Trans-Pennine Rail Route: Electrification
Thursday, 19 November 2026
Contributions
Question for Short Debate
Asked by
Lord McCobb
To ask His Majesty’s Government what plans they have to deliver full electrification of the TransPennine rail route, in line with the commitments set out in the Hull and East Yorkshire Devolution Deal.
Lord McCobb (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords taking part this afternoon and to the House of Lords Library for its excellent briefing, which tells, in short, a story of promises made to Hull and East Yorkshire over many years which, sadly, have not yet been delivered. In my maiden speech last month, I told the House that it is faster to travel by train from London to Paris than it is from Hull to Liverpool. Today, I want to talk about the specific promise that was meant to change that, set out in black and white by two consecutive Governments. In October 2023, the previous Government’s Network North plan confirmed full electrification to Hull. A devolution deal for Hull and East Yorkshire followed, and in September 2024 this Government signed it. On rail, they could not have been clearer: “The government will bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line speed between Hull to Leeds and Hull to Sheffield”. That deal promised to cut the journey time from Hull to Leeds from 58 minutes to 48, and that from Hull to Manchester from 107 minutes to 84. It promised two fast trains an hour to Leeds, double the services to Sheffield and double the capacity. Those were clear, specific commitments, and what a rare and uplifting moment of cross-party consensus that deal represented—Conservative-led East Riding of Yorkshire Council agreeing with Lib Dem-led Hull City Council to sign a deal with a Conservative Government, then confirmed under a Labour one, to deliver at long last the infrastructure that this neglected corner of Yorkshire so vitally needs. Indeed, the explicit commitments in this agreement to these long-awaited improvements were key elements in finally persuading several others who remained sceptical about the mayoral devolution model that this was an opportunity to be embraced. Then, in January this year, Hull was left out of the Government’s Northern Powerhouse Rail plans. Sadly, this huge disappointment is not new. As the Library briefing records, electrification of the trans-Pennine route in full was announced in 2011, for completion by 2019. Fifteen years on, around a quarter of it is electrified, and the line to Hull is not included in any plans at all. In 2013, Hull Trains offered to finance electrification from Selby to Hull at an estimated cost of £100 million. In 2016, the then Government said no. Each time, the message to Hull and East Yorkshire has been the same: “Not yet, not you—maybe later”. This is not good enough. Other parts of Britain would simply not stand for this repeated delay, and neither should Hull and East Yorkshire. In place of that promise, the Government now offer battery electric trains on the existing track. In response to my Written Questions, the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, told me that these would cut the journey time from Hull to Leeds by “up to a minute”, and that: “Full electrification would not deliver additional journey time benefits without wider infrastructure enhancements”. I agree. That is precisely why the Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal committed to both electrification and improved line speed. Yet now we appear to be getting neither. There is a bigger problem still: freight. Battery trains may serve passengers, but heavy freight trains need the wires. If you stop rail electrification short of Hull, the line to one of the UK’s great ports will be left running on diesel while the rest of the route is upgraded. My noble friend Lord Fox will set out later what this means for freight in the Humber ports, but it severely risks driving more business elsewhere. The damage does not stop at Hull. For Beverley, Driffield and Bridlington, every train runs through Hull before heading west across the trans-Pennine route and to the east coast main line. Without electrification to Hull, those towns will be left even further at the end of the line in every sense, and the coastal communities who desperately need improved connectivity will fall even further behind. Hull and East Yorkshire have waited long enough. For a place as geographically isolated as ours, connectivity is everything. Yet, as I said last month, our motorway, the M62, stops 15 miles outside the city, and the nearest airport is in a field near Scunthorpe, with no rail link and often no public transport at weekends. Our second-nearest airport is Leeds Bradford Airport, to which we have no direct rail link either, and Hull recently lost its direct rail link to Manchester Airport. This is a city of more than a quarter of a million people at the heart of a region of 600,000 people, and a major port vital to this country’s economy, without a single direct rail link to an international airport. I will focus on one telling example of some of the problems faced by people in Hull and East Yorkshire. In 2022, Network Rail planned a new footbridge at Hessle station, with the intention of it lasting 120 years, but did not plan to build it with any clearance for future electrification. Emma Hardy MP wrote to Network Rail, reporting that the contractors had allegedly been told that there was “never going to be electrification on the line”. For a start, that is not planning for Hull’s future, but designing it out. In her letter, Emma Hardy wrote that electrification between Hull and Liverpool would be “a fundamental requirement in addressing regional rail inequalities”. I agree with every word she wrote. In 2022, she and her party were in opposition, but today her party is in government and has the power to deliver that. Hull is the UK’s green energy capital, but no one can build a modern economy on railway lines that have barely changed since the days of Dr Beeching. I have some important questions for the Minister. First, do the Government still stand by the commitment they signed in the devolution deal to electrify and improve line speed between Hull, Leeds and Sheffield? People in Hull and East Yorkshire deserve a clear answer. Secondly, will the Government publish the