L

Lord Fuller (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Housing Market

Contribution

My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, on his compelling maiden speech. It is a pleasure to find another Norfolk kinsman in your Lordships’ House, particularly one with Conservative back stories. There is £35 billion burning a hole in the Government’s pocket. The Prime Minister tells us he wants to unleash the greatest council house building programme for a generation. I am not sure the rhetoric wholly survived the reality of the Budget, but let us not nitpick the stated intent. I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, for introducing this debate. He anticipated some of the remarks I wanted to make about the consequences of many RSLs being swallowed up into larger organisations. It is a fact that so many of these larger combines have forgotten their social purpose. As a consequence, a focus on local matters, such as anti-social behaviour, has been relegated to the subs bench. This morning, I dealt with such a case in Bergh Apton, in my own case load. I found a housing officer hiding behind emails instead of mediating. The desire to solve a problem was replaced by the dismal management of a case load. In these larger organisations, tenant reps have been excised from the landscape. Local accountability is lacking, with RSLs populating their boards with the great and good from out of town. Some social housing in my village in Norfolk is headquartered in Gloucestershire. These are national organisations and, with billions in investment at stake, RSLs have become dependent on speculation and property development backed by cheap government finance. Our job is to force these organisations to remember their social purpose and stop them behaving like pound-shop developers benefiting from finance that is unavailable to private builders, whom this Government have brought to their knees. I listened carefully to the comments from the noble Lord about RSLs being ready to build, like a hairspring. In my book, if they want a share of the state’s largesse, they should sign up to six key social principles as a condition for taking the money: the promotion of tenant well-being; effective estate management; the prevention and reduction of anti-social behaviour; community engagement; the provision and maintenance of safe and sustainable neighbourhoods; and getting the balance between development activity and social responsibilities right. Too many RSLs have taken the wrong path. They have strayed from their original purpose and lost sight of that social purpose. It is our job to say, here and now, “If you want to take the money, signing up to the social purpose is the hair on the deal”. Building homes alone is not enough. It should not need to be said, but I have studied shared ownership, and that is where I want to focus now. I am concerned about the asymmetry of power and the imbalance in negotiating strength between the landlord in a shared ownership situation, normally an RSL, and the tenant. I do not want to characterise the people who enter into these arrangements as financially unsophisticated, but the truth is that schemes are available only to people on limited incomes, and, in their understandable desire to own at least part of a place they live in, they accept a situation where they sign up to the possibility of only half the uplift but the certainty of all the costs. The terms of trade are stacked against them. In June, I became aware of a couple in Oakham who wanted to sell their shared ownership house, where they had lived for 20 years. It was time for them to move. They inquired of the RSL about the process to sell, and the RSL replied that about 80 years remained on their lease. In fact, just over 80 years remained. At that stage, they could have entered into a lease extension without any marriage value charge at all, which would have assisted their move. The RSL manager, who styled herself as an adviser, did not disclose that any delay could crystallise this marriage value charge or that the case was urgent—that was sharp practice. Time apparently was not of the essence, when it was. A few months passed, and they were quoted £12,000 for the marriage value, plus various fees for solicitors, valuation and inspections, totalling over £16,000 plus VAT. By my reckoning, as they owned only 50%, the marriage value should have been at worst £8,000. But that should not obscure the truth that, had they been correctly advised 12 months previously, they would have owed little. My correspondents were misadvised by their social landlord, who acted as a privateer in its own self-interest rather than the tenants’. Meanwhile, the underlying value of their flat had diminished, and the RSL repudiated any responsibility for the equity loss of a home in which it had a 50% interest. All along, the tenants were responsible for 100% of the maintenance and 100% of the service charges. That is wrong. Elsewhere, last week, the Daily Telegraph highlighted a more egregious case where an elderly woman, who has since died, had taken a shared ownership of a retirement property, now unsaleable because the RSL continues to charge her son and daughter-in-law for meals not eaten—she is dead—and all manner of other charges. The RSL has every reason to obstruct a sale and resist a buyback, and it continues to charge with abandon. The basic terms of both these shared ownership arrangements were unfair and wrong. The tenant keeps all the charges, assumes all the losses and is often trapped in an unsellable home, unable to move on with their life, especially in the case of young couples with a growing family. Meanwhile, the state-backed landlord gets off scot free. By their actions we see they are not the cuddly social organisations the National Housing Federation would have you believe. In the case of shared ownership, they behave in a predatory manner with obvious conflicts of interest. There is an asymmetry of market and pricing power. They ignore the duty of care to their customers. Costs which should be apportioned are not, and there is a lack of pro-active information for financially unsophisticated tenants at the outset of the sale. This supports my wider point that the social purpose of RSLs is being ignored, and we should do something about it. These shared ownership homes are being mis-sold on unfair terms that would shame a scammer. We need a fundamental review to reinvigorate the case for a fair and balanced shared ownership system. That review must look at the affordability of shared ownership for leaseholders; the extent to which shared ownership provides a viable route to full home ownership, including costs, fees and valuation requirements; the purchase of additional shares; the barriers faced by shared ownership leaseholders in staircasing to higher levels of ownership or to full ownership; the impact of service charges, repair obligations and other housing costs; and to see whether regulatory changes are required to improve the transparency, affordability and access to full ownership. Parliament determined that shared ownership is a good idea, and I agree. However, it has become tainted, which is a shame. It is being fatally damaged unless the actions of the predatory RSLs—which exploit an imbalance of power and condemn people to live in unsaleable homes with unfair and usurious terms from which they are unable to extricate themselves—are addressed. Unless RSLs can get their house in order and relearn their social purpose, then the availability of cheap development finance should be withheld. That is the bargain we need to have a fresh start and reinvigorate this tenure so it stops harming, possibly irreparably, the opportunity for couples to accumulate capital and a stake in their homes and in the communities in which they live.

More from Lord Fuller (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.