Housing Market
Thursday, 19 November 2026
Contributions
Motion to Take Note
Moved by
Lord Stoneham of Droxford
That this House takes note of the role of investment in social housing, shared ownership and zero-carbon homes in addressing challenges facing the housing market.
Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)
My Lords, I draw the House’s attention to my interests in property and as a former chairman of three housing associations. I am not sure who to thank for winning a balloted debate like this; presumably, the democratic procedures of the House. I do thank them and I welcome this opportunity for a debate on social housing, although I am sorry to burden our Housing Minister when she is also coping with the Representation of the People Bill, but maybe she will be relieved to get back to social housing—a subject she knows well with her experience in Stevenage. On these Benches, we share her commitment. I am looking forward to the maiden speeches of the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, and my noble friend Lord Petterson, and I wish them well. I thank all noble Lords for taking part in this debate. I congratulate and thank the Government for all the initiatives they have been taking to build more social houses in difficult economic and financial circumstances. It takes time for new initiatives to show through and they deserve credit for starting them. Thanks to the Government’s new rules for investment expenditure, over £40 billion has been made available to the Social and Affordable Homes Programme 2026-36 to build 300,000 social and affordable homes with 180,000 for social rent. They have already awarded £9.6 billion, which should see over 70,000 social homes built. The 10-year rent settlement gives financial strength to social housing providers to invest more securely. They have provided clarity for regulation after improvements in home standards and energy efficiency. We pay tribute to the Prime Minister’s initiative to end rough sleeping. We have been given a commitment through him for the biggest programme of social and council housebuilding since the post-war era. This should create a stable background and platform for the sustained growth of social housing over the next 10 years. Combined with the energy and new impetus of Homes England and the National Housing Bank across the country, we have the potential for progress and change in our housing supply. As a nation, we have to make a significant inroad into reducing the numbers of single women and children, in particular, in temporary accommodation. The temporary accommodation bill to help 170,000 adults was £2.93 billion last year, an increase of 88% over the last five years. One in four councils is struggling to pay these bills. We know that increasing social housing will improve health and well-being for those who would otherwise be in insecure housing. It will help abate the growth of housing benefit, which grew from £21 billion a year to £39 billion under the last Government, as more people lacking social housing had to succumb to rising private sector rents. This investment in social housing should make a significant contribution to the nation’s economic growth. It will need strong cross-party support for success to be sustained and a fair economic wind, but it will deserve it, as this investment is long overdue. Noble Lords might ask, if so much progress is being made, why have a debate at this time? There are four areas of concern that I wish to raise so that they do not become obstacles to what we need to achieve. There is the current dire state of the private housing market and the need for economic growth generally, and the important role social housing could now play in that. I am also concerned that we maintain a flexible and innovative approach to providing social housing and use what is working rather than resort to old formulas for the sake of it. There is also a need to address several long-term issues in the social housing sector now we are starting to build more social homes, and I hope to have time to get to those. Let me start on the state of the housing market. We must be concerned about confidence in the housing market at the moment, which is dire and could get worse. I accept that government debt restrains freedom of action, and it is one reason why we want debt down, so we can respond better in a Keynesian way when times are tough. International uncertainty and the rise of interest rates have taken five-year mortgage rates back up to 5% from 1% just over five years ago. Rising construction costs over the past six years since Brexit are adding to the problem, with many development sites no longer viable as house prices fall. After a period of very low interest rates, which allowed asset prices to rise, some areas of the country are still expecting falls of 10% to 20% in house prices to come through in order to adapt to the high mortgage rates that are now likely to stay. This completely distorts the business model for developers, which have depended for too long on the rising value of their land holdings for their profitability. National output in the last quarter grew by 0.9%, but the construction industry was down by 0.7%. Housing figures within those figures were even worse: private housing was down by 8.6% for the quarter and in September down by 12.9%, so the trend is getting worse. Savills is projecting that we will be building only 170,000 homes per year in the five years to 2029-30, on current trends. In reality, developers are becoming more risk averse and very selective about where they develop. Inevitably, this will slow the building of Section 106 social housing schemes. However, if growth in construction became positive, that would transform our national economic growth. So what should the Government do? In the Budget, they added £1.5 billion to the social and affordable homes programme, but that is for council housing, so the impact will not be immediate. They also responded to building industry pressure and launched a £4.7 billion first home scheme to support 70,000 first-time buyers with equity loans. I admit to being very sceptical about those schemes, as they can simply increase house prices for first-time buyers while improving developers’ profits. The Government’s recent research is very patchy on the impact of past schemes, depending on local market conditions. Certainly, in London, it shows that they increase prices. So, despite the research, these schemes should be treated with caution. It might therefore be more effective and timely for the Government to use their headroom for productive public sector investment to allow local authorities and housing associations to drive hard bargains with overextended housebuilders, such as Vistry, to buy homes for social rent to help them stay solvent and keep building. In the current climate, the Government need to encourage Homes England to allocate funds to social housing schemes that are shovel ready, to build the homes soonest and boost the construction sector. From the recent £9.6 billion allocation in August, 73,617 social homes are envisaged, but there was scope for another 41,000 additional housing association homes if another £5 billion could be found. I have evidence from housing associations that were disappointed by the allocation. They had schemes with developers to start as soon as the funds were forthcoming. The construction sector desperately needs those schemes to help revive construction. With a construction downturn in play, addressing supply in a market where demand is strong for social housing must be the priority for any government contingency action until the private sector recovers. There is some indication as well that Homes England held back funds on the recent August allocation to housing associations because it was waiting for councils to scale up for housing development. The capacity of councils to scale up is obviously a problem, as the Government are allocating special funds of over £40 million for them to do this. In my experience, it always takes longer for organisations to scale up, and there is not much benefit if they simply recruit personnel from housing associations. The quickest way for councils to make an impact is in direct partnership with housing associations, which have the proven capacity to build more now. In 2025-26, housing associations built nearly 43,000 homes and their starts were 15% up. They are building nearly a quarter of all housing completions. Housing associations build 10 times more houses than councils currently do and, at their current rate of build, they could build more than 400,000 social homes over 10 years, surpassing the Government’s target of 300,000. The Government should be encouraging them to do even better and not hold them back. Every £1 in grants to housing associations is matched by £3 in private investment. It is less of a burden on public sector borrowing than council housing, and should be the focus in the short and medium term for pump-priming. Let us get the social housing built. Before I conclude, I will refer briefly to several longer-term issues. To help create more funding for social housing, the Government must be prepared to use their new powers in the Planning and Infrastructure Act vigorously to free up land for social housing at much cheaper, low or no-hope value. Partnership working between councils, mayors, housing associations and developers will be crucial to scaling up regeneration work. Social housing must be a major component of housing supply. If we cannot achieve 1.5 million homes in this Parliament, which I accept, we can at least push to construct nearly 300,000 homes per annum after five years. Housing associations are not perfect. Building their capacity is as important as it is for councils; in reality, they are a long way ahead. They must not lose their local focus or social purpose. We must guard against large housing associations becoming remote from the communities they serve. I end with three questions for the Minister. First, are the Government on top of contingency plans if the housing market worsens, and do they see social housing playing a major role in boosting the sector? Secondly, do the Government share the view that, although they want to boost council housing and building, the overriding objective is to deliver more social housing, from wherever it is sourced? Thirdly, do they recognise now the huge potential of housing associations to deliver more social housing than the government target is currently aiming for?
