L

Lord Moylan (Con)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 20 November 2026

Debate

Complications from Abortions (Annual Report) Bill [HL]

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken in the debate, the great majority of whom engaged to some extent with the Bill. I will go through a few comments that were made. The noble Baronesses, Lady Thornton and Lady Sugg, and others, raised the question of abortion being exceptionalised by the Bill. I refute that. It is the case that abortion is treated exceptionally because of the 1967 Act. I do not know what was in the minds of parliamentarians in 1967 when they put the requirement for mandatory reporting in a statute—something that exists, I agree, but does not exist for other medical procedures—but they did so, and I am simply taking that for granted. Nobody has suggested removing it. It is perfectly legitimate to suggest removing it, but you need a different Private Member’s Bill. It is not one that arises in relation to today. The noble Baroness, Lady Thornton, also said it was difficult to collect the statistics to which I am referring. It is more difficult to collect them than it might be if they were reported directly. The OHID had to go into hospitals to get the data, but data is already available, as the Minister said. It is recorded in hospital episode statistics by code—the NHS has a code for nearly every procedure it carries out. It would be less difficult to collect it if hospitals were simply required to report it on a routine basis. It would then be held centrally and could be gathered. It is not a difficult thing to do. The noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, misunderstood me in one respect. I said I thought that the HSA4 form is required for every termination, not only in the case of complications, so she is right about that. We are in strong agreement on the matter. As far as data is concerned, I did not say that 1.8%, or 2% if you prefer to round it up, was a high figure. I simply said that it is a great deal higher—about 10 times higher—than the figure routinely reported, with great complacency, by the department, which is extremely misleading. The Minister deflected the point about confidentiality. There is no suggestion that, in carrying out its work in 2023, the OHID either had access to individual personal records or that there was a risk of breach of confidentiality, or that one occurred. There are many interesting questions in the debates on the Health Bill concerning the single patient record that may well relate to confidentiality. None of them is relevant to what is being discussed here. Confidentiality is not an issue, and it is not at risk. The noble Baroness, Lady Freeman of Steventon, brought great expertise to this, but the conclusion of her argument arose in the assertion that “a lot of care is taken over abortion … statistics”. In my speech, I said that I am confident that abortion providers do return HSA4 forms and, except for the recent collapse and catastrophe over the last couple of years, statistics have until 2023 been published accurately. The fact is that they capture only about 1/10th of the incidents that they are meant to capture. It seems to me the noble Baroness brings a certain level of complacency to this. To say that they are being carefully collected when they are not even aimed at collecting incidents that take place outside the abortion notification system seems to me either complacent or misleading.

More from Lord Moylan (Con)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.