route-level analysis and whole-life cost comparison for the battery train decisions for Hull, including the impact on freight across the trans-Pennine route and, in particular, in relation to the port of Hull? Thirdly, will every bridge renewed on these lines in future leave room for wires to enable future electrification rather than design it out? Fourthly, when will the promised line speed improvements and better connectivity through to Sheffield come? The Minister previously said that they would be considered only in future years. Fifthly, can the Minister confirm that pre-agreed electrification between Leeds and York is on track, given that battery services to Hull will depend on it? Finally, will the Minister come to Hull to meet me, the leaders of our two local authorities, the chamber of commerce and the ports, and hear for himself why this matters so much? I will gladly take the train to Hull with him. This is not a party-political point. The leaders of both Hull City Council and East Riding of Yorkshire Council back this campaign, as do the University of Hull, the Hull and Humber Chamber of Commerce, our ports, civic and business leaders, and thousands of individual businesses and residents across Hull and East Yorkshire. The people of Hull and East Yorkshire are not asking for special treatment; we are asking for what other parts of the UK have come to take for granted. We are asking for what we were promised and what was signed and sealed in black and white in that devolution deal. I look forward to the Minister’s reply.
Lord Fox (LD)
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord McCobb and I congratulate him on securing this important debate. I am standing ahead of a quartet of formidable Yorkshire Liberal Democrats. I will talk predominantly about freight and its effect on business development but, before that, I want to take us south and west and back in time. My maternal grandfather was a lifelong Great Western Railway man. Indeed, I inherited his gold watch. The pinnacle of his career was to become the stationmaster at Dursley in the mid-1950s. It was a reasonably busy station, and I have a mental picture of him standing on the platform of his rural Gloucestershire station, watching the passengers alight as milk and eggs were loaded into the goods van. Perhaps this is a rather idealised view but, as we discussed together later, he knew that the real importance of his station was not just getting children to school and agricultural products to market; it was centred on RA Lister and Company. In the mid-1950s, Lister’s made engines that were the workhorses of the United Kingdom. In factories and on farms across the country, Lister’s engines of all sizes powered productivity. At Dursley, it manufactured hundreds of thousands of engines of all types, and it was the railway that moved these engines around Britain and beyond. Without the railway, it would have been impossible for Lister’s to operate in such a rural setting and, without an efficient railway hub, the area would have lost good jobs and the local prosperity that Lister’s delivered. Coincidentally, the 1950s was a time when steam was giving way to diesel. For all the romance of steam, the efficiency of the new engines was undeniable. Of course, there is a parallel today. So, although the stationmaster of historic Dursley is sadly no longer with us, the stationmaster of Great Britain is sitting opposite in the form of the Minister. Right now, he is presiding over railways during the next transformation: from diesel to electric. This change offers huge benefits to the communities adjacent to newly electrified lines. In 2012, the coalition Government said: “Electrification is an important element in delivering a long-term low-cost railway. Electrification will allow us to replace diesel trains, reducing journey times, increasing the railway’s capacity, and improving its environmental performance. These benefits will progressively extend to freight as well as passenger services”. It would be helpful if the Minister could confirm whether he subscribes to this view. As we have heard, a devolution deal drawn up by the Conservatives, and signed off by Labour in September 2024, pledged to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line speed between Hull and Leeds and between Hull and Sheffield. Once in place, full electrification would have cut Hull to Manchester journey times significantly. But, as my noble friend Lord McCobb explained, although the rail route from Manchester to York is currently being electrified, the lines to Hull are not. To be clear, Hull has not been included in recent government announcements on investment in northern rail infrastructure. As we have heard in an Answer to a Question from my noble friend, the Minister has offered only battery-electric trains on the existing track east of York, with a later explanation that these will cut journey times between Hull and Leeds by up to a minute. I cannot help thinking that that is very well within the bounds of the margins of most timetables. Crucially, a University of Birmingham study this summer found that rail freight needs full electrification and will not run on battery rolling stock in the foreseeable future, except over very short distances. Electric freight trains are around twice as powerful as diesel, faster up gradients and quicker to clear the line for passenger trains. Network Rail expects the wider trans-Pennine upgrade that it is doing to add up to 15 freight trains a day and take 1,000 lorries a day off the region’s roads. Without full electrification, Hull and Humber ports are shut out of that. The Government seem perfectly able to see the benefit of joining two university complexes together via the Oxford-Cambridge link. I ask them to take the same approach when linking industrial capacity to important freight infrastructure. That is why this debate is important. The new PM has talked about seeking “growth in every postcode”, but there can be no meaningful growth without significant infrastructure upgrades. This railway connection is a very good example of the upgrade we need. According to Associated British Ports, the Humber is the UK’s largest trading gateway by volume, handling around 17% of the nation’s port traffic, which largely passes through Immingham, Hull, Grimsby and Goole. Taken