B

Baroness Thornhill (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Housing Market

Contribution

Well, my Lords, we might not have had the quantity of speakers that other debates have had, but we have certainly had the quality—that is how we pronounce it in Watford. All contributions have been wide-ranging, compassionate and informed—and perhaps at times controversial. I, too, thank my noble friend Lord Stoneham for securing this important and timely debate. As ever, he brings his passion, persistence and experience to one of the defining challenges that face our community and our country. Before turning to the debate itself, I warmly congratulate my noble friend Lord Petterson on an excellent maiden speech. I first met him about a year ago at a Centrepoint project in Peckham, where we were both looking at support for young homeless people. His enthusiasm and compassion for the situation those youngsters were in shone through. He spoke today with experience and insight, particularly about the relationship between housing and our net-zero ambitions—and we are ambitious. Too often, when we discuss housing, energy and sustainability, we regard them as separate, competing issues, when in reality they are deeply intertwined. The homes we build must be affordable not only to rent and buy but to heat and live in. I look forward to the noble Lord’s future contributions. I also greatly enjoyed the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, whose maiden speech reminded us that this House is continually strengthened by new voices and fresh perspectives. I loved the extraordinary story of his family history, which I am sure in some ways has motivated him to be where he is today. Today’s debate has reminded us that housing is what policy wonks call a “wicked” issue. Every part of the system affects every other. I was reminded of Eric Morecambe’s comment to André Previn that he was indeed playing all the right notes but not necessarily in the right order. Housing policy can feel a bit like that. Planning matters. Investment matters. Housing associations are indispensable. Local government is pivotal. Good regulation is critical. Net-zero homes matter. Social housing matters. Shared ownership matters. The question is not whether these are the right notes but whether they are working together to produce the outcome that we all want, which is people living in good-quality homes that they can genuinely afford. We have heard different perspectives on that challenge from noble Lords, and I expected nothing less. The noble Lord, Lord Best, echoes many of us when he urges the Government just to get on with it. I particularly agree with the warning from the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, about councils’ ability to step up quickly enough. The insights of my noble friend Lord Dixon of Jericho, having worked at the sharp end of the housing crisis, have reminded us that homelessness probably deserves a debate in its own right. We are dealing with some of the most vulnerable people in our society and yet too often we seem more willing to fund crises rather than prevention. My own perspective is inevitably shaped by many years in local government, as is that of many other noble Lords here. Every Friday afternoon, there would be people arriving at the council’s one-stop shop carrying everything they owned in suitcases, rucksacks and carrier bags, and all too often carrying crying children as well. You knew immediately that they had reached the end of the road. They were not statistics or entries in a homelessness return; they were people who simply had nowhere else to go. That experience never leaves you. Usually, they ended up in a B&B and were then moved on to “temporary” accommodation, some of it lasting years and the realities of which I think we are all familiar with. I believe the situation with temporary accommodation is almost a marker for the wider health of the housing system. Every council leader knows this story. More and more local authority resources are absorbed by managing the housing crisis rather than preventing it. Money that could be spent on prevention, regeneration, local services or future supply is increasingly spent on coping with immediate need. In many ways, and this is shocking, the most expensive housing in the country is often the housing we never intended to provide and we wish we did not have to. Perhaps the real question is not whether public money is being spent on housing—with this Government it clearly is; the question is whether we are investing enough in long-term solutions that reduce those pressures in the future. We often talk about social housing as a cost to the public purse. Of course it is, but increasingly I think we should see it as social infrastructure. We do not expect roads, schools or flood defences to pay for themselves. We invest in them because of the wider value they create. Good social housing should be viewed in the same way. It reduces pressure elsewhere in the system, strengthens communities and helps prevent the housing crises that councils are increasingly having to manage. We often talk about what social housing costs. We spend less time talking about what not building it costs, yet several noble Lords have mentioned eye-watering figures this afternoon. That means recognising that if we want more genuinely affordable homes, public subsidy will always remain part of the answer. The Minister will rightly point to the significant investment now committed to housing, and we on these Benches welcome that. Perhaps the challenge before us is no longer simply investment—though the sector always says “more, please”—but delivery. Homes are not built by ministerial announcements; they are built by institutions with the confidence, capacity, confidence and capability to deliver. Housing associations sit at the heart of that challenge. The noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, and the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe, made that case particularly powerfully today. We ask housing associations to improve existing homes, meet higher safety standards, strengthen consumer protections, tackle damp and mould, decarbonise their stock and build new homes. These are all important objectives, but have we been honest enough about their cumulative impact on the sector’s capacity to build? Some of the criticism of some housing associations from the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, was accurate, but I felt there were far too many sweeping statements, as many of our housing associations are doing a very good job. At the same time, we are also, rightly, encouraging local authorities to build again, and government is looking to a wider range of delivery partners. I am sure the Minister will not be surprised to hear me say that we should also be doing everything we can to bring more SME builders to play a larger role. Given the scale of the housing challenge, we will need every capable organisation doing its bit. Can the Minister reassure the House that housing associations remain central to the Government’s ambitions and tell us what steps are being taken to provide the confidence, financial resilience and long-term certainty needed for them to continue investing and building at scale? My heart sank when I saw a debate title containing the words “shared ownership” with a speakers’ list that did not include the noble Lord, Lord Young of Cookham, although I am pleased to see that he is in his place. Fortunately, the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, and the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, stepped into that vacancy—the latter with a very different style. Too often, social rent and shared ownership are presented as competing priorities for finance; I do not believe they are, and they certainly should not be. Social rent remains indispensable for those on the lowest income and for those unable to access the housing market at all. Shared ownership serves a different but equally important purpose. For many working households, it remains one of the few realistic routes between renting indefinitely and owning outright. Can the Minister therefore say a little more about the Government’s long-term vision for shared ownership and the role it will play within the wider affordable housing programme? I do not think anybody in this House believes there is a single lever that will solve the housing crisis. The Government are right to pull on many levers, but the challenge is ensuring that they are pulling together and that the institutions expected to deliver change have the capacity to do so. The Government are reforming planning, and we are all watching that space. They are investing in affordable housing—noble Lords have mentioned the speed at which the money is coming out the door from Homes England. The Government are supporting local authority delivery, but we have concerns about when that will kick in. They are strengthening regulation and expanding the number of organisations expected to contribute to supply. But how will the Government define success? We all want to see more homes built, but the test is not simply how many homes we build; it is whether there are fewer people sleeping rough, fewer children growing up in temporary accommodation and more families able to access a secure and genuinely affordable home. Building more homes clearly matters, but so does building the right homes, in the right places, with the right affordability and the right mix of tenures. The challenge is making sure that all the right notes are played together at the right time, otherwise we risk never quite playing in tune. While we continue to debate how the orchestra should be arranged, too many families are still waiting for somewhere safe, secure and affordable to call home. I look forward to the contribution of the noble Lord, Lord Jamieson, and to the Minister’s response.

More from Baroness Thornhill (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.