L

Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Trans-Pennine Rail Route: Electrification

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord McCobb for securing this important debate. I will be focusing, not surprisingly, on the importance of real investment in South Yorkshire and the wider region because of its economic benefits. The debate about full electrification of the trans-Pennine route is about much more than technology powering our trains: it is about the economic opportunities that we heard about earlier; regional equality, as we heard from my noble friend, with regard to coastal and rural communities; and delivering a transport system that connects all parts of the country. For too long, transport investment in this country has been concentrated in London and the south-east, as we heard from the noble Lord, Lord Wallace. I will not say much more than that. While other regions have been promised improvements, too many communities, including us in the north of England, have experienced delays, cancellations, overcrowding and projects that have been announced, reannounced, scaled back and postponed. Sheffield and South Yorkshire know this all too well from personal experience. My home city of Sheffield is one of the largest cities in England, yet the rail connectivity there does not reflect its economic importance or potential. Our businesses, universities, manufacturers and communities depend on reliable connections to Manchester, Leeds, Hull, Liverpool and the wider north. The trans-Pennine route is therefore of strategic importance not just for the cities directly served by it but for the economic future of the Hull region. As we heard from my noble friend Lord McCobb, the Government’s own Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal made an explicit commitment to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, including electrification and improved line speeds between Hull and Leeds and between Hull and Sheffield. That commitment was significant, and it envisaged, as we heard earlier, reducing the journey time between Hull and Leeds from 58 to 48 minutes and between Hull and Manchester from 107 to 84 minutes. It promised two fast trains an hour between Hull and Leeds and increasing the services between Hull and Sheffield from one an hour to two an hour. Those are important ambitions, but they must not be just another set of promises that are quietly diluted away. I recognise the Government’s January 2026 northern growth strategy and the proposed £45 billion investment in Northern Powerhouse Rail. I also welcome the commitment to prioritise electrification and upgrades between Leeds and Sheffield, alongside improvements at Sheffield station. The agreement signed between the Government and the South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority is particularly welcome. It identifies four fast trains an hour between Sheffield and Leeds as an ambition, alongside increasing capacity at Sheffield station to accommodate more direct services. That is all welcome. These are precisely the kind of investments that our region needs. However, I am concerned that the Government’s approach to the Hull connection risks creating a two-tier railway, in which some routes receive the full benefits of being electrified and infrastructure investments, while others are expected to make do with less ambitious solutions. The Government have suggested that 29 new battery-electric trains will enable electric services to operate in Hull, but that that infrastructure will be designed to accommodate future Northern Powerhouse Rail bi-mode trains. I welcome a move away from diesel, and battery technology has a role to play in modernising our railways, but we must not distinguish between introducing new rolling stock and investment in the railway infrastructure itself. New trains cannot on their own solve the problems of capacity, bottlenecks, unreliability and inadequate line speeds, and nor should battery technology become an excuse to abandon a long-term ambition of having a properly electrified and modernised network. I am aware that the Government will argue that full electrification will not deliver additional journey time savings without wider infrastructure improvements. That may be true for journey times alone, but the case of electrification is much broader; it includes operational resilience, environmental benefits, long-term costs and the ability to accommodate future growth. For South Yorkshire, connectivity between Hull and Sheffield is particularly important. Sheffield should not be treated as an afterthought to plans designed primarily around Leeds and Manchester. In her speech last week, my noble friend Lady Kitching of Penistone explained that, although towns like Penistone may be served well by roads, they are not served well by trains. Here, I also make the case for a Woodhead tunnel; it is important for connectivity between South Yorkshire and Manchester. In Sheffield, we also have major manufacturing bases, a world-class university, significant opportunities and clean energy. Better rail connections will help these businesses access markets, attract investment and enable people to reach employment and education opportunities. There is also an important question about freight. South Yorkshire’s industrial economy depends on efficient transport links, including connections to the Humber ports. Improving passenger and freight infrastructure can strengthen the economic relationship between Sheffield, Doncaster, Hull and the wider Humber region. I also urge the Government to recognise that investment in rail is of regional importance. We cannot expect the north to deliver its full economic potential if travelling between its major cities remains slow, unreliable and inconvenient. Therefore, I have three questions for the Minister. First, will the Government reaffirm that their commitment in the Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal to electrify and improve line speed between Hull, Leeds and Sheffield remains intact, rather than it being replaced by a commitment to simply introduce battery electric trains? Secondly, what timetable will the Government set for assessing and progressing the necessary improvements to the Sheffield and Hull corridor, including electrification, line speed, capacity and service frequency? In particular, will they commit to delivering the promised two trains an hour between Hull and Sheffield? Thirdly, will the Government work with South Yorkshire Mayoral Combined Authority, Hull and East Yorkshire Combined Authority and other regional leaders to develop an integrated investment plan that recognises the importance of connections between Sheffield, Leeds, Hull and the wider northern growth corridor? For many years, we have had promises about levelling up, regional growth and rebalancing the economy. What matters now is delivery. Our region does not want any special treatment; it wants a fair share of the national investment and transport infrastructure needed to compete, create jobs and attract businesses. The railways must connect our northern cities, not reinforce the economic division between them. I hope the Minister will provide some reassurance that the Government’s ambitions for Northern Powerhouse Rail will translate into real improvements for passengers and businesses in Yorkshire and across the wider north.

More from Lord Mohammed of Tinsley (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.