L

Lord McCobb (LD)

Speaking in the House of Lords on 19 November 2026

Debate

Trans-Pennine Rail Route: Electrification

Contribution

My Lords, I am grateful to all noble Lords taking part this afternoon and to the House of Lords Library for its excellent briefing, which tells, in short, a story of promises made to Hull and East Yorkshire over many years which, sadly, have not yet been delivered. In my maiden speech last month, I told the House that it is faster to travel by train from London to Paris than it is from Hull to Liverpool. Today, I want to talk about the specific promise that was meant to change that, set out in black and white by two consecutive Governments. In October 2023, the previous Government’s Network North plan confirmed full electrification to Hull. A devolution deal for Hull and East Yorkshire followed, and in September 2024 this Government signed it. On rail, they could not have been clearer: “The government will bring Hull into Northern Powerhouse Rail, electrifying and improving the line speed between Hull to Leeds and Hull to Sheffield”. That deal promised to cut the journey time from Hull to Leeds from 58 minutes to 48, and that from Hull to Manchester from 107 minutes to 84. It promised two fast trains an hour to Leeds, double the services to Sheffield and double the capacity. Those were clear, specific commitments, and what a rare and uplifting moment of cross-party consensus that deal represented—Conservative-led East Riding of Yorkshire Council agreeing with Lib Dem-led Hull City Council to sign a deal with a Conservative Government, then confirmed under a Labour one, to deliver at long last the infrastructure that this neglected corner of Yorkshire so vitally needs. Indeed, the explicit commitments in this agreement to these long-awaited improvements were key elements in finally persuading several others who remained sceptical about the mayoral devolution model that this was an opportunity to be embraced. Then, in January this year, Hull was left out of the Government’s Northern Powerhouse Rail plans. Sadly, this huge disappointment is not new. As the Library briefing records, electrification of the trans-Pennine route in full was announced in 2011, for completion by 2019. Fifteen years on, around a quarter of it is electrified, and the line to Hull is not included in any plans at all. In 2013, Hull Trains offered to finance electrification from Selby to Hull at an estimated cost of £100 million. In 2016, the then Government said no. Each time, the message to Hull and East Yorkshire has been the same: “Not yet, not you—maybe later”. This is not good enough. Other parts of Britain would simply not stand for this repeated delay, and neither should Hull and East Yorkshire. In place of that promise, the Government now offer battery electric trains on the existing track. In response to my Written Questions, the noble Lord, Lord Hendy, told me that these would cut the journey time from Hull to Leeds by “up to a minute”, and that: “Full electrification would not deliver additional journey time benefits without wider infrastructure enhancements”. I agree. That is precisely why the Hull and East Yorkshire devolution deal committed to both electrification and improved line speed. Yet now we appear to be getting neither. There is a bigger problem still: freight. Battery trains may serve passengers, but heavy freight trains need the wires. If you stop rail electrification short of Hull, the line to one of the UK’s great ports will be left running on diesel while the rest of the route is upgraded. My noble friend Lord Fox will set out later what this means for freight in the Humber ports, but it severely risks driving more business elsewhere. The damage does not stop at Hull. For Beverley, Driffield and Bridlington, every train runs through Hull before heading west across the trans-Pennine route and to the east coast main line. Without electrification to Hull, those towns will be left even further at the end of the line in every sense, and the coastal communities who desperately need improved connectivity will fall even further behind. Hull and East Yorkshire have waited long enough. For a place as geographically isolated as ours, connectivity is everything. Yet, as I said last month, our motorway, the M62, stops 15 miles outside the city, and the nearest airport is in a field near Scunthorpe, with no rail link and often no public transport at weekends. Our second-nearest airport is Leeds Bradford Airport, to which we have no direct rail link either, and Hull recently lost its direct rail link to Manchester Airport. This is a city of more than a quarter of a million people at the heart of a region of 600,000 people, and a major port vital to this country’s economy, without a single direct rail link to an international airport. I will focus on one telling example of some of the problems faced by people in Hull and East Yorkshire. In 2022, Network Rail planned a new footbridge at Hessle station, with the intention of it lasting 120 years, but did not plan to build it with any clearance for future electrification. Emma Hardy MP wrote to Network Rail, reporting that the contractors had allegedly been told that there was “never going to be electrification on the line”. For a start, that is not planning for Hull’s future, but designing it out. In her letter, Emma Hardy wrote that electrification between Hull and Liverpool would be “a fundamental requirement in addressing regional rail inequalities”. I agree with every word she wrote. In 2022, she and her party were in opposition, but today her party is in government and has the power to deliver that. Hull is the UK’s green energy capital, but no one can build a modern economy on railway lines that have barely changed since the days of Dr Beeching. I have some important questions for the Minister. First, do the Government still stand by the commitment they signed in the devolution deal to electrify and improve line speed between Hull, Leeds and Sheffield? People in Hull and East Yorkshire deserve a clear answer. Secondly, will the Government publish the route-level analysis and whole-life cost comparison for the battery train decisions for Hull, including the impact on freight across the trans-Pennine route and, in particular, in relation to the port of Hull? Thirdly, will every bridge renewed on these lines in future leave room for wires to enable future electrification rather than design it out? Fourthly, when will the promised line speed improvements and better connectivity through to Sheffield come? The Minister previously said that they would be considered only in future years. Fifthly, can the Minister confirm that pre-agreed electrification between Leeds and York is on track, given that battery services to Hull will depend on it? Finally, will the Minister come to Hull to meet me, the leaders of our two local authorities, the chamber of commerce and the ports, and hear for himself why this matters so much? I will gladly take the train to Hull with him. This is not a party-political point. The leaders of both Hull City Council and East Riding of Yorkshire Council back this campaign, as do the University of Hull, the Hull and Humber Chamber of Commerce, our ports, civic and business leaders, and thousands of individual businesses and residents across Hull and East Yorkshire. The people of Hull and East Yorkshire are not asking for special treatment; we are asking for what other parts of the UK have come to take for granted. We are asking for what we were promised and what was signed and sealed in black and white in that devolution deal. I look forward to the Minister’s reply.

More from Lord McCobb (LD)

Other recent Hansard contributions by the same speaker.

About Hansard

Hansard is the official verbatim record of proceedings in the UK Parliament. Every word spoken in the Commons and Lords is recorded and published — this page is a single contribution from that record.