Lord Davey of Chalk Farm (Lab) (Maiden Speech)
My Lords, I am honoured to follow the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, to give my maiden speech, and to contribute to this important debate about housing. I will now put my glasses on before I forget what I am doing. I thank the Lord Speaker and noble Lords across your Lordships’ House for their warm and generous welcome. After a career spent in theatres, concert halls and galleries, I have learned that you can sense an organisation’s culture from its very first welcome. The welcome here is second to none. I also thank the Clerk of the Parliaments and her staff, Black Rod and his team, and especially the doorkeepers, who saved me in my first week when I ended up in the other place while looking for the Long Room. I am deeply grateful to my introducers, my noble and great friend Lady McIntosh and my noble friend Lady Rebuck, for their encouragement and for gently warning me of the many late-night votes ahead. As I start this next chapter of my life, I am blessed to have the support of my wonderful family: Tatty and our sons Solomon and Samson. When my Letters Patent were read out at my introduction, I heard two names side by side: the one my family gave me and the other I chose, Chalk Farm. I was named after my Czech great uncle, who survived the horrors of Terezín. Although his brother, my grandfather Frederick Tintner, lost almost everything in the Second World War, he managed to build a new life here, marrying my grandmother Ruth in Norwich in 1943. He lived to a remarkable 102. He had been ordered on to a train in the early 1940s but, due to his obstinacy, courage and foresight not to get on it, he escaped by foot, chased by dogs over snow-covered mountains in midwinter, which meant he survived. He really loved his family and taught us resilience, determination and humour in the face of adversity. Politically we argued, as he was a lifelong Conservative. However, my grandmother, like me, was a Labour supporter. As one election approached, my grandfather took me aside with a twinkle in his eye and implored me to have a word with my grandmother, saying, “Every time she votes, she cancels out my vote!” I carry my great uncle’s name, Marcus, and my grandfather’s example with pride. I grew up in the beautiful county of Cumbria, the son of teachers and artists, Robin and Ruth. We thought of Manchester as down south. As a teenager, however, I needed my grandfather’s resilience. I was bullied, especially after my hair fell out when I was 14; and, with undiagnosed dyslexia, I became somewhat withdrawn. I mention this not for sympathy but because it is how I found the arts. Making ceramics and painting pictures in classes taught by my parents opened a new and wonderful world to me. Playing the cello in the Northern Junior Philharmonic Orchestra gave me confidence and friends—music-loving creatives who valued what I valued. That experience has driven my whole career. The arts connect us, create belonging and give us understanding. Participation in them builds community. They fire our imaginations, expand our sense of what is possible and, potentially most importantly, make us happy. From amateur choirs and brass bands to renowned producing companies, great artists, festivals and magnificent venues, we in the UK are defined by our creative arts and are rightly proud of them. However, our world-leading arts do not happen by accident; they need nurturing and funding. It is said that the two most important days in your life are the day you are born and the day you find out why. My given name tells you who I am; my chosen name, Chalk Farm, tells you why. For 27 years, I had the privilege of leading the Roundhouse in Chalk Farm. Noble Lords may know it as a music and arts venue, which of course it is, but at its heart it is Europe’s leading creative centre for young people. Last year alone, 12,000 young people aged 11 to 30, the vast majority from areas of multiple deprivation, learned skills, gained experience and moved into education, employment and training. In helping to build a creative home for young people, I found one for myself. I turn to today’s debate. Young people are disproportionately affected by the housing crisis. Few own their own homes; many more rent privately, and younger renters spend the largest proportion of their income on housing. This affects quality of life and aspiration. In addition, young people are particularly at risk of homelessness, driven above all by a shortage of affordable and social housing. It is very hard to hold down an apprenticeship, finish a course or turn up to a rehearsal if you do not know where you are sleeping that night. As we know, talent is spread evenly across this country; secure homes are not. Without one, the young people I have spent my career working with are shut out of the arts long before they can fulfil their potential. If we are serious about bringing a generation back into education, employment and training, housing must be part of the answer. No young person can find their path in life without a home. Without art and self-expression, a life well lived is also out of reach. I will use the privilege of membership of your Lordships’ House to advocate passionately for the arts, and maybe even more passionately for young people and everything that affects them.
Baroness Warwick of Undercliffe (Lab)
My Lords, it is a joy to follow my noble friend and congratulate him on a wonderful maiden speech. We learned about his fascinating background and his family’s courage and resilience, which have clearly endured in everything he has done during his impressive career. However, what he did not say is just as fascinating: the mammoth task he faced when he took over at the iconic Roundhouse, and the herculean way in which he—and I know he would say his team—have made it the transformational venue it has become today. There must be others in this Chamber who have fond memories of the Roundhouse and its colourful reputation. I recall Blondie’s wonderful gig and the amazing Helen Mirren as the Duchess of Malfi. That must have been in the early 1980s, a little after its more unruly 1960s and 1970s, but I also recall its tattiness, the awful loos, the precarious finances, and the run-down area that was then Camden. Marcus, my noble friend Lord Davey, was only 32 when he undertook the rebuilding of the Roundhouse, transforming it into the venue that now enables thousands of young people to express their energy, creativity and potential, all backed by strong commercial enterprises. That also helped to bolster the transformation of Camden to be the thriving, exciting place it is now. His determination, foresight, financial acumen and creative energy have made the Roundhouse an international centre—indeed powerhouse—for the creative arts and for the many disadvantaged young people who now thrive because of its work. In case this makes my noble friend seem a little too serious, I can personally attest that, as my new roommate, he is warm-hearted, charming, optimistic, very kind, and really funny. Music and performance and a desire to transform lives have been the golden threads running through my noble friend’s life and work and driven his passionate commitment to the arts. I know we can look all forward to the same passion in his contribution to our debates. I turn to the subject of this debate and look forward to the maiden speech of the noble Lord, Lord Petterson, who I know has had long association with child homelessness charities, so I welcome him. As my noble friend Lord Davey rightly emphasised, a secure and genuinely affordable home is a foundation on which so much else rests—good health, educational attainment, well-being and the solid base we need to thrive in life. Yet, today, more than 1.3 million households are on social housing waiting lists, while councils are spending record sums providing temporary accommodation. I strongly welcome the Government’s ambition for a major programme of social and council housebuilding. If we are to achieve the largest increase in social housebuilding since the post-war period, we must make full use of the distinctive strengths of both councils and housing associations. Housing associations are anchor institutions investing in neighbourhoods, local economies and public services. Working alongside councils, mayors and other partners, they help people to live healthy, secure and independent lives. They are long-term partners in the communities they serve. They also have an exceptional record of leveraging private finance for public benefits. In recent decades, the housing association model has attracted more than £100 billion of private investment, underpinned by independent regulation, long-term ownership and the reinvestment of surpluses. They have shown their ability to deliver. Last year, housing associations built the highest number of social rent homes in more than a decade. The National Housing Federation’s data shows a 50% increase in social rent starts to March 2026. Last year, 77% of all social housing was delivered by housing associations. The Government should be congratulated on delivering on their manifesto commitment to rebuild the capacity of housing associations and councils after years of underinvestment. I want to repeat a point I made only recently in this Chamber and which was emphasised today by the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, in his opening speech. Housing associations have significant capacity, appetite and ambition to do more. Across the country, schemes ready to proceed are held back by funding and viability constraints. The recent commitment of £10 billion for strategic partners through the social and affordable homes programme is extremely welcome, as was the Chancellor’s recent announcement of an additional £1.5 billion in SAHP funding. As the Minister will know, the SAHP is oversubscribed, following ambitious bids from housing associations in every part of the country. It is clear evidence of the sector’s appetite and capacity to build. Will the Minister ensure that the Government build on that momentum with a further wave of funding for strategic partners? Will she also ensure that the National Housing Bank’s £2.5 billion of low-interest loans for social housing providers is deployed quickly and expanded if demand warrants it? To reinforce the point, it has huge additional benefits. Construction of these more affordable homes could generate an additional £6.86 billion in economic activity and support 93,000 jobs. Strategic partnerships give the long-term certainty to acquire land, enter contracts, invest in skills and create development pipelines years in advance. Scheme-by-scheme funding cannot provide the same level of certainty. I also want to touch on an incredibly important part of the work that housing associations do to meet housing need: supported housing. Alongside general needs homes, housing associations provide specialist homes that enable older people, disabled people, survivors of domestic abuse, people experiencing homelessness and others with support needs to live safely and independently. They have a vital role in preventing pressure elsewhere in our public services. As the Prime Minister has argued, too often we spend money on dealing with the consequences of housing insecurity rather than preventing people reaching crisis point in the first place. Investment in supported housing is preventive public spending. It can reduce pressure on homelessness services, hospitals, social care and the criminal justice system, while delivering better outcomes for some of the most vulnerable people in our society. A sustainable, long-term funding settlement for supported housing would give providers the confidence to invest and ensure services are there when people need them. I have a request for the Minister: will she undertake to put supported housing at the heart of the Government’s approach to homelessness, rough sleeping and public service reform, and recognise the savings it can generate across departmental budgets rather than treating it simply as an upfront housing cost? Turning to shared ownership, I welcome the Government’s decision to raise the income caps for the first time since 2016. Increasing the threshold to £90,000 outside London and £110,000 in the capital reflects how much earnings and housing costs have changed over the past decade. It will enable more working households to benefit from the scheme. I know that this is something that housing associations have welcomed. I also welcome the Government’s continued focus on reducing energy costs, including removing standing charges from gas bills. I hope the same can be achieved for electricity. The £100 council tax rebate will also undoubtedly provide relief for millions of households, particularly those on low incomes. I conclude with some comments about rough sleeping. We have already seen what housing associations can contribute when government and the sector come together around a shared national mission. When the Prime Minister pledged to end rough sleeping, housing associations heard that call and responded, identifying over 2,000 additional potential homes and bed spaces. Some of these homes could be made available quickly; others will require investment. Crucially, providing a home must be accompanied by the right support if we are to provide a lasting route away from homelessness. This response shows both the commitment and the capability of the housing association sector. When government sets an ambitious national mission, housing associations can mobilise their homes, expertise and local partnerships to help deliver it. I hope that the Government will continue to provide housing associations with the certainty and investment they need to go further, building the homes we desperately need, supporting people to live independently and, ultimately, setting us on a path towards ending the housing crisis for good.
