Hansard·Grand Committee·Vol. 861

Education: Instruction about Soils

Thursday, 19 November 2026

13 contributions6 members

Contributions

  1. Question for Short Debate

    View contribution permalink →

  2. Asked by

    View contribution permalink →

  3. Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle

    To ask His Majesty’s Government what steps they are taking to support inclusion of instruction about soils at all levels of the education system, including undergraduate and post-graduate, and what steps they are taking to increase the level of soil science research.

    View contribution permalink →

  4. Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

    My Lords, I begin with thanks to the British Society of Soil Science, the National Trust and the charity Buglife for their assistance in preparation for this debate. I also thank the noble Baroness, Lady Smith of Malvern, who gave me one starting point: her response yesterday to my Written Question about the current number of postgraduate soil science students. The Answer was that, in total, at UK HE providers, there are 45, of whom only 15 are on research courses—fifteen people. Two separate searches of UK job sites this year found more than 100 vacancies for soil scientists each time. The other starting point was an event held last month by the British Society of Soil Science, an attempt to kick-start discussion about what can only be described as the collapse of soil science education and research in the UK. It was under Chatham House rules, so I cannot attribute this, but a sentence that stuck with me was, “We employed the last soil science PhD”. It is worth saying that many people’s work is focused on soils—I note particularly the work of academic geographers, anthropologists and regenerative farmers—but soil science brings particular understandings and approaches essential to all our futures in a particular way. As the National Trust says, our understanding of soil, how it functions and the importance of its biology has changed significantly in the past 10 to 15 years. Nearly everything I was taught about soil science in an Australian agricultural science degree 40 years ago was wrong. We talk about it far more and have come to realise just how important soil is to food security, carbon storage and biodiversity. In fact, of course, it is biodiversity. A 2007 countryside survey estimated that just the top 8 cm of UK soil has 12.8 quadrillion invertebrates—before we even get to the fungi, bacteria, protozoa, algae and archaea. There are up to a billion organisms, maybe tens of thousands of species, in a healthy teaspoon of soil. As Buglife explains, the technology has recently come a long way, particularly with eDNA monitoring tools, which could revolutionise the monitoring of soil fauna. However, that relies on good barcode libraries, which in turn depend on the collection and identification of species by experts. I could easily have made this debate instead about the collapse of biological taxonomy courses, which I was lamenting with the Royal Entomological Society this week. We know that our soils are in a terrible state. If you want to count by pound value, one estimate suggests that the degradation of soils costs England and Wales £1.2 billion annually. Pesticides, veterinary medicines and intensive cultivation are all having significant impacts. Then add in the application of sewage sludge—which can introduce concentrated antibiotics and other pharmaceuticals, pesticides, PFAS, heavy metals and microplastics—and the impact of the climate emergency, including droughts, floods and storms. What of the soil science university programmes that might be preparing students first to understand and then to tackle these pressing issues? Master’s programmes at Aberdeen, Cranfield and Edinburgh were recently closed or paused due to the university funding crisis. For