L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Trans-Pennine Rail Route: Electrification

Contribution

My Lords, I am not entirely sure why the noble Lord, Lord Wallace of Saltaire, thinks that I in particular need to be told where Daventry is. As somebody brought up in the Midlands, I am very well aware where Daventry is. Perhaps I can just tell the noble Lord, who does not have that advantage, that it is a great deal closer to Coventry than it is to Watford. I am not entirely sure either why the noble Baroness, Lady Pinnock, thinks that this is a failure of the Conservative Government since, as she said, it was included in Conservative plans but, as the noble Lord, Lord McCobb, said, had cross-party support. I want to be as sympathetic as I can to the noble Lord, because it is not our decision to scrap the plans for electrification. In principle, we would like to see them go ahead. But what we would like to see most of all at this stage, and what would be helpful to everybody, is a proper assessment of the two alternatives, set out clearly as to cost, feasibility and time of deliverability. If the Minister could give an assurance that such an assessment was properly carried out before a decision was taken and that he is willing to put it in the public domain, that would take a great deal of heat out of the argument, while at the same time paying respect to the people of Hull and its vicinity, because they would be able to see and engage with the arguments, which at the moment I do not think they can. Since I have had an opportunity to think about this issue, which without the Question from the noble Lord I might not have done, I will focus on the thing that struck me—the electric battery trains. The order is for £1 billion, but I believe it is £1.2 billion in total because £200 million of that is a commuted sum for lifetime maintenance of the trains. There will be 29 trainsets for that, which gives each a cost of roughly £34 million. For five-car trainsets, that seems to me very expensive. If you include the maintenance costs, you are at over £40 million. If their sole achievement in transport terms is to improve journey times by up to a minute, which appears to be what the Minister has said in response to Questions, I really wonder whether this is the right decision in the first place in terms of value for public money. There is also the question of the reliability of the trains. I do not want to cast any aspersions, but we do not have such trains in the UK. This will be a first for us. I believe they are to be built by Alstom in England. That plant has never built such trains. My understanding is that Alstom has built such trains elsewhere, but are we confident that they will be reliable? They will have to travel roughly 40 miles from Selby to Hull on batteries alone. They can draw power from overhead lines on electrified lines, but if the line is not electrified then they will be travelling solely on battery for 40 miles. Where is the charging infrastructure going to be? I understand that it will be at Hull station. Will it be there alone? If it is at Hull station alone, that means 80 miles between charges—these are round numbers. Is that feasible for batteries carrying such weight? A train is very much heavier even than one of those lumbering Chinese motor vehicles that go around on the streets, which are heavy enough. It is a great deal heavier than that, and it has to be hauled a considerable distance. How dependable is the charging infrastructure? Is there spare capacity at Hull station so that, if one charging facility does not work, another one is available—or will the trains be marooned there? What consideration have the Government given to what they will do if trains start breaking down mid-route? How will this be fixed retrospectively? Could the trains turn out to be white elephants? I have no reason to think that they will, but I am suspicious when people embark on new technologies that have not been tested, at least in the UK. We do not have experience of them in the UK. I understand that some ex-District line trains run on batteries in Richmond, or somewhere in that vicinity, but I do not think they are comparable to what we are discussing here. We do not have experience of them, and I am a little suspicious when they are rolled out for reasons that are unclear, given that they achieve almost nothing in terms of journey time improvements and the transport improvements are so low. These are genuine questions. I would genuinely like to know. They are certainly questions that I would ask if I were the Minister and being asked to sign off on such an expensive order of trains. I am sure he asked them before he approved the placement of this order in September 2026, and I would be keen to hear what answers he got. If he is not able, in the 10 minutes or so allotted to him, to give those answers, or to answer my earlier questions, I would be grateful if he could write to me. But I would like to hear answered in Grand Committee whether a proper assessment has been carried out of the alternatives, whether it is available to him and whether he will publish it. That is indispensable if we are to have a sensible debate about this obviously sensitive and important topic.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.