Lord Fuller (Con)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, on his compelling maiden speech. It is a pleasure to find another Norfolk kinsman in your Lordships’ House, particularly one with Conservative back stories. There is £35 billion burning a hole in the Government’s pocket. The Prime Minister tells us he wants to unleash the greatest council house building programme for a generation. I am not sure the rhetoric wholly survived the reality of the Budget, but let us not nitpick the stated intent. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, for introducing this debate. He anticipated some of the remarks I wanted to make about the consequences of many RSLs being swallowed up into larger organisations. It is a fact that so many of these larger combines have forgotten their social purpose. As a consequence, a focus on local matters, such as anti-social behaviour, has been relegated to the subs bench. This morning, I dealt with such a case in Bergh Apton, in my own case load. I found a housing officer hiding behind emails instead of mediating. The desire to solve a problem was replaced by the dismal management of a case load. In these larger organisations, tenant reps have been excised from the landscape. Local accountability is lacking, with RSLs populating their boards with the great and good from out of town. Some social housing in my village in Norfolk is headquartered in Gloucestershire. These are national organisations and, with billions in investment at stake, RSLs have become dependent on speculation and property development backed by cheap government finance. Our job is to force these organisations to remember their social purpose and stop them behaving like pound-shop developers benefiting from finance that is unavailable to private builders, whom this Government have brought to their knees. I listened carefully to the comments from the noble Lord about RSLs being ready to build, like a hairspring. In my book, if they want a share of the state’s largesse, they should sign up to six key social principles as a condition for taking the money: the promotion of tenant well-being; effective estate management; the prevention and reduction of anti-social behaviour; community engagement; the provision and maintenance of safe and sustainable neighbourhoods; and getting the balance between development activity and social responsibilities right. Too many RSLs have taken the wrong path. They have strayed from their original purpose and lost sight of that social purpose. It is our job to say, here and now, “If you want to take the money, signing up to the social purpose is the hair on the deal”. Building homes alone is not enough. It should not need to be said, but I have studied shared ownership, and that is where I want to focus now. I am concerned about the asymmetry of power and the imbalance in negotiating strength between the landlord in a shared ownership situation, normally an RSL, and the tenant. I do not want to characterise the people who enter into these arrangements as financially unsophisticated, but the truth is that schemes are available only to people on limited incomes, and, in their understandable desire to own at least part of a place they live in, they accept a situation where they sign up to the possibility of only half the uplift but the certainty of all the costs. The terms of trade are stacked against them. In June, I became aware of a couple in Oakham who wanted to sell their shared ownership house, where they had lived for 20 years. It was time for them to move. They inquired of the RSL about the process to sell, and the RSL replied that about 80 years remained on their lease. In fact, just over 80 years remained. At that stage, they could have entered into a lease extension without any marriage value charge at all, which would have assisted their move. The RSL manager, who styled herself as an adviser, did not disclose that any delay could crystallise this marriage value charge or that the case was urgent—that was sharp practice. Time apparently was not of the essence, when it was. A few months passed, and they were quoted £12,000 for the marriage value, plus various fees for solicitors, valuation and inspections, totalling over £16,000 plus VAT. By my reckoning, as they owned only 50%, the marriage value should have been at worst £8,000. But that should not obscure the truth that, had they been correctly advised 12 months previously, they would have owed little. My correspondents were misadvised by their social landlord, who acted as a privateer in its own self-interest rather than the tenants’. Meanwhile, the underlying value of their flat had diminished, and the RSL repudiated any responsibility for the equity loss of a home in which it had a 50% interest. All along, the tenants were responsible for 100% of the maintenance and 100% of the service charges. That is wrong. Elsewhere, last week, the Daily Telegraph highlighted a more egregious case where an elderly woman, who has since died, had taken a shared ownership of a retirement property, now unsaleable because the RSL continues to charge her son and daughter-in-law for meals not eaten—she is dead—and all manner of other charges. The RSL has every reason to obstruct a sale and resist a buyback, and it continues to charge with abandon. The basic terms of both these shared ownership arrangements were unfair and wrong. The tenant keeps all the charges, assumes all the losses and is often trapped in an unsellable home, unable to move on with their life, especially in the case of young couples with a growing family. Meanwhile, the state-backed landlord gets off scot free. By their actions we see they are not the cuddly social organisations the National Housing Federation would have you believe. In the case of shared ownership, they behave in a predatory manner with obvious conflicts of interest. There is an asymmetry of market and pricing power. They ignore the duty of care to their customers. Costs which should be apportioned are not, and there is a lack of pro-active information for financially unsophisticated tenants at the outset of the sale. This supports my wider point that the social purpose of RSLs is being ignored, and we should do something about it. These shared ownership homes are being mis-sold on unfair terms that would shame a scammer. We need a fundamental review to reinvigorate the case for a fair and balanced shared ownership system. That review must look at the affordability of shared ownership for leaseholders; the extent to which shared ownership provides a viable route to full home ownership, including costs, fees and valuation requirements; the purchase of additional shares; the barriers faced by shared ownership leaseholders in staircasing to higher levels of ownership or to full ownership; the impact of service charges, repair obligations and other housing costs; and to see whether regulatory changes are required to improve the transparency, affordability and access to full ownership. Parliament determined that shared ownership is a good idea, and I agree. However, it has become tainted, which is a shame. It is being fatally damaged unless the actions of the predatory RSLs—which exploit an imbalance of power and condemn people to live in unsaleable homes with unfair and usurious terms from which they are unable to extricate themselves—are addressed. Unless RSLs can get their house in order and relearn their social purpose, then the availability of cheap development finance should be withheld. That is the bargain we need to have a fresh start and reinvigorate this tenure so it stops harming, possibly irreparably, the opportunity for couples to accumulate capital and a stake in their homes and in the communities in which they live.
Lord Best (CB)
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford, for initiating this debate and for his perceptive opening speech. I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, on his brilliant maiden speech. I declare my interests in social housing as chair of Renew, the Northern Housing Consortium’s housing-led regeneration initiative, as chair of the universities-based Urban Retrofit UK, and as a vice-president of the LGA and of the Town and Country Planning Association. My remarks are confined to a simple plea to the Minister: please convey to your ministerial colleagues the urgency of allocating more of the social and affordable housing programme now to the housing providers that are ready and willing to deliver the new homes we so badly need. With housebuilders operating at a low ebb, with stalled schemes and undeveloped land with planning consent, now is the time to step up the contribution which the public funding makes possible. This countercyclical public investment protects against the construction industry and the social housing sector having to shed staff and lose capacity that takes a long time to restore. It has been great to see a significant allocation of public funds dispersed through Homes England and the GLA: a total, after the £1.5 billion Budget top-up, of over £40 billion. About a quarter has been committed for the programmes of a small number of strategic partners, but there is now some uncertainty as to when the bulk of the investment will follow. I am worried that opportunities will be lost if delays set in. It is so important to speed up, not hold back, production of desperately needed social rented homes. Why is there anxiety about the speed of allocating the available funds? The Prime Minister has talked of his determination to build significantly more “council housing”. I have not taken his wording to mean any intention to provide less support to the housing associations, which are currently the main providers of social housing. Most of the Government’s programme at present is spent on developments that are based on co-operation and partnership between councils and housing associations. Very few authorities are currently developing on their own, with some excellent exceptions. But is government now planning to keep back a large part of the remaining £30 billion funding to await more local authorities getting back into the development business? I think it would be a grave mistake to do so. For sure, it would be good to add to the number of social housing providers: local authorities acting as developers have the potential to be highly sensitive to local needs and opportunities. Some have landholdings that they can utilise. But gearing up the whole of the local government sector to take on this role will take a huge amount of time and resource. Many councils have not been in this business for 30 years and more. All face severe financial constraints and other competing priorities. Those that have retained their landlord role, rather than transferring their stock to a housing association or to an arm’s-length management organisation, may well want to give priority to upgrading their existing housing stock to today’s decent homes standards. Meanwhile, the market conditions—and the government target of 1.5 million homes this Parliament—demand immediate action, and cannot wait for a revival of the role of local authorities as developers. I should add that housing associations, now often called “registered providers”, bring some special advantages of their own, as well as being ready with bids for new homes, as the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe, has so forcibly underlined. Their borrowing costs do not add to the national debt, which pleases HM Treasury, and they are experienced at creating mixed-tenure developments that avoid social housing becoming stigmatised, as has sometimes been the case with estates exclusively of social rented homes. The National Housing Federation, as the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, has noted, says its members could do much more. It found that 41,000 affordable homes could have been delivered, of which 25,000 would be for social rent, if government had fully funded the housing association bids through the recent strategic partners allocation outside London. My plea to the Minister is for parallel government activity: first, for government to press ahead now, urgently, with the release of the available funding to those organisations ready to buy the land and progress new development. This means Homes England and the GLA getting the go-ahead to approve more of the outstanding bids from the housing associations, and also from a small number of councils that are eager to get on with the job. My second plea is for government to support more local authorities over a period of time to recruit the team and build the skills to recreate or expand the role of councils as social housing developers, in due course. I know the APPG on Council and Social Housing is looking at the barriers to developing new homes, and its work will progress this agenda. If social housing programmes are to get even close to reaching the demand for truly affordable new homes—variously estimated at twice or three times current levels—then an additional social housing contribution from councils as developers is going to be very welcome. But bringing forward and bolstering local authority providers of social housing should be a significant component for the Government’s 10-year national housing plan, which is due to be published next year. Meanwhile, most local authorities will need preparing, nurturing and supporting. Just as with the build-up of depleted local authority planning teams, this will take time and effort. I look forward to the response of the Minister, which I feel sure will be one of reassurance.