undergraduates, only the BSc in plant and soil science at Aberdeen remains, although there were many courses at many universities only a few decades ago. The recent suspension of agriculture degree recruitment at the University of Nottingham further highlights the vulnerability of land-based education provision, reducing a key pathway through which graduates enter soil-related careers. This Government, like many Governments before them, are keen on apprenticeships. Cranfield organised a soil apprenticeship, but it was discontinued after one intake. The state of research, unsurprisingly, reflects the state of funding. The Ag.Impact report, The State of Agricultural Research and Innovation , released just last month, found a halving in total UK funding in 2025 compared to the previous three years. Of UKRI-funded agricultural research, only 6% is focused on soils and water, with 42% for crops and 18% for livestock. Defra’s funding is also dominated by crops and livestock; “soils and water” gets just 9%. Yet farmers, growers and other land managers are crying out for more information, given that our understanding has so fundamentally transformed in the past couple of decades. In January, I will again be at the Oxford Real Farming Conference, and I have no doubt that we will see many people coming down the road from the conference desperate for new insights, particularly into soils, and for sources of information that are not from people selling products. As the National Trust noted, the lacunae of unbiased research have created space for markets and products based on dubious or non-existent evidence. There are so many products—all too often backed by giant multinational companies—that are causing great harm to our soils, yet the only information available to farmers comes from the firms pushing those products. I have focused up to now on higher education, because the collapse there is so obvious and deeply concerning, but we need the understanding of soils to be a basic, foundational part of everyone’s education. We need extensive practical further education about soils to equip our land-workers of the future. I included in the Question all levels of soil education, in the hope—which was not entirely successfully—of broadening participation. I suspect I know what the Minister has planned: a list saying that soils are mentioned in primary curriculums and in geography and science at secondary levels. However, I refer to the BSSS: “Soil is rarely taught as a subject in its own right at primary or secondary level in England”. According to the National Trust: “Soil is only touched on lightly in GCSE and A-level Geology”. Soil is what rocks turn into or what plants grow on, rather than the focus of attention; those subjects are not going to grab the attention of the next generation of soil scientists. I also tabled a Written Question about the planned new natural history GCSE, which is an obvious opportunity to improve the teaching of soil science. The Answer I got was, in short: wait for the consultation. I hope to persuade the Government that they need to listen to submissions calling for a stand-alone soil science element, rather than the learning being spread across the study of habitats, ecosystems and environmental processes. After all, the whole aim of the course is—or should be—dirty boots, and understanding what is on those boots is foundational. I circle back to where I started, to the answer from the noble Baroness, Lady Smith, to my Written Question. She concluded that the providers are autonomous, and provision and recruitment to those courses are matters for individual providers. The challenge I put to the Minister is that, simply and clearly, that is patently not good enough. We need far more people trained at all levels, including at postgraduate level, to tackle the challenges of our degraded, damaged and depleted soils, the foundations of our life.