together, they handle some £60 billion of trade each year. Despite this national significance, the Humber’s ability to serve manufacturing, logistics and consumer markets across northern England is increasingly held back by inadequate east-west rail freight connectivity. Rail freight demand continues to grow, but the network serving the Humber remains constrained by limited capability, ageing infrastructure and restricted access. This is a genuine barrier to economic growth and private investment as congestion and uncertainty over long-term infrastructure delivery continue to restrict freight paths, undermine business confidence and limit development of new services. As a result, the trans-Pennine corridor currently carries far less freight than its strategic position would suggest. It is little wonder, therefore, that increasing freight capacity along this rail route has long been a priority for the Hull and Humber Chamber of Commerce and the area’s local authorities. In conclusion, despite their importance to the UK’s trade, energy and industrial sectors, Hull and the wider Humber area have historically been sold short on northern transport and growth strategies. This is illustrated fully by the Government’s current electrification plans, which screech to a shuddering halt at Selby. Yet it is not clear to me why this is the case. If this Government really want growth across that region, the economic benefits all point to full electrification. I look forward to the Minister’s explanation as to why this is not happening.
Lord Wallace of Saltaire (LD)
My Lords, we have a long history of talking about restoring growth in the north by transforming its railways. I declare a past interest as an active member of the trans-Pennine rail passengers group between 1968 and 1970. Things have improved a little since then, but not that much. Twelve years ago in 2014, George Osborne promised a major transformation of the system and a new line across the Pennines. He said that it would be complete by 2030. Transport for the North was then formed, and in 2019 Boris Johnson again pledged a fast line between Leeds and Manchester, which would be the core of a northern growth corridor for rail between Liverpool and Hull. Then, in her short period as Prime Minister, Mrs Truss promised the same thing, but the Sunak Government cut it back. It is a very good thing to have a Lords Minister here who understands the railways well. I still remember the noble Baroness, Lady Vere of Norbiton, promising, in spite of cutting the idea of a new line between Leeds and Manchester, that Bradford would have its line to Leeds electrified. She appeared unaware that there were two lines between Leeds and Bradford, one of which was electrified a very long time ago. Living on the electrified Leeds to Skipton and Leeds to Bradford line, I am amazed by how much a fast and reliable electric line—it is the only electrified local line in Yorkshire—has lifted the whole Aire Valley, in terms of house prices, commuting into Leeds and Bradford and local industries. Skipton is now regularly rated as one of the most popular places to live in and retire to in Britain. Electrification has very broad economic effects. We have been talking about, but not doing much to implement, the pulling together of Leeds, Manchester, Liverpool, Sheffield, Bradford, York and Hull. The Yorkshire local authorities together wanted a single regional administration for Yorkshire, recognising that Hull was the port that served for Leeds, Sheffield and Bradford. I declare a particular interest regarding Bradford because we are the largest city in Britain without a mainline railway station, and we have now at last been promised a new station but nothing in the way of a new line. I looked at the website for the new station this morning, and it tells me that when the new station is built we will have trains from Leeds to Bradford in 12 minutes and from Bradford to Manchester in 30 minutes. I think the Minister will agree with me that those are both not credible. Every train I have ever taken to Leeds stops for two to three minutes at the Leeds West junction, because there is so much congestion, which means it simply could not be done. The Yorkshire region and the north-west also depend on an effective trans-Pennine link, and the core of Northern Powerhouse Rail was the idea of a new line. We are very short of capacity for passengers and for freight. I remember a rail manager telling me not that long ago, “If you want to put more freight trains on the trans-Pennine line to get them from Liverpool to Hull and back, the easiest way to do it is to route them via Daventry”. I should explain for the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, that Daventry is north of Watford but actually very close to Watford Gap, so it would take us quite a long way to the south. So electrification is needed, but we understand that we are up against a Treasury which does not think more than 10 years’ investment ahead while this investment would be for 50 years or more. What we need is long-term public investment. I have just read the northern growth strategy that this Government put out some months ago, and it tells me that on transport: “The first phase will prioritise the quickest wins via upgrades to lines East of the Pennines for delivery in the 2030s… The second phase, west of the Pennines, will see major construction works in the 2030s and beyond… For the third phase, we will look at better cross-Pennine links”. Well, I hope my grandchildren see them. We desperately need more capacity. Electrification in itself will provide some extra capacity. The Minister may like to tell me at some point whether the current tunnels through the Pennines can fit the sort of heavy containers that we need to have, and which I regularly see on the M62 being carried by trucks because there is no space for them on the railway lines. We are therefore talking about the need for long-term investment, which is key to getting the north going. We have all sat through long debates as we saw Crossrail finished along with the east-west railway line to build a growth corridor between Oxford and Cambridge. We need to do the same for the north of England, and that includes Hull and Liverpool and—I speak as someone who lives on the outskirts of Bradford—it absolutely has to include Bradford.
Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord McCobb for securing this important debate. I will be focusing, not surprisingly, on the importance of real investment in South Yorkshire and the wider region because of its economic benefits. The debate about full electrification of the trans-Pennine route is about much more than technology powering our trains: it is about the economic opportunities that we heard about earlier; regional equality, as we heard from my noble friend, with regard to coastal and rural communities; and delivering a transport system that connects all parts of the country. For too long, transport investment in this country has been concentrated in London and the south-east, as we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Wallace. I will not say much more than that. While other regions have been promised improvements, too many communities, including us in the north of England, have experienced delays, cancellations, overcrowding and projects that have been announced, reannounced, scaled back and postponed. Sheffield and South Yorkshire know this all too well from personal experience. My home city of Sheffield is one of the largest cities in England, yet the rail connectivity there does not reflect its economic importance or potential. Our businesses, universities, manufacturers and communities depend on reliable connections to Manchester, Leeds, Hull, Liverpool and the wider north. The trans-Pennine route is therefore of strategic importance not just for the cities directly served by it but for the economic future of the Hull region. As we heard from my noble friend Lord McCobb, the Government’s own Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal made an explicit commitment to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, including electrification and improved line speeds between Hull and Leeds and between Hull and Sheffield. That commitment was significant, and it envisaged, as we heard earlier, reducing the journey time between Hull and Leeds from 58 to 48 minutes and between Hull and Manchester from 107 to 84 minutes. It promised two fast trains an hour between Hull and Leeds and increasing the services between Hull and Sheffield from one an hour to two an hour. Those are important ambitions, but they must not be just another set of promises that are quietly diluted away. I recognise the Government’s January 2026 northern growth strategy and the proposed £45 billion investment in Northern Powerhouse Rail. I also welcome the commitment to prioritise electrification and upgrades between Leeds and Sheffield, alongside improvements at Sheffield station. The agreement signed between the Government and the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority is particularly welcome. It identifies four fast trains an hour between Sheffield and Leeds as an ambition, alongside increasing capacity at Sheffield station to accommodate more direct services. That is all welcome. These are precisely the kind of investments that our region needs. However, I am concerned that the Government’s approach to the Hull connection risks creating a two-tier railway, in which some routes receive the full benefits of being electrified and infrastructure investments, while others are expected to make do with less ambitious solutions. The Government have suggested that 29 new battery-electric trains will enable electric services to operate in Hull, but that that infrastructure will be designed to accommodate future Northern Powerhouse Rail bi-mode trains. I welcome a move away from diesel, and battery technology has a role to play in modernising our railways, but we must not distinguish between introducing new rolling stock and investment in the railway infrastructure itself. New trains cannot on their own solve the problems of capacity, bottlenecks, unreliability and inadequate line speeds, and nor should battery technology become an excuse to abandon a long-term ambition of having a properly electrified and modernised network. I am aware that the Government will argue that full electrification will not deliver additional journey time savings without wider infrastructure improvements. That may be true for journey times alone, but the case of electrification is much broader; it includes operational resilience, environmental benefits, long-term costs and the ability to accommodate future growth. For South Yorkshire, connectivity between Hull and Sheffield is particularly important. Sheffield should not be treated as an afterthought to plans designed primarily around Leeds and Manchester. In her speech last week, my noble friend Lady Kitching of Penistone explained that, although towns like Penistone may be served well by roads, they are not served well by trains. Here, I also make the case for a Woodhead tunnel; it is important for connectivity between South Yorkshire and Manchester. In Sheffield, we also have major manufacturing bases, a world-class university, significant opportunities and clean energy. Better rail connections will help these businesses access markets, attract investment and enable people to reach employment and education opportunities. There is also an important question about freight. South Yorkshire’s industrial economy depends on efficient transport links, including connections to the Humber ports. Improving passenger and freight infrastructure can strengthen the economic relationship between Sheffield, Doncaster, Hull and the wider Humber region. I also urge the Government to recognise that investment in rail is of regional importance. We cannot expect the north to deliver its full economic potential if travelling between its major cities remains slow, unreliable and inconvenient. Therefore, I have three questions for the Minister. First, will the Government reaffirm that their commitment in the Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal to electrify and improve line speed between Hull, Leeds and Sheffield remains intact, rather than it being replaced by a commitment to simply introduce battery electric trains? Secondly, what timetable will the Government set for assessing and progressing the necessary improvements to the Sheffield and Hull corridor, including electrification, line speed, capacity and service frequency? In particular, will they commit to delivering the promised two trains an hour between Hull and Sheffield? Thirdly, will the Government work with South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority, Hull and East Yorkshire Combined Authority and other regional leaders to develop an integrated investment plan that recognises the importance of connections between Sheffield, Leeds, Hull and the wider northern growth corridor? For many years, we have had promises about levelling up, regional growth and rebalancing the economy. What matters now is delivery. Our region does not want any special treatment; it wants a fair share of the national investment and transport infrastructure needed to compete, create jobs and attract businesses. The railways must connect our northern cities, not reinforce the economic division between them. I hope the Minister will provide some reassurance that the Government’s ambitions for Northern Powerhouse Rail will translate into real improvements for passengers and businesses in Yorkshire and across the wider north.
