B

Baroness Pinnock (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Trans-Pennine Rail Route: Electrification

Contribution

My Lords, this is the fifth contribution among those of us who actually live in Yorkshire to today’s debate. My noble friend Lord McCobb rightly shone a light on a decision that so disadvantages people living in Hull and East Yorkshire. This debate has demonstrated that the concerns are of practicality and principle. The trans-Pennine upgrade is vital because improving connectivity leads to improving economic and social opportunities for people. If, as the Prime Minister pledged, every postcode will benefit from growth, how is it possible to make a decision that fails to provide fast and efficient rail connections to the great city of Hull? The north of England has the port city of Liverpool in the west, with access to sea trade to north America, and the port area of Humberside in the east, with sea access to trade with northern Europe. The Victorians understood their importance to business. How is it that the Government have failed to understand the pivotal significance of these ports to the well-being and prosperity of our country? My noble friend Lord Fox described the vital link to Humberside for freight transport, especially as ports in Hull alone handle £12 billion-worth of goods each year. My noble friend Lord Wallace pointed out the significant economic benefits of the electrification of rail links in the Aire Valley. Regular users of the M62 motorway, like me, which ostensibly connects the trans-Pennine route by road, will experience the large volume of HGVs seeking to access the ports. HGVs driving on the M62 towards Hull will find that, 15 miles from the port, the motorway ends and the route continues on basic A roads. It is shocking that not only does the motorway fail to reach Hull but this failure is being compounded by a decision not to electrify and modernise the rail link to Hull. Comparing recent major transport infrastructure decisions by Governments tells its own story. The successful Elizabeth line cost around £18 billion. The projected cost of the trans-Pennine upgrade, which excludes improvements to the line from Leeds to Hull, is £8 billion. The trans-Pennine upgrade is not just about electrifying the line so that we can get rid of diesels, but includes major modernisation of signalling and, in some areas, doubling the track, so that more services can be provided between the great cities of the north of England, as well as reducing travel time. It will be a much-needed, much-anticipated improvement to connectivity. Meanwhile, the line from Selby to Hull is not to benefit. The decision not to make the investment on that section of the route has long-term consequences, not just for Hull and the region but for the country, as do the similar decisions for lack of investment in modernising links with South Yorkshire, particularly the great city of Sheffield, as my noble friend Lord Mohammed of Tinsley explained. The Government’s decision to invest in the dual battery-electric trains is one to ponder because, as my noble friend Lord McCobb pointed out, the journey times from Hull to Leeds are apparently reduced by just one minute. Can the Minister explain why spending on battery electric trains, which cost twice as much as normal electric trains, can be justified? Those are the practicalities resulting from the decision to omit Hull and the wider area of East Yorkshire from the benefits of the upgrade. What is unforgivable is the broken promises. Both Conservative and Labour Governments have reneged on a specific commitment that was then endorsed as part of the devolution deal for Hull and the East Riding that the rail line would be included as part of the trans-Pennine upgrade. In 2023, the Conservative Government published their draft devolution deal, which promised to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line and therefore the speeds between Hull to Leeds and Hull to Sheffield. This would, as we have heard, cut journey times from Leeds and Hull from 58 to 48 minutes—a significant improvement—and from Hull to Manchester from 107 to 84 minutes. It would also enable two fast trains an hour to Leeds, double the trains between Hull and Sheffield from one to two an hour and enable capacity to double. So lots of benefits were outlined at the time. That agreement was then rubber-stamped by the incoming Labour Government, and everybody was delighted that that was the case. However, it seems that that is not now to happen. Trust is lost, promises are broken and the result is lost opportunities not only for the whole area but, as we have explained, for the country as a whole, particularly as the broken ties with our European neighbours begin to be restored. The fervent hope from those of us who live in and care about Yorkshire is that the Government will reconsider so that the whole area can benefit and those living there can begin to feel valued by central government. We look forward to what the Minister has to say. I recognise that he is devoted to the importance of rail and improving rail infrastructure, and I cannot imagine that he has been part of this decision to omit Hull from improvements to much-needed rail links.

More from Baroness Pinnock (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.