    View contribution permalink →

  5. Lord Fuller (Con)

    My Lords, I do not suppose there are many Members of your Lordships’ House who studied soil science at Reading University, but I did, as part of a BSc in agriculture back in the late 1980s. I am delighted that the Soil Research Centre at my alma mater is still going. My course notes are long gone, but you never quite forget the distinction between a sandy loam and a loamy sand, which stains the fingers when rubbed together in a way that a sand does not. I have spent my career in the fertiliser industry, which fortifies those soil substrates that underpin our crop and animal production systems and our nation’s food security. To those involved in farming in the countryside, it is no surprise that we have some of the world’s most productive agriculture. We have the basic knowledge not just of the soils themselves, those gritty particles—except of course in the case of a silt, which is not gritty at all—but of the soil chemistry. It is the interaction between soils and their chemistry that is so important, and you do not need to be a chemist to see the results. The acidic soils of the West Country and Wales support the grassland production landscapes, whereas the alkali soils in the east have shaped an arable countryside rich in hedgerows and heaths. These soils make phosphate immobile and require different approaches. The black sands of the Fenland skirt need manganese, but please, at all costs, avoid applying too much boron on the calcareous sands of north Norfolk. You will get blind ears in barley, and that is no good for Horlicks, beer or whisky. I do not intend in this debate to provide a lecture on fertiliser, save to say that the fertiliser industry assurance scheme, which is a non-statutory regulatory framework, provides robust and recognised qualifications for advisers and agronomists to ensure that fertilisers are applied only when necessary, in the right manner and at the correct time. Only FIAS-qualified advisers, taking into account soil analysis, cropping, season and soil type, can prescribe crop nutrition products. That is how it should be, especially because wasting them is expensive and bad for business. I am delighted to acquaint the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, with the fact that it is not just a question of a Wild West. This is an organised, regulated and intellectually underpinned enterprise. I attended a Greenpeace event about 10 days ago at the launch of a report, Our Poisoned Land . Its ill-informed contents perpetuated wrong and out-of-date stereotypes about crops, farming and nutrition, conveniently forgetting that nitrogen use is down by one-third over 40 years as efficiency has increased. Clearly, none of them studied, let alone was aware of, a FIAS qualification. I do not suppose they let the facts get in the way of a good story. It is common ground that soil organic matter affects the moisture-retaining capacity of soils. It is the principal determinant of yield potential and is impacted by soil depth, which determines how much moisture the crop can access during the growing season. This is all basic understanding, but so often in government, including among those who should know better, there is no understanding at all. That leads to all sorts of misdirection and adverse macroeconomic consequences. This Motion calls for soil science to be included more effectively in our education system, and amen to that, but it is incomplete. Soil science should be extended to our regulators too. I am reminded of Natural England’s wilful misdirection and misrepresentation in the nutrient neutrality debate. As a local authority leader in an affected area, I asked Natural England for the scientific justification for its assertion that any additional nutrients in a territory arising from the flushing of a loo in a new home anywhere in that area would damage a special area of conservation miles away. It sent me a summary with a collection of scientific papers which claimed to support its assertions. I read those papers, and they did not. I will not list all the ways in which those papers contradicted Natural England’s stance, but, through ignorance of soil, soil chemistry and soil science, they either disregarded or confused a whole range of natural mitigation factors. They confused adsorption with absorption—two completely different phenomena. They ignored the precipitation of phosphates in the calcareous soils, which makes them immobile, as well as the related effects of high pH in locking up those phosphates, the effect of the dilution of rainwater, the winter riparian flows and so forth. That misdirection and ignorance of soils persuaded Ministers to ban housebuilding in the 75 local authority areas with the greatest housing potential, on a completely false premise. As a direct result of that misdirection, we have a building hiatus that means that the Government will miss their manifesto commitment to build 1.5 million homes in this Parliament. It has prevented the building of new affordable housing, the bankruptcy of local architects, the closure of builders’ merchants, the liquidation of many small builders and the folding of white-van journeyman contractors—the plasterers, plumbers, groundworkers, roofers and tilers. I congratulate the noble Baroness on bringing this debate, which has allowed us to shine a light on one of the root causes—pun intended—of some of the macroeconomic difficulties we face, which arise from ignorance of soil science. But it is not just Natural England. Elsewhere, our regulators encourage the use of 20 million tonnes of digestate slop—the liquid remains from so-called green anaerobic digestion. One arm of government is mandating the digestion of chicken manure from the West Midlands and AD plants in the east, while another complains that the slop applied at huge rates by regulation at the wrong time of year, when it cannot be used by growing crops, passes straight into the aquifer or turns our rivers green. The hard truth here is that it is our regulators which are turning our rivers green, in part because they do not understand the difference between absorption and adsorption. You should apply nutrients to our soils only when crops can use them, not when the fields are bare. They continue to promulgate these stereotypic tropes. Not everyone can have the opportunity to understand soils, soil chemistry and nutrition as I did, but I hope the Minister recognises that it is the farmers, agronomists and other advisers, and my colleagues in the fertiliser industry, who are fertiliser FIAS-qualified and have their house in order. She might like to ensure that the regulators in other parts of government do likewise, because the evidence is that their prejudices and ignorance of our soils are harming both our environment and our economy. We really should expect better from them.