Baroness Pinnock (LD)
My Lords, this is the fifth contribution among those of us who actually live in Yorkshire to today’s debate. My noble friend Lord McCobb rightly shone a light on a decision that so disadvantages people living in Hull and East Yorkshire. This debate has demonstrated that the concerns are of practicality and principle. The trans-Pennine upgrade is vital because improving connectivity leads to improving economic and social opportunities for people. If, as the Prime Minister pledged, every postcode will benefit from growth, how is it possible to make a decision that fails to provide fast and efficient rail connections to the great city of Hull? The north of England has the port city of Liverpool in the west, with access to sea trade to north America, and the port area of Humberside in the east, with sea access to trade with northern Europe. The Victorians understood their importance to business. How is it that the Government have failed to understand the pivotal significance of these ports to the well-being and prosperity of our country? My noble friend Lord Fox described the vital link to Humberside for freight transport, especially as ports in Hull alone handle £12 billion-worth of goods each year. My noble friend Lord Wallace pointed out the significant economic benefits of the electrification of rail links in the Aire Valley. Regular users of the M62 motorway, like me, which ostensibly connects the trans-Pennine route by road, will experience the large volume of HGVs seeking to access the ports. HGVs driving on the M62 towards Hull will find that, 15 miles from the port, the motorway ends and the route continues on basic A roads. It is shocking that not only does the motorway fail to reach Hull but this failure is being compounded by a decision not to electrify and modernise the rail link to Hull. Comparing recent major transport infrastructure decisions by Governments tells its own story. The successful Elizabeth line cost around £18 billion. The projected cost of the trans-Pennine upgrade, which excludes improvements to the line from Leeds to Hull, is £8 billion. The trans-Pennine upgrade is not just about electrifying the line so that we can get rid of diesels, but includes major modernisation of signalling and, in some areas, doubling the track, so that more services can be provided between the great cities of the north of England, as well as reducing travel time. It will be a much-needed, much-anticipated improvement to connectivity. Meanwhile, the line from Selby to Hull is not to benefit. The decision not to make the investment on that section of the route has long-term consequences, not just for Hull and the region but for the country, as do the similar decisions for lack of investment in modernising links with South Yorkshire, particularly the great city of Sheffield, as my noble friend Lord Mohammed of Tinsley explained. The Government’s decision to invest in the dual battery-electric trains is one to ponder because, as my noble friend Lord McCobb pointed out, the journey times from Hull to Leeds are apparently reduced by just one minute. Can the Minister explain why spending on battery electric trains, which cost twice as much as normal electric trains, can be justified? Those are the practicalities resulting from the decision to omit Hull and the wider area of East Yorkshire from the benefits of the upgrade. What is unforgivable is the broken promises. Both Conservative and Labour Governments have reneged on a specific commitment that was then endorsed as part of the devolution deal for Hull and the East Riding that the rail line would be included as part of the trans-Pennine upgrade. In 2023, the Conservative Government published their draft devolution deal, which promised to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line and therefore the speeds between Hull to Leeds and Hull to Sheffield. This would, as we have heard, cut journey times from Leeds and Hull from 58 to 48 minutes—a significant improvement—and from Hull to Manchester from 107 to 84 minutes. It would also enable two fast trains an hour to Leeds, double the trains between Hull and Sheffield from one to two an hour and enable capacity to double. So lots of benefits were outlined at the time. That agreement was then rubber-stamped by the incoming Labour Government, and everybody was delighted that that was the case. However, it seems that that is not now to happen. Trust is lost, promises are broken and the result is lost opportunities not only for the whole area but, as we have explained, for the country as a whole, particularly as the broken ties with our European neighbours begin to be restored. The fervent hope from those of us who live in and care about Yorkshire is that the Government will reconsider so that the whole area can benefit and those living there can begin to feel valued by central government. We look forward to what the Minister has to say. I recognise that he is devoted to the importance of rail and improving rail infrastructure, and I cannot imagine that he has been part of this decision to omit Hull from improvements to much-needed rail links.
