Contribution
My Lords, I, too, congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm and Lord Petterson, on their excellent and moving maiden speeches. I also thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, for securing this debate and setting out the issues so clearly. Having worked in the social housing sector for almost two decades, I have seen at first hand the life-changing power of a secure, warm home and the deep human and financial cost when the housing system falls short.
Before turning to the regional, demographic and delivery pressures that still need urgent attention, it is important to recognise the genuine progress this Government have made in putting social housing back at the heart of national policy. We have already heard about the £39 billion social and affordable homes programme running for 10 years from 2026 to 2036, with at least 60% earmarked for social rent, and nearly £10 billion already allocated in the first wave, which gives housing providers the multi-year financial certainty they have lacked for well over a decade.
Equally welcome is the Social Housing Bill, which completed its stages in this House in September and is now progressing through the other place. Raising the right-to-buy qualifying period from three to 10 years, capping discounts, exempting new builds for 35 years and introducing mandatory eight-week disposal notices will finally stem the net loss of irreplaceable social homes. Paired with stronger protections for victims of domestic abuse and a statutory duty to collaborate on homelessness prevention, the legislative framework is moving decisively in the right direction.
However, as I have said, my experience from nearly 20 years in the sector tells me that funding and legislation alone do not build homes; delivery capacity does. Right now, housing associations are ready, agile and far better equipped to respond quickly to meet the Government’s ambitious targets, as we have already heard from the noble Lords, Lord Stoneham and Lord Best, and the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick. By contrast, it will take a considerable time for many local authorities to step up at scale, simply because, over the past 15 years, so many councils have seen their in-house housing and development departments hollowed out.
We must back housing associations to lead the immediate charge while giving councils the time and support to rebuild their technical capacity. We must also look squarely at planning and land supply, an issue raised by other noble Lords. Across the country, too many private developers are sitting on land banks with existing planning permissions, waiting for market conditions to shift. Especially now, amid a noticeable downturn in commercial developments, the Government need to do much more to encourage and, where necessary, compel developers to build out consented sites immediately, or to partner with social housing providers so that we can get spades in the ground.
At the same time, we cannot build 300,000 affordable homes, or retrofit millions, without the workforce to do it. We need far more innovative thinking around bringing young people who are not in education, employment or training into structured apprenticeships in the construction and green retrofit sectors. We also need to stress to all our housing partners to take on not only NEETs but also new graduates, in the same way that I was given an opportunity by a local authority when I became a new graduate. It was not just a job; the authority supported me to undertake the three-year Institute of Housing qualifications that meant I was able to go on and run two housing associations. Doing this means that we will turn an acute labour shortage into a genuine pathway to skilled, secure careers.
We also know that the headline targets can mask sharp regional disparities both in where new homes are built and in the condition of the existing stock. Taking the West Midlands as a clear example, across the region more than 65,000 households sit on waiting lists and over 7,400 families are living in temporary accommodation.
Devolution is beginning to make a real difference. Through the West Midlands Combined Authority, over £400 million was released in August as the first tranche of a £1.7 billion regional social and affordable homes programme, aiming to deliver 2,000 social rent homes per year by 2028. We can already see what targeted investment unlocks in cities such as Coventry, where brownfield schemes such as Spon End and Spirit Quarters are replacing outdated estates with modern affordable housing, and in Birmingham, where developments such as Port Loop are delivering zero-carbon-ready homes alongside major council stock reinvestment.
The West Midlands also illustrates the sheer scale and cost of legacy stock conditions. Across England, roughly 430,000 social homes still fail the decent homes standard, and English Housing Survey modelling shows that the West Midlands has one of the highest regional rates of damp. In Birmingham, where overcrowding is more than double the national average and thousands of residents live in ageing Victorian terraces and post-war estates, an estimated 90,000 homes across the wider region fall below decent standards. With Awaab’s law now in force for social landlords—expanding this month to cover excess cold, structural hazards and electrical safety—providers in cities such as Birmingham, Coventry and Wolverhampton face a heavy capital bill to remediate existing homes without crowding out new supply.
When we discuss addressing challenges in the housing market, we must also recognise that a healthy system requires a wide spectrum of housing provision, tailored to very different stages and circumstances of life. General needs social rent is the bedrock, of course: providing permanent, genuinely affordable security for working families and low-income households. But alongside that, intermediate tenures such as shared ownership remain an essential bridge for households priced out of outright purchase, forming a vital part of mixed-tenure regeneration across Midlands cities. Yet investment in shared ownership addresses market challenges only if the product is fair, transparent and sustainable. As scrutiny in this House has repeatedly highlighted, too many shared owners still face steep staircasing costs, escalating service charges, complex lease terms and real barriers to reaching full ownership, particularly where building safety or retrofit costs are passed on.
Beyond general needs and intermediate housing, we cannot afford to overlook specialist and supported housing—something I have seen the vital importance of throughout my career. Care leavers stepping out into adult life for the first time, ex-offenders trying to break the cycle of reoffending to rebuild their lives, military veterans adjusting to civilian life, and homeless families stuck in unsuitable bed and breakfasts do not simply need four walls and a roof. They need tailored, supported accommodation with wraparound care.
When we fail to invest in specialist housing, the costs simply shift elsewhere into our prisons, hospitals and overstretched children’s services, as my noble friend Lady Warwick eloquently underlined. Equally, we should be championing community-led housing, co-operative models and modern, well-managed, private build-to-rent schemes and raising standards across the board.
I turn very quickly to zero-carbon homes. One of the biggest blind spots in our housing climate strategy sits at the intersection of ageing demographics and underoccupied family homes. According to the findings of the Older People’s Housing Taskforce, nearly nine in 10 people aged between 65 and 79 live in underoccupied homes, and more than half live in properties with two or more spare bedrooms. At the same time, Office for National Statistics analysis shows that heating drafty, poorly insulated, large family homes is carbon intensive and financially punishing for people on fixed pensions.
I will quickly move on to sum up and ask the Minister a couple of questions. First, on regional equity and stock condition, how will the Government ensure that funding under the social and affordable homes programme and the warm homes plan balances the urgent need to remediate older, damp social stock in cities such as Birmingham and Coventry without slowing down new-build delivery there or in high-cost areas such as London and the south? Secondly, on supporting older people to downsize into warmer, manageable homes, what practical incentives, specialist housing supply and safe equity release or rightsizing schemes are the Government putting in place to help older people?