    View contribution permalink →

  6. Lord Bilimoria (CB)

    My Lords, Sir Partha Dasgupta of the University of Cambridge wrote a fantastic, superb report, The Economics of Biodiversity , in which he said that nature is our “most precious asset”. The British Society of Soil Science said that, by one estimate, degradation of soil costs England and Wales £1.2 billion annually. Globally, restoring land could generate $1.8 trillion in annual benefits, with every dollar invested estimated to return between $7 and $30. COP 26 was from 31 October to 13 November 2021. I took part actively as president of the Confederation of British Industry—the CBI—and spoke 40 times over those two weeks. Not once was soil brought up in that conference. The following year, in March 2022, when I was chancellor of the University of Birmingham, I was asked to host one of India’s most famous spiritual leaders, Sadhguru, in Birmingham. I hosted two big events with hundreds of people, if not thousands. To put it in context, Sadhguru’s social media following alone is over 25 million people. He was about to set off on a journey. He went to the ExCeL centre in London, where I spoke, with thousands of people there. Then, on 21 March, my Zoroastrian Parsi new year, fellow parliamentarians and I flagged him off on his “save soil” motorcycle journey, which was an overland journey going across to India to raise awareness. His campaign was to ask every Government to legislate a minimum of 3% to 6% organic matter in agricultural soil. He shared a platform with Prime Minister Narendra Modi. Sadhguru, in this journey of 100 days, reached almost 4 billion people in 81 countries, spreading the message that soil is a living thing that is going extinct; that food security, water, climate and peace depend on it; and that everyone should take it seriously. In this journey, which was a great success, he did not ride every part of it on his motorbike; he had to take some journeys by road and by sea, but he got to India. Prime Minister Modi set out India’s five-pronged approach to soil: first, make soil chemical-free; secondly, protect the organisms living in the soil, the organic matter; thirdly, keep soil moist and improve water availability; fourthly, repair damage caused by falling groundwater; and fifthly, stop erosion caused by shrinking forest cover. According to Sadhguru, 52% of the world’s agricultural soil is already degraded, and 90% of the world’s soil will be degraded by 2050 at current rates. Half the planet’s topsoil has been lost in 150 years. Soil needs at least 3% organic matter to be productive. Intensive farming has cut organic content in arable soils by 40% to 60%. Food output could fall by 40% by around 2045, when the world population crosses 9 billion. Does the Minister agree with some of these facts? The reality is that soil is a living thing facing extinction. Sadhguru believes that, to get to the target of between 3% and 6% organic matter, every nation should legislate a minimum of this organic content in agricultural soil as a target, incentivise farmers and introduce a quality mark for food. Apart from the organic quality mark, state the organic content in the soil. He clearly said that this is not a protest movement. He is not blaming farmers or anyone for it; this is something we should all strive towards. The Soil Association brought out an excellent report called Saving Our Soils: Healthy Soils for Our Climate, Nature and Health . It states: “Our planet is called ‘Earth’ for good reason. Soil is one of the most important natural resources. It is the planet’s skin, a rich and complex ecosystem that provides the life systems we all need to survive: oxygen, clean water and food. It is no exaggeration to say that civilisations rise and fall according to the health of the soils on which they are built”. There is a quote from Franklin D Roosevelt that states: “The nation that destroys its soil destroys itself”. The report says that 25% of our biodiversity lives in our soils. Groundwater quality has been deteriorating in the UK. There is a narrow diversity of crops. Soil has saved countless lives as a source of new antibiotics. Soil erosion remains a critical problem. The report talks about seven ways to save the soil. I will summarise them: monitor soil health on farms, increase the amount of plant and animal matter going back into fields, improve soil life by reducing tillage and chemicals, cover up bare soil with continuous plant cover, bring more trees on to farmland, reduce soil compaction from machinery and livestock, and design crop rotations to improve soil health. As an alumnus of the University of Cambridge and currently a doctoral student at the Cambridge Judge Business School, Professor Bhaskar Vira spoke about the work being done at the Centre for Landscape Regeneration. At the University of Cambridge, I was privileged to co-chair the TIGR2ESS programme, which was run by Cambridge Global Food Systems and headed by Professor Howard Griffiths, one of the world experts on plant science. This was all about transforming India’s green revolution with an interdisciplinary research programme. The green revolution of the 1960s in India established the country as one of the largest agricultural producers, sustaining its booming population and boosting its economy. The TIGR2ESS programme was about the second green revolution in India, helping to deliver vision-driven partnership. The best thing about it was that it was interdisciplinary between the University of Cambridge, other British institutions and universities, and 19 Indian partners. It was a huge success. The National Trust said that there is a need for soil education. As the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, whom I thank for initiating the debate, said, there is currently little dedicated soil education at any level. Soil is touched on lightly in GCSE and A-level geology. There is no undergraduate degree in the UK that majors in soil science. There is no master’s degree at all. Cranfield used to offer it—I am an alumnus of that university—but it no longer does so. Cranfield, with industry support, organised a soil apprenticeship but after one intake it was discontinued. When it comes to CPD, there is little structured programming. It really matters. There is a lack of awareness among our children: 40% of 17 year-olds did not know or did not think that soil mattered. It hardly features in the curriculum. According to Professor Howard Griffiths, there is a proposed GCSE in nature conservation. Can the Minister confirm that there will be a new English natural history GCSE? Professor Howard Griffiths says that 4 million hectares of soil are at risk of compaction and 2 million hectares of soil are at risk of erosion. Intensive agriculture has caused arable soils to lose 40% to 60% of organic content, and soil degradation, as I said earlier, costs about £1.2 billion every year. The Government have not explicitly set out their policy on soil science in education or research since Prime Minister Andy Burnham took office. Can the Minister confirm that it will be a priority for the Government?