Lord Moylan (Con)
My Lords, I am not entirely sure why the noble Lord, Lord Wallace of Saltaire, thinks that I in particular need to be told where Daventry is. As somebody brought up in the Midlands, I am very well aware where Daventry is. Perhaps I can just tell the noble Lord, who does not have that advantage, that it is a great deal closer to Coventry than it is to Watford. I am not entirely sure either why the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, thinks that this is a failure of the Conservative Government since, as she said, it was included in Conservative plans but, as the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, said, had cross-party support. I want to be as sympathetic as I can to the noble Lord, because it is not our decision to scrap the plans for electrification. In principle, we would like to see them go ahead. But what we would like to see most of all at this stage, and what would be helpful to everybody, is a proper assessment of the two alternatives, set out clearly as to cost, feasibility and time of deliverability. If the Minister could give an assurance that such an assessment was properly carried out before a decision was taken and that he is willing to put it in the public domain, that would take a great deal of heat out of the argument, while at the same time paying respect to the people of Hull and its vicinity, because they would be able to see and engage with the arguments, which at the moment I do not think they can. Since I have had an opportunity to think about this issue, which without the Question from the noble Lord I might not have done, I will focus on the thing that struck me—the electric battery trains. The order is for £1 billion, but I believe it is £1.2 billion in total because £200 million of that is a commuted sum for lifetime maintenance of the trains. There will be 29 trainsets for that, which gives each a cost of roughly £34 million. For five-car trainsets, that seems to me very expensive. If you include the maintenance costs, you are at over £40 million. If their sole achievement in transport terms is to improve journey times by up to a minute, which appears to be what the Minister has said in response to Questions, I really wonder whether this is the right decision in the first place in terms of value for public money. There is also the question of the reliability of the trains. I do not want to cast any aspersions, but we do not have such trains in the UK. This will be a first for us. I believe they are to be built by Alstom in England. That plant has never built such trains. My understanding is that Alstom has built such trains elsewhere, but are we confident that they will be reliable? They will have to travel roughly 40 miles from Selby to Hull on batteries alone. They can draw power from overhead lines on electrified lines, but if the line is not electrified then they will be travelling solely on battery for 40 miles. Where is the charging infrastructure going to be? I understand that it will be at Hull station. Will it be there alone? If it is at Hull station alone, that means 80 miles between charges—these are round numbers. Is that feasible for batteries carrying such weight? A train is very much heavier even than one of those lumbering Chinese motor vehicles that go around on the streets, which are heavy enough. It is a great deal heavier than that, and it has to be hauled a considerable distance. How dependable is the charging infrastructure? Is there spare capacity at Hull station so that, if one charging facility does not work, another one is available—or will the trains be marooned there? What consideration have the Government given to what they will do if trains start breaking down mid-route? How will this be fixed retrospectively? Could the trains turn out to be white elephants? I have no reason to think that they will, but I am suspicious when people embark on new technologies that have not been tested, at least in the UK. We do not have experience of them in the UK. I understand that some ex-District line trains run on batteries in Richmond, or somewhere in that vicinity, but I do not think they are comparable to what we are discussing here. We do not have experience of them, and I am a little suspicious when they are rolled out for reasons that are unclear, given that they achieve almost nothing in terms of journey time improvements and the transport improvements are so low. These are genuine questions. I would genuinely like to know. They are certainly questions that I would ask if I were the Minister and being asked to sign off on such an expensive order of trains. I am sure he asked them before he approved the placement of this order in September 2026, and I would be keen to hear what answers he got. If he is not able, in the 10 minutes or so allotted to him, to give those answers, or to answer my earlier questions, I would be grateful if he could write to me. But I would like to hear answered in Grand Committee whether a proper assessment has been carried out of the alternatives, whether it is available to him and whether he will publish it. That is indispensable if we are to have a sensible debate about this obviously sensitive and important topic.
