Contribution
My Lords, it is a pleasure to take part in this debate. There have been some excellent speeches. The noble Lord, Lord Bilimoria, quoted Franklin D Roosevelt referring, I believe, to the dust bowl disaster in the 1920s and 1930s, when intensive crop growing led to a catastrophic disaster in food growing. I pay tribute to my noble friend Lord Fuller’s expertise in his study of soil. However, some of us who went to bog-standard comprehensive schools might also remember our environmental science lessons. On the first day of the academic year, we put soil into three glass bowls and then put an apple core in one, a sweet—I think it was a Mars bar—in another and a crisp packet in the third. We were told to look at what had happened every time we went to the lesson: 10 months later, the apple core had disappeared; funnily enough, the Mars bar had just about disappeared; but the crisp packet was still there staring at us. I have to say, the 1970s have a lot to answer for.
I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Bennett of Manor Castle, for securing this debate and giving the Committee the chance to dig into a subject that is not well-trodden ground. Let me start with some common ground. Soil is the foundation of our food, our farming and our countryside; it holds the roots of our crops and hedgerows; it stores carbon, filters our water and supports an enormous amount of life. We believe that this importance is already reflected in the national curriculum. Geography includes soils in the programmes of study at key stage 1 and key stage 3. Learning about soils is featured in the programmes of study for science, particularly at the post-16 level, where the environmental science AS-level and A-level include teaching about soil fertility, degradation, erosion and management. It is already being cultivated across several subjects and at several stages of a child’s education.
However, learning about soil can offer only so much. Soil matters most in the field, as the basis of our agricultural prosperity and national food security. Schools can offer pupils fundamental concepts, but the technical knowledge is at best instrumental. The best soil education in this country takes place at the grass roots: on our farms and in the hands of those who have looked after the same ground for generations. The place of soil within the national curriculum can certainly prepare for that education, but it cannot replace it. That is why soil is taught within other subjects rather than standing as a subject of its own.
That brings me to the Opposition’s main concern. Many important topics are taught as part of wider disciplines in schools and in higher education. We do this because subject areas are vast, and if we give a disproportionate share of time to any one topic, the time left for other equally important material shrinks. That is why we approach the curriculum and assessment review with apprehension. By scrapping established pathways such as the English baccalaureate and promoting “creative” subjects at the expense of languages and humanities, the Government risk sacrificing depth for breadth. However tempting it may be, the curriculum cannot become a repository for every social or environmental cause, however worthy. The same applies to soil. It is already taught throughout our schools; giving it a premium would divert teaching time away from the core fundamentals of English and mathematics above all. We should not let the curriculum become even more thinly spread.
The folly of this approach has been demonstrated in the most recent PISA results. England climbed the international rankings while our neighbours in Scotland and Wales fell back. That improvement came from reforms under the previous Conservative Government, who concentrated on fundamentals and gave schools the freedom to teach them well. Those reforms have taken root and are bearing the fruit. Pulling up those now established measures root and branch, the curriculum included, is not the way to raise standards.
This matters most in early years and primary education. Children’s minds are most fertile at these stages. This is when we sow the seeds of literacy and numeracy from which everything else grows, including any later study of the natural world. A child who cannot read fluently will struggle with a textbook on soil science, in the same way that a child without confident numeracy cannot analyse data on crop yields. If children are to spend more time studying climate change or soil science, can the Minister guarantee that not a single hour of teaching time for reading, writing and maths will be lost? Our education system is designed to grow from the ground up. Pupils begin with a broad base and, as they mature, they narrow their interests and specialise. Children who pick up an interest in soil can continue it through their A-levels, degrees, agricultural college and further professional training.
If the Government want to strengthen soil education, they should begin by widening the routes for those who choose to pursue it, rather than mandating it for all. They could even begin by reversing a decision of their own and reinstate funding for the level 7 soil scientist apprenticeship for learners over 22 without the help of an EHCP. Over half of the people taking it are over 25, so under the new rules most of them will now be ineligible. Will the Minister commit to reinstating funding for this route?
Soil education is plainly important, and we believe it is already recognised as such in our national curriculum. If there is to be reform, let it give those with a real interest in soil more opportunities to pursue it, rather than taking already limited teaching time away from the subjects that every child needs.