    View contribution permalink →

  7. Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)

    I am grateful to the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, for securing this important debate. I begin with a personal reflection. My family originates from the Kashmir region of Pakistan, where generations of our family are firmly rooted in farming. My ancestors understood the importance of land, the seasons and, above all, the quality of the soil. Of course, life took a rather different turn for us, and we ended up in Tinsley in Sheffield, at the heart of the steel industry, where generations of our family worked in the steel industry rather than in the fields. One might say that we swapped the ploughshares for the steelworks, but those farming roots have never left us, and we have never forgotten them. Perhaps that gives me a particular appreciation of why the health of our soil matters. Soil is one of the most overlooked natural resources in our country, if not the world, yet it is a fundamental part of our food security, biodiversity, climate resilience and long-term health for our environment. It is estimated that around 95% of global food production depends on our soil. Soil also acts as a major carbon store, supports biodiversity, filters water and helps reduce flooding. Yet decades of intensive agriculture, pollution, erosion and poor land management have placed considerable pressure on that resource. I was smiling when the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, was talking about his time and knowledge from the 1990s. I reflected on my grandfather, Naik Alam, who was very much an organic farmer. It would have been brilliant to have been able to have him here—he, sadly, passed away in the 1980s—to argue and debate with the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, about the changes to how we have managed our soil. Yes, some things might have been very relevant in the 1990s, but as we are moving on with climate change and population growth, we may well have to deal with soil in a very different way. The area I really want to major on is education and skills. If we are serious about protecting our natural environment, we must ensure that the next generation understands the importance of soil and has the significant scientific knowledge and practical skills to manage it sustainably. As we heard earlier, at primary school level, children are introduced to soil through science and geography. However, coverage remains relatively limited. At secondary level, soil science is often treated as a small component of geography or environmental sciences, rather than a subject deserving greater attention in its own right. The Government’s review of the national curriculum presents an important opportunity. I really hope that the Minister will be able to comment on that. Will she ensure that the revised curriculum gives greater prominence to soil health, soil biodiversity, carbon storage, food production and sustainable land management? I would welcome a greater opportunity for outdoor learning, school gardens and practical investigations. This should not stop at the school level. We need to strengthen the pathways to further and higher education, including apprenticeships, undergraduate degrees and postgraduate research. There is a growing need for skilled soil scientists, environmental researchers and land management specialists. The Government should work with universities, colleges and employers to identify skills shortages, expand specialist training and encourage more young people into these careers. Research is really important not just for our country but for the world. This week we discussed the Commonwealth conference and what unites us with our former colleagues and friends. The UK could take a major lead in supporting those developing nations through the fantastic research, skills and knowledge that we have to help them deal with the challenges they have with food security and other issues. But we cannot do that without properly protecting what we have. I welcome initiatives such as the national soil map of England and Wales and the Government’s farming innovation programme. However, we need sustained, long-term investment in soil research, including in soil biodiversity, microplastics, carbon capture, erosion and the impact of climate change. This is important for the Liberal Democrats. Our party has championed regenerative farming, healthier soils, improved water retention and biodiversity. We believe that nature-friendly farming must be properly supported through environmental land management schemes, and I would like to see greater collaboration between universities, farmers, agricultural colleges and research institutions. We heard about Cranfield University; I would also mention the James Hutton Institute. I have three questions for the Minister. Will the Government commit to strengthening soil education in the forthcoming national curriculum review, including practical outdoor learning? I ask this as someone from a city of which one-third is in the Peak District National Park. I remember well the outdoor learning that we had when I was at primary and secondary school. Secondly, what plans exist to increase the number of undergraduate and postgraduate students specialising in soil science? Thirdly, will the Government consider a dedicated, long-term soil science research programme, bringing together universities, farmers and research institutions, with appropriate funding through UK Research and Innovation, to deal with some of the challenges that I have mentioned around the Commonwealth? Soil may be beneath our feet, but its importance reaches into almost every aspect of our lives. Protecting it is not simply an environmental responsibility; it is an investment in our food security, public health, economic resilience and future prosperity. We must ensure that the next generation understands its value and has the skills to protect it and the scientific knowledge to restore it. I hope the Minister will recognise the importance of putting soil education and research firmly on the national agenda.

