions are referred to the appropriate Secretaries of State. This will continue to be an ongoing discussion to which all Members will continue to contribute. Please rest assured that the Government are committed.

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Baroness Kidron (CB)

    I recognise what the noble Lord said about where the Home Office sits versus DCMS and the attempt to understand our frustration, but will he agree that despite everything he has laid out, there is nowhere for parents to go in the current regime because Ofcom does not take individual complaints?

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Lord Hanson of Flint (Lab)

    I accept that Ofcom will not look at individual complaints, but it is still worth raising those complaints, because the issues are examined collectively by Ofcom and, as I have mentioned already, Ofcom will take down sites, as it has done with 100 sites to date, and fine companies, as it has done with 7 million to date. Ofcom will continue to do that and it will know, independent as it is of government, that there is considerable pressure in this House and in the House of Commons for it to improve its performance in overall regulation of these sites. I hope that is of help. I have taken more than my time.

    View contribution permalink →

  13. Baroness Kidron (CB)

    I do not wish to detain the House, but I cannot say that to a parent whose child died two months ago. I am sorry.

    View contribution permalink →

  14. Lord Hanson of Flint (Lab)

    I cannot imagine what it must be like to face a parent who has suffered the sort of loss the noble Baroness refers to. I say to her and to my noble friend Lady Berger that there are a range of steps in place for criminal activity already, and a range of protections. Ofcom is reviewing its performance, and we are considering and will bring forward measures which will strengthen that performance around young people having access to social media. I fully accept that platforms need to improve their performance as well, and I will refer those matters to the relevant Secretaries of State. I thank my noble friend for commencing this important debate today.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441472.