Contribution
My Lords, it is always a pleasure to follow the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, and I shall be playing the same notes but not necessarily in the same order.
I too congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm and Lord Petterson, on their excellent maiden speeches. I really enjoyed their back stories. It shows what a great country we are that people can come from such difficult backgrounds, be welcomed here and succeed. Also, we cannot have enough engineers, and I am glad that we have another one of us here. I have to declare my interest as a councillor in Central Bedfordshire. I was also previously on the board of a housing association.
I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford, for securing this important debate. I think we can all agree—I am almost going to pick notes from the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill—that we need the right homes in the right places, with the right infrastructure, available at the right time. I am not sure that we are doing that as a country. Investment in social housing, shared ownership and zero-carbon homes undoubtedly has a role to play. Across the House, we have pretty much all identified the problems. We may have variations on what we think are the right solutions. That is the great thing about this House: we bring a variety of expertise from different people and perspectives to solve the problems, and there is no one unanimous and single route to doing that.
I will address the fundamental problem: we are in a housing crisis. Homes are simply unaffordable, whether that is to buy or rent. A private renter is typically paying around 30% of their income on rent. The average first-time buyer is now 34, whereas they were 29 in the 1990s. As I think the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, mentioned earlier, in the ONS GDP report, private housing construction was down 4.7% in the last quarter.
Housing numbers are not an abstract statistical issue. Access to a safe, secure home at a cost they can afford is crucial for families and individuals. It is the bedrock of society and successful communities, yet, as others have mentioned, there are 1.34 million people on council waiting lists and 134,000 households in temporary accommodation, and those households include 178,000 children, which is up 5% in a year. Rough sleeping, despite the Prime Minister’s commitment, hit its highest level of 8,748 across the month of June this year.
This is not just an economic failure; it is a moral failure. We on these Benches support the Government’s commitment to end rough sleeping and deliver 1.5 million homes. Unfortunately, the Government are on track to deliver fewer than the 1 million homes under the previous Conservative Government, and I worry that they will not achieve their commitment on rough sleeping. We need to get serious if we are to address the UK’s housing crisis.
Fundamentally, we do not have enough homes relative to our population. The Centre for Cities estimates a shortfall of 4.3 million homes compared to the European average. Not only do we have a shortage; as other noble Lords have mentioned, our housing stock is older, less energy efficient and less suited to modern needs.
Under the previous Conservative Government, the delivery of affordable homes almost doubled between 2015 and 2023 to 64,000 a year. Since then, it has stalled, and we are now being told by housing associations that they do not have the resources to buy Section 106 housing, never mind develop their own. As the noble Baroness, Lady Thornhill, mentioned, it is a viability issue for housing associations and councils.
The Government have been trumpeting their now £40.5 billion social and affordable housing programme for nearly two years, but announcements are not delivery. Many have mentioned the need to get on with it. I understand that not one home has been completed and occupied under this programme, so—not for the first time—I ask the Minister: how many homes will be completed and occupied under this programme by July 2029?
There is a key role for social housing to address the need for specialist and supported accommodation, as mentioned by the noble Baroness, Lady Gill, among others. Supporting the elderly, those downsizing, those with disabilities and the vulnerable, such as care leavers and prison leavers, will not only improve lives but will reduce the cost to the estate. While I was leader of Central Bedfordshire, we started a programme of building supported housing for the elderly and those with disabilities. I could go on all night with the wonderful stories of how that changed people’s lives but I do not have time. From a financial perspective we estimated that each new apartment saved the council around £2,000 a year on social care costs. A similar amount was saved to the NHS. The Minister, while leader of Stevenage, kindly came and visited one of our schemes. I thank her for her positive response to the taskforce on older people’s accommodation, of which I was previously a member.
It is disappointing that the Government’s Social Housing Bill sought to restrict right to buy. As discussed in the passage of the Bill, not only will this deprive many of the opportunity to own their own home but, as the Government’s own impact assessment showed, it will result in thousands fewer social homes being built every year from the proceeds of sales. That is fewer opportunities to build specialist accommodation and fewer opportunities for people to get off council waiting lists.
We cannot solve a housing shortage without increasing supply, yet buyers are unable to afford higher prices due to the increased cost of mortgages and other household expenses such as energy and council tax. In many areas, however, it is increasingly unviable for developers to build, as mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford. A recent CPS report estimated that around 58% of the cost of a new two-bedroom flat in Camden is due to government and mayoral regulations and levies. That is £442,000 out of £775,000. While the situation is better outside London, without the additional mayoral obligations, the estimated cost of a three-bedroom home in Chelmsford is still £224,000 out of a £535,000 delivery cost. It is not surprising that housebuilding is reducing. London has an assessed need of 88,000 homes per year, yet analysis from Molior showed only 754 starts in the last two months: a staggering 96% drop since 2016. Major housebuilders such as Barratt and Berkeley are leaving the market or no longer seeking new sites in London.
I do not believe the cure to viability is subsidy, as some noble Lords have suggested; rather, it is to tackle the underlying problems of costs. That is why the Conservative Party have proposed cutting £50,000 from the cost of building a new home by reducing unnecessary regulation and taxation and having a single infrastructure levy. The Government must reduce barriers to construction, rather than simply announcing ever higher targets that cannot be delivered.
There is also the issue of where homes should be built. It has not been mentioned today, but there seems to be a general agreement that “brownfield first” is the right policy, but that will not happen if sites are unviable. As the CPS analysis showed, the cost of regulation and levies is greater on brownfield sites in London. What future plans do this Government have to improve the viability of brownfield sites in places such as London and other cities?
I turn to shared ownership, which has been mentioned by a number of noble Lords, particularly the noble Baroness, Lady Gill. In principle this is a good scheme to enable more people to access their own home, but it is not working in practice. In the other place, my honourable friend Gareth Bacon rightly described shared ownership as a
“logistical, legal and financial nightmare”.—[Official Report, Commons, 10/9/26; col. 1265.]
My noble friend Lord Fuller raised many of the same issues I would about increasing service charges, substantial maintenance liabilities, costly barriers to purchasing, additional equity and the fact that the equity owner has a much weaker hand. We should not be trapping people in arrangements where costs continue to rise but opportunities remain limited. This is particularly true for those impacted by fire and safety issues. I am pleased that my noble friend Lord Young of Cookham is here; he raised this in the Social Housing Bill. We must do something to help those trapped in houses that they can neither sell nor live in. Can the Minister explain what steps the Government are taking to ensure that shared ownership works for the shared equity owners, and whether they have set measurable milestones to do so?
Before I finish, I must also address the role of zero-carbon homes. The future homes standard, by requiring new builds to adhere to costly energy-efficient standards, delays the delivery of homes and makes some unviable. It also limits the ability of developers to build beautiful homes, with features such as sash windows effectively banned. Can the Minister explain what assessment the Government have made of the impact of the future homes standard on construction costs and design flexibility, and how they intend to ensure that these additional requirements do not further undermine their already struggling housebuilding targets?
Social housing, shared ownership and zero-carbon homes have a role to play in combating the scale of today’s housing shortage, but, ultimately, the success of any housing policy must be measured not by promises made or money announced but by the homes that are delivered and occupied.