    View contribution permalink →

  8. Lord Evans of Rainow (Con)

    My Lords, it is a pleasure to take part in this debate. There have been some excellent speeches. The noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, quoted Franklin D Roosevelt referring, I believe, to the dust bowl disaster in the 1920s and 1930s, when intensive crop growing led to a catastrophic disaster in food growing. I pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Fuller’s expertise in his study of soil. However, some of us who went to bog-standard comprehensive schools might also remember our environmental science lessons. On the first day of the academic year, we put soil into three glass bowls and then put an apple core in one, a sweet—I think it was a Mars bar—in another and a crisp packet in the third. We were told to look at what had happened every time we went to the lesson: 10 months later, the apple core had disappeared; funnily enough, the Mars bar had just about disappeared; but the crisp packet was still there staring at us. I have to say, the 1970s have a lot to answer for. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, for securing this debate and giving the Committee the chance to dig into a subject that is not well-trodden ground. Let me start with some common ground. Soil is the foundation of our food, our farming and our countryside; it holds the roots of our crops and hedgerows; it stores carbon, filters our water and supports an enormous amount of life. We believe that this importance is already reflected in the national curriculum. Geography includes soils in the programmes of study at key stage 1 and key stage 3. Learning about soils is featured in the programmes of study for science, particularly at the post-16 level, where the environmental science AS-level and A-level include teaching about soil fertility, degradation, erosion and management. It is already being cultivated across several subjects and at several stages of a child’s education. However, learning about soil can offer only so much. Soil matters most in the field, as the basis of our agricultural prosperity and national food security. Schools can offer pupils fundamental concepts, but the technical knowledge is at best instrumental. The best soil education in this country takes place at the grass roots: on our farms and in the hands of those who have looked after the same ground for generations. The place of soil within the national curriculum can certainly prepare for that education, but it cannot replace it. That is why soil is taught within other subjects rather than standing as a subject of its own. That brings me to the Opposition’s main concern. Many important topics are taught as part of wider disciplines in schools and in higher education. We do this because subject areas are vast, and if we give a disproportionate share of time to any one topic, the time left for other equally important material shrinks. That is why we approach the curriculum and assessment review with apprehension. By scrapping established pathways such as the English baccalaureate and promoting “creative” subjects at the expense of languages and humanities, the Government risk sacrificing depth for breadth. However tempting it may be, the curriculum cannot become a repository for every social or environmental cause, however worthy. The same applies to soil. It is already taught throughout our schools; giving it a premium would divert teaching time away from the core fundamentals of English and mathematics above all. We should not let the curriculum become even more thinly spread. The folly of this approach has been demonstrated in the most recent PISA results. England climbed the international rankings while our neighbours in Scotland and Wales fell back. That improvement came from reforms under the previous Conservative Government, who concentrated on fundamentals and gave schools the freedom to teach them well. Those reforms have taken root and are bearing the fruit. Pulling up those now established measures root and branch, the curriculum included, is not the way to raise standards. This matters most in early years and primary education. Children’s minds are most fertile at these stages. This is when we sow the seeds of literacy and numeracy from which everything else grows, including any later study of the natural world. A child who cannot read fluently will struggle with a textbook on soil science, in the same way that a child without confident numeracy cannot analyse data on crop yields. If children are to spend more time studying climate change or soil science, can the Minister guarantee that not a single hour of teaching time for reading, writing and maths will be lost? Our education system is designed to grow from the ground up. Pupils begin with a broad base and, as they mature, they narrow their interests and specialise. Children who pick up an interest in soil can continue it through their A-levels, degrees, agricultural college and further professional training. If the Government want to strengthen soil education, they should begin by widening the routes for those who choose to pursue it, rather than mandating it for all. They could even begin by reversing a decision of their own and reinstate funding for the level 7 soil scientist apprenticeship for learners over 22 without the help of an EHCP. Over half of the people taking it are over 25, so under the new rules most of them will now be ineligible. Will the Minister commit to reinstating funding for this route? Soil education is plainly important, and we believe it is already recognised as such in our national curriculum. If there is to be reform, let it give those with a real interest in soil more opportunities to pursue it, rather than taking already limited teaching time away from the subjects that every child needs.