Lord Petterson (LD) (Maiden Speech)
My Lords, I am grateful for this opportunity to make my maiden speech and thank my noble friend Lord Stoneham of Droxford for introducing this debate on social housing. I give a huge congratulations to the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, on a brilliant maiden speech—a tough act to follow. I see we share a number of things, including my love of the Roundhouse. I was there in the 1970s at gigs after I left school in Stevenage. I must declare ongoing interests. I am a trustee and funder of Banbury Young Homelessness Project, and I have a long-standing involvement with Centrepoint, which is delivering over 300 social housing units as stepping-stone accommodation for youngsters leaving supported hostels. I would like to start by thanking Black Rod and everyone across the estate—the clerks, the doorkeepers, the attendants, the police, the Lib Dem team, and others—for helping me settle into this very unfamiliar and, frankly, quite daunting environment. My late parents were supportive, intelligent and aspirational, but both left school in their mid-teens and were unable to provide much counsel as I went off to college to study engineering—the first person in my family to go to university. But I did have a role model of sorts, whose image adorns the wall in the Royal Gallery. You will find me there when in need of further inspiration, as I was a little earlier, looking up at everyone’s favourite Mecklenburger: Field-Marshal Blücher, or “Marshal Forwards”, as his adoring troops called him, because of his bravery and determination. My career has been built on hard work, proper planning, large doses of luck, my very supportive wife Vanessa and my girls, great colleagues and a willingness to take risks. My early working years were spent as an operational petroleum engineer offshore in the North Sea—unknowingly gaining useful experience and a skill set that would stand me in good stead later in life, in a completely new sector. My last 25 years of a long career in the energy industry have been as an entrepreneur in the offshore wind sector. I was project director of the pioneering developments that helped lay the foundation for our now dynamic industry. Thanet, the second of my three projects, was the world’s largest offshore wind farm when it came online in 2010. Thanet also made the UK the largest market for offshore wind, a position only very recently relinquished to China. We remain comfortably in second place, supporting many tens of thousands of good jobs. My surname is Swedish in origin. An economic migrant, my grandfather set up home in Walthamstow in 1880 with his German wife. I suspect that the German Swede gene pool combo may account for my sense of humour, if not my regular moist-eyed lapses to emotion, for which I apologise to the House in advance. Oscar Frederick Petterson became a British citizen on 25 September 1911, taking the same oath of allegiance as I did here last month. I know this, as I have a copy of his naturalisation papers, kindly signed by the then Home Secretary in that great reforming Liberal Government: a certain Winston Churchill. That radical Liberal Government laid the foundations for the welfare state by, among other things, bringing in health insurance, state pensions and unemployment insurance for the first time. I am pleased that this Government also plan to be radical in areas such as the care sector, NEETs and social housing. Let us hope that they are “on it like Nigel Bonnett” in terms of delivery. My noble friend Lady Thornhill has, in other debates, stated our ambitious targets for social housing, and I heard only this week that the Lib Dem-run Hull City Council now has plans and funding for more of these crucial assets. I have long thought that rebuilding our social housing stock is the best and most progressive way forward. Government bodies and housing associations will have to do most of the heavy lifting here, I suspect, but will then save billions on housing benefits and it will help with other societal issues, including homelessness. An increase in social housing would reduce the pressure on the private rental market, slowly deflating that particular bubble, which would then save even more on the housing benefit bill. The National Housing Federation reports that in England alone over 1.3 million households are currently on social housing waiting lists. In addition, I look forward to the opportunity to contribute when this House considers the Energy Independence Bill in the near future. I will be very keen to hear what detailed plans the Government have to ensure that all new builds use one of the many low-carbon or zero-carbon designs that are now available, making this a fundamental principle for future housebuilding, with no exceptions and no loopholes Zero-carbon housing can have a transformative impact on the lives of the families involved. Energy bills would virtually disappear for them, probably solving their personal cost of living challenge at a stroke. Although the UK will largely remove the remaining carbon from our power system over the next five years or so, we are in a hole on domestic heat, and the first thing you should do when in a hole is stop digging. We have built around 2 million homes since 2015, most of which will need to be retrofitted. We must stop adding to this huge challenge. Some 20% of the housing stock that the UK will have by 2050 will be built between now and then. I know how very fortunate I have been overall and this appointment, which is the honour of my life, provides me with the opportunity to make a difference. In this place, I hope to bring my business and project management experience to our collective work on energy, housing and other topics, and I look forward to learning from your Lordships at the same time. Despite the many challenges the UK faces, I remain hugely optimistic for this great country of ours. Commandeering the nickname of my hero, Blücher, the Prince of Wahlstatt, and hoping that this spurs on the Government to show bravery and determination on delivering well-designed social housing in volume, I say: forwards.
Lord Dixon of Jericho (LD)
My Lords, I thank my noble friend Lord Stoneham for securing this debate and congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Davey, on his maiden speech. I am a huge admirer of anyone who takes a British institution that has fallen on hard times and tries to revitalise it and show its true potential. I know how hard that is and how much generosity of spirit, determination and raw perseverance it takes. His efforts in that have been truly valiant. From a personal perspective, I thank him for talking about dyslexia in the way he did. That is extremely important for many young people, including people who are dear to me. It is a real pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord Petterson and to congratulate him on such a personal, heartfelt and wide-ranging maiden speech. I have known Mark for nearly a decade and, as ever with maiden speeches, I was delighted to learn lots of new things about him today. He told us that he was the first in his family to go to university and that he studied engineering. He talked about Thanet as merely the second of his three projects—the largest offshore wind farm in the world and the one that enabled our country to do this and to have confidence about it. He did not say that trips to Thanet on a really upsetting boat that makes you feel sick are available to any Member of this House that would like to go to see it. I do not recommend it. Many of us in this House care passionately about clean energy, and he built a large part of that industry in our country. As we look to the challenges this country faces and we revitalise high-skilled manufacturing, it can only be good to have more engineers in this House and on these Benches. My noble friend Lord Petterson also omitted to tell the House that he is an accidental publican, the driving force behind an ever-expanding cultural festival in Oxfordshire, the creator of thriving local communities wherever he goes, a dedicated Spurs fan—which he did slip into his speech, although many noble Lords may not have noticed—and a cricket enthusiast. His chosen position is wicket keeper. For those who do not understand, like or are enthused by cricket, that is the terrifying position where every minute or so someone throws an incredibly hard ball at your head as hard as they can and you have to try to catch it. It is a position that gets very little credit and is not showy, and you are expected to catch anything and everything thrown at you without warning. If that is not good preparation for being on the Liberal Democrat Benches, I do not know what is. Nearly 10 years ago, I was chief executive of a large drug and alcohol recovery charity. We worked with about 100,000 people in recovery. I tried to spend as much time on the front line as I could. I remember a particular day more vividly than almost any other in that time. I was in a small town in the south-west with one of our outreach workers. We were checking that people sleeping on the street were okay, that they had cardboard underneath them so that they would be warm, and that they had naloxone so that, if the worst happened, they would be okay. The outreach worker knew everyone by name. He knew when to be kind, when to be direct and when to be fierce. Like many people who have been through recovery themselves, he was extraordinarily open, direct and wise. I remember him telling me at the end of the day that he had been street homeless himself. He had lived under a bridge for three years before he came through recovery, volunteered to work and ended up as a paid outreach worker. I remember asking him, “Why did this happen, sleeping under a bridge for three years, when you are clearly talented, skilled, dynamic, can talk to people and are brilliant?” He said, “It was because you couldn’t take it away from me”. When you are sleeping on the street, you have nothing to lose and cannot go lower—and that is safety. When you do not have a home, it is that safety of sleeping on the street that is compelling for lots of people in that situation. I heard that again and again in that role. What got him out was being prepared finally to risk losing things he cared about. It is so easy for us in this place to think about rights, responsibilities, targets and incentives when, at the bottom of it all, as my noble friend Lord Petterson showed, is raw human emotion. A home where you belong and feel safe is the foundation of everything else. If you are worried that it will be taken from you, that you will lose it or that you cannot afford it, you cannot start the rest of your life. In the last few years, temporary accommodation was a factor in the coroners’ reports of 104 children who died. Even today, lots of children and their families are being put in temporary accommodation—in places without a kitchen, and with a bathroom they must share with strangers. That is not acceptable. It is a moral failure for our country and an extraordinarily bad way to spend money, even over the medium term. For every pound we spend on building homes, we spend 74p on rooms that taxpayers rent by the night, and which are gone the moment that we stop paying. While I agree with the Government’s ambition here, and with my noble friend Lord Stoneham, the route to more and affordable housing is not national imposition. It is working with local people and meeting them on their own terms. It is giving local authorities the power to adjust right to buy in their area, depending on local need. It is working with local communities to identify where houses can be built. Most people you speak to on the doorstep, which we do a lot, are not opposed to new homes. However, they want reassurance that the infrastructure will go in first. They want communities where you can get a GP appointment, where there is parking, where there is a dentist and a school. That is not unreasonable. They do not want development stretching further down an arterial road, with a promise of more GPs that is never kept. If you can convince people that those things will happen, they are on your side and will move forward with you. That is why Liberal Democrats on these Benches, in the Commons and in local government are pushing so hard for local authorities to be given stronger powers to boost local housing supply and to take a leading role in that. We absolutely agree with the noble Lord, Lord Best, that housing associations must be a strong part of this, but we must make sure that, in the social housing Bill, for example, councils are given the power to acquire lost homes. We must make sure that social rents are linked to local incomes. We must end excessive service charges and repair costs in social ownership. Like the noble Lord, Lord Best, I have one question for the Minister. Will she redouble efforts to bring communities with her in making these changes? If we can bring people with us, we will make change that lasts.