The Minister of State, Department for Transport (Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill) (Lab)
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lord on securing this debate and thank noble Lords for their contributions. I will write to noble Lords if I do not answer all their questions in this speech—I cannot answer all the questions, so I will have to write. I will certainly write to the noble Lord, Lord Mohammed of Tinsley, who asked me more questions about Sheffield than Hull. I can answer them, but I cannot do so now. This Government are ambitious for Hull and East Yorkshire, as they are for elsewhere in the north of England. We want a railway that matches the ambition of its people, businesses and communities, connecting them to jobs and education opportunities, supporting investment and recognising Hull and the Humber’s national economic importance. I recognise the strength of feeling about electrification, but it is not right to measure success by whether we have overhead wires. It should be measured by reliable, frequent services and trains and infrastructure that meet the standards that passengers and freight rightly expect. Electrification is one route to achieving these outcomes, but it is not on its own the definition of success. I will outline today the improvements that Hull will see and our strategy for achieving them. At the heart of our ambition is Northern Powerhouse Rail. Announced in January as part of the northern growth strategy, our new plans supersede previous proposals, including those in the devolution deal, and the more extensive but speculative, complex and unfunded Network North document produced by the previous Sunak Government. We inherited those transport schemes, announced without any funding to deliver them. January’s Northern Powerhouse Rail announcement reflected careful consideration of what could realistically and responsibly be funded and delivered. Difficult choices were unavoidable, but they do not diminish the ambition for Hull. The announcement in January was of an investment of up to £45 billion in Northern Powerhouse Rail, building on the £11 billion trans-Pennine route upgrade already under way, to create a faster, more frequent and more reliable railway connecting Liverpool, Manchester, Bradford, Leeds, Sheffield and York, with more frequent and regular services to Chester, Newcastle and, crucially, Hull. Our ambition for a transformational turn-up-and-go railway across the whole northern growth corridor will connect more people to good jobs, support housing and help businesses invest, grow and recruit. Phased delivery is essential and will bring benefits progressively: first, the benefits of the trans-Pennine upgrade, which I will come on to a bit later; then electrification upgrades, and upgrades between Leeds and Bradford, Leeds and Sheffield and Leeds and York; then the major new Liverpool to Manchester line in the west, followed by further cross-Pennine connections. I should be clear that the Government are committed to Northern Powerhouse Rail benefits for Hull. January’s announcement did not commit to continuous overhead electrification west of Hull, but that is not required for NPR to reach and better serve the city and should not be mistaken for a lack of ambition. As I said, the trans-Pennine route upgrade is transforming the 70-mile railway between Manchester and York via Huddersfield and Leeds with electrification, increased capacity and station improvements. Although outside the core infrastructure route, Hull will benefit from the wider transformation. It is the Government’s largest transport investment currently in delivery in the north of England, and 96% of the route is now at the design or delivery stage. Of the £11 billion total, £7.8 billion is already committed. Improvements will arrive progressively, with many important passenger benefits, by the early to mid-2030s, ahead of full completion by 2041. Crucially, the project is on time and on budget. A faster, more frequent, more reliable and higher-capacity passenger railway with more capacity for freight will strengthen Hull’s connections to Leeds, Manchester and the wider north, creating opportunities for passengers, businesses, freight and the Humber ports, laying the foundation, as I said, for Northern Powerhouse Rail. As noble Lords have heard, £1 billion is being invested in 29 new British-built trans-Pennine express trains, supporting more than 350 skilled jobs in Derby and almost 6,000 across the UK supply chain. The planned service uplift after the trans-Pennine route upgrade concludes will provide three additional trains an hour between Manchester and Leeds, increasing services from five to eight. We are planning for a 100% increase in frequency, with two services per hour continuing to and from Hull. Crucially, as noble Lords have heard, the fleet will include the UK’s first battery-electric trains for long-distance mainline services, bringing the prospect of significant investment in charging infrastructure around Hull. Those investments will improve the services, trains infrastructure and capacity on which passengers and the local economy depend. Alongside investment, we also have a generational opportunity to change how the railway is run. Through Great British Railways, we are bringing track and train together under one directing mind, placing passengers and freight customers at the centre of decision-making. Trains infrastructure, timetables and depots will be planned together, not in isolation, with clearer accountability for results. GBR will bring these choices together with clearer accountability for outcomes. For Hull, that means planning connections as part of a coherent railway rather than treating each fleet, route or infrastructure project separately. It means taking a long-term view of service development, sequencing investment and supporting the region’s economic ambitions. That whole-system approach will go hand in hand with partnership with local leaders, ensuring that decisions reflect the needs of the places served. Structural change is of course not an end in itself; the true test is whether it delivers a more reliable, responsive railway, better able to make the-long term decisions that Hull and the country need. Our plan is that it will do so. I turn to how we power trains serving Hull. Electrification is central to the trans-Pennine route upgrade in