    View contribution permalink →

  9. Baroness in Waiting/Government Whip (Baroness Ramsey of Wall Heath) (Lab)

    My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, for securing this debate, and all noble Lords who have taken part. The noble Baroness has been a determined champion of soil health in this House for many years. I looked at a paragraph or two in her maiden speech, where she said that “I continue to be fascinated by the amazing and still barely understood ecology of the soil on which all our lives depend ”.—[ Official Report , 17/10/19; col. 218.] So I certainly knew that I was facing at least one expert, but of course there are other noble Lords who are expert in their differing ways—before I even get on to the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, and fertiliser. I understand that the noble Baroness’s Question today is a natural extension of her work. Healthy soils underpin our food security, our resilience to flooding and drought, and the recovery of nature. That is why the Government’s environmental improvement plan commits to bringing at least 40% of England’s agricultural soil into sustainable management by 2028, rising to 60% by 2030. Meeting that ambition depends on people: farmers, land managers, perhaps also providers and producers of fertiliser—who understand their soils—and scientists, who deepen our knowledge of them. Education and research both have a vital part to play, from the classroom and technical training through to the laboratory and the field. I will have to come back to the noble Lord, Lord Fuller, on regulation and a non-statutory framework, but I certainly hope he recognises that we recognise the importance of soil to society and the economy. A number of noble Lords mentioned the national curriculum. We are already building on people’s understanding of soils through the national curriculum. In science, soil is included in the statutory curriculum at key stages 2 and 3, including through teaching about rocks, soils and plant growth. At key stage 2, pupils should be taught to explore the requirements of plants for life and growth, including nutrients from soil, and to recognise that soils are made from rocks and organic matter. Related non-statutory guidance sets out that pupils can explore different kinds of rocks and soils, including those in the local environment, as well as compare different soils and investigate how soils are formed. Moving on to key stage 3, soil is explicitly included under nutrition and digestion. Pupils are taught about plants making carbohydrates in their leaves by photosynthesis and gaining mineral nutrients and water from the soil via their roots. Although soil is not named in GCSE and A-level subject content, in GCSE biology there are requirements that enable teaching about soil, including those covering the uptake of water and mineral ions by plants, as well as abiotic and biotic factors. This is reflected in GCSE combined science, with material cycling and the role of microorganisms in the environment. In A-level biology, soil is covered when teaching about ecosystems. I will say a little more about the curriculum, but I hope that covers some of the questions on the curriculum throughout a child’s school life, from key stage 1 all the way through, for the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley, who raised that. Soil also features in geography and is specifically named in the statutory curriculum at key stages 1 and 3. It can be taught at key stage 2, and it forms part of GCSE geography and A-level subject content. For the natural history GCSE, mentioned by the noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, the proposed subject content requires students to understand the main habitats of the UK and how factors such as underlying soil and rock contribute to their formation, providing a further opportunity for young people to deepen their understanding of the natural world. Soil science already features in the environmental science A-level, which covers how human activities affect soil fertility, the causes of soil degradation and erosion, and strategies to manage soils more sustainably. Although I have set out where soil is named and some examples of where else it could be covered, this is not an exhaustive list, because I do not have sufficient time in 10 minutes. But teachers themselves will incorporate teaching about this matter wherever relevant. I will go a little further in response to the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley. We cannot comment about what is in the new curriculum, but a consultation on the new national curriculum is coming shortly, and this will set out our proposals. We are also building expertise through technical education. The agriculture, land management and production T-level provides a substantial level 3 route into the sector. I was hoping that someone would ask me whereabouts in the country there is uptake as I feel, given present company, that noble Lords might like to know that the colleges offering those courses are in East Anglia and Kendal College in Cumbria. Its core develops students’ understanding of sustainability, environmental legislation, climate change and biosecurity alongside occupational specialisms including crop and plant production, horticulture, tree and woodland management. Importantly for soil science specifically, the crop and plant production specialism is aligned to the occupational standard for soil-based systems, providing a clear connection between classroom learning and the skills required in modern agriculture. The noble Lord, Lord Evans, referred to post-16 technical and vocational qualifications including T-levels, which I mentioned. We are building expertise through technical education, and I mentioned those particular colleges. The lifelong learning entitlement, which will replace and transform the existing student finance system in England, is going to broaden access to high-quality, flexible education and training. The current LLE modular offer includes all higher technical qualifications, and there are currently two HTQ quality-marked qualifications, in farm management and arboriculture—I was going to struggle to say that—and both qualifications develop learners’ understanding of soils, from soil management requirements in farming to applying soil science. I turn to the comments from the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett, on HE and colleges. Higher education, as noble Lords know, is made up of independent and autonomous providers. It is therefore for individual providers to decide on how they organise their business models, including course offerings and locations. The Government are not responsible for decisions made by individual universities. Total student enrolment has remained relatively stable in 2024-25. In one of the courses that was mentioned, for example, it is up from 35 in 2019-20 to 50.

