L

Lord Fuller (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Education: Instruction about Soils

Contribution

My Lords, I do not suppose there are many Members of your Lordships’ House who studied soil science at Reading University, but I did, as part of a BSc in agriculture back in the late 1980s. I am delighted that the Soil Research Centre at my alma mater is still going. My course notes are long gone, but you never quite forget the distinction between a sandy loam and a loamy sand, which stains the fingers when rubbed together in a way that a sand does not. I have spent my career in the fertiliser industry, which fortifies those soil substrates that underpin our crop and animal production systems and our nation’s food security. To those involved in farming in the countryside, it is no surprise that we have some of the world’s most productive agriculture. We have the basic knowledge not just of the soils themselves, those gritty particles—except of course in the case of a silt, which is not gritty at all—but of the soil chemistry. It is the interaction between soils and their chemistry that is so important, and you do not need to be a chemist to see the results. The acidic soils of the West Country and Wales support the grassland production landscapes, whereas the alkali soils in the east have shaped an arable countryside rich in hedgerows and heaths. These soils make phosphate immobile and require different approaches. The black sands of the Fenland skirt need manganese, but please, at all costs, avoid applying too much boron on the calcareous sands of north Norfolk. You will get blind ears in barley, and that is no good for Horlicks, beer or whisky. I do not intend in this debate to provide a lecture on fertiliser, save to say that the fertiliser industry assurance scheme, which is a non-statutory regulatory framework, provides robust and recognised qualifications for advisers and agronomists to ensure that fertilisers are applied only when necessary, in the right manner and at the correct time. Only FIAS-qualified advisers, taking into account soil analysis, cropping, season and soil type, can prescribe crop nutrition products. That is how it should be, especially because wasting them is expensive and bad for business. I am delighted to acquaint the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, with the fact that it is not just a question of a Wild West. This is an organised, regulated and intellectually underpinned enterprise. I attended a Greenpeace event about 10 days ago at the launch of a report, Our Poisoned Land. Its ill-informed contents perpetuated wrong and out-of-date stereotypes about crops, farming and nutrition, conveniently forgetting that nitrogen use is down by one-third over 40 years as efficiency has increased. Clearly, none of them studied, let alone was aware of, a FIAS qualification. I do not suppose they let the facts get in the way of a good story. It is common ground that soil organic matter affects the moisture-retaining capacity of soils. It is the principal determinant of yield potential and is impacted by soil depth, which determines how much moisture the crop can access during the growing season. This is all basic understanding, but so often in government, including among those who should know better, there is no understanding at all. That leads to all sorts of misdirection and adverse macroeconomic consequences. This Motion calls for soil science to be included more effectively in our education system, and amen to that, but it is incomplete. Soil science should be extended to our regulators too. I am reminded of Natural England’s wilful misdirection and misrepresentation in the nutrient neutrality debate. As a local authority leader in an affected area, I asked Natural England for the scientific justification for its assertion that any additional nutrients in a territory arising from the flushing of a loo in a new home anywhere in that area would damage a special area of conservation miles away. It sent me a summary with a collection of scientific papers which claimed to support its assertions. I read those papers, and they did not. I will not list all the ways in which those papers contradicted Natural England’s stance, but, through ignorance of soil, soil chemistry and soil science, they either disregarded or confused a whole range of natural mitigation factors. They confused adsorption with absorption—two completely different phenomena. They ignored the precipitation of phosphates in the calcareous soils, which makes them immobile, as well as the related effects of high pH in locking up those phosphates, the effect of the dilution of rainwater, the winter riparian flows and so forth. That misdirection and ignorance of soils persuaded Ministers to ban housebuilding in the 75 local authority areas with the greatest housing potential, on a completely false premise. As a direct result of that misdirection, we have a building hiatus that means that the Government will miss their manifesto commitment to build 1.5 million homes in this Parliament. It has prevented the building of new affordable housing, the bankruptcy of local architects, the closure of builders’ merchants, the liquidation of many small builders and the folding of white-van journeyman contractors—the plasterers, plumbers, groundworkers, roofers and tilers. I congratulate the noble Baroness on bringing this debate, which has allowed us to shine a light on one of the root causes—pun intended—of some of the macroeconomic difficulties we face, which arise from ignorance of soil science. But it is not just Natural England. Elsewhere, our regulators encourage the use of 20 million tonnes of digestate slop—the liquid remains from so-called green anaerobic digestion. One arm of government is mandating the digestion of chicken manure from the West Midlands and AD plants in the east, while another complains that the slop applied at huge rates by regulation at the wrong time of year, when it cannot be used by growing crops, passes straight into the aquifer or turns our rivers green. The hard truth here is that it is our regulators which are turning our rivers green, in part because they do not understand the difference between absorption and adsorption. You should apply nutrients to our soils only when crops can use them, not when the fields are bare. They continue to promulgate these stereotypic tropes. Not everyone can have the opportunity to understand soils, soil chemistry and nutrition as I did, but I hope the Minister recognises that it is the farmers, agronomists and other advisers, and my colleagues in the fertiliser industry, who are fertiliser FIAS-qualified and have their house in order. She might like to ensure that the regulators in other parts of government do likewise, because the evidence is that their prejudices and ignorance of our soils are harming both our environment and our economy. We really should expect better from them.

More from Lord Fuller (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.