Contribution
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham of Droxford, for initiating this debate and for his perceptive opening speech. I congratulate the noble Lord, Lord Davey of Chalk Farm, on his brilliant maiden speech. I declare my interests in social housing as chair of Renew, the Northern Housing Consortium’s housing-led regeneration initiative, as chair of the universities-based Urban Retrofit UK, and as a vice-president of the LGA and of the Town and Country Planning Association.
My remarks are confined to a simple plea to the Minister: please convey to your ministerial colleagues the urgency of allocating more of the social and affordable housing programme now to the housing providers that are ready and willing to deliver the new homes we so badly need. With housebuilders operating at a low ebb, with stalled schemes and undeveloped land with planning consent, now is the time to step up the contribution which the public funding makes possible. This countercyclical public investment protects against the construction industry and the social housing sector having to shed staff and lose capacity that takes a long time to restore.
It has been great to see a significant allocation of public funds dispersed through Homes England and the GLA: a total, after the £1.5 billion Budget top-up, of over £40 billion. About a quarter has been committed for the programmes of a small number of strategic partners, but there is now some uncertainty as to when the bulk of the investment will follow. I am worried that opportunities will be lost if delays set in. It is so important to speed up, not hold back, production of desperately needed social rented homes.
Why is there anxiety about the speed of allocating the available funds? The Prime Minister has talked of his determination to build significantly more “council housing”. I have not taken his wording to mean any intention to provide less support to the housing associations, which are currently the main providers of social housing. Most of the Government’s programme at present is spent on developments that are based on co-operation and partnership between councils and housing associations. Very few authorities are currently developing on their own, with some excellent exceptions. But is government now planning to keep back a large part of the remaining £30 billion funding to await more local authorities getting back into the development business? I think it would be a grave mistake to do so.
For sure, it would be good to add to the number of social housing providers: local authorities acting as developers have the potential to be highly sensitive to local needs and opportunities. Some have landholdings that they can utilise. But gearing up the whole of the local government sector to take on this role will take a huge amount of time and resource. Many councils have not been in this business for 30 years and more. All face severe financial constraints and other competing priorities. Those that have retained their landlord role, rather than transferring their stock to a housing association or to an arm’s-length management organisation, may well want to give priority to upgrading their existing housing stock to today’s decent homes standards. Meanwhile, the market conditions—and the government target of 1.5 million homes this Parliament—demand immediate action, and cannot wait for a revival of the role of local authorities as developers.
I should add that housing associations, now often called “registered providers”, bring some special advantages of their own, as well as being ready with bids for new homes, as the noble Baroness, Lady Warwick of Undercliffe, has so forcibly underlined. Their borrowing costs do not add to the national debt, which pleases HM Treasury, and they are experienced at creating mixed-tenure developments that avoid social housing becoming stigmatised, as has sometimes been the case with estates exclusively of social rented homes.
The National Housing Federation, as the noble Lord, Lord Stoneham, has noted, says its members could do much more. It found that 41,000 affordable homes could have been delivered, of which 25,000 would be for social rent, if government had fully funded the housing association bids through the recent strategic partners allocation outside London.
My plea to the Minister is for parallel government activity: first, for government to press ahead now, urgently, with the release of the available funding to those organisations ready to buy the land and progress new development. This means Homes England and the GLA getting the go-ahead to approve more of the outstanding bids from the housing associations, and also from a small number of councils that are eager to get on with the job. My second plea is for government to support more local authorities over a period of time to recruit the team and build the skills to recreate or expand the role of councils as social housing developers, in due course.
I know the APPG on Council and Social Housing is looking at the barriers to developing new homes, and its work will progress this agenda. If social housing programmes are to get even close to reaching the demand for truly affordable new homes—variously estimated at twice or three times current levels—then an additional social housing contribution from councils as developers is going to be very welcome. But bringing forward and bolstering local authority providers of social housing should be a significant component for the Government’s 10-year national housing plan, which is due to be published next year. Meanwhile, most local authorities will need preparing, nurturing and supporting. Just as with the build-up of depleted local authority planning teams, this will take time and effort.
I look forward to the response of the Minister, which I feel sure will be one of reassurance.