    View contribution permalink →

  10. Baroness Bennett of Manor Castle (GP)

    We have a neoliberal marketised university system, so each is trying to survive. Do the Government really think that this is going to provide the skills, in this area and many others, that the country needs?

    View contribution permalink →

  11. Baroness Ramsey of Wall Heath (Lab)

    I will come on to answer that question. On the level of research funding, I remind noble Lords that funding decisions are made independently of the Government, as per the Haldane principle. This states that decisions about which research projects to fund should be made through independent evaluation by experts based on the quality and likely impact of that research. A recent independent review by the UK Centre for Ecology & Hydrology’s long-term observation portfolio concluded that soils remain a priority area for future development, particularly agricultural soils. The Natural Environment Research Council also sustains the long-term natural soil monitoring datasets and archives used by universities and PhD students, which provide the evidence and opportunity to train future generations of scientists. On the point made by the noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, soil health has indeed become a growing focus of environmental farming policy. Defra’s Environmental Improvement Plan sets targets for bringing more of England’s agricultural soil into sustainable management by 2030. Defra is also developing better ways to measure soil health. I am conscious of time, but I will also say on research that investment by the Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council in its soil science research portfolio has risen from £11.9 million in 2021-22 to £23.2 million in 2025-26, reflecting investment at institutes such as Rothamsted Research. From classroom to laboratory, we are building the knowledge and skills on which our soils and the farmers, land managers and scientists who care for them depend. I thank noble Lords again for their contributions, and I will write on any points that I have not been able to address today.

    View contribution permalink →

  12. Sitting suspended.

    View contribution permalink →

Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441478.