Baroness Gill (Lab)
My Lords, I, too, congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm and Lord Petterson, on their excellent and moving maiden speeches. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, for securing this debate and setting out the issues so clearly. Having worked in the social housing sector for almost two decades, I have seen at first hand the life-changing power of a secure, warm home and the deep human and financial cost when the housing system falls short. Before turning to the regional, demographic and delivery pressures that still need urgent attention, it is important to recognise the genuine progress this Government have made in putting social housing back at the heart of national policy. We have already heard about the £39 billion social and affordable homes programme running for 10 years from 2026 to 2036, with at least 60% earmarked for social rent, and nearly £10 billion already allocated in the first wave, which gives housing providers the multi-year financial certainty they have lacked for well over a decade. Equally welcome is the Social Housing Bill, which completed its stages in this House in September and is now progressing through the other place. Raising the right-to-buy qualifying period from three to 10 years, capping discounts, exempting new builds for 35 years and introducing mandatory eight-week disposal notices will finally stem the net loss of irreplaceable social homes. Paired with stronger protections for victims of domestic abuse and a statutory duty to collaborate on homelessness prevention, the legislative framework is moving decisively in the right direction. However, as I have said, my experience from nearly 20 years in the sector tells me that funding and legislation alone do not build homes; delivery capacity does. Right now, housing associations are ready, agile and far better equipped to respond quickly to meet the Government’s ambitious targets, as we have already heard from the noble Lords, Lord Stoneham and Lord Best, and the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick. By contrast, it will take a considerable time for many local authorities to step up at scale, simply because, over the past 15 years, so many councils have seen their in-house housing and development departments hollowed out. We must back housing associations to lead the immediate charge while giving councils the time and support to rebuild their technical capacity. We must also look squarely at planning and land supply, an issue raised by other noble Lords. Across the country, too many private developers are sitting on land banks with existing planning permissions, waiting for market conditions to shift. Especially now, amid a noticeable downturn in commercial developments, the Government need to do much more to encourage and, where necessary, compel developers to build out consented sites immediately, or to partner with social housing providers so that we can get spades in the ground. At the same time, we cannot build 300,000 affordable homes, or retrofit millions, without the workforce to do it. We need far more innovative thinking around bringing young people who are not in education, employment or training into structured apprenticeships in the construction and green retrofit sectors. We also need to stress to all our housing partners to take on not only NEETs but also new graduates, in the same way that I was given an opportunity by a local authority when I became a new graduate. It was not just a job; the authority supported me to undertake the three-year Institute of Housing qualifications that meant I was able to go on and run two housing associations. Doing this means that we will turn an acute labour shortage into a genuine pathway to skilled, secure careers. We also know that the headline targets can mask sharp regional disparities both in where new homes are built and in the condition of the existing stock. Taking the West Midlands as a clear example, across the region more than 65,000 households sit on waiting lists and over 7,400 families are living in temporary accommodation. Devolution is beginning to make a real difference. Through the West Midlands Combined Authority, over £400 million was released in August as the first tranche of a £1.7 billion regional social and affordable homes programme, aiming to deliver 2,000 social rent homes per year by 2028. We can already see what targeted investment unlocks in cities such as Coventry, where brownfield schemes such as Spon End and Spirit Quarters are replacing outdated estates with modern affordable housing, and in Birmingham, where developments such as Port Loop are delivering zero-carbon-ready homes alongside major council stock reinvestment. The West Midlands also illustrates the sheer scale and cost of legacy stock conditions. Across England, roughly 430,000 social homes still fail the decent homes standard, and English Housing Survey modelling shows that the West Midlands has one of the highest regional rates of damp. In Birmingham, where overcrowding is more than double the national average and thousands of residents live in ageing Victorian terraces and post-war estates, an estimated 90,000 homes across the wider region fall below decent standards. With Awaab’s law now in force for social landlords—expanding this month to cover excess cold, structural hazards and electrical safety—providers in cities such as Birmingham, Coventry and Wolverhampton face a heavy capital bill to remediate existing homes without crowding out new supply. When we discuss addressing challenges in the housing market, we must also recognise that a healthy system requires a wide spectrum of housing provision, tailored to very different stages and circumstances of life. General needs social rent is the bedrock, of course: providing permanent, genuinely affordable security for working families and low-income households. But alongside that, intermediate tenures such as shared ownership remain an essential bridge for households priced out of outright purchase, forming a vital part of mixed-tenure regeneration across Midlands cities. Yet investment in shared ownership addresses market challenges only if the product is fair, transparent and sustainable. As scrutiny in this House has repeatedly highlighted, too many shared owners still face steep staircasing costs, escalating service charges, complex lease terms and real barriers to reaching full ownership, particularly where building safety or retrofit costs are passed on. Beyond general needs and intermediate housing, we cannot afford to overlook specialist and supported housing—something I have seen the vital importance of throughout my career. Care leavers stepping out into adult life for the first time, ex-offenders trying to break the cycle of reoffending to rebuild their lives, military veterans adjusting to civilian life, and homeless families stuck in unsuitable bed and breakfasts do not simply need four walls and a roof. They need tailored, supported accommodation with wraparound care. When we fail to invest in specialist housing, the costs simply shift elsewhere into our prisons, hospitals and overstretched children’s services, as my noble friend Lady Warwick eloquently underlined. Equally, we should be championing community-led housing, co-operative models and modern, well-managed, private build-to-rent schemes and raising standards across the board. I turn very quickly to zero-carbon homes. One of the biggest blind spots in our housing climate strategy sits at the intersection of ageing demographics and underoccupied family homes. According to the findings of the Older People’s Housing Taskforce, nearly nine in 10 people aged between 65 and 79 live in underoccupied homes, and more than half live in properties with two or more spare bedrooms. At the same time, Office for National Statistics analysis shows that heating drafty, poorly insulated, large family homes is carbon intensive and financially punishing for people on fixed pensions. I will quickly move on to sum up and ask the Minister a couple of questions. First, on regional equity and stock condition, how will the Government ensure that funding under the social and affordable homes programme and the warm homes plan balances the urgent need to remediate older, damp social stock in cities such as Birmingham and Coventry without slowing down new-build delivery there or in high-cost areas such as London and the south? Secondly, on supporting older people to downsize into warmer, manageable homes, what practical incentives, specialist housing supply and safe equity release or rightsizing schemes are the Government putting in place to help older people?
