Contribution
My Lords, it is a great pleasure to follow my noble friend Lord McCobb and I congratulate him on securing this important debate. I am standing ahead of a quartet of formidable Yorkshire Liberal Democrats. I will talk predominantly about freight and its effect on business development but, before that, I want to take us south and west and back in time.
My maternal grandfather was a lifelong Great Western Railway man. Indeed, I inherited his gold watch. The pinnacle of his career was to become the stationmaster at Dursley in the mid-1950s. It was a reasonably busy station, and I have a mental picture of him standing on the platform of his rural Gloucestershire station, watching the passengers alight as milk and eggs were loaded into the goods van. Perhaps this is a rather idealised view but, as we discussed together later, he knew that the real importance of his station was not just getting children to school and agricultural products to market; it was centred on RA Lister and Company.
In the mid-1950s, Lister’s made engines that were the workhorses of the United Kingdom. In factories and on farms across the country, Lister’s engines of all sizes powered productivity. At Dursley, it manufactured hundreds of thousands of engines of all types, and it was the railway that moved these engines around Britain and beyond. Without the railway, it would have been impossible for Lister’s to operate in such a rural setting and, without an efficient railway hub, the area would have lost good jobs and the local prosperity that Lister’s delivered.
Coincidentally, the 1950s was a time when steam was giving way to diesel. For all the romance of steam, the efficiency of the new engines was undeniable. Of course, there is a parallel today. So, although the stationmaster of historic Dursley is sadly no longer with us, the stationmaster of Great Britain is sitting opposite in the form of the Minister. Right now, he is presiding over railways during the next transformation: from diesel to electric. This change offers huge benefits to the communities adjacent to newly electrified lines. In 2012, the coalition Government said:
“Electrification is an important element in delivering a long-term low-cost railway. Electrification will allow us to replace diesel trains, reducing journey times, increasing the railway’s capacity, and improving its environmental performance. These benefits will progressively extend to freight as well as passenger services”.
It would be helpful if the Minister could confirm whether he subscribes to this view.
As we have heard, a devolution deal drawn up by the Conservatives, and signed off by Labour in September 2024, pledged to bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line speed between Hull and Leeds and between Hull and Sheffield. Once in place, full electrification would have cut Hull to Manchester journey times significantly. But, as my noble friend Lord McCobb explained, although the rail route from Manchester to York is currently being electrified, the lines to Hull are not.
To be clear, Hull has not been included in recent government announcements on investment in northern rail infrastructure. As we have heard in an Answer to a Question from my noble friend, the Minister has offered only battery-electric trains on the existing track east of York, with a later explanation that these will cut journey times between Hull and Leeds by up to a minute. I cannot help thinking that that is very well within the bounds of the margins of most timetables.
Crucially, a University of Birmingham study this summer found that rail freight needs full electrification and will not run on battery rolling stock in the foreseeable future, except over very short distances. Electric freight trains are around twice as powerful as diesel, faster up gradients and quicker to clear the line for passenger trains. Network Rail expects the wider trans-Pennine upgrade that it is doing to add up to 15 freight trains a day and take 1,000 lorries a day off the region’s roads. Without full electrification, Hull and Humber ports are shut out of that.
The Government seem perfectly able to see the benefit of joining two university complexes together via the Oxford-Cambridge link. I ask them to take the same approach when linking industrial capacity to important freight infrastructure. That is why this debate is important. The new PM has talked about seeking “growth in every postcode”, but there can be no meaningful growth without significant infrastructure upgrades. This railway connection is a very good example of the upgrade we need.
According to Associated British Ports, the Humber is the UK’s largest trading gateway by volume, handling around 17% of the nation’s port traffic, which largely passes through Immingham, Hull, Grimsby and Goole. Taken together, they handle some £60 billion of trade each year. Despite this national significance, the Humber’s ability to serve manufacturing, logistics and consumer markets across northern England is increasingly held back by inadequate east-west rail freight connectivity. Rail freight demand continues to grow, but the network serving the Humber remains constrained by limited capability, ageing infrastructure and restricted access.
This is a genuine barrier to economic growth and private investment as congestion and uncertainty over long-term infrastructure delivery continue to restrict freight paths, undermine business confidence and limit development of new services. As a result, the trans-Pennine corridor currently carries far less freight than its strategic position would suggest. It is little wonder, therefore, that increasing freight capacity along this rail route has long been a priority for the Hull and Humber Chamber of Commerce and the area’s local authorities.
In conclusion, despite their importance to the UK’s trade, energy and industrial sectors, Hull and the wider Humber area have historically been sold short on northern transport and growth strategies. This is illustrated fully by the Government’s current electrification plans, which screech to a shuddering halt at Selby. Yet it is not clear to me why this is the case. If this Government really want growth across that region, the economic benefits all point to full electrification. I look forward to the Minister’s explanation as to why this is not happening.