the first phase of Northern Powerhouse Rail, but modern technology does not always require overhead wires over every mile. The recently published GBR Rolling S tock and Infrastructure Strategy recognises that partial electrification with battery-electric trains can replace ageing diesel fleets, delivering cleaner modern services while avoiding the cost, disruption and time associated with continuous electrification. The new trans-Pennine express fleet is an important step. Those trains are funded, they are ordered and they will be delivered. They will recharge beneath overhead wires, then continue on batteries with additional charging infrastructure where necessary, and including Hull, which I will get to. Incidentally, we are planning that the east-west railway route from Oxford to Cambridge, which has been referred to today, will also be electrified discontinuously with battery-electric trains. I will look to see what we can publish on the value-for-money analysis of bi-mode trains, as noble Lords have asked. Normally the department will publish a whole business case for the major schemes, but I will see what we can do in that respect. As I explained in my Written Answer, the new trains are expected to cut Hull to Manchester journey times by five to six minutes. In fact, that was a pessimistic view. For trains that stop between Leeds and Manchester it will be five to six minutes, but for fast trains it is up to 11 minutes, which reconciles the benefits quoted for trans-Pennine upgrade with the Answer that I gave to the noble Lord’s Question. Hull is a regional priority because several expected fleets are being developed around battery-electric technology. Battery-electric technology is relatively new but is rapidly developing. As the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, said, there are examples being manufactured elsewhere in the world. We have to use the best of technological advances, and the railway rolling stock industry is an international industry, so tests in other countries will do just as well as tests here. The technology offers electrification without wires or the associated cost of infrastructure. Network Rail is developing a single railway requirement so that infrastructure serving different operators and passengers will be interchangeable and will adapt to demand. Northern is preparing to procure a large new fleet with provision for ultra-low emission operation and/or conversion to zero-emission operation through electric and/or battery power. As noble Lords will know, Hull Trains, an open access operator, already operates bi-mode trains. The charging infrastructure that we are proposing to install in Hull will create opportunities for it to consider batteries in future fleet decisions. Not every service can transition identically or simultaneously. Decisions must reflect the needs of passengers, distances, costs, freight and operational requirements, including depot journeys, stabling, maintenance and timetables. Crucially, advances in technology, not only before the new trains are delivered but during their lives, will also make a difference. A station charger alone is not enough: trains, power supplies, charging and depots must work together. These are requirements for reliable delivery, not arguments against ambition, and they are, of course, infrastructure investments in themselves. All the questions that the noble Lord, Lord Moylan, asked about the practicability of these trains can be answered. The noble Lord, Lord Fox, rightly talked about freight. The trans-Pennine upgrade creates the capacity for more freight paths across the Pennines and electrifies a major part of the route. The new generation of bi-mode freight locomotives can use the wires where they exist and are powered by diesel where they do not. That is the answer to the noble Lord’s question. The TRU gives the capacity, and a new generation of freight locomotives—funded, incidentally, by the private sector—will be helped by the freight target to be brought in by the Railways Bill. The answer to the noble Lord, Lord Wallace of Saltaire, is that the trans-Pennine upgrade will allow the largest containers to travel across the Pennines in freight trains in the way that they currently do today. January’s Northern Powerhouse Rail announcement does not preclude enhancements through other funding routes where there is a strong investment case. Further improvements, including Hull’s Sheffield connections, will continue to be considered in future years. We simply cannot do everything at once. To conclude, Hull’s mayor has welcomed this investment. He said that the battery trains are a “better option” than electrification. I have strong engagement with Hull’s three MPs, who back it and want the wider move away from diesel to continue and to see better services to Hull. We are ambitious for Hull; we will deliver what I have talked about today. Northern Powerhouse Rail is funded, as are the new trains, and I look forward to working with noble Lords, local leaders, operators and everyone with a stake in Hull’s future to turn our ambition into better journeys, stronger connections and greater opportunity.
Lord McCobb (LD)
Before the Minister sits down, may I press him briefly on two points? First, will he clarify that, in saying that the plans announced in January supersede previous plans, including the devolution deal, he is expressly saying that the devolution deal no longer stands? Secondly, on the point about engagement with local leaders, the Minister talked about engagement with the combined authority mayor. Will he give a commitment to engage with the leaders of the two local authorities, who both agree that the deal that they signed in good faith has not been adhered to?
Lord Hendy of Richmond Hill (Lab)
The Government’s commitment is to the northern growth corridor and the Northern Powerhouse Rail announcement in January, which represents the first funded programme for rail improvement in the north for a very long time. All previous plans, whatever they were, were both aspirational and unfunded. I am committing to things that can be actually delivered with money that is actually available, not plans that are long into the future. I will write to the noble Lord about local engagement. It is not my intention to exclude any particular local political section.
Sitting suspended.
Source: UK Parliament Hansard API. Debate ID: 5441477.