Baroness Thornhill (LD)
Well, my Lords, we might not have had the quantity of speakers that other debates have had, but we have certainly had the quality—that is how we pronounce it in Watford. All contributions have been wide-ranging, compassionate and informed—and perhaps at times controversial. I, too, thank my noble friend Lord Stoneham for securing this important and timely debate. As ever, he brings his passion, persistence and experience to one of the defining challenges that face our community and our country. Before turning to the debate itself, I warmly congratulate my noble friend Lord Petterson on an excellent maiden speech. I first met him about a year ago at a Centrepoint project in Peckham, where we were both looking at support for young homeless people. His enthusiasm and compassion for the situation those youngsters were in shone through. He spoke today with experience and insight, particularly about the relationship between housing and our net-zero ambitions—and we are ambitious. Too often, when we discuss housing, energy and sustainability, we regard them as separate, competing issues, when in reality they are deeply intertwined. The homes we build must be affordable not only to rent and buy but to heat and live in. I look forward to the noble Lord’s future contributions. I also greatly enjoyed the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, whose maiden speech reminded us that this House is continually strengthened by new voices and fresh perspectives. I loved the extraordinary story of his family history, which I am sure in some ways has motivated him to be where he is today. Today’s debate has reminded us that housing is what policy wonks call a “wicked” issue. Every part of the system affects every other. I was reminded of Eric Morecambe’s comment to André Previn that he was indeed playing all the right notes but not necessarily in the right order. Housing policy can feel a bit like that. Planning matters. Investment matters. Housing associations are indispensable. Local government is pivotal. Good regulation is critical. Net-zero homes matter. Social housing matters. Shared ownership matters. The question is not whether these are the right notes but whether they are working together to produce the outcome that we all want, which is people living in good-quality homes that they can genuinely afford. We have heard different perspectives on that challenge from noble Lords, and I expected nothing less. The noble Lord, Lord Best, echoes many of us when he urges the Government just to get on with it. I particularly agree with the warning from the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, about councils’ ability to step up quickly enough. The insights of my noble friend Lord Dixon of Jericho, having worked at the sharp end of the housing crisis, have reminded us that homelessness probably deserves a debate in its own right. We are dealing with some of the most vulnerable people in our society and yet too often we seem more willing to fund crises rather than prevention. My own perspective is inevitably shaped by many years in local government, as is that of many other noble Lords here. Every Friday afternoon, there would be people arriving at the council’s one-stop shop carrying everything they owned in suitcases, rucksacks and carrier bags, and all too often carrying crying children as well. You knew immediately that they had reached the end of the road. They were not statistics or entries in a homelessness return; they were people who simply had nowhere else to go. That experience never leaves you. Usually, they ended up in a B&B and were then moved on to “temporary” accommodation, some of it lasting years and the realities of which I think we are all familiar with. I believe the situation with temporary accommodation is almost a marker for the wider health of the housing system. Every council leader knows this story. More and more local authority resources are absorbed by managing the housing crisis rather than preventing it. Money that could be spent on prevention, regeneration, local services or future supply is increasingly spent on coping with immediate need. In many ways, and this is shocking, the most expensive housing in the country is often the housing we never intended to provide and we wish we did not have to. Perhaps the real question is not whether public money is being spent on housing—with this Government it clearly is; the question is whether we are investing enough in long-term solutions that reduce those pressures in the future. We often talk about social housing as a cost to the public purse. Of course it is, but increasingly I think we should see it as social infrastructure. We do not expect roads, schools or flood defences to pay for themselves. We invest in them because of the wider value they create. Good social housing should be viewed in the same way. It reduces pressure elsewhere in the system, strengthens communities and helps prevent the housing crises that councils are increasingly having to manage. We often talk about what social housing costs. We spend less time talking about what not building it costs, yet several noble Lords have mentioned eye-watering figures this afternoon. That means recognising that if we want more genuinely affordable homes, public subsidy will always remain part of the answer. The Minister will rightly point to the significant investment now committed to housing, and we on these Benches welcome that. Perhaps the challenge before us is no longer simply investment—though the sector always says “more, please”—but delivery. Homes are not built by ministerial announcements; they are built by institutions with the confidence, capacity, confidence and capability to deliver. Housing associations sit at the heart of that challenge. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, and the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe, made that case particularly powerfully today. We ask housing associations to improve existing homes, meet higher safety standards, strengthen consumer protections, tackle damp and mould, decarbonise their stock and build new homes. These are all important objectives, but have we been honest enough about their cumulative impact on the sector’s capacity to build? Some of the criticism of some housing associations from the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, was accurate, but I felt there were far too many sweeping statements, as many of our housing associations are doing a very good job. At the same time, we are also, rightly, encouraging local authorities to build again, and government is looking to a wider range of delivery partners. I am sure the Minister will not be surprised to hear me say that we should also be doing everything we can to bring more SME builders to play a larger role. Given the scale of the housing challenge, we will need every capable organisation doing its bit. Can the Minister reassure the House that housing associations remain central to the Government’s ambitions and tell us what steps are being taken to provide the confidence, financial resilience and long-term certainty needed for them to continue investing and building at scale? My heart sank when I saw a debate title containing the words “shared ownership” with a speakers’ list that did not include the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, although I am pleased to see that he is in his place. Fortunately, the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, and the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, stepped into that vacancy—the latter with a very different style. Too often, social rent and shared ownership are presented as competing priorities for finance; I do not believe they are, and they certainly should not be. Social rent remains indispensable for those on the lowest income and for those unable to access the housing market at all. Shared ownership serves a different but equally important purpose. For many working households, it remains one of the few realistic routes between renting indefinitely and owning outright. Can the Minister therefore say a little more about the Government’s long-term vision for shared ownership and the role it will play within the wider affordable housing programme? I do not think anybody in this House believes there is a single lever that will solve the housing crisis. The Government are right to pull on many levers, but the challenge is ensuring that they are pulling together and that the institutions expected to deliver change have the capacity to do so. The Government are reforming planning, and we are all watching that space. They are investing in affordable housing—noble Lords have mentioned the speed at which the money is coming out the door from Homes England. The Government are supporting local authority delivery, but we have concerns about when that will kick in. They are strengthening regulation and expanding the number of organisations expected to contribute to supply. But how will the Government define success? We all want to see more homes built, but the test is not simply how many homes we build; it is whether there are fewer people sleeping rough, fewer children growing up in temporary accommodation and more families able to access a secure and genuinely affordable home. Building more homes clearly matters, but so does building the right homes, in the right places, with the right affordability and the right mix of tenures. The challenge is making sure that all the right notes are played together at the right time, otherwise we risk never quite playing in tune. While we continue to debate how the orchestra should be arranged, too many families are still waiting for somewhere safe, secure and affordable to call home. I look forward to the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, and to the Minister’s response.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, and I shall be playing the same notes but not necessarily in the same order. I too congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm and Lord Petterson, on their excellent maiden speeches. I really enjoyed their back stories. It shows what a great country we are that people can come from such difficult backgrounds, be welcomed here and succeed. Also, we cannot have enough engineers, and I am glad that we have another one of us here. I have to declare my interest as a councillor in Central Bedfordshire. I was also previously on the board of a housing association. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford, for securing this important debate. I think we can all agree—I am almost going to pick notes from the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill—that we need the right homes in the right places, with the right infrastructure, available at the right time. I am not sure that we are doing that as a country. Investment in social housing, shared ownership and zero-carbon homes undoubtedly has a role to play. Across the House, we have pretty much all identified the problems. We may have variations on what we think are the right solutions. That is the great thing about this House: we bring a variety of expertise from different people and perspectives to solve the problems, and there is no one unanimous and single route to doing that. I will address the fundamental problem: we are in a housing crisis. Homes are simply unaffordable, whether that is to buy or rent. A private renter is typically paying around 30% of their income on rent. The average first-time buyer is now 34, whereas they were 29 in the 1990s. As I think the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, mentioned earlier, in the ONS GDP report, private housing construction was down 4.7% in the last quarter. Housing numbers are not an abstract statistical issue. Access to a safe, secure home at a cost they can afford is crucial for families and individuals. It is the bedrock of society and successful communities, yet, as others have mentioned, there are 1.34 million people on council waiting lists and 134,000 households in temporary accommodation, and those households include 178,000 children, which is up 5% in a year. Rough sleeping, despite the Prime Minister’s commitment, hit its highest level of 8,748 across the month of June this year. This is not just an economic failure; it is a moral failure. We on these Benches support the Government’s commitment to end rough sleeping and deliver 1.5 million homes. Unfortunately, the Government are on track to deliver fewer than the 1 million homes under the previous Conservative Government, and I worry that they will not achieve their commitment on rough sleeping. We need to get serious if we are to address the UK’s housing crisis. Fundamentally, we do not have enough homes relative to our population. The Centre for Cities estimates a shortfall of 4.3 million homes compared to the European average. Not only do we have a shortage; as other noble Lords have mentioned, our housing stock is older, less energy efficient and less suited to modern needs. Under the previous Conservative Government, the delivery of affordable homes almost doubled between 2015 and 2023 to 64,000 a year. Since then, it has stalled, and we are now being told by housing associations that they do not have the resources to buy Section 106 housing, never mind develop their own. As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, mentioned, it is a viability issue for housing associations and councils. The Government have been trumpeting their now £40.5 billion social and affordable housing programme for nearly two years, but announcements are not delivery. Many have mentioned the need to get on with it. I understand that not one home has been completed and occupied under this programme, so—not for the first time—I ask the Minister: how many homes will be completed and occupied under this programme by July 2029? There is a key role for social housing to address the need for specialist and supported accommodation, as mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, among others. Supporting the elderly, those downsizing, those with disabilities and the vulnerable, such as care leavers and prison leavers, will not only improve lives but will reduce the cost to the estate. While I was leader of Central Bedfordshire, we started a programme of building supported housing for the elderly and those with disabilities. I could go on all night with the wonderful stories of how that changed people’s lives but I do not have time. From a financial perspective we estimated that each new apartment saved the council around £2,000 a year on social care costs. A similar amount was saved to the NHS. The Minister, while leader of Stevenage, kindly came and visited one of our schemes. I thank her for her positive response to the taskforce on older people’s accommodation, of which I was previously a member. It is disappointing that the Government’s Social Housing Bill sought to restrict right to buy. As discussed in the passage of the Bill, not only will this deprive many of the opportunity to own their own home but, as the Government’s own impact assessment showed, it will result in thousands fewer social homes being built every year from the proceeds of sales. That is fewer opportunities to build specialist accommodation and fewer opportunities for people to get off council waiting lists. We cannot solve a housing shortage without increasing supply, yet buyers are unable to afford higher prices due to the increased cost of mortgages and other household expenses such as energy and council tax. In many areas, however, it is increasingly unviable for developers to build, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford. A recent CPS report estimated that around 58% of the cost of a new two-bedroom flat in Camden is due to government and mayoral regulations and levies. That is £442,000 out of £775,000. While the situation is better outside London, without the additional mayoral obligations, the estimated cost of a three-bedroom home in Chelmsford is still £224,000 out of a £535,000 delivery cost. It is not surprising that housebuilding is reducing. London has an assessed need of 88,000 homes per year, yet analysis from Molior showed only 754 starts in the last two months: a staggering 96% drop since 2016. Major housebuilders such as Barratt and Berkeley are leaving the market or no longer seeking new sites in London. I do not believe the cure to viability is subsidy, as some noble Lords have suggested; rather, it is to tackle the underlying problems of costs. That is why the Conservative Party have proposed cutting £50,000 from the cost of building a new home by reducing unnecessary regulation and taxation and having a single infrastructure levy. The Government must reduce barriers to construction, rather than simply announcing ever higher targets that cannot be delivered. There is also the issue of where homes should be built. It has not been mentioned today, but there seems to be a general agreement that “brownfield first” is the right policy, but that will not happen if sites are unviable. As the CPS analysis showed, the cost of regulation and levies is greater on brownfield sites in London. What future plans do this Government have to improve the viability of brownfield sites in places such as London and other cities? I turn to shared ownership, which has been mentioned by a number of noble Lords, particularly the noble Baroness, Lady Gill. In principle this is a good scheme to enable more people to access their own home, but it is not working in practice. In the other place, my honourable friend Gareth Bacon rightly described shared ownership as a “logistical, legal and financial nightmare ”.—[ Official Report , Commons, 10/9/26; col. 1265.] My noble friend Lord Fuller raised many of the same issues I would about increasing service charges, substantial maintenance liabilities, costly barriers to purchasing, additional equity and the fact that the equity owner has a much weaker hand. We should not be trapping people in arrangements where costs continue to rise but opportunities remain limited. This is particularly true for those impacted by fire and safety issues. I am pleased that my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham is here; he raised this in the Social Housing Bill. We must do something to help those trapped in houses that they can neither sell nor live in. Can the Minister explain what steps the Government are taking to ensure that shared ownership works for the shared equity owners, and whether they have set measurable milestones to do so? Before I finish, I must also address the role of zero-carbon homes. The future homes standard, by requiring new builds to adhere to costly energy-efficient standards, delays the delivery of homes and makes some unviable. It also limits the ability of developers to build beautiful homes, with features such as sash windows effectively banned. Can the Minister explain what assessment the Government have made of the impact of the future homes standard on construction costs and design flexibility, and how they intend to ensure that these additional requirements do not further undermine their already struggling housebuilding targets? Social housing, shared ownership and zero-carbon homes have a role to play in combating the scale of today’s housing shortage, but, ultimately, the success of any housing policy must be measured not by promises made or money announced but by the homes that are delivered and occupied.
The Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State, Ministry of Housing, Communities and Local Government (Baroness Taylor of Stevenage) (Lab)
My Lords, before I respond to this debate, I am afraid that I have to mention a very tragic incident that occurred in Bradford this afternoon, where an independent councillor was stabbed while out canvassing. I am sure the whole House wishes Councillor Ibrar Ali a speedy recovery. Our thoughts are with all those in Bradford who are affected by this awful incident. I am sorry to have to start on that note. I am pleased to respond for the Government on this very important issue. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford, for securing today’s debate and particularly for giving me a welcome break from election policy. I also thank all noble Lords who have contributed. We had two excellent maiden speeches this afternoon, including that from my noble friend Lord Davey of Chalk Farm. I say to my noble friend that my grandfather was also a Conservative, so we share that in common. My noble friend told a wonderful story of his grandfather’s escape across snowy ground and the courage that was shown, and the place that it led his family to in this country. It was genuinely heartwarming. I thank my noble friend for all the work he did in his many years of leading at the Roundhouse, and for the work that that institution has done for our young people. I am so grateful to him for that. I appreciated the comment from the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, about taking on and reviving institutions that have fallen on hard times. We all have experience of that, not least in the political spectrum. I was fascinated by the speech from the noble Lord, Lord Petterson. When he came into this House, it was very interesting to know that he had been at the Thomas Alleyne school. As the noble Lord may know, this week we have been celebrating our 80th birthday in Stevenage, but the Thomas Alleyne school traces its roots back to 1558, which just shows that, while we are a new town, we have some very deep roots. The other thing I share with the noble Lord is his roots in Walthamstow: my dad’s side of the family come from that area. I liked his points about our radical Government and what we are doing on the care sector, NEETs and housing. I was beginning to think the noble Lord was almost perfect in every way, until the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, told me that he is a Spurs fan, but nobody is perfect. I thank the noble Lord for a very powerful maiden speech, which we all enjoyed. I do not want to misquote him, but I think one of the lines in his speech was: “rebuilding our social housing stock is the best and most progressive way forward”. As a passionate advocate for social housing, I could not agree more. At its heart, this debate is about a fundamental question: how we build a housing system that provides people with the safe, secure and affordable homes they need, while creating a housing market capable of meeting the needs of future generations. The housing market challenges we face are deep-rooted. Too many people cannot afford a secure home. Too many families remain in temporary accommodation, as many noble Lords have said. It is an absolute scandal to see 170,000 families in temporary and emergency accommodation. For too many young people, the dream of home ownership feels out of their reach. As a councillor, I have had exactly the experience that the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, outlined. Every time I held a surgery, an awful lot of the problems I dealt with were to do with housing. This Government remain committed to their ambition to deliver 1.5 million safe and decent homes during this Parliament. My Secretary of State has repeated that. But success cannot be measured by a national number alone. We have to build the right mix of homes in the places where they are needed, supported by infrastructure and services and affordable to the people who live there, and of course working with local communities as we do so. As passionate as I am about devolution, I simply do not believe we can deliver this without giving local people—councillors, housing associations and local residents—the powers and funding to deliver against this housing need. We know that the housing market has become more difficult, but the answer cannot be to give up on building. That is why we will pull every lever at the Government’s disposal to support delivery: from ambitious planning reforms, unlocking stalled sites, supporting councils and housing associations to build and making a record £40 billion investment in social and affordable housing. We are absolutely committed to this. I know that many noble Lords will have heard the Prime Minister make his personal commitment not just to housing but to tackling homelessness and rough sleeping. We understand that the scale of this challenge is significant. The shortage has contributed to rising house prices and rents. At the same time, the conditions for building the homes we need have become increasingly difficult. Rising construction costs, shortage of skilled workers and capacity constraints are all making delivery more challenging. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, referred to the cost of temporary and emergency housing, never mind the costs to those who experience the housing crisis at first hand. The cost is very significant. In my own area, if you are in a house that was bought under right to buy and is now privately rented, and you are on benefits, the cost of those benefits will be twice as much as the cost would be if you were in social housing. That is why we put housing supply at the heart of our Government’s manifesto and that commitment is starting to pay off. Estimated new-build starts reached more than 136,000 in the year to June 2026, an increase of 15% on the previous year. That shows we are moving in the right direction, and we are determined to build on that momentum to deliver the homes this country needs. I have seen some incredible developments around the country. Peabody has built 189 passive house affordable homes at Deptford Landings in Lewisham, 130 of which are for social rent. That is a fantastic development. I was up in Liverpool a couple of weeks ago. There is a magnificent scheme for the north docks: 17,700 new homes are being built, we hope with a development corporation. An application has been made for a development corporation there. In my own area of Stevenage, we are building 91 independent living apartments with Bugler Homes in a comprehensive regeneration scheme with new shops, a church, community centre, et cetera. As we know, investment is central to achieving that ambition, but it is not simply about spending more, as the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, very powerfully said. It is about using public investment to unlock the infrastructure, capacity, skills and private finance needed to deliver homes at scale and support a resilient housing market. My noble friend Lady Warwick referred to the National Housing Bank, launched in April. The bank is backed by £16 billion and is expected to unlock £53 billion of private investment, supporting the delivery of more than 500,000 homes. We want to mobilise that funding as quickly as possible and work is going on at pace to do that. Alongside that, our National Housing Delivery Fund is providing around £5 billion of capital grant funding for infrastructure, land assembly, remediation and viability support. This will unlock housing delivery across the country. We are also investing in the workforce needed to build those homes. The Government are spending more than £600 million on construction skills and £2.5 billion through the youth guarantee and the growth and skills levy. This will help recruit up to 60,000 additional construction workers by 2029. My noble friend Lady Gill rightly referred to the fact that, as we go through the process of working on the Milburn review, we must also get those NEETs employed in the construction industry and to be engineers—I look to the noble Lord, Lord Petterson. As noble Lords have rightly highlighted today, overall supply is only one part of the answer. We must also ensure that we are delivering the homes that people can afford and with a level of energy efficiency that helps people with their cost of living and works towards to our carbon-neutral ambition. That is why the Government have made a generational commitment to social and affordable housing. The social and affordable homes programme represents the largest long-term investment in social and affordable housing in a generation. Following the additional £1.5 billion announced at the Budget, as noble Lords have mentioned, the programme now exceeds £40 billion. We are already turning that investment into delivery. In August, we confirmed nearly £10 billion in allocations to 33 strategic partners working with Homes England, supporting the delivery of over 70,000 homes. I will come on to the issues around housing associations in a moment. Investment must also be accompanied by action to protect the social homes we already have, as my noble friend Lady Gill said. Our Social Housing Bill will reform right to buy so that it provides a fair route into home ownership for long-standing tenants, while protecting much-needed social housing stock. The noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, queried this Bill; I know that we had many discussions during its passage, but it is important that councils have the confidence to build council housing stock. Councils will now retain 100% of right-to-buy receipts with greater flexibility to invest those receipts in replacement homes, and newly built social homes will be protected from sale for 35 years. Our analysis suggests that the overall package of reforms will result in a net gain of around 18,000 social homes over 10 years. Regarding regulation, I say to the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, that I make no apology for wanting homes to be safe and warm. It was the Conservatives who abandoned the local authority building control process, with somewhat devastating consequences. It is really important that, where we need regulation, we have it. If we need it to keep homes safe and warm, we should do that.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
I want to be absolutely clear: we on these Benches want safe homes. We would never advocate anything other than safe homes. I am slightly offended that anybody would imply that we would not.
Baroness Taylor of Stevenage (Lab)
I am sure that that is the case, but we get constant criticism about regulation and I think we all need to understand that we do not put in regulation for the sake of it; we put it in to protect people and make sure that their homes are safe.
Lord Jamieson (Con)
We had a debate on this on the Budget and I raised questions such as whether we need dual-aspect housing and to mandate balconies. I do not believe that those are critical safety features, as examples.
Baroness Taylor of Stevenage (Lab)
If the noble Lord had spoken to the lady I spoke to in Camden during the recent by-election there, whose son died because a balcony on a flat collapsed, I think he would understand the need for regulation in that area. We also recognise the important role that shared ownership can play. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Young—I am pleased to see him in his place—for his efforts and advocacy on behalf of shared owners. I thank him for the work that he has done with me and my right honourable friend the Housing Minister to make some necessary changes to the Social Housing Bill. For many households who cannot afford to purchase a suitable home on the open market, shared ownership provides an alternative route to home ownership. We recognise the concerns raised that the tenure does not always work as well as it should for consumers, which is why we have begun a phased programme of improvements to make shared ownership fairer, more transparent, more affordable over the long term and easier to navigate. The first phase is already being delivered through the new social and affordable homes programme, including stronger expectations on providers to consider customers’ long-term affordability and improve the transparency and fairness of costs. The next phase will consider barriers to staircasing, how we can better support resales and how existing buyback arrangements are working. Alongside that, we are improving service charge transparency and giving shared owners a statutory right to extend their leases. I take the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, about service charges. I heard a case myself this week of a deceased woman whose family was still being charged very excessive service charges while trying to sort out quite a complicated probate situation. Finally, increasing housing supply cannot come at the expense of our ambitions for warmer, greener and more efficient homes. The noble Lord, Lord Petterson, raised this issue. The homes we build now will still be standing for generations. We therefore have an opportunity, and a responsibility, to get them right from the outset, which I think is the point that the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, was making. Our future homes and buildings standards will ensure that new homes have high levels of energy efficiency, low-carbon heating and, in most cases, solar panels. The new standards will come into force in March 2027. Taking action when homes are built is both more cost-effective and less disruptive than having to retrofit them later. As my noble friend Lady Gill said, we must improve the homes people already live in. Through the warm homes plan, we will support up to 5 million homes by 2030, prioritising measures including rooftop solar, clean heating, energy storage and insulation, while protecting the vast majority of funding directed towards low-income households and social housing. I give a nod to the fantastic green skills centre that has been developed in Peterborough, which is training our young people to deliver some of these technologies. I am sure that other green skills centres are available, but that is the one I have been to visit. Today, my right honourable friend the Housing Minister introduced the Commonhold and Leasehold Reform Bill in the other place to finally bring the feudal leasehold system to an end. I do not have time to go into the details of that today; it is a mammoth Bill. I look forward to debating it with noble Lords, probably at length, in due course. I have written to all noble Lords today setting out the basic principles behind the Bill. A number of noble Lords raised issues around homelessness and rough sleeping. The noble Lords, Lord Stoneham, Lord Dixon and Lord Jamieson, all spoke about this, as did my noble friend Lady Warwick. A secure and affordable home is absolutely the foundation on which people build their lives. That is why we must tackle homelessness and rough sleeping. We launched an £874 million rough sleeping programme, taking our total investment in tackling homelessness and rough sleeping to more than £4.4 billion over the next three years—a record level of funding. This programme combines urgent action with a longer-term solution, and that is the important thing about it. It will provide an immediate route off the streets, alongside settled accommodation and that intensive support that we know rough sleepers will need to get back into a settled lifestyle. By investing in prevention and providing accommodation, alongside increasing the number of social homes, we are taking action across the system to ensure that more people have the security of a safe, decent and affordable home. As the noble Lord, Lord Dixon, said, you cannot start the rest of your life until you have a stable home to live in. A number of noble Lords raised housing associations. I absolutely understand that housing associations have a critical role to play in delivering the social and affordable homes our country needs. Over the last decade, they have delivered around 80% of new social and affordable housing. But we recognise that many providers face financial pressures. They are investing in the safety, quality and energy efficiency of their existing homes while managing higher financing and development costs to build the next generation of housing. That is why our approach is not simply to provide more grants but to rebuild the sector’s long-term capacity to borrow and invest. This includes a 10-year rent settlement and social rent convergence from April 2027, giving providers greater certainty over future income and a stronger basis on which to make long-term investment decisions. We have also committed over £1 billion to support cladding remediation for social landlords, ensuring equal access to building safety funds. On the social and affordable homes programme, which has been mentioned many times this afternoon, the core strategy of the programme is to maximise supply, particularly of social rent homes, with a target to deliver at least 60% of the homes in the programme as social rent. We have already made significant strides in kick-starting that delivery, as I set out. Noble Lords were concerned about housing association funding. I stress that Homes England is open for bids as part of its continuous market engagement funding route. It is allocating money and potential bidders should reach out to it. There is around £17 billion of funding outside London and £5 billion in London still to allocate. This includes funding in each year of the spending review. The Government will prioritise social rented homes and, in particular but not exclusively, council housing to achieve the Prime Minister’s ambition for a council housing boom, but we encourage providers to come forward with their bids. On first-time buyers and home ownership, we have addressed the issues in the review of the Help to Buy scheme as we have drawn together our new scheme, Your First Home. In the Autumn Budget, we confirmed the £4.7 billion, as was mentioned, for Your First Home, a new equity loan scheme that will enable eligible first-time buyers to purchase a participating new-build home with a deposit of at least 2.5%. We expect it to help around 70,000 households to purchase their first home. We are introducing a new first-time buyer ISA, and these measures form part of our commitment to make home ownership a realistic prospect for more people. The road map for buying and selling, which we are about to introduce, will speed up and simplify the process to make it more straightforward. I hope all that helps to boost the market. There is no single intervention that will resolve the challenges in our housing market. To pick up the challenges from the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, and the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, we need more homes, and more social and affordable homes, credible routes into home ownership, and to ensure that the homes we build today are fit for the future. Investment is what joins those ambitions together. Through more than £40 billion for the social and affordable homes programme, the National Housing Bank, the national housing delivery fund and our wider reforms to planning, skills and housing standards, we are putting in place investment and the right conditions for a housing market that delivers more homes across a greater range of tenures in the places where people need them. That is the long-term task before us. It will require partnership between the Government, councils, mayors, housing associations, developers, investors and communities across the country. To pick up the musical analogy from the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, this needs an orchestra to deliver it, not a soloist. We have made significant progress, but we recognise that there is much more to do. I therefore thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, once again for bringing this important matter before the House, and I thank all noble Lords for their thoughtful contributions.
Lord Stoneham of Droxford (LD)
My Lords, I thank everyone who took part in the debate, and join the Minister in her thoughts on what has happened in Bradford this afternoon. It has been an excellent debate, a key feature of which has been the maiden speeches, on which I congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Davey and Lord Petterson. Combining the remarkable industrial architecture of the Roundhouse with its vibrant art centre, as was described by the noble Lord, Lord Davey, is quite a remarkable achievement. We are going to benefit from the noble Lord’s contributions to this House. Culture and the arts are so important to the economy and our nation; we are very good at them, so we should be doing more. The noble Lord, Lord Petterson, is a valued addition to our ranks. I am glad we have another energy expert in our midst. It took some persuading from me for him to talk about Thanet being the biggest windfarm of its kind at the time, until the Chinese took over—I did not know the last fact—which is a remarkable achievement. He is going to be a major force in the House, tackling some of our important energy issues. The noble Lord reminded us of the need for energy-efficient housing. On a poignant note, one of my colleagues reminded us that, in 2014, our late lamented Lord Andrew Stunell developed a scheme for zero-carbon housing standards. That was accepted by the Government at the time, but sadly abandoned the following year, after the general election. We have had 10 years without that. I am very glad to have had support from the noble Lord, Lord Best, and the noble Baronesses, Lady Thornhill and Lady Warwick, who basically said, “Get on with it”, that they were enthusiastic, and to use every lever you can to get us there. The noble Lord, Lord Fuller, certainly reminded us not to be complacent. Both councils and housing associations have scope to improve their performance, and should do, but we should also make sure that the poor performers learn from the better and best practice of others. I was very pleased to have the contributions of the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, and the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, particularly talking about our need to prepare for an ageing society, and their remarks on shared ownership. The noble Lord, Lord Dixon, referred to the importance of local focus to get support for housing. I think I have covered everybody who spoke in the debate—I hope I have—and I am very grateful to them for doing so. I thank the Minister for her contribution and commitment; we are very lucky to have her in post at this time. I liked the phrase “every lever at the Government’s disposal”, and the “orchestra” that the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, referred to, to get us to our goal. I end by referencing the speech of the noble Lord, Lord Petterson, who recalled Field-Marshal Blücher as one of his heroes. With all due deference to our normal hero, Wellington—the cold, calculating Wellington, as I would describe him—it was good to have the passion, energy and bravery of Blücher to win Waterloo. It is passion, energy and persistence that we now need in the world of social housing. I beg to move.
Motion agreed.
House adjourned at